Community

Share your automotive expertise

2 Write a Blog Post

Filed in: Marketing

Your Facebook Page Insights are Inaccurate

By JD Rucker on Feb 23, 2013

Facebook Insights

If you run a Facebook page, you may or may not have noticed big changes in the numbers between August and December, 2012. For those who do not run many ads, the numbers were lower than expected. For those who run ads often, the numbers were likely higher than expected. This discrepancy led many to believe that Facebook was going to a “pay to play” model and despite reassurances by Facebook that this wasn’t true, the numbers told a different story.

Facebook discovered “a few weeks ago” that the insights reporting feature for pages was getting bad data. They were not counting views from the upgraded Android and iOS apps due to streamlining, while desktop views on sponsored posts were getting counted twice. They finally admitted to it today. The fix will be in place on Monday.

This is a minor bug that has caused major headaches to marketers. Those who are heavy on ads were seeing more impressions than they expected. If the results from these ads were poor, it’s hard to justify paying to present something to thousands of people if only a handful reacted. Conversely, those who use Facebook more organically or use the ads sparingly were made to believe that their efforts weren’t working. People adjusted strategies. Company owners and marketers complained. It was a mess.

While it looks like that (hopefully) going forward the right data will be displayed, it’s still a black eye for a company that is trying to position itself as a useful advertising platform. Google analytics have been around forever and haven’t seen the same level of bugs that Facebook insights have seen in a much shorter period. This is bad as Google Adwords budgets are the very dollars that Facebook is targeting. They want a chunk and they’re not doing a good job at proving that they’re worth it.

Perhaps most importantly, why are we finding out about this so late? If the data is inaccurate and being used by advertisers to measure success and failure, they should have divulged it the moment they discovered the problem. Instead, they kept it hidden until they fixed it. That’s not a good move for a public company that relies on user and advertiser trust.

What else is broken that we aren’t being told about yet?

Comments

I'd noticed the drop and like many assumed it was FB favoring paid advertising over organic engagement. Even if it's been "addressed" the lack of transparency is upsetting.

Feb 25, 2013

I've had a page for 6 weeks and find the statistic bewildering. I haven't advertised yet, my fans are growing steadily. I now have 100 fans, usually about 40-60 of them talking about posts, Previous posts have shown 45-90 views. This week I've had two for 150 and 350 however my reach has dropped from 800 to 500. The 2 posts didn't show up in my list of post statistics. The strange this is I haven't had anyone like the page who is a mutual friend of another follower. How is this possible? I feel like my posts make it to my fan and not to their friends although the last post of 350 said 300 was viral. Why haven't I seen an improvement in reach or even one fan join because of this.. I don't get it.

Feb 28, 2013

Comments 1 - 2 of 2

You must be logged in to comment

Login Create an account

Add your comments:

   

JD Rucker's Recent Posts

Related Posts

  • The Good. The Bad. The Ugly. The Crazy?

    How would you classify the results from your website specials? If you can honestly say that you are seeing GOOD results, chances are the process needed to get you there is UGLY. It’s a time consuming and pull-your-hair-out undertaking. If you are seeing BAD or UGLY results, then you might say that the process isn’t all that bad…why? Because you aren’t doing it! You either:  don’t believe that great specials pages can and will yield great results, or  you are just too busy to maintain them and the process is too overwhelming I sincerely hope that the majority of you who have ugly specials pages, or non-existent ones, fall under the latter category. Otherwise…well…you officially fall under the CRAZY category. Ugly, in this case, is fixable. Crazy is another challenge altogether. Read post

  • Digital Marketing tips for non-failure

    There are many digital marketing success articles out there, but not many focus on simply what not to do - which can be equally as important.  While most modern businesses should have digital marketing campaigns to acquire business, many will not understand whether the marketing is working, or even what kind of value they should be seeking from each channel. One digital marketing mistake to avoid is getting too caught up in the results of marketing tactics used, and not confirming that those results align to a business strategy.  A strategy would be comprised of an overall goal of the marketing such as gaining 25% sales growth by increasing online visibility, while tactics are the methods used to achieve said goal.  Many marketers get bogged down in rankings increases, high click through rates and high levels of engagement on social media while producing zero advancement towards a business goal. The reverse is also true.  Many digital marketing mistakes originate from companies w...Read post

  • New PostFacebook, YouTube and Instagram Upgrades

    Social Media News for the Week of July 27, 2015 New Facebook Video Tools for Businesses This week Facebook delivered updates to make up for some of the limitations released earlier in the year. The new video library gives users a centralized location to store and organize videos.   Improved upload flow now offers users the ability to customize video distribution options in order to reach a more targeted audience. For automotive dealerships, this offers yet another opportunity to reach a specific audience when it comes to sharing straight-off-the-lot news and updates. Facebook Secret Videos Users now have the added capability to add secret videos accessible only through a direct URL and aren’t searchable on Facebook. This is great for users who want to use Facebook to host videos to embed on third-party site, or share them with anyone who has the URL.  Direct your audience to a private video containing special offers or upcoming events without having to post it anywhere ...Read post

  • Use Data to Create Better Content

    According to a recent article in The Atlantic, soon reporters at two of the country’s leading newspapers will have access to the most basic type of digital analytics: They will be able to see web-traffic data for their own stories. That is, they will at least know how many people clicked on them, where they came from, and how long they lingered.   The Washington Post—in a concession to its reporters’ union—told journalists they would soon have access to this data, which they had long demanded. It also recently emerged that The New York Times would follow suit.   The crux of the argument was that the inability to view data on pieces they had previously written, prevented journalists from tailoring future content based on empirical data about the types of content their audience wanted. In addition, some suspected that the performance of their pieces could contribute to their compensation, future promotions and other job advancement opportunities.   Knowing your audie...Read post

  • Dealers, It's Time to Get 'Touchy-Feely' with Your Website Content

    The year was 2009. We were working on building out website content for a client and we wanted to get to know the different departments in order to personalize the content to make the visitors more likely to do business with them. A savvy General Manager taught me a lesson that stuck with me throughout my career. "We don't need to sell the dealership. We need to sell our website to Google," she said. "There may come a time when people read the crap we put on the pages, but that's not today." I didn't fully agree then, but I understood the point. It wasn't until very recently that I realized how right she was, particularly the last line. I was aware that website visitors do tend to go straight to inventory or specials, but I was always aware from testing that 14% of the visitors lingered on videos or read through content before moving on from or to the inventory. This 14% was why I didn't fully agree. Now, I realize how right she was. 14% is a drop in the bucket. Today, that number ...Read post

  • Navigating SEO: How to Improve a Content Page in 30 Minutes or Less

    ​​ Navigating SEO is a DrivingSales.com exclusive series by Timothy Martell, CEO of Wikimotive. In this series, Tim breaks down ways that car dealers can improve their SEO and offers insight into how it will benefit business.   One of the problems most dealership websites suffer from is a lack of truly unique content. I don't just mean the words on the page, though. I'm talking about the things that really sell people on your dealership, its service, and your product line.   Unfortunately, most website providers come with cookie-cutter designs, content, and page formatting.  So how do you improve upon that and make your pages stand out to visitors? In this post, I'll show you five ways you can take a page from zero to hero in 30 minutes or less.   Add Images and Video   It sounds like such an obvious answer, but images and video can be crucial components when creating content.   For instance, if you're looking to improve your service department's page, adding a...Read post

  • Why Every OEM Needs a “Me First” Relationship Management Strategy

    The relationship management trend among OEMs today is to drive positive review count on 3rd party sites such as Yelp in what we call a “spend to send” model. In this scenario, OEMs, either directly or through their franchised dealerships refer customers to these sites to write and read reviews. This makes sense, right? After all, consumers love these review sites and recent surveys have found that up to 88% of consumers trust online reviews as much as personal recommendations. But there’s a problem. In this strategy the OEM is paying (in marketing dollars) to send people away from its own consumer website and their franchised dealership websites to a 3rd party site where captive consumers are exposed to competitors’ reviews, new and used inventory, and competitor advertisements. While it’s a good idea for OEMs and dealers to be involved in reputation management related to 3rd party sites, there’s another strategy that will move the reputation needle faster, easier, and mor...Read post

  • Innovative Dealer Partners with Village to Increase Sales and Loyalty

    According to an article in Automotive News, one dealer in Illinois has come up with a pretty ingenious loyalty rewards program idea – to leverage taxpayer dollars to increase car sales, while also helping to support local businesses.   Glenn Bockwinkel, President of Acura of Libertyville, approached the mayor of his local town and proposed an idea that he pitched as a win-win for the village’s car dealers, local business, consumers and the city -- The Shop Libertyville Rewards program.   It works like this: Any customer that shops at a local car dealership is given vouchers which can be exchanged for $200 in gift certificates, redeemable at 86 local retail businesses. Or, the $200 can be used to purchase aftermarket products at the local dealerships themselves. The idea is to keep local customers from purchasing outside the area, which helps the dealers stay in business and provides the city with additional tax revenue. In addition, any local businesses that accepts these c...Read post