Community

Share your automotive expertise

2 Write a Blog Post

Filed in: Marketing

Your Facebook Page Insights are Inaccurate

By JD Rucker on Feb 23, 2013

Facebook Insights

If you run a Facebook page, you may or may not have noticed big changes in the numbers between August and December, 2012. For those who do not run many ads, the numbers were lower than expected. For those who run ads often, the numbers were likely higher than expected. This discrepancy led many to believe that Facebook was going to a “pay to play” model and despite reassurances by Facebook that this wasn’t true, the numbers told a different story.

Facebook discovered “a few weeks ago” that the insights reporting feature for pages was getting bad data. They were not counting views from the upgraded Android and iOS apps due to streamlining, while desktop views on sponsored posts were getting counted twice. They finally admitted to it today. The fix will be in place on Monday.

This is a minor bug that has caused major headaches to marketers. Those who are heavy on ads were seeing more impressions than they expected. If the results from these ads were poor, it’s hard to justify paying to present something to thousands of people if only a handful reacted. Conversely, those who use Facebook more organically or use the ads sparingly were made to believe that their efforts weren’t working. People adjusted strategies. Company owners and marketers complained. It was a mess.

While it looks like that (hopefully) going forward the right data will be displayed, it’s still a black eye for a company that is trying to position itself as a useful advertising platform. Google analytics have been around forever and haven’t seen the same level of bugs that Facebook insights have seen in a much shorter period. This is bad as Google Adwords budgets are the very dollars that Facebook is targeting. They want a chunk and they’re not doing a good job at proving that they’re worth it.

Perhaps most importantly, why are we finding out about this so late? If the data is inaccurate and being used by advertisers to measure success and failure, they should have divulged it the moment they discovered the problem. Instead, they kept it hidden until they fixed it. That’s not a good move for a public company that relies on user and advertiser trust.

What else is broken that we aren’t being told about yet?

Comments

I'd noticed the drop and like many assumed it was FB favoring paid advertising over organic engagement. Even if it's been "addressed" the lack of transparency is upsetting.

Feb 25, 2013

I've had a page for 6 weeks and find the statistic bewildering. I haven't advertised yet, my fans are growing steadily. I now have 100 fans, usually about 40-60 of them talking about posts, Previous posts have shown 45-90 views. This week I've had two for 150 and 350 however my reach has dropped from 800 to 500. The 2 posts didn't show up in my list of post statistics. The strange this is I haven't had anyone like the page who is a mutual friend of another follower. How is this possible? I feel like my posts make it to my fan and not to their friends although the last post of 350 said 300 was viral. Why haven't I seen an improvement in reach or even one fan join because of this.. I don't get it.

Feb 28, 2013

Comments 1 - 2 of 2

You must be logged in to comment

Login Create an account

Add your comments:

   

JD Rucker's Recent Posts

Related Posts

  • Creating an Effective Email Marketing Strategy for a World of Mobile Users

    Mobile phones are a fact of life, and are growing fast. A 2014 Pew Research Center study found that smartphone use among US adults grew from 35% to 56% from May 2011 to May 2013. With growth that fast, dealers need to think mobile – it is definitely the future of our business! Read post

    By Cobalt on December 17, 2014

  • Announcing: Dealer Engage Sonar

    Dealer Engage is excited to announce the launch of Sonar, a powerful lead tracking tool which provides complete behaviour and activity tracking to enable businesses to create highly effective targeted campaigns. Read post

  • 15 Candles On Our Cake

    Digital marketing company IMN (iMakeNews Inc.) celebrates its 15-year anniversary as a turnkey email newsletter and marketing service that helps automotive retailers create and distribute newsletters affordably, efficiently, and effectively. Read post

  • Inventory Photos – VDP Photo Ideas

    It’s common knowledge that a bulk of the selling on a dealer’s website occurs on a vehicle display page (VDP). Inventory photos of the actual vehicle are an aspect of a VDP that many dealers fail to give enough credit. Many times, this is the main selling point of the entire VDP! The first thing a dealer should do is look for stock photos in their website VDPs. These should be replaced with photos of the actual vehicle being sold as soon as possible. One does not need an expensive camera to take great inventory photos. Most modern cameras (including phone cameras) should suffice – provided the photos are all taken at uniform aspect ratios and in decent lighting. The best VDPs have 10 or more photos of the vehicle. The main photo should show the best angle of the automobile, and could be a profile shot or a 3/4 shot of the driver’s side. For dealers that are unsure of what other kinds of inventory photos to take, some options for exterior shots might include straight on, lowe...Read post

  • More Traffic or Better Converting Websites? Why Choose?

    In our blog post about the two ways dealers can increase leads, I talked about the differences between driving more traffic as a strategy versus improving your websites ability to generate leads from the traffic it's already getting. This is on our blog and obviously I'm going to lean towards our own expertise when posting to my website, but here I'd like to point out the obvious: you don't have to choose one or the other. Why can't we have both? When I was a sales manager, I would hear about how this advertising campaign brought in weaker traffic or that campaign brought in too little traffic. We were always searching for the goose that would lay the golden egg - better foot traffic and more of it! Now that everything has gone digital, the old complaints are manifesting in the form of lead generation. Driving more shoppers to your website can help you generate more leads and improving the way that website converts them can do the same. Let's look at the math to see which is bett...Read post

  • Don’t Be So Serious!

    A little over a month ago, a couple of employees at a car dealership in Illinois published a music video on YouTube titled “Keys In A Box,” which parodied a sketch from Saturday Night Live. These two individuals proceeded to have a great time and showcased their dealership in a creative and fun way. Their reward? Over 67,000 views in just one month, as well as compliments from Jalopnik, Edmunds and AdWeek. I wouldn’t be surprised if this helps place the dealership top-of-mind when a local customer is ready to buy their next vehicle.       Having fun with your branding and being creative with any videos can help you stay top-of-mind with your customer base. Think of the Volkswagen commercial that debuted a few Super Bowls ago – the one where the little kid dressed as Darth Vader and ran around trying to use the “Force.” It was a huge hit and created a lot of media interest and created quite a firestorm on social media.   But why do videos like these stay in our m...Read post

  • Pop Quiz - Are you a Jay Prichett dealership or a Phil Dunphy dealership?

    ABC's Modern Family takes on a controversial subject: How painful (really) is the dealership experience. This popular show should have dealers everywhere thinking about their own consumer experience. If you missed it, here's a short recap as well as questions you should be asking yourself to make sure you are not a "Jay" dealer.Read post

  • Software vs Strategy and the Power of Insanity in the Face of Oblivion

    From a business perspective, there's really only one choice for marketing vendors. Software sells. It's easier to sell to businesses, particularly in the automotive industry. It's easier to sell a software company to a larger entity. Software is scalable. Strategy is too confining. Strategy relies too much on people. It isn't scalable in most circumstances. Unlike software, the more that dealers start using a particular strategy, the less effective it becomes. Anyone wanting to build a successful digital marketing company in the automotive industry should definitely choose building software over building strategies. To build a company that's based upon strategies is absolutely insane. I like being insane. It's good for the digestion. Car dealers have the potential luxury of being able to take software and build strategies around them. Vendors can as well, but it's much riskier to do so. There are several companies who were built around the concept of supplying like-gated contests ...Read post