Community

Share your automotive expertise

2 Write a Blog Post

Too Little, Too Late?

By Jim Bell on Aug 23, 2011

 

When is it too little too late for a dealership?  Honda of San Marcos recently ran an auction on eBay for a 2009 Nissan GT-R.  The winning bid was at $55,100.  There was a ‘mistake’ on the listing within the auction and the final auction price wasn’t going to be honored by the dealer and they were offering the customer the same vehicle for $59,000.  Later, the dealership said that they would honor the winning bid and it was their mistake. 

I am all about dealers being successful, especially Honda dealers since I work at one.  Unfortunately, this dealer is hurt and is going to feel the hurt for a while over this ‘mistake’ on their eBay listing.  Their online reputation is completely shot and currently has 61 reviews with a 1.5 star rating.  There is now a Facebook page with 829 ‘likes’ that is bashing the dealership.  Honda of San Marcos actually shut their Facebook page down and is inactive due to this and opened another Facebook account where you have to request friendship with them.

So when is it too little too late?  When you have a mistake within management, you must own up to it.  Unfortunately, this is not what they did.  They did admit right off the bat that they had made a mistake and put it on the listing agent who was off for the week, but they didn’t own up to it and offered the vehicle to the customer for almost $4,000 more than the winning bid.  They shouldn’t have dodged the phone calls from the customer on that Monday morning.  This may take a while for their online reputation management to get back up to par.  Yes, a lot of the reviews happened after the auction ended, and who knows how many of them are legit.  They will have to sort through all of this with Google and Dealerrater and the other online review sites that they have been bashed on. 

Honda of San Marcos will have to come up with a plan to overcome the hurt that has been placed on them.  They will have to get every one of their happy customers to try to bury all of the negative comments. 

You can read the whole story here with the customer comments and responses from Honda of San Marcos.     

Comments

There is nothing for a dealership to even think about here. When you auction cars on eBay you need to know exactly what you would do in a situation like this and do it instantly. Great post Jim. After reading this, I'm sure lots of dealers know what they would do and how fast they would do it.

Aug 23, 2011

I think the point here is that the response needs to be TIMELY and RELEVANT. Years ago there would always be the one picketer who may show up and someone would immediately go out and determine whether to address their issue, ignore it or call the Police. There is no lag time luxury in todays world. The Highway your located on is Digital and therefore worldwide. Whether this was to be honored or not, addressing it immediately and a pre-emptive Press Release may have been well advised. Now their "Dealer name" sucks page has their only social presence. Ouch! Probably not even a true reflection of the majority of their customer's experience.

Aug 23, 2011

Exactly what I was trying to get across Brian.

Aug 23, 2011

Comments 1 - 3 of 0

You must be logged in to comment

Login Create an account

Add your comments:

   

Jim Bell's Recent Posts

Related Posts

  • If Your Employees are on a Need to Know Basis, Here's What You Need to Know: Your Employees Aren't Motivated

    What's the most important skill a great leader must possess? Above all, I believe the ability to communicate is critical to the long-term success of any business. Specifically, leaders who communicate effectively with their employees benefit from higher levels of employee engagement and morale. The more engaged employees are, the more motivated they become, providing more value to the organization all around.   As a leader, are you communicating effectively? Most leaders don't get to be in leadership positions without good communications skills, so your first instinct may be to answer in the affirmative. But the focus of effective communications is less about your style of communication, and more about what information you choose to communicate.   Here are recommendations for the type of communications that leaders should be sharing with their employees:   1) Share your vision. Every leader has a vision for their company. You know your organizational goals cannot be achieved w...Read post

  • Increasing Shop Productivity with the Right Equipment

    Whether you are working in a huge warehouse or a cozy garage, you naturally want to use the hydraulic auto lift that is best suited to your unique needs. For decades, professionals were compelled to make the most of very limited lift options. However, modern workers have access to innovative alternatives of which you may not even be aware. Using the proper equipment for your situation will allow you to work more efficiently, and you may want to consider some of the following choices. In-Ground Lifts The earliest lifts were comprised of holes dug into the ground, with ramps installed above them to allow light to penetrate the viewing area. These may seem uninteresting to someone who is looking for a futuristic-looking piece of machinery, but in-ground lifts are actually very effective and are still common today. They require very little space and are ideal for any size garage. Hydraulic scissors or pistons are sometimes added to increase versatility, combining modern technology with t...Read post

  • DSES 2015: DrivingSales Innovation Cup Application Deadline Fast Approaching

    If you’re a vendor with a bright idea that will help dealerships win at business, the Innovation Cup is for you. We realize there are hundreds of vendors working hard to provide dealerships with products and services that allow them to sell more cars and service more vehicles, which is why the contest was created. We would like to reward the most innovative idea of the year and by providing a platform for dealers to vote on who had the most innovative product/service. The Innovation Cup allows vendors to stand infront of the most progessive dealers in the country and compete head-to-head for the Innovation Cup. The DrivingSales Innovation Cup contest is held during a DSES general session and uncovers the Most Innovative Solution of the Year. Five automotive vendors finalists are invited on stage to present their solution/product and compete head-to-head with each other. A panel of on-stage dealer judges reviews each solution with the competitors, then determines the winner of the...Read post

  • LeBron James & The Cleveland Cavaliers: A Story of Loyalty

    There’s no better story about the perils of loyalty than that which played out in the summer of 2010. At the time, Lebron James was the most desired free agent in all of basketball. For the prior two seasons, he had been pressured by fans to announce whether he would stay with the Cavaliers, or leave for another team. Cavalier fans were intensely loyal to James, who was a first-round pick in 2003. He proceeded to showcase his talent over the course of seven years in Cleveland by making six all-star teams and brought the Cavaliers to their first ever NBA Finals.   In early July 2010, Lebron made his decision. With a great amount of publicity, including his own nationally televised special named “The Decision,” Lebron broke the hearts of Cavalier fans and the city of Cleveland when he announced that he was joining Dwayne Wade and Chris Bosh with the Miami Heat. Fans labelled him as selfish and the owner of the Cavaliers issued a scathing public announcement. Fans expressed the...Read post

  • “Hello?” What is Wrong with Our Phone Calls?

    What happened to phone etiquette? Is texting to blame for our apparent lack of interest in voice-on-voice interaction, and our apparent amnesia about how the conversation should flow? I’m blown away every time I call a business and receive an answer of “Hello?” It happens fairly frequently and each time I’m sure the recipient can feel my discomfort when I have to ask, “Am I speaking to XYZ Company?” Usually that’s all it takes for the tone of voice to change and the switch flipped to business mode with a swift and perky, “Um, Yes! This is Carl with XYZ, how may I help you?” On occasion however, you have to go through Round 2, and its excruciatingly poor form. “Hello?” “Hi, I’m trying to reach XYZ Company, is this the correct number?” “Yes.” “Uhhh… great, can I speak to someone in sales?” “Yes, hold please.” [INSERT EXPLITIVE HERE] What in the world is going on? Often it’s easy to tell you’ve reached a business person on their mobile...Read post

  • The Irony of Simplicity in Choice for Discerning Dealers

    Consolidation is happening. We see it in the automotive industry all the time. Large dealer groups are getting larger. Big vendors are getting bigger. This adds a level of simplicity for dealers as they make decisions for operations, marketing, and processes. The irony is that this is something the industry needed six years ago when the recession was starting to turn the corner and dealers were making choices on their own. In many ways, there were too many choices. Consolidation back then might have been a good thing. Dealers were forced to fend for themselves and as a result, the "discerning dealers" chose to modernize their procedures and decision-making capabilities. In other words, they started hiring and training to meet the demands of the digital age. They hired new people or trained old ones who understood Schema.org, responsive design, and behavioral targeting. If they didn't know what geofencing was, they researched it. Many dealers today know more about the various produc...Read post

  • What the rise in "Near Me" Searches means for Dealerships

    In a recent post on Think With Google, a compelling study shows how "Near Me" type searches are on the rise and not just for retail and restaurant locations either. High consideration searches such as those for car dealerships are also on the rise.Read post

  • Igniting Ideas – Fueling Collaboration

    Dealers across the country report over 50,000 new car sales each day. Each sale represents the end of a customer sales journey. Over weeks – or even months – each customer conducts research, interacts with brands, and ultimately moves through the process of completing the sale. Dozens – if not hundreds – of dealers, OEMS, vendors and companies influence the customer along the way. For example, in the media alone, competing advertising messages impact the customer at each level:  OEM, Dealer Association, and individual dealership. The path to purchase is complex, and yet, it all comes together. One sale at a time. The complexity of our cross-tier community sparked the idea for this column. My goal is to building a community where people in our industry can come together and strengthen collaborative relationships across the tiers - especially between dealers and OEMs. This column is quite literally meant to spark conversation, ignite ideas, and fuel collaboration. What wi...Read post