Share your automotive expertise

2 Write a Blog Post

Filed in: Marketing

The Apples and Oranges of Dealer Marketing

By Dennis Galbraith on Feb 21, 2013

The wealth of data being provided to dealers from their vendors is truly incredible. Twenty years ago, dealers thought it was amazing when I could show them cost-per-thousand numbers for their radio, TV, print, and outdoor advertising. Today the amount of marketing data available to a typical dealer has increased more than one-hundred fold.

This spawned a number of additional products available to dealers, from full business intelligence tools like our own DrivingSales Data to an array of dashboard products designed to organize the data. That's the good news. The bad news is some of these products are mixing apples and oranges. The purpose is to have valid, reliable information for decision making. Mixing incompatible data can lead to precisely inaccurate results that drive dealers in the wrong direction.

DrivingSales recently conducted a research project to uncover the true meaning and compatibility of vendor metrics. We found a wide range of cases where metrics with the same name do not mean the same thing from vendor to vendor. None of these vendors are necessarily wrong, but it is wrong to group their metrics together in a dashboard simply because they have the same label attached to them.

The complete report is available for dealers and vendors alike in the latest edition of Dealer Innovation Guide, Over time, vendors will come together around standards and third parties, like Google Analytics, will provide apples to apples comparisons. Those provide everything from simple dashboards to complete business intelligence suites will understand which metrics can be aggregated and which cannot. Until then, more and more research like this will be need so dealers can know what to trust. 


Dennis, I couldn't agree with you more that our industry needs to create a lexicon of terms and definitions. For example, think of the word "leads". If website form submissions are "leads" then we could mix up job applications, finance applications, and sales leads. That of course makes no sense.

Inventory VDP and SRP views have a wide range of meanings, and third party classified sites seem to feel that they are defined differently by site.

So, as the industry moves toward data warehouses and business intelligence tools, a lexicon needs to be created. Sign me up if you plan to organize a committee on this project.

Feb 22, 2013

Glad you brought this up Dennis - it is something we have been struggling with in our Internet 20 Group as we discussed. Analytics are taken from one URL but we have a portal and 4 micro sites along with two OEM mandated sites. Marketing is mainly on the portal but the data is just from our Honda store. Some in our group have RVs too which can mess with the gross averages. F&I revenues is another bone of contention as to what is or is not included.

Some things just can't be split out when there is more than one roof top. Cost of Websites was another issue, some of us were dividing the cost between 5 URLs others were putting in the whole cost so the range was from $280 to $2800 for Website costs. Apples to Apples is tough, but we have to try to get it as close as possible. Love what you are doing Dennis - Love the Driving Sales Think Tank! We all benefit immensely!

Feb 22, 2013

Thank you Brian and Jon. Brian, we do need to work together on these things, and it's always a pleasure to do so with you.

Jon, you are pioneering something wonderful in the Internet 20 groups. I've enjoyed watching the progress of the groups and the growing profitability of the members. One of the wonderful aspects of the 20 group is that you do talk and you do uncover these things. There will always need to be a balance between time spent improving the inputs and time spent increasing profitability with the good findings coming from the outputs. Over time, the shift has been from the former to the latter. Members seem to be getting more from the groups each time they meet. Thank you for your pioneering leadership in this area.

Feb 23, 2013

Dennis, thank you. Analytics and data have become overwhelming and confusing for many dealers. On the one hand it is exciting to see information that was never before available. But on the other hand, it is increasingly difficult to organize, interpret and make use of the vast amount of information. It would help tremendously if there were benchmarks and agreed upon terms for what we're seeing across the spectrum.

Feb 23, 2013

Collecting the data is imperative to understanding the store's opportunities and shortcomings. It's hard to move forward without garnering the right data. You're right that there needs to be universal understanding of the data terms so everyone can measure the same logic. The most difficult part for dealers, however, is taking the data and actually enacting corporate structure/policies to improve their performances. That is the biggest gap in understanding. Data to directives.

Feb 24, 2013

Joe, few people understand that link form data to information to profitable action items the way you do. Some trainers and consultants fear data; it holds them accountable. The good ones realize the availability of a well constructed database allows them to do more for dealers and show credible results. As the need for people in math-oriented positions outstrips our education system's supply of them, it is a certainty that most dealership are not going to find all the talent they need in-house. Long live the out-sourced expert.

Feb 25, 2013

Tom, I don't want to oversell; the system we are building is much better than the system we have available today. However, dealers can access it for free. After putting dealership data into the system, you can see your data compared to the average of other dealers in the system, benchmarking.

The system is strictly for marketing strategy. The privacy policy is designed to protect dealers, and It does not collect data at the VIN, customer, lead, or employee level.

Feb 25, 2013

The wide array of interpretive analytics can be confusing at best. Morphing the data to quantifiable action plans can be even more so. When OEMs, Vendors and Dealership personnel quit trying to manipulate reporting to look good rather than be good changes can occur.
Thanks for a great post and sharing the link

Mar 26, 2013

Comments 1 - 8 of 8

You must be logged in to comment

Login Create an account

Add your comments:


Dennis Galbraith's Recent Posts

Related Posts

  • Myth: Negative Comments are Bad For Biz

    Many businesses have avoided social interaction for fear that an existing bad reputation, or possible negative comments will come back to bite them.  These ideas may be true if the issues are left unchecked, but for a business that is highly active on social media, negative comments can turn into a positive experience. Legitimate customer comments around a product or service will definitely start to pop up when a business decides to start regularly using social media to promote their business.  Many of these could be negative comments which may cause some alarm to those not well-versed in the ways of social media marketing.  However, there is one simple solution - use social media as a platform to address customer issues head-on and allow customer service to shine. Rather than hiding legitimate concerns or negative comments, a business should provide a thoughtful response with options to further assist a customer via phone or email.  Also, someone should follow up internally to e...Read post

  • Navigating SEO: The 4 Most Important Factors to Dealership SEO Success

    Navigating SEO is a exclusive series by Timothy Martell, CEO of Wikimotive. In this series, Tim breaks down ways dealers can improve their SEO and offers insight into how it will benefit business.   While there are thousands of articles that talk about search ranking factors, the majority of your site's success will come down to a few core factors. Ensuring you've got those boxes checked is what ultimately allows you to have the best search presence in your market.   In this post, I'll go over four of the most important factors that determine SEO success for car dealers, while offering tips and tricks to help you improve your site, grow organic traffic consistently, and sell more cars as a result.   Website Architecture   By now, you all know how important it is to actually have a website. There's just no contesting this in 2015. But beyond simply having a website, it's important that your site is developed and designed to allow it to comply with curren...Read post

  • 3 Birds Launches All-New Dealer Solution 3 Birds ME at Digital Dealer 19

    3 Birds Marketing has launched its all-new 3 Birds ME digital solution, the industry’s first all-in-one solution to show the results of each marketing component and reveal extra opportunities, at Digital Dealer 19. ME stands for “Market Effectively” and is a complete integrated solution that makes it easy to say the right thing at the right time across key channels on any device to reach the best customers. ME further eliminates frustrations and removes unnecessary layers of account management thanks to an advanced “Always On, Always Learning” analytics engine, developed in-house to meet the needs of modern dealers, regional groups, and OEMs.Read post

  • In Praise of a Balanced #AutoMarketing Strategy (It's about more than your website)

    I’ve made people that I actually like and respect very angry with me because I’ve questioned their belief system. No, not their religion; their belief that developing their primary website – at the expense of almost all other digital marketing – is a laudable goal. They even have data to back up the argument, but I will argue that their analysis of the data is fundamentally flawed for a couple of very important reasons – Reason Number One – Automotive is not ecommerce. They analyzie the data as if they were analyzing an ecommerce site and that will inherently lead them astray. Let’s look at the ecommerce model for moment; everything must eventually funnel into the primary website to sell the product – to gain the conversion. With automotive that is not the case. With automotive, everything must eventually funnel into the physical dealership – not the digital one. Let’s face it, we’ve been talking about the website as being the ‘Digital Showroom’ for so long t...Read post

  • Get Creative with Fall Car Care

    For many Americans, October marks the beginning of fall. For some of the country, the leaves have already started to change and the weather is getting cooler, but for the automotive industry, October is known as Fall Car Care Month. The month of October presents the perfect opportunity for Service Departments everywhere to increase traffic by reaching out to customers about needed fall maintenance. Most dealerships will be offering tips and savings to drive people into their service drives and this type of marketing is a great idea and probably much needed. But, what if you did something a little different this year? What if you decided to get really creative with your fall car care marketing? Instead of just delivering tips and savings to customers, what if you hosted targeted events at your dealership? Check out these two event ideas to promote fall car care by getting creative. Host a DIY New Owner’s Clinic This year think about hosting a DIY event in your Service Department. I...Read post

  • 3 Birds Marketing Unveils New Corporate Website in Support of 3 Birds ME

    3 Birds Marketing, the premier customer demand generation and retention marketing platform and solutions provider in the automotive retail space, has unveiled its all-new corporate website at The completely redesigned website supports the recent rollout of 3 Birds ME (Market Effectively), an all-new digital solution for connecting and communicating with today’s automotive consumers.Read post

  • Communication: Keys to Dealership Success

    Communication Drives Dealership Success When you think of all the things that go into making your dealership a success, communication ranks at the top of the list. In fact, without good communication—both inside the dealership and with your customer base—you’ll likely suffer unnecessary losses in sales, employees, and customers. And while it’s one of the most integral pieces to your success, great communication can also be one of the most difficult things to achieve. Why? Because your dealership is a complicated machine with many constantly-moving parts, and that makes it tough to ensure everyone stays on the same page. The goal of any great businessperson is to communicate well with those in our professional circles, however, it’s common for everyday issues to get in the way of delivering clear, concise messages to everyone who should receive them. George Bernard Shaw once said, “The single biggest problem with communication is the illusion that it has taken place.” C...Read post

  • AutoAlert Study Highlights Risk to Future Vehicle SAAR Growth without Shortening the Trade Cycle

    According to the latest U.S. vehicle registration data analysis by global market intelligence firm IHS, length of vehicle ownership continues to increase, hitting another all-time high average of 67.9 months – nearly 78 months for new vehicles and 63 months for used vehicles. This is more than a two year length of ownership increase for all vehicles since 2006. "How long a consumer holds on to their vehicle has a direct impact on the SAAR and is a key performance indicator of the overall health of the auto industry," said AutoAlert CEO Brian Skutta.  "To put this in context, the lengthening ownership lifecycle is resulting in consumers buying fewer vehicles over their lifetime giving dealers fewer opportunities to sell them cars if you wait for them to come to you."             "How long a consumer holds on to their vehicle has a direct impact on the SAAR (Seasonally Adjusted Annualized Rate of auto sales) and is a key... In order to gain direct insight...Read post