Share your automotive expertise

2 Write a Blog Post

Filed in: Marketing

Did We Make a Big Google Mistake?

By Christine Rochelle on Aug 17, 2012

For weeks I've found myself saying the same one-liner, "reviews are missing from your Google+ Local listing, we reported it to Google but there's not much else we can do."

I find myself cringing every time I have to utter those words. I send them the link on Google's response to missing reviews, which really doesn't say much, and then we all wait. After coaching a dealer to ask customers to post reviews for them on Google, how do you explain to them why Google would then delete nearly every single one of those positive reviews, only leaving the negative reviews behind? For two years I have motivated dealers to hop on the Google train, branding them online as "Top Rated Dealer on Google" - but they aren't the top rated dealer anymore.

Did we all make a big Google mistake?

I've looked outside the auto industry and I have been tracking the very same issues for other businesses. Mike Blumenthal of has even took it upon himself to collect all the issues pertaining to missing reviews so that they are reported on the Google forum in one post. He also posts his own formula on the missing reviews.


Since there is not much a client or SEO can do, I also provide them with the 6,6,6 rule for lost reviews to guide them as to what to expect in terms of recovery of the reviews. It might offer some small comfort.
What is the 6,6,6 review rule? (any client imagined thoughts about the devil suggested by my guideline are actively encouraged)
  • If reviews don’t come back to the Google Places page in 6 days, they might return in 6 weeks
  • If they don’t return in 6 weeks they might return in 6 months
  • If they don’t return in 6 months they have descended to Dante’s 6th Ring of Hell

Joking aside, what are the next steps for a dealer who has had their reviews missing from Google? And what about a dealer who has had all of their positive reviews go missing?

Google is a free tool, after all, we don't have to use it. In fact, when you create a Google login their terms of service that you probably blindly accepted made that very clear:


Did we make a mistake in molding a business' digital presence around something no one has control over? Do we start over, or do we keep fighting?

I'd love to know your thoughts on this.




Christine --
There is no question that Google is a huge source of frustration for dealers (and those of us who help them). There are frequent changes and what can seem like an arbitrariness that the rest of us are left to try to react. For the pro-active among us, this is an uncomfortable position to occupy! It's not just Google though. Yelp with it's filtering system and the "Yelp sort" are also challenging.

At the end of the day, it's Google's world and we all just live in it (at least from a search engine perspective), so it is a fact of life that we all have to deal with. As with all issues related to online reputation and review sites, it all starts with what happens at the dealership and the good news is that that actually can be controlled by dealers! If the process is solid, followed consistently and there is care paid to the experience customers have in every department in the dealership, that should extend into the online world and be reflected in the reviews written about the dealership.

Thanks for kicking off an important discussion.

Kristen Judd

Aug 17, 2012

Thanks so much Kristen! You are so right - it is a Google world, we just live in I check my Gmail through my Chrome browser :). I have suggested to dealers to try to encourage customers to mention the salespersons name in the review and the model they purchased...more details could make them stick? It's just a theory, an option.

Aug 17, 2012

For what it's worth, I have been working with Google on maps issues for about a year, and now on this very issue. After talking to a few other sources, I suspect that as Google places more importance on reviews they are beefing up their spam algorithms. I think that legitimate reviews were removed along the way. The process we use at our stores to gather reviews has been vetted by my contact at Google, but without getting into the nitty gritty, I believe that the process we use may have led to the reviews being mistakenly labelled spam.

My contact was aware of other issues at stores in different markets, but those stores had stopped following up so he assumed it had resolved itself. After sending over the information I had gathered, it was clear that the issue was not resolved, and it was escalated internally.

Aug 17, 2012

Thanks for the insight Mark. I hope that it is handled for your stores and Google sees that so my dealers are passionate about their Google reviews.

Aug 17, 2012

If we all agree that positive Google reviews are an asset and we know Google to date has offered zero help I suggest we fight the battle. Start over! One of our Google+ Local pages is now MIA so its not just a review issue.

Aug 19, 2012

Mark it would be helpful if you told us why you think your process was the reason your reviews are gone. What process did you use

Aug 19, 2012

I do not see how this is not a liability issue for Google. I would understand if all reviews disappeared but to leave just the negative aones amounts to slander in my opinion, whether intentional on Google's part or not. Whether we pay to have reviews in my opinion is not relevant, they are paid by advertisers who see their sites as relevant and reviews are a part of that. All of the reviews were done by our clients and never done at the dealership. We had 88 positive reviews and four negative and were left with just the four. Our web traffic dropped as a result. This hurt our business and Google should be held responsible in some way. There is legislation in some places where false reviews have punitive results, I do not see how arbitrary removal of reviews, without notification to the proprietor, is any different. It would be very easy for us to contact each client and have them verify that they wrote our reviews yet we were given no chance to verify.

Aug 24, 2012

Comments 1 - 7 of 0

You must be logged in to comment

Login Create an account

Add your comments:


Christine Rochelle's Recent Posts

Related Posts

  • Get Creative with Halloween

    You may have noticed Halloween and fall decorations adorning your favorite retail stores or maybe you’ve seen the random Halloween outlet stores popping up in shopping centers near you. With the excitement building around this much anticipated holiday, you may want to get in on the fun. Halloween is the time of year for goblins and ghouls, but it’s also a time to get creative. Demonstrate your creative side to customers and prospects with one of these Halloween marketing ideas. Host a Costume Contest People who spend money and time on their Halloween costumes want to show them off, that’s why hosting a Halloween costume contest is a great way to bring top-of-mind awareness to your dealership. You could run a traditional contest and incentivize people to dress up and come to your dealership, or you could take a simpler approach and host the costume contest on your social media channels. Leveraging social media for your contest improves your dealership’s online reputation, reac...Read post

  • Digital Dealer 19 Twitter Recap

    As usual around this time of year, I like to remind automotive industry professionals everywhere that Twitter is a GREAT learning tool during the conference season, thanks to so many attendees who tweet valuable information they learn during the speaking sessions. So if you missed this week’s Digital Dealer 19 conference, no worries, I put this recap together just for you! So take a few minutes out of your busy day - sit back, relax, and review some of the best informational tweets from Digital Dealer 19 that can help you improve your dealership’s business! #StayCurrent #DD19 A good reminder that video marketing is important: "If you don't use video to merchandise your vehicles and brand yourselves, you don't understand the data behind video." ~ @brentwees #dd19 — Joe Webb (@zonewebb) October 5, 2015 We all make mistakes, but our faults don’t have to be broadcasted. Address any shortcomings privately and professionally with your team. And don’t forget to boost employee morale with open praise when they do something right! A mentor is someone who praises you publicly and criticizes you privately. #ChallengeOneAnother@signontheline #DD19 — Subi Ghosh (@subi101) October 5, 2015 This is a good question to ask. Make sure your advertising is in the right place to get the best results! Does your ad spending match your consumers media preference? #dd19 — DealerSocket Inc. (@DealerSocket) October 5, 2015 Most customers want to buy somRead post

  • Creating a Culture of Communication

    Great Communicators Have Meaningful Conversations Creating a culture of strong communication can make or break your dealership.  And great communicators just seem to have a way with people. Strong leaders understand the importance of good communication for building strong partnerships and are able to authentically connect with customers.  People gravitate toward people who are good communicators when it’s time to get information. Good communicators master the art of reading people, and understanding what’s driving their interaction. Meaningful Conversations Matter Today’s consumers and employees crave communication and are looking for meaningful interactions in the marketplace. According to Mashable, 83% of people do online research before buying a car, with 81% of consumers being less likely to purchase from an aggressive salesperson. We’ve all learned authenticity is key when connecting with individuals in today’s fast-paced world, so how do you help your sales p...Read post

  • 3 Ways to Acquire On-Line and In-Market Car Shoppers

    When a shopper comes into your dealership, you can almost be guaranteed that they have done their research and in fact, the majority of their purchase decision has already been made. Here are 3 ways to be considered at the very beginning and throughout the car purchase journey.Read post

  • Google Map Pack Update: 5 Thoughts on the New Design

    Local SEO has become one of the most important focuses in the digital marketing community. This means it's only natural for everyone to take notice and rethink strategy when Google makes an update to its local Map Pack results. In its latest update, which occurred around August 6, 2015, Google redesigned the Map Pack to fit with its mobile design scheme and reduced the maximum number of results from 7 to 3. A lot of business owners went to sleep seeing their business on page one, but woke up completely pushed off. As SEOs and business owners, what are you supposed to take away from this change? In this post, we'll explore five of the most important thoughts and takeaways from the latest Google Map Pack update:   Local Rankings Matter Even More While it's always been important to rank #1, it's more important than ever to ensure your business actually shows up within the map pack, as there are now only 3 positions available on the initial SERP. (In order for users to see more r...Read post

  • What Are You Doing to Reach Mobile Customers?

    There’s no doubt that people are in love with their phones.  As a result, memes and jokes constantly circulate the Internet about how some people no longer participate in “normal” activities because they simply can’t put down their phones. People aren’t reading newspapers anymore - at least not in print - and they’re fast-forwarding through commercials. So where are they? You guessed it. On their phones.    In a recent article on, a respected publication that covers the global digital ecosystem: digital marketing, media and commerce, it was reported that 2015 is “a benchmark year for ad spending in the US, as mobile surpasses desktop spending for the first time.”     In fact, eMarketer estimates that mobile will account for almost 52 percent of all digital spending by the end of the year. It attributes the shift to consumer demand and estimates that adults spend almost 3 hours per day on “nonvoice activities” on mobile devices – 1.5 hours...Read post

  • Why Does Offering Service Valet Increase RO Value by 20%?

    Why do customers who do not visit the dealership spend 18% more on auto service? Evidence and armchair psychology support our analysis. I recently published a case study about the effects of service pick-up and delivery (service valet) on loaner turn time.  You can read the paper . (Spoiler alert: Loaner turn time was reduced by approximately 1.2 days, or over 40%.) The study had a few other gems.  Among them, analysis showed customers who used service valet had RO values 18% higher than those who did not use service valet. Theoretically, these service valet customers  could have had more expensive repairs but that is not likely given the large sample size. Instead, our longstanding experience shows service valet customers purchase more recommended services. So this begs the question:   Why do customers who do not visit the dealership spend 18% more on auto service? Evidence and armchair psychology support our analysis.  Consider the psychology from the customer’s viewpoi...Read post

  • Mike Martinez of DMEautomotive Selected to Present at the 2015 DrivingSales Executive Summit

    Martinez’s presentation “GRO Your Bottom Line” selected by auto dealers in a highly competitive process; joins an agenda with four award-wining authors and other industry experts Daytona Beach, FL – October 6, 2015 – Mike Martinez, Chief Marketing Officer of DMEautomotive and AutoPoint, has been selected to present at the seventh annual DrivingSales Executive Summit (DSES), one of the largest gatherings of progressive dealer executives, on October 19th at 11:15 AM at the Bellagio Las Vegas. Martinez’s presentation “GRO” Your Bottom Line was selected by a panel of dealers in a highly competitive process, in which only 1 in 3 applications was accepted.    Martinez joins a powerhouse DSES agenda that includes a Harvard Business School faculty member, leading search marketing and content marketing strategists, branding experts and technology visionaries, and award-winning authors. The DSES has sold out every year since inception and hosted over 1,000 attendees last y...Read post