Share your automotive expertise

2 Write a Blog Post

Opinion: As R.L. Polk considers a sale, CARFAX still faces major challenges.

By Jeremy Alicandri on Mar 16, 2013

REQUIRED DISCLAIMER: This article is based on the opinions of the author and nothing contained herein should be construed as a matter of fact.

At least from my perspective, it seems 2013 is proving to be a difficult year for the folks at CARFAX. After years of being the nation’s top VHR provider, the company is facing serious challenges. Since I began blogging about CAFAX, there have been major developments. These developments include a controversial Automotive News story, a potential anti-trust lawsuit seeking treble damages, and a 20/20 investigative report that nationally portrayed CARFAX’s reports as misleading. But wait! There’s more! CARFAX’s parent, RL Polk, announced the company is for sale!

Last year, I published near 10 pages of material outlining what I felt was wrong with CARFAX’s business model. However, I’m going to keep this post short by just providing my opinions and insights of some of the more recent developments:

  • 20/20 Story – While I enjoyed the investigative journalism, from an industry expert’s perspective, I didn’t learn anything new. Both CARFAX/AutoCheck have limitations –neither report is infallible. However, the 20/20 report substantiated(opinion) my November 30 opinion to OEMs where I wrote: “I feel the OEMs are distracting their branding efforts from the reliability of their own certification programs and instead attempting to substantiate the reliability of their vehicles by promoting their association with CARFAX. This is a dangerous practice for OEMs since associations with CARFAX will also associate the OEM’s brand with issues that plague CARFAX.” Ok, so now what? In my opinion, I believe this 20/20 story is just another wake-up call for the car manufacturers to better brand their own Certification programs and reduce their dependence on co-branding with companies like CARFAX.
  • Potential Anti-Trust Lawsuit – Leonard Bellavia is building momentum for an anti-trust lawsuit against CARFAX. From what I understand, Bellavia is claiming that CARFAX used exclusive agreements with OEMs and other companies to force dealers to pay premium charges for VHR reports. Apparently, dealers who join Bellavia’s suit are seeking treble damages. I won’t provide legal advice, but Bellavia provides detailed information on his suit on this website: (scroll down for the red CARFAX box)
  • R.L. Polk For Sale (or IPO) – While a company executive is quoted as stating: “There was no catalyst that made this happen,” I naturally have my opinions as to why Polk is looking for a new home. Given AutoTrader’s canned automotive IPO, and other factors, it’s my opinion that Polk’s announcement is probably more about finding an exit plan for its owner Stephen Polk vs. an actual IPO. I’m not sure if Mr. Polk wants to retire or continue with his business, but I don’t feel there is Wall Street IPO appeal for this niche company – especially with all the looming issues. But I do feel Polk could be a great acquisition for a big data firm. With that said, I’d like to add that I never met Mr. Polk, but I did have one interaction with him via e-mail that left me with a favorable impression. I do know people who describe him as a friendly and classy industry veteran.


If you want to read a more detailed analysis of my coverage of CARFAX, and related articles, below is a timeline of events that started on October 3, 2012 with my first published CARFAX post:

CARFAX Timeline:


*The dates indicated above are right. Any correction, or update to a published post on will change the date on the post’s page, thus causing a discrepancy if you compare both. So please refer to the original dates posted above.


I did like the fact that the consumer advocate on 20/20 rightly mentioned that consumers should still check out the vehicle (i.e. their mechanic). I know that for years I have volunteered to drop the vehicle off at the customers mechanic so it can be checked out and almost none of them take me up on it. I'm sure it is part trust in our operation, but it is also laziness on the consumers part, which is what i see with Carfax. Instead of accepting the Carfax "guarantee" and its many holes. He should have mentioned getting a guarantee in writing, not unlike a certification warranty. On the very rare occasion that a vehicle slips through the crack, the increased trust and sales would more than make up for the hit of a repurchase. MN Dealer

Mar 19, 2013

CarFax has the best system to address concerns associated with negative online entries in the CarFax database. If you have a concern that a specific CarFax entry (in their database) is inaccurate then address the issue on their website by clicking on the "Data Correction Form" link on their home page. They will investigate the issue and communicate with you until a resolution is reached. Their resolution staff is the best in the industry and their system to resolve these issues is exceptional. Yes, there are errors in both CarFax and AutoCheck information databases but the resolutions can be reached if you spend the time to address the issues. There are more positives then negatives associated with CarFax and their staff will genuinely attempt to help you if you give them a chance.

Mar 19, 2013

I think the main issue with the 20/20 report was that the consumer could not detect the issue because it was not in the CARFAX database.

Mar 20, 2013

As always - fantastic coverage jeremy. Looking forward to seeing you next month in NY!

Mar 20, 2013

Thanks Jared!

Mar 21, 2013

Excellent coverage...keep it coming. Thanks.

Apr 4, 2013

Comments 1 - 6 of 6

You must be logged in to comment

Login Create an account

Add your comments:


Jeremy Alicandri's Recent Posts

Related Posts

  • How Employee Causes Can Help Increase Volunteerism

    Auto/Mate has been recognized for six years in a row as a "Best Place to Work" by the Albany Business Review and four years in a row as a "Top Workplace" by the Times-Union. One of the perks Auto/Mate offers is eight hours of paid volunteer time to every employee. To encourage employees to use the time and get involved in the community, Auto/Mate organizes groups to identify and participate in local charities.   Ronald McDonald House   Kelly Shaw, a payroll benefits specialist with Auto/Mate, discovered the Ronald McDonald House when her own child was in the hospital. "I started making small dinners, or cookies and cakes, and dropping them off at the hospital," Shaw said. "When I realized that some of the parents were from out of town and were staying at the Ronald McDonald House, I started bringing food over there."   Shaw's involvement with the charity grew and her manager at Auto/Mate encouraged her to get fellow employees involved. When Shaw posted flyers asking for volunt...Read post

  • Dealers Must Streamline their Retail Process to Meet Consumer Need

    Today’s consumers dictate the customer experiences they want and brands are listening. Think about Amazon. You can literally tweet your order to them and it will be at your house in 2 days. In some markets, they’ll deliver your order in an hour. Why has Amazon become the behemoth that it is today? Because it has leveraged technology to create the most efficient retail experience possible. No matter how you want to purchase a product, Amazon provides it. Want to order from their website? Done. Via a mobile app? Done. By tweeting to them? Done. Amazon has become so powerful that they have disrupted many industries. The U.S. Postal Service never delivered mail on Sundays… until Amazon told them to. Just think about that for a minute. How did one company become so powerful that an organization started in 1775 allowed Amazon to change the way they operate?   Because consumers demanded it.   Almost every industry has adapted to increasing consumer demand for easier transactions...Read post

  • Auto/Mate Receives a “Best Places to Work” Award from the Albany Business Review Six Years Running

    Albany, N.Y. – November 9th, 2015 – Auto/Mate Dealership Systems ( announced today that it has been named a "Best Places to Work" in New York State’s Capital region by the Albany Business Review. Auto/Mate was one of nine companies honored in the medium-large category (companies with 50 to 149 employees). It is the sixth year running that Auto/Mate has received the award.   "Many business leaders focus on customer satisfaction, but at Auto/Mate we focus on employee satisfaction," said Mike Esposito, President and CEO of Auto/Mate. "When employees come first and you have happy employees, you will always have happy customers."   This year the Albany Business Review honored 36 companies in four categories. The winners are chosen based on results of an anonymous employee survey conducted by Quantum Workplace, a Nebraska based research firm. This is the 12th year of the award, which allows companies to showcase their work environments and is highly compe...Read post

  • Jennifer Briggs has been named Director of Dealer Strategy of ZMOT Auto

    MONTEREY, CA -- the Cardinale-Group of companies is pleased to announce that Jennifer Briggs has been named Director | Dealer Strategy of ZMOT Auto, effective immediately. In this role, Ms. Briggs will provide ‘Dealer to Dealer’ leadership of digital retail integration and performance management to ZMOT dealer clients within the United States, Canada and Mexico. With more than 13 years of professional leadership experience in retail sales, marketing, operations and finance, Jennifer is sure to provide ZMOT Auto dealer clients with remarkable guidance and success throughout their entire digital strategy. “On behalf of our entire group, we are very pleased that Jennifer has chosen to join our ZMOT Auto team. We have watched her career flourish over the past many years, and we appreciate her tenacity, decisiveness and bold vision of continuous improvement within the automotive retail industry”, said Erich K. Gail, COO of the Cardinale-Group of companies and CEO of ZMOT Auto. “...Read post

  • Three Things Auto Dealers Can Learn From the Kardashians

    How did Kim Kardashian become so famous? Ten years ago, she was a regular Los Angeles socialite, just like hundreds of other socialites. She wasn't the most beautiful socialite, and she wasn't an actress or model. She didn't invent anything. She didn't have any noteworthy talents to speak of. Her only claim to fame was that she was friends with, and a personal assistant to, Paris Hilton; so in 2007, a leaked sex tape featuring Kim attracted some minor media attention.   Kim's manager and mother Kris knows a thing or two about branding. The Kardashians leveraged the friendship with Paris and the leaked sex tape to build a social media following for Kim and get as much publicity as possible, which soon after led to a reality television show. The rest is history. Today Kris is still largely in control of the Kardashian brand and rules it with an iron fist. The Kardashians are brilliant brand marketers/Read post

  • Helion Releases Free eBook: Cyber Crimes Happen to Auto Dealerships Without Warning. Are you Prepared?

    Timonium, MD -- November 2nd, 2015-- Helion Automotive Technologies, a leading provider of information technology (IT) solutions for auto dealers, announced today the release of a free eBook for auto dealers, titled: Don't Get Cyber-Clobbered! Cyber Crimes Happen to Auto Dealerships Without Warning. Are You Prepared? The eBook shares recent data and examples of the growing number of "hack attacks" that threaten customer data at auto dealerships nationwide. The eBook also presents a series of "good, better and best" security defenses that auto dealers can implement to ensure their data--and money--stay safe.   "One cyber attack that successfully steals customer information from a DMS database can cost a dealership anywhere from one hundred thousand up to a couple million dollars," said Erik Nachbahr, President and CEO of Helion Automotive Technologies. "Dealers are struggling with security because the type of threats that exist are so numerous and change so rapidly that it's almost...Read post

  • Authenticom Solutions Group Hires Brown as Senior Sales Executive

    LA CROSSE, WI – Authenticom is pleased to announce the hiring of Jeffrey D. Brown, Senior Sales Executive. A long-time resident of the La Crosse Coulee Region, Jeff brings a wealth of sales experience in the automotive industry to the Authenticom Solutions Group. After graduating from the University of Wisconsin-La Crosse, Jeff Brown has been working in and outside of the automotive sales capacity for over 12 years. Brown spent over five years with as a Senior Advertising Sales Consultant, where he provided expert-level insights to dealer principals to help boost sales and improve ROI. He has also worked in roles calling on automotive and auction customers for industry giants such as Manheim, Cox Automotive and to manage all aspects of dealer relationships and consult with decision-makers to analyze needs and effectively deliver value-added technology solutions. Read post

  • Auto/Mate Releases Free eBook: The Auto Dealer's Ten-Step Guide To Hiring the Best Employees

    Albany, N.Y. – October 26th, 2015 – Auto/Mate Dealership Systems ( announced today the release of a free eBook titled "The Auto Dealer's Ten Step Guide to Hiring the Best Employees." The eBook reveals the bottom line costs associated with a bad hiring decision, and shares best practices to help auto dealers avoid common hiring mistakes so they can hire long-lasting, loyal employees.   In 2014 the average turnover rate for sales consultants in dealerships was 72 percent, while the average turnover rate for all employees in dealerships was 39 percent. In non-luxury dealerships, the average sales turnover rate skyrockets to 80 percent, according to the 2015 NADA Dealership Workforce Study. Additionally, 28 percent of all terminations happened within the first 90 days and 41 percent of sales turnover happened within 90 days.   "These statistics tell us that many dealers are making common hiring mistakes such as hiring too quickly, not having an established...Read post