Community

Share your automotive expertise

2 Write a Blog Post

Too Little, Too Late?

By Jim Bell on Aug 23, 2011

 

When is it too little too late for a dealership?  Honda of San Marcos recently ran an auction on eBay for a 2009 Nissan GT-R.  The winning bid was at $55,100.  There was a ‘mistake’ on the listing within the auction and the final auction price wasn’t going to be honored by the dealer and they were offering the customer the same vehicle for $59,000.  Later, the dealership said that they would honor the winning bid and it was their mistake. 

I am all about dealers being successful, especially Honda dealers since I work at one.  Unfortunately, this dealer is hurt and is going to feel the hurt for a while over this ‘mistake’ on their eBay listing.  Their online reputation is completely shot and currently has 61 reviews with a 1.5 star rating.  There is now a Facebook page with 829 ‘likes’ that is bashing the dealership.  Honda of San Marcos actually shut their Facebook page down and is inactive due to this and opened another Facebook account where you have to request friendship with them.

So when is it too little too late?  When you have a mistake within management, you must own up to it.  Unfortunately, this is not what they did.  They did admit right off the bat that they had made a mistake and put it on the listing agent who was off for the week, but they didn’t own up to it and offered the vehicle to the customer for almost $4,000 more than the winning bid.  They shouldn’t have dodged the phone calls from the customer on that Monday morning.  This may take a while for their online reputation management to get back up to par.  Yes, a lot of the reviews happened after the auction ended, and who knows how many of them are legit.  They will have to sort through all of this with Google and Dealerrater and the other online review sites that they have been bashed on. 

Honda of San Marcos will have to come up with a plan to overcome the hurt that has been placed on them.  They will have to get every one of their happy customers to try to bury all of the negative comments. 

You can read the whole story here with the customer comments and responses from Honda of San Marcos.     

Comments

There is nothing for a dealership to even think about here. When you auction cars on eBay you need to know exactly what you would do in a situation like this and do it instantly. Great post Jim. After reading this, I'm sure lots of dealers know what they would do and how fast they would do it.

Aug 23, 2011

I think the point here is that the response needs to be TIMELY and RELEVANT. Years ago there would always be the one picketer who may show up and someone would immediately go out and determine whether to address their issue, ignore it or call the Police. There is no lag time luxury in todays world. The Highway your located on is Digital and therefore worldwide. Whether this was to be honored or not, addressing it immediately and a pre-emptive Press Release may have been well advised. Now their "Dealer name" sucks page has their only social presence. Ouch! Probably not even a true reflection of the majority of their customer's experience.

Aug 23, 2011

Exactly what I was trying to get across Brian.

Aug 23, 2011

Comments 1 - 3 of 0

You must be logged in to comment

Login Create an account

Add your comments:

   

Jim Bell's Recent Posts

Related Posts

  • First-Ever Women in Automotive Convention to Debut in 2015 – Industry Pioneer named as Keynote Speaker

    Orlando, FL – The inaugural Women in Automotive Convention will take place this summer with the purpose assisting the automotive community in recruiting, retaining and developing female employees and leaders. Women make up just 17% of employees at auto dealerships according to NADA – and organizers of the conference are working diligently to raise this number, beginning with this event. The conference is set for Tuesday-Thursday, August 18-20 at the Ballroom at Church Street in Downtown Orlando. The three-day conference includes speakers, breakout sessions, workshops and booth displays – all centered on the goal of educating and inspiring women in all areas of the automotive industry. Keynote speaker, Lisa Copeland, has been a pioneer in the field of automotive marketing and management for more than 25 years. She is currently Managing Partner of Fiat of Austin, the top Fiat retailer in North America since the brand’s return. “The topic of women in the automotive industry h...Read post

  • New Community Feature – Featured Columns

    ​Our mission at DrivingSales is to bring you the network, education and practical insights to advance your careers and your business’ performance. I am pleased to announce a new program to support this mission – featured columnists from leading research houses and consultancies who will bring insights from all aspects of automotive to the community for discussion, debate and application. Read post

  • Auto/Mate Receives Platinum Award in Auto Dealer Monthly's Dealers' Choice Awards

    ALBANY, N.Y. – May 18th, 2015 – Auto/Mate Dealership Systems (http://www.automate.com) announced today it has received a Platinum award in the 2015 Auto Dealer Monthly Dealers' Choice Awards. This year marks the second time that Auto/Mate has received a top ranking in the publication's annual award program, which recognizes the industry's best product and service providers. Winners of the Dealer's Choice Awards are selected exclusively by dealership personnel, each of whom has to manually enter their partner companies' names.    "Our number one priority at Auto/Mate is to be the top DMS provider in customer satisfaction, and we have achieved that with a 97.5 percent customer retention rate," said Mike Esposito, President and CEO of Auto/Mate. "Our customers appreciate us because we make an effort to hire people who have worked in dealerships so we know what our customers are experiencing, and we empower our employees to take care of our customers first."   “This year’s a...Read post

  • ELEAD1ONE PRESENTED WITH TWO 2015 DEALERS’ CHOICE AWARDS

    ELEAD1ONE, the industry leader in customer contact management, CRM and dealership software for automotive retailers announced today it has been named the recipient of two awards presented by the publishers of Auto Dealer Monthly Magazine in the 11th annual 2015 Dealers’ Choice Awards. This is the company’s fifth consecutive win for the highest-ranking Diamond Award in Customer Relationship Management and the second consecutive win for Digital Marketing. Read post

  • Help Out a DrivingSales Car Guy in Need

    "I will tell you now, we had come to grips with the fact that Tamarra is dying and we would try to make the most of our time. Now, for the first time in years, we have hope...and for that my friends I cannot thank you enough. God truly works in mysterious ways and I feel blessed beyond measure." For years, Bryan Armstrong has been an incredible Community Editor for Driving Sales and a top-tier contributor to the automotive industry. He has helped many in and outside of the car business to find both joy and success, perpetually doing the right things for others. Whether it's helping someone new to the industry learn the ropes, guiding a vendor to improve their services for dealers, or adopting children into his family to give them a nurturing home, Bryan is the epitome of living life the right way. That's the Bryan Armstrong that we know and love, but there's another aspect of his life that has been very private for some time. His wife, Tamarra, has Superior Mesenteric Artery Syndro...Read post

  • ELEAD1ONE JOINS NIADA AS A NATIONAL CORPORATE PARTNER

    (ATLANTA) – ELEAD1ONE, the leader in customer contact management, CRM and dealership software for auto retailers today announced it has joined with the National Independent Automobile Dealers Association (NIADA) as a Bronze-level National Corporate Partner. With over thirty years experience in dealership software and customer retention strategies, ELEAD1ONE serves as a pioneer in the CRM space for automotive retailers. The award-winning CRM platform scales to any size retail operation to give Independent Dealers a fast, friendly and flexible solution proven to increase conversion and maximize every business opportunity. With the easy-to-use ELEAD CRM Flex platform, Independent Retailers will have access to: Read post

  • What We Can Learn From American Pharaoh

    How many hours per week do trainers work with a horse like American Pharaoh to prepare him to compete in and win the Kentucky Derby? It’s probably easier to measure in years, as thoroughbreds begin early training when they are too young to ride. Eventually, when they are two or three years old they actually move to the racetrack to live full-time and train there. Every day. For a race that will last no longer than two minutes! Then, if they are lucky and healthy and fast enough, they will take a day or two off before they begin training again for the Preakness and Belmont Stakes. And remember that only eleven horses have EVER won all three races – The Triple Crown. Eleven horses since 1919 and the most recent one was in 1978. My point? Many of us may have it backwards. We hire our salespeople, of whom many have never been “on the track,” and expect them to win. We make them run their race every day and stop to train them only occasionally. When they are no longer suited for the track, we promote them and expect them to train the young thoroughbreds and the cycle continues. Read post

  • Offer Value Above a Paycheck To Increase Employee Retention

    Automotive News recently reported that FCA will offer free college tuition to all FCA dealership employees. It will begin immediately in the southeast region and roll out to the rest of the U.S. by the third quarter. This move comes from a deal cut between FCA and Strayer University. According to the article, it potentially covers 118,000 employees. The program is FCA’s effort to increase dealership employee retention. Head of FCA’s dealer network, Al Gardner, states in the article that this is a big pain point for FCA dealers. He believes that this program will “give the dealerships a lever that no one else has.” He also believes that it will give FCA dealers a competitive advantage when a potential employee is considering job opportunities at other brands. And that it could attract job seekers who otherwise may not have considered a job in the auto industry.   It has been widely covered that there is a real shortage of well-trained technicians. And this is only becoming ...Read post