Community

Share your automotive expertise

2 Write a Blog Post

Filed in: Marketing, General Mgt

The Battle: Facebook VS Google+ [Infographic]

By Eric Miltsch on Sep 5, 2013

Most people may simply look at the headline and proclaim Facebook as the winner based on size and user base. Don't be so quick to judge without taking a good look at the key characteristics of both platforms. Grasping the differences can help shape your content strategy as well as the tactics used to connect with users. 

Notice, and understand, the differences with regards to the how users behave within these networks. Facebook has become a personal escape for many; checking in on your friends' activities, benign updates about their daily rituals and a seemingly never ending stream of game invites. Google+ has almost positioned itself as a place to escape Facebook and connect people with more related interests with their ability to easily build your Circles. 

The demographics also tells an interesting story. Facebook has more females and a younger user base while G+ skews towards older males. 

Oddly, the infographic below doesn't mention Google+'s Knowledge Graph, but it does reference Facebook's Graph Search. Both are keys elements of the semantic web, the future of search as it relates to adding more meaning to content and connecting personas with content for improveed search results. Still early stage stuff, but important enough to be aware of as it develops and user behavior slowly shifts.

Ultimately both platforms offer tremendous opportunities for dealers. Marketers need to continue creating experiences that enable social users to explore and connect within a deeper layer of the social exploration spectrum. 

 Facebook vs. Google+

Infographic credit: SocialAnex 

Comments

While I (begrudgingly) agree that G+ is a (last on the list) necessary social platform for businesses, some of the data here is very misleading. Particularly when considering things like daily active users. One must consider the type of user; the percentage of fake accounts, etc. Remember, figures lie and liars figure ;)

Also, the suggestion that Google + effects organic SEO is speculative and not based on fact (However Google + does affect Organic seo for personalized results according to Matt Cutts). Lacking from this comparison is also a similar speculation that shares and posts on Facebook affect organic SEO. This too is speculative and not factual.

Context is everything here. Should a social media strategy include G+? Maybe... Maybe even a really strong maybe. Should it include Facebook? Without question.

Sep 8, 2013

Comments 1 - 1 of 1

You must be logged in to comment

Login Create an account

Add your comments:

   

Eric Miltsch's Recent Posts

Related Posts

  • Why are dealers not completing their staff pages with photos?

    This is just a short rant, but I see this all the time.  If you go to a dealer's website, and look at the "Meet our Staff" page you might see something like this:  A single name and phone number, and possibly an email address, with a big black silhouette where a photo should be.  Sometimes there will be just a single person as a contact, sometimes you can see multiple black silhouettes filling the page.  How have you not gotten around to adding a photos yet?  My guess is that some dealers do not think that is important.  I think this sets the stage for how you view digital marketing.  One of the ground rules to succeed in digital marketing, is to treat digital customers the same as "real world" customers.  Don't give them less service, don't wait to respond to them, or treat them as any less important than customers who stop into your dealership.  Having photos on your website is part of this as well. It is hard enough to establish a personal connection with someone by email...Read post

  • Canadian Dealership’s Reality TV Show Comes to DrivingSales Event

    At DrivingSales we advocate that dealers operate transparently to cultivate trust with their customers. You cannot get more transparent than have a nationally broadcasted reality TV show in your dealership. Ride Time in Winnipeg, MB (that’s in Canada for you southerners) was the backdrop for the reality show The Bargain Brothers on Business News Network (BNN). Two brothers Andrew and Doug MacIver are the stars and owners of the dealership with their family making up a large portion of their staff. Needless to say having the camera running all the time in a family owned dealership makes for some interesting moments. However, the self declared “Bargain Brothers” see their dedication to telling their story through TV and social media as a way to stay in the forefront of their customers’ minds. “Branding is a point of differentiation for every dealership,” says Andrew MacIver. “It's how you're perceived in the local market and often tells the tale of how you do business. W...Read post

  • Service Dilemmas: What Would You Do?

    Every dealership has seen this customer—the one who demands to be reimbursed for damage they claim happened while the car was in the dealership’s care, or because of faulty service work. You might find it challenging to deal with these customers, especially when you don’t believe your team is at fault. So what is the best way to handle them?   To help answer this question, I have compiled a couple of scenarios. I happen to know how these cases were handled, and I will share the results in my next blog. But first I want your feedback on what these dealerships should’ve done. These are both 100% real events involving simple oil changes that happened just this past Memorial Day weekend. So, my question is: What would you do?   Scenario #1:   A customer brought their vehicle into the dealership the Friday before Memorial Day weekend for a routine oil change. As part of the check-in process, the service advisor rolled down the window to prevent the keys from getting locke...Read post

  • Do Press Releases Still Have SEO Value?

    The quick answer to the question is not so much anymore. These days press releases are branding, validation, and credibility tools for companies, not SEO tools.  Quite simply it means PR firms are shifting the focus of how they utilize press releases for their clients.   Companies have been utilizing press releases for over 100 years.  Initially a press release was a way to get information to the news media.  They were rarely seen by the public and were not created to be an advertisement. The point was to get the media’s attention about a story or news worthy event gets them to write about it. To accomplish this, organizations had to write a release that had real news value.   The Internet, along with media channels, blogs and social networks, has changed the press release landscape.  Company branding, pushing content, infographics and press releases became a tool in the SEO arsenal. This shift led to a glut of releases that were no longer “real news,” but promotional c...Read post

  • Recipe for Success: Mixing Technology with your BDC

    We live in exciting, crazy times--and these times have drastically changed the way we sell and service cars. I was in High School in the early 90’s, still using a typewriter, and taking notes with pen and paper. Cell phones were just becoming more common, and the first text was sent in 1992.  Today there will be 36 billion texts sent worldwide. In just a little over 20 years, this technology has literally exploded and dramatically shifted the way we communicate. Things have changed. And the automotive industry has been greatly affected by these changes. According to an article in Strategy&, just a decade ago electronics and technology accounted for less than 20% of total costs spent in the industry. Today, it is at least 35% or higher, and 90% of all new features deal with technology--more specifically telematics. It is easy to assume much of what we do will be digitized, automated, and technologically enhanced. There are new tools created every day which help with many of o...Read post

  • Your customers talk...so listen!

    Moral of the story - listen to your customers! If they know something, they're not always lying (we've all heard the phrase, 'buyers are liars,'). Give them some credit - some of them are honest and just trying to make the whole process easier! What do you think? Have you run into any scenarios where you think listening to a customer would be beneficial?Read post

  • Increase Sales through Conquesting Consumers Motivated by Open Recalls

    Following tremendous pressure from the NHTSA, Takata has expanded the recall on its faulty airbags. In fact, it just doubled the number of vehicles that are subject to recall to 34 million – that’s one in seven vehicles on the road today – and the largest recall in automotive history. Since then, consumers have been flooding the NHTSA website, searching to see whether their vehicles are affected. In fact, according to an article in Automotive News, daily website traffic increased by 62 times -- to an incredible 598,000 searches, up from 9,662 per day. Consumers want answers and, once they get them, they’ll be looking to dealers to help them.   Be prepared for a large surge in recall-related questions and ensure that you have answers for your customers. Due to the incredible volume and the reported shortage of parts, there is not much dealers can do to expedite parts orders to handle these issues. But, most consumers will want their vehicles fixed as soon as possible, perha...Read post

  • Need a Raise? It’s Sitting Right In Front of You!

    Do you know anyone who would not say that they would like to make more money? I know I don’t! This does not surprise me, as I believe that money is a motivator for us all. Those who don’t admit it are lying about it. Depending on which source you trust, the average automotive salesperson in the U.S. makes anywhere between $38k and $61k per year - Glassdoor.com quotes an average of $47,852. We all know folks at the lower end of that spectrum, and many of us may know (or are ourselves) the superstar who makes far more than the upper end. But, for the most part, I think most would agree with me that car salespeople’s wages generally do not reflect how many hours they work. There is plenty of chatter on automotive blog sites and social media pages about pay plans, commission structure, doing away with commission altogether, scheduling flexibility, bonus and spiff compensation, blah, blah, blah. Listen, it all comes down to this: You are trading with your employer; your time for their money! Read post