Community

Share your automotive expertise

2 Write a Blog Post

Filed in: Marketing

Your Facebook Page Insights are Inaccurate

By JD Rucker on Feb 23, 2013

Facebook Insights

If you run a Facebook page, you may or may not have noticed big changes in the numbers between August and December, 2012. For those who do not run many ads, the numbers were lower than expected. For those who run ads often, the numbers were likely higher than expected. This discrepancy led many to believe that Facebook was going to a “pay to play” model and despite reassurances by Facebook that this wasn’t true, the numbers told a different story.

Facebook discovered “a few weeks ago” that the insights reporting feature for pages was getting bad data. They were not counting views from the upgraded Android and iOS apps due to streamlining, while desktop views on sponsored posts were getting counted twice. They finally admitted to it today. The fix will be in place on Monday.

This is a minor bug that has caused major headaches to marketers. Those who are heavy on ads were seeing more impressions than they expected. If the results from these ads were poor, it’s hard to justify paying to present something to thousands of people if only a handful reacted. Conversely, those who use Facebook more organically or use the ads sparingly were made to believe that their efforts weren’t working. People adjusted strategies. Company owners and marketers complained. It was a mess.

While it looks like that (hopefully) going forward the right data will be displayed, it’s still a black eye for a company that is trying to position itself as a useful advertising platform. Google analytics have been around forever and haven’t seen the same level of bugs that Facebook insights have seen in a much shorter period. This is bad as Google Adwords budgets are the very dollars that Facebook is targeting. They want a chunk and they’re not doing a good job at proving that they’re worth it.

Perhaps most importantly, why are we finding out about this so late? If the data is inaccurate and being used by advertisers to measure success and failure, they should have divulged it the moment they discovered the problem. Instead, they kept it hidden until they fixed it. That’s not a good move for a public company that relies on user and advertiser trust.

What else is broken that we aren’t being told about yet?

Comments

I'd noticed the drop and like many assumed it was FB favoring paid advertising over organic engagement. Even if it's been "addressed" the lack of transparency is upsetting.

Feb 25, 2013

I've had a page for 6 weeks and find the statistic bewildering. I haven't advertised yet, my fans are growing steadily. I now have 100 fans, usually about 40-60 of them talking about posts, Previous posts have shown 45-90 views. This week I've had two for 150 and 350 however my reach has dropped from 800 to 500. The 2 posts didn't show up in my list of post statistics. The strange this is I haven't had anyone like the page who is a mutual friend of another follower. How is this possible? I feel like my posts make it to my fan and not to their friends although the last post of 350 said 300 was viral. Why haven't I seen an improvement in reach or even one fan join because of this.. I don't get it.

Feb 28, 2013

Comments 1 - 2 of 2

You must be logged in to comment

Login Create an account

Add your comments:

   

JD Rucker's Recent Posts

Related Posts

  • Netsertive Launches Innovative Fixed Operations Solution for Automotive Industry

    Netsertive, a digital marketing intelligence company that brings brands and local businesses together to win local customers, today announced the introduction of its Fixed Operations solution for automotive dealerships. Netsertive’s Fixed Ops solution harnesses the collective digital marketing insights of its national dealership network to help individual dealers maximize Service Department profits and reclaim local market share from independent service shops. Read post

  • Make a Resolution to Save Marketing Dollars

    As we quickly finish up January and move into the second month of the year, you may already be able to see the predicated trend of rising vehicle sales for 2015. Vehicle sales is the number one indicator of success in the auto industry from year to year. However, I’m sure there are a number of other metrics you use to determine your yearly success, like customer retention, CSI scores, RO count, revenue, etc. All of these key performance indicators are important to you and the success of your dealership. Due to the nature of our business, we always ask dealers to look at their marketing spend and cost per sale and service as a metric of success. For many of the dealers, we see an average marketing spend of $50,000 - $150,000, depending on the size of the store and allocated funds. At the core of our business, we strive to reduce a dealer’s marketing spend and find ways to drive down the cost per sale and service. Today, I’ll share five ways you can leverage our best practices and...Read post

  • Women Car Shoppers

    Women-Drivers.com recently released their 2015 US Women’s Car Dealership Report which contains the findings of their survey of over 3,450 women regarding buying vehicles and their car dealership experiences. Some interesting insights regarding women car shoppers can be gleaned from the results. To start, women car shoppers have increased overall. The most popular vehicles shopped include Volkswagen, Ford, Chevrolet, Jeep, and Buick, while the most popular vehicles purchased include Mercedes-Benz, Lincoln, Dodge, Jeep and Chrysler. In fact, numbers are up across the board – including increased leasing and servicing completed by women car shoppers. Where it gets interesting for digital marketers is that almost one third of women car shoppers surveyed reported that the dealership website was not helpful! Women in the survey visited on average 2 dealerships before making a purchase. Over half went by themselves in person to shop, and most of those that leave without purchasing never ...Read post

  • Build a Marketing Plan Around Funneling Car Shoppers to Your Website

    Targeting is the name of the game. Most dealers (and even some vendors) are really starting to embrace this concept. Gone are the days of illogically spent marketing budgets and shotgun techniques... ...at least we wish those days were gone. Unfortunately, they're not. Many vendors still promote bulk marketing practices and many dealers are still buying into it. Producing favorable numbers is easy. Taking qualified buyers and getting them to engage in a meaningful way with your dealership is harder, but there's a silver lining: you have tools available to you to target the right people and get them to the right venues. The Right Venue First and foremost, the best venue for producing more sales is your website. That's not to say that there's anything wrong with AutoTrader, Cars.com, or any of the other places where your inventory can be seen. However, any opportunity you have to take them to your website will yield more favorable results. Between social media advertising, search e...Read post

  • Top Brands Rated by Women | 2015 US Womens Car Dealership Report

    Our company has published it’s second annual report which showcases women are having empowering experiences at progressive car dealerships in the United States. Women are responsible for buying over 13 million cars at new car dealerships; that’s an impressive 36,000 vehicles a day. Dealerships have to literally change gears, advertising, amenities and their sales strategies to attract this powerful buying force. “It’s a very competitive industry” shares Women-Drivers.com President, Anne Fleming. “Women know they can buy a car anywhere in their respective city. It’s in dealer’s best interest to strategize and market to women. However, it takes more than just having a family female spokesperson.” The research in the 2015 US Women’s Car Dealership Report comes from over 3,450 women’s surveys from the company’s website. From these surveys, the company generates a Women Satisfaction Index® or WSI score. The range is from a 5.0 (the highest) to 1.0 (the lowest)....Read post

  • New Dealership Websites from Naked Lime Marketing

    Naked Lime Marketing has launched an all-new, comprehensive website platform for automobile retailers: Aptus Websites™. Naked Lime developed Aptus to help automobile retailers build a more effective digital dealership that supports a smoother, more flexible end-to-end retail experience for consumers.Read post

  • Auto Dealer Onsite SEO

    Although generally content is king when it comes to onsite SEO for car dealerships, the set text on a dealer's home, service, specials, contacts and other static pages also contributes to the site’s overall appearance in search engine rankings.  While adding content via an onsite blog is a suggested SEO maintenance strategy, dealers should also be making sure that these static pages are optimized as well. Most buyers aren't necessarily interested in the text at the bottom of an automotive dealership's home page.  Google, however, scans these pages and periodically caches them.  Of course, it’s optimal if these pages have slight content changes from time to time.  But if not, a dealer should at least make sure that all the cities they serve and all the services they provide are summarized on the home page.  It is not advisable to "keyword stuff" this text, but if key terms are worked into this text in a somewhat natural way, it can be of great benefit to a website's SEO rankin...Read post

  • CallSource Automotive Brings Industry-Leading Call Tracking and Management System to Australia

    Company to help Australian dealers improve call-to-conversion ratios with U.S.-patented system that generates an average of $320K+ in additional annual earnings for US dealers; Hyundai Australia first to roll out system to dealer network   San Francisco, Calif. - January 23, 2015 - CallSource, the U.S. leader in call tracking, management and training, announced today at the 2015 National Automobile Dealer Association Convention in San Francisco that it has launched its patented system in Australia. This will give Australian auto dealers access to the same tools US dealerships are using to significantly improve their call-to-conversion rates. Partnering with Australia’s Dealer Solutions, CallSource’s initial rollout is with Hyundai Australia’s dealer network. Dealers and OEMs spend billions of dollars generating leads – a vast majority of which come in as phone calls. CallSource data shows that a mishandled call results in the customer defecting to another brand more than 50...Read post