Community

Share your automotive expertise

2 Write a Blog Post

Filed in: Marketing

Why I Quit Klout and Why You Should Too!

By Eric Miltsch on Dec 13, 2012

DrivingSales dScore PreviewVery rarely do I ever rant about something, but enough already with the obsession about Klout and your score. This debate continues to drone on and I'm simply tired of hearing about what Klout "means" - I'll tell you what it means: Nothing.

Sure, it's very easy to complain about something. I learned at a young age that if you're going to complain about something, you better be prepared to change it. Otherwise, keep you mouth shut and deal with it. That's why you don't often hear from me in this tone. My experiment is over, I've learned a ton and I believe I've made something that can have the same natural impact as it relates to your professional activities. (More on that shortly.) 
 
I understand we all desire adulation and some form of self-actualization. Ask yourself, is getting Klout and seeing your score fluctuate truly satisfying these needs for you and is it beneficial in any way?
 
This has created a non-productive behavior modification with everyone playing along. Stop giving +K, stop thanking people for giving you +K and stop trying to get more perks. I've heard people justify a high score by saying that it represents your "overall understanding" of how social media works, how the tools can be leveraged, how to understand people. Oh, just stop. I'll tell you what it means. It means you know how to post a ton of crap in a lot of places. (And I know that because that's what I did.) 
 
I've played with Klout long enough (three years+) to understand the mechanics of the platform, how to game it and to realize that it hasn't provided an ounce of benefit to me within it's intended scope. Sure, I got some free stuff. A four-pack of Red Bull is nice, but Red Bull doesn't need me telling my friends about it. They had a guy free fall from space, they don't need me or anyone else telling you about their brand. I got some herbs to plant in three cute Bing planters. Two of them sprouted, one died; I still don't use Bing. I got a cool t-shirt from Subaru, unfortunately it's the same size shirt I wore in 8th grade. All I can really do is tell people I got a t-shirt from Klout. That is, if I want to sound like a complete tool and cause an abrupt end to the conversation. 
 
Let's review the basic elements of Klout. They claim they're the standard for influence measurement. My beef with this claim is that it's so difficult, near impossible, to measure true influence online. (As do Kred, Naymz & PeerIndex) Measuring influence online involves tracking the change in behavior, or actions, that one person creates in another person. There are only a handful of people this can actually work for. One great example is someone like Trey Ratcliff. He's one of the most famous photographers in the world, due in part to his social media efforts and mostly due to his amazing photography skills. He's influential. If he mentions how he does something, people listen. If he shares what equipment he uses and recommends it, I'll buy it without any other consideration. That's influence. But he doesn't need Klout to tell him, or anyone else, that he's a hot commodity. 
 
Now let's look at a flawed result created by Klout due to the broad stroke measure of its algorithm. London's Big Ben clock has a twitter account that tweets out it's "bongs" - it's influential on the topic of drugs. Relevant? Hardly. 
 
In order for you to become influential, you need to have experience. Gaining experience means you need to have relevant activity. Malcolm Gladwell says the golden rule of becoming an expert in your field dictates you need 10,000 hours of relevant activity. Seth Godin pushes it out even further saying you need 20,000 hours, depending on your segment and other factors such as competition. 
 
So, what's the solution? With the help of the awesome people within DrivingSales, we're introducing the dScore. This is intended to be the first activity and experience measurement tool for automotive professionals. Our algorithm will simply monitor and measure your activity within the DrivingSales community as related to your specific activity and contributions. The formula is simple: (Activity + Experience)Relevance = Influence.
 
This wasn't designed to be a popularity contest and can't be manipulated. This was designed to help you. Over time, the measurement factors will grow and adapt. For now, the goal is simply to measure and reward you for your activity. Your activity will contribute to your score. Initially, the rewards will come in the form of an improved score and visually by unlocking different achievements. Each activity can impact your score differently. Here's a few examples of the activity measured and it's impact on your score: 
 
DrivingSales dScore Preview
  • Contributing original content (High impact, unlocks achievement)
  • Receiving comments (Moderate impact, unlocks achievement)
  • Having your content shared (Moderate impact, unlocks achievement)
  • Sharing content (Low impact, unlocks achievement) 
  • Completed your profile (No impact, unlocks achievement)
Unlike Klout, we want to be extremely transparent with regards to why we're doing this, how it works and what this means to you before we publish the new feature to the site. You can expect to see this live by next week.
 
First, we're doing this to raise the overall level of quality activity within the community. You want better content and we want to provide that to you. We don't want content that is diluted and posted to every other online community. This doesn't help other users and it doesn't help your brand whether you're a dealer or vendor. We also want to continue building our position as a premier destination for the best performance improvement content in the business. 
 
Second, here is the initial list of activities that will unlock achievements and/or impact your score. No surprises, standard community activity, while including offline activity as well.
  • Joining DrivingSales.com
  • Your length of time as a member
  • Connecting with other members
  • Contributing original content (Blogs, forums, strategies, videos, etc) 
  • Receiving comments on your content
  • Having your content shared
  • Sharing content   
  • Completed your profile  
  • Contributing to the Dealership Innovation Guide (DIG) 
  • Appearing on the cover of DIG 
  • Speaking at DrivingSales Executive Summit (DSES) 
  • Attending DSES & President's Club events
Pro Tips: If your activity involves contributing content (writing a blog) and generates engagement (receiving comments) - that will improve your score. If the activity involves a basic community function (completing your profile) - that won't affect your score. There's also a time decay element; dScores will decrease if there is no activity. Again, the goal is to encourage timely activity and current experience. 
 
Lastly, we want to help provide you a visual validation for your contributions, reward your activities and help you build your professional brand. As these activities increase and user experience grows, we can begin to leverage the power of the community's influence to help other users gain access to more helpful information about vendor products and services as well. More activity will allow us to provide the most relevant rewards for your activity - rewards that you can actually use and benefit from. (Vendor rewards, discount prices, meaningful products, etc) Sharing your experiences within our incredible community online, in print and at our events, benefits everyone. 
 
I welcome your feedback. I love this industry, the wonderful people I've met over the years and truly want to see everyone continue to improve. Doing so helps yourself, your business and our industry. Let's focus on productive efforts rather than time wasters. 
 
(Thanks for reading my rant too!)

Comments

But will you send me free Red Bull like Klout does? :-)

Dec 13, 2012

Ed, I'll send you whatever you want:)

Dec 13, 2012

Forget the Red Bull, I want a vintage Subaru shirt that would only fit Larry Bruce!

Dec 13, 2012

The last time I saw Larry he was outside of a Ikea in a really sharp little coat...

Dec 13, 2012

Where is the 'like' button when I need it!!

Dec 13, 2012

Great article Eric, sorry you spent 3 plus years on the experiment, but now we can all enjoy your findings.

Dec 13, 2012

Love it Eric, I wrote about this recently as well. Couldn't agree more, great article! (and btw, this comment will put your dScore over the top...)

Dec 13, 2012

Thanks Kevin.

Enjoyed your article as well. I had hoped to publish this sooner, just needed a bit more time to get everything in place.

Dec 13, 2012

Thanks Carl - definitely learned a few things about the platform, but even more about our behaviors.

Dec 13, 2012 (Last Edited: 2012-12-13 12:37:13)

Its yours Glen!

Dec 13, 2012

Comments 1 - 10 of 17

You must be logged in to comment

Login Create an account

Add your comments:

   

Eric Miltsch's Recent Posts

Related Posts

  • Get Your Customers Properly Engaged with Your Dealership

    I know. It's a buzzword. It's impossible to keep track of number of times experts in the car business have used the word "engagement" when describing how to get more customers. Engage on social. Engage on search. Engage on YouTube. Engage on your website. It's a mess but it's still important to be engaged with potential customers. On the other hand, it's even more important to be engaged with your past and present customers. The people who just bought a car from you, the people in your service waiting lounge, even the people who bought a vehicle from you a couple of years ago - these are the people that could really use some engagement with you immediately. It gets frustrating to see so many dealers focused on driving new business and conquest business while pretty much taking their eyes off of the low hanging fruit in their database. It's as if the industry has given up on loyalty. It's true that loyalty numbers are lower than ever before. Between the internet allowing further re...Read post

  • Fall into Customer Loyalty with End of Summer

    With Labor Day here and the official start of fall coming up quickly, now is the time to leverage an end of summer campaign to drive revenue and traffic plus gain additional customer loyalty for your dealership. But, what is an impactful end of summer campaign to help you do just that? Before fall officially sets in, try one of these revenue generating campaign ideas. Host an End of Summer Blast Invite customers, prospects, and members of your community to an event at your dealership. Be sure to have appealing activities to attract an audience such as live music, food and beverages, games, giveaways, etc. You can partner with other local business to keep costs down. Make sure to send an announcement to all customers to let them know you’re hosting one last blast before the cooler weather sets in. Beach Ball Blowout Chances are you’re looking to get rid of those 2014 vehicles on your lot to make room for your 2015 lineup. You could host a blowout event at your dealership to offer ...Read post

  • Autotrader vs. Cars.com

    Currently we use both AutoTrader and Cars.com. We have used them both for quite some time. The measurement that we use for them is cost per vehicle detail page. We feel that it is a good measurement for them. In our opinion it is their responsibility to get the customer to our vehicle detail page. We feel that our marketing takes over at that point. (Good pictures, right car, right place, etc.) They are currently below .50 cents per vehicle detail page. We try to keep them under .60 cents per vehicle detail page. My question for the community is this. Do I need both? Based on our reporting both companies are performing well. AutoTrader seems to perform slightly better. They are also a lot easier to work with then cars.com. I just do not know if I would get the same customers with just one of them.      ...Read post

  • Top Reasons Why You Should Buy "Likes"

    There's lots of excitement over buying "likes". But should you? Read this and then you decide.Read post

  • How CPS can help justify your traffic from sites like Autotrader and Cars.com

    CPS stands for Cars Per Shopper and its a number that we have been tracking weekly looking at the amount of shoppers on Autotrader divided by the amount of total..Read post

  • Social Media: When Marketing Becomes Mocketing

    Social media can be a tricky thing. Finding and publishing content that a business’s audience will both enjoy and interact with can be challenging. And as Facebook exposure for business pages is increasingly diminishing, businesses are more dependent on audience engagement than ever for those elusive likes, shares and comments. The type of content posted is highly important as there is a line that can be crossed and turn public perception against you. Sometimes, what may have been a sincere piece of content can be perceived as simply self-promotional.   The reality is that behind every piece of content produced by a business there is a person. Whether that’s one person or a team, ultimately, it can be difficult for marketers to separate personal feelings from their social media content. Take for example the viral campaign to raise awareness and money for the ALS Association named “The Ice Bucket Challenge.” It’s fantastic that individuals are raising money for the ALS Assoc...Read post

  • Consulting Conundrum: “You can do whatever you want, as long as…”

    Yes, this is opinion. However don't take it as fable. It’s the consistent vicious circle in consulting: do it all as long as it’s what is wanted at that moment, backed up by someone else, doesn’t bite back at the factory stance, mostly makes sense and when you can grab the proper attention. And don’t blink because all of that can change with one call or a visit from a nice set of pearly whites with a tan and a low-slung top. In a dramatically fluid world, all of that is a constant. Meeting with a dealer the other day, their factory (only) site has issues, their SEO/SEM isn’t close to completely transparent in work, reporting or results, their new CRM isn’t installed properly or completely and their sales team can’t seem to do their job. And the store is doing, what most would consider, fine. In less than five hours, a solution to every hole that was shot in their operation was provided, a path to resolution (in some cases multiple) was drawn out and improvement benchm...Read post

  • Natural Unselection (It Takes Time…)

    Yes, it is getting more and more difficult for business owners to make decisions today that will positively impact their business, especially in the arena of digital marketing. You might say “bull hooey” and protest that it has become easier. And you’d be half fright… Nothing is more frustrating to a business owner that not understanding something that should otherwise be “easy” to do so. That’s where misguided trust and blind recommendations become so darn appealing. Attend a 20 Group and you just might be amazed as to how eloquent an otherwise inept presenter can be. We live in a world of regurgitated content, many times so prolific that anyone can claim it to be theirs. Car dealers and executive management, typically, know what has been and possibly what is happening now.  They’re still overwhelmingly blind to what is going to happen, even though it’s in front of their eyes. And smartphones. However, the chasm that exists does so simply because the dots aren’...Read post