Share your automotive expertise

2 Write a Blog Post

Filed in: Marketing

Reputation Management is More than Just an Email

By JD Rucker on Dec 19, 2013

Online reputation has been a hot topic for a couple of years now. As solutions continue to emerge and the business of reputation management as a service expands, there's a dangerous trend that should be addressed.

Reputation management isn't about sending an email. It's not about filtering results by checking their sentiment first before directing them to the review sites. It's not even about trying to identify any challenges that they had with their experience. It's about making their experience strong from the start and learning from the challenges some customers pointed out.

First and foremost, stop blaming the customer. If they leave a bad review, it's not because they were just trolling. It's not because they get a kick out of burning businesses on Yelp, Google Local, or DealerRater. It's not even about them thinking they should have received a better deal than they got even if you gave it away. They were unhappy with the experience and there was something you could have done differently to prevent them from leaving a bad review. Learn from it.

Once you get the customer-is-to-blame mentality out of your head, it's time to figure out how to collect and address the feedback. Yes, emails help here. They're not the cure, but they're a good thermometer. While there are plenty of filtering services out there that send a "survey" first before asking for feedback, these are dangerous and will someday be shot down as the devious technique that they are.

In case you're not familiar with them, here's how they work:

  1. Customer receives a survey in their email asking about their experience
  2. Their replies are collected by the reputation management system and sorted between positive and negative sentiment
  3. If the sentiment was positive, they are sent an email asking them to share their experience on review sites like Yelp
  4. If the sentiment is negative, they're sent an apology email with a link to give direct feedback to the owner or general manager

This all seems like a good process until you realize that the review sites don't like this. They rightfully believe that it's manipulation of reviews and it's one of the primary culprits in their war on "fake" reviews. According to Yelp:

"No, you shouldn’t ask your customers to post reviews on Yelp. For one thing, most businesses tend to ask their happiest customers to write reviews, not the unhappy ones."

They are correct and it's the main reason that so many businesses work hard (or pay good money) only to find that their Yelp reviews disappeared. It's simply not a good practice to find out whether or not your customers are going to burn you before asking them to write a review for you.

The most important thing that any business can do to improve their reputation is to accept the feedback, positive or negative, and apply a two-step process. First, share the feedback with employees. If it's good, let them know as much about the situation as possible and why it turned into a positive review. If it's bad, do the same thing but offer suggestions that could have prevented the negative feedback from happening. This is important whether the feedback comes directly to the company or if it's posted online.

Second, you'll want to reply to reviews. Every review. EVERY review. Positive, negative, indifferent - if someone takes the time to give you feedback about your business whether it's on a public site or directly to you, it is your responsibility to reply. If it's positive, humility and appreciation are in order. They're your customers - the lifeblood of your business. If it's negative, professionalism and empathy must apply. Remember, how you reply to negative feedback is often the most important aspect of reputation management. People don't expect any business to be perfect. You can go a long way towards impressing people with how you handle the bad situations as much if not more than the benefits of getting good reviews.

Reputation isn't a star rating. Reputation management isn't an email. In this golden age of digital, you have at your fingertips the ability to learn how to improve your business practices from the very people that do business with you. Are you listening to them?

Article originally posted on Business2Community.


One term that can be used in Reputation Management is "Domino Effect". Yes either way positive or negative there is a Domino effect - probably more so on the Negative end. When consumers do not get the experience they are looking for they WANT to tell others. They feel it is their duty to. I agree that it is all the elements in being proactive that can give the consumer the best experience possible.

Dec 20, 2013

Comments 1 - 1 of 1

You must be logged in to comment

Login Create an account

Add your comments:


JD Rucker's Recent Posts

Related Posts

  • Creating a Culture of Communication

    Great Communicators Have Meaningful Conversations Creating a culture of strong communication can make or break your dealership.  And great communicators just seem to have a way with people. Strong leaders understand the importance of good communication for building strong partnerships and are able to authentically connect with customers.  People gravitate toward people who are good communicators when it’s time to get information. Good communicators master the art of reading people, and understanding what’s driving their interaction. Meaningful Conversations Matter Today’s consumers and employees crave communication and are looking for meaningful interactions in the marketplace. According to Mashable, 83% of people do online research before buying a car, with 81% of consumers being less likely to purchase from an aggressive salesperson. We’ve all learned authenticity is key when connecting with individuals in today’s fast-paced world, so how do you help your sales p...Read post

  • 3 Ways to Acquire On-Line and In-Market Car Shoppers

    When a shopper comes into your dealership, you can almost be guaranteed that they have done their research and in fact, the majority of their purchase decision has already been made. Here are 3 ways to be considered at the very beginning and throughout the car purchase journey.Read post

  • Google Map Pack Update: 5 Thoughts on the New Design

    Local SEO has become one of the most important focuses in the digital marketing community. This means it's only natural for everyone to take notice and rethink strategy when Google makes an update to its local Map Pack results. In its latest update, which occurred around August 6, 2015, Google redesigned the Map Pack to fit with its mobile design scheme and reduced the maximum number of results from 7 to 3. A lot of business owners went to sleep seeing their business on page one, but woke up completely pushed off. As SEOs and business owners, what are you supposed to take away from this change? In this post, we'll explore five of the most important thoughts and takeaways from the latest Google Map Pack update:   Local Rankings Matter Even More While it's always been important to rank #1, it's more important than ever to ensure your business actually shows up within the map pack, as there are now only 3 positions available on the initial SERP. (In order for users to see more r...Read post

  • What Are You Doing to Reach Mobile Customers?

    There’s no doubt that people are in love with their phones.  As a result, memes and jokes constantly circulate the Internet about how some people no longer participate in “normal” activities because they simply can’t put down their phones. People aren’t reading newspapers anymore - at least not in print - and they’re fast-forwarding through commercials. So where are they? You guessed it. On their phones.    In a recent article on, a respected publication that covers the global digital ecosystem: digital marketing, media and commerce, it was reported that 2015 is “a benchmark year for ad spending in the US, as mobile surpasses desktop spending for the first time.”     In fact, eMarketer estimates that mobile will account for almost 52 percent of all digital spending by the end of the year. It attributes the shift to consumer demand and estimates that adults spend almost 3 hours per day on “nonvoice activities” on mobile devices – 1.5 hours...Read post

  • Why Does Offering Service Valet Increase RO Value by 20%?

    Why do customers who do not visit the dealership spend 18% more on auto service? Evidence and armchair psychology support our analysis. I recently published a case study about the effects of service pick-up and delivery (service valet) on loaner turn time.  You can read the paper . (Spoiler alert: Loaner turn time was reduced by approximately 1.2 days, or over 40%.) The study had a few other gems.  Among them, analysis showed customers who used service valet had RO values 18% higher than those who did not use service valet. Theoretically, these service valet customers  could have had more expensive repairs but that is not likely given the large sample size. Instead, our longstanding experience shows service valet customers purchase more recommended services. So this begs the question:   Why do customers who do not visit the dealership spend 18% more on auto service? Evidence and armchair psychology support our analysis.  Consider the psychology from the customer’s viewpoi...Read post

  • Mike Martinez of DMEautomotive Selected to Present at the 2015 DrivingSales Executive Summit

    Martinez’s presentation “GRO Your Bottom Line” selected by auto dealers in a highly competitive process; joins an agenda with four award-wining authors and other industry experts Daytona Beach, FL – October 6, 2015 – Mike Martinez, Chief Marketing Officer of DMEautomotive and AutoPoint, has been selected to present at the seventh annual DrivingSales Executive Summit (DSES), one of the largest gatherings of progressive dealer executives, on October 19th at 11:15 AM at the Bellagio Las Vegas. Martinez’s presentation “GRO” Your Bottom Line was selected by a panel of dealers in a highly competitive process, in which only 1 in 3 applications was accepted.    Martinez joins a powerhouse DSES agenda that includes a Harvard Business School faculty member, leading search marketing and content marketing strategists, branding experts and technology visionaries, and award-winning authors. The DSES has sold out every year since inception and hosted over 1,000 attendees last y...Read post

  • Myth: Negative Comments are Bad For Biz

    Many businesses have avoided social interaction for fear that an existing bad reputation, or possible negative comments will come back to bite them.  These ideas may be true if the issues are left unchecked, but for a business that is highly active on social media, negative comments can turn into a positive experience. Legitimate customer comments around a product or service will definitely start to pop up when a business decides to start regularly using social media to promote their business.  Many of these could be negative comments which may cause some alarm to those not well-versed in the ways of social media marketing.  However, there is one simple solution - use social media as a platform to address customer issues head-on and allow customer service to shine. Rather than hiding legitimate concerns or negative comments, a business should provide a thoughtful response with options to further assist a customer via phone or email.  Also, someone should follow up internally to e...Read post

  • Navigating SEO: The 4 Most Important Factors to Dealership SEO Success

    Navigating SEO is a exclusive series by Timothy Martell, CEO of Wikimotive. In this series, Tim breaks down ways dealers can improve their SEO and offers insight into how it will benefit business.   While there are thousands of articles that talk about search ranking factors, the majority of your site's success will come down to a few core factors. Ensuring you've got those boxes checked is what ultimately allows you to have the best search presence in your market.   In this post, I'll go over four of the most important factors that determine SEO success for car dealers, while offering tips and tricks to help you improve your site, grow organic traffic consistently, and sell more cars as a result.   Website Architecture   By now, you all know how important it is to actually have a website. There's just no contesting this in 2015. But beyond simply having a website, it's important that your site is developed and designed to allow it to comply with curren...Read post