Community

Share your automotive expertise

2 Write a Blog Post

Too Little, Too Late?

By Jim Bell on Aug 23, 2011

 

When is it too little too late for a dealership?  Honda of San Marcos recently ran an auction on eBay for a 2009 Nissan GT-R.  The winning bid was at $55,100.  There was a ‘mistake’ on the listing within the auction and the final auction price wasn’t going to be honored by the dealer and they were offering the customer the same vehicle for $59,000.  Later, the dealership said that they would honor the winning bid and it was their mistake. 

I am all about dealers being successful, especially Honda dealers since I work at one.  Unfortunately, this dealer is hurt and is going to feel the hurt for a while over this ‘mistake’ on their eBay listing.  Their online reputation is completely shot and currently has 61 reviews with a 1.5 star rating.  There is now a Facebook page with 829 ‘likes’ that is bashing the dealership.  Honda of San Marcos actually shut their Facebook page down and is inactive due to this and opened another Facebook account where you have to request friendship with them.

So when is it too little too late?  When you have a mistake within management, you must own up to it.  Unfortunately, this is not what they did.  They did admit right off the bat that they had made a mistake and put it on the listing agent who was off for the week, but they didn’t own up to it and offered the vehicle to the customer for almost $4,000 more than the winning bid.  They shouldn’t have dodged the phone calls from the customer on that Monday morning.  This may take a while for their online reputation management to get back up to par.  Yes, a lot of the reviews happened after the auction ended, and who knows how many of them are legit.  They will have to sort through all of this with Google and Dealerrater and the other online review sites that they have been bashed on. 

Honda of San Marcos will have to come up with a plan to overcome the hurt that has been placed on them.  They will have to get every one of their happy customers to try to bury all of the negative comments. 

You can read the whole story here with the customer comments and responses from Honda of San Marcos.     

Comments

There is nothing for a dealership to even think about here. When you auction cars on eBay you need to know exactly what you would do in a situation like this and do it instantly. Great post Jim. After reading this, I'm sure lots of dealers know what they would do and how fast they would do it.

Aug 23, 2011

I think the point here is that the response needs to be TIMELY and RELEVANT. Years ago there would always be the one picketer who may show up and someone would immediately go out and determine whether to address their issue, ignore it or call the Police. There is no lag time luxury in todays world. The Highway your located on is Digital and therefore worldwide. Whether this was to be honored or not, addressing it immediately and a pre-emptive Press Release may have been well advised. Now their "Dealer name" sucks page has their only social presence. Ouch! Probably not even a true reflection of the majority of their customer's experience.

Aug 23, 2011

Exactly what I was trying to get across Brian.

Aug 23, 2011

Comments 1 - 3 of 0

You must be logged in to comment

Login Create an account

Add your comments:

   

Jim Bell's Recent Posts

Related Posts

  • Seven Mistakes Employees Make That Could Cost You Millions

    Recently an auto dealership experienced an all-too-common security breach. An employee in the accounting department received an email from someone who he thought was the dealer asking him to initiate a $30,000 transfer from the dealership's bank account to another bank account. The accounting employee complied with the request and it was discovered later that the email was a scam. Unfortunately, there was no way to retrieve the funds. This dealership has a state-of-the-art firewall and security software, but today's increasingly sophisticated hackers are finding ways to get through even the toughest defenses. The most common method for gaining access to a dealership's network and data is to trick or 'scam' employees. That's why it's so important to have a corporate security policy in place and to train your employees, so they don't make these mistakes: 1) Not verifying email addresses. Any time an employee receives a request to transfer money, check the sender's email address and be...Read post

  • If I Surround Myself with Champions, I Can't Help but Win

    I’m sure that every management team sits down on occasion to discuss ways to improve dealership operations. Whether that improvement has to do with sales goals, employee satisfaction, or simply lot appearance, typically what happens is that everyone is gung-ho about it and it kicks off great. Then, slowly that momentum dies and all of a sudden nobody is making an effort anymore. Sound familiar?   How many times has your dealership implemented a new technology, lead source, or any new initiative just to find that they don’t get used, or seem to fail? Sometimes we find ourselves scratching our heads in wonder. Perhaps it’s not the technology, but rather our team members aren’t following a process or using it improperly. It’s very easy to dismiss a new technology or process as ineffective simply because employees tell you it’s not working. In my experience, most of the time it’s not the technology or the newly launched process that’s the problem. The problem is usuall...Read post

  • Which marketing tactic gives the best ROI?

    People want to buy cars from people that they know and trust, and to achieve that one of the most important things is brand recognition. Not just recognition of the manufacturer but of you, the dealership. Without a strong brand all of your other marketing channels are weakened. Read post

  • Vast® Closes $14 Million Investment from Capital One Growth Ventures

    Austin, TX - February 09, 2016 -Vast, the data-as-a-service platform for autos and real estate, today announced a $14 million investment from Capital One Growth Ventures. Vast connects buyers and sellers of cars and homes through data-driven discovery experiences. CarStory.com, Vast’s consumer marketplace, utilizes the Vast data platform to understand consumer intent and match each shopper with the right vehicle. The investment by Capital One Growth Ventures will enable Vast to grow its CarStory® product footprint while bringing its big data platform to other industries such as real estate. As part of the investment, Jaidev Shergill, Managing Partner of Capital One Growth Ventures will join the Vast board of directors. “What Vast is delivering to consumers with its CarStory product is very intriguing to us at Capital One,” said Shergill. “Consumers expect more information at their fingertips and for that data to be personalized and customized. Big data technologies enable thi...Read post

  • [Infographic] 2015 Auto Industry Recap

    Six years ago US auto industry sales were struggling in the midst of a major economic downturn.  Fast forward to today and the industry is fresh off a record-setting year. In 2015, 17,470,659 vehicles were sold (a 5.7% increase from 2014) bringing in over $570B in revenue.  There were many factors contributing to the sales increase, including lower gas prices, lower interest rates, lossening lending standards, more purchase incentives (average incentive was $3,063 last year), as well as more older cars on the road.  Domestic cars dominated the truck category, while imported vehicles experienced 146% more sales in the car category.  The Ford F-Series remained the best-selling vehicle in America for the 34th consecutive year.  But, this is just the tip of the iceberg. There was a mountain of data collected at the end of 2015, and the team at Rawhide has distilled a lot of it into the infographic shown below. Find out which car categories experienced the greatest year-over-year g...Read post

  • Auto/Mate Announces Integration with Scan123, Saving Auto Dealers Money While Improving Productivity

    Albany, N.Y. – February 1st, 2016 – Auto/Mate Dealership Systems today announced the integration of its dealership management system (DMS) with Scan123's electronic document management system. Auto dealerships using Scan123's solution can now store documents in, and retrieve documents from, Auto/Mate's Automotive Productivity Management Suite (AMPS) DMS. The integration helps auto dealers transition to a paperless environment, streamline workflow and comply with federal law.   "The ability to instantly retrieve information from a DMS allows employees to quickly answer inquiries from partners and customers, increasing productivity and customer satisfaction," said Mike Esposito, President and CEO of Auto/Mate Dealership Systems. "With a document management solution, your employees may never have to say, 'let me look that up and get back to you' again."   "Integrating our system with Auto/Mate's DMS was inexpensive and relatively easy due to the Open/Mate integration program, wh...Read post

  • Is Uber Shooting Itself in the Foot with Surge Pricing?

    Ever popular transportation service Uber is coming under fire for what some say is an exploitative business practice. Uber tends to be a convenient and economical way to get around town – especially for inner city dwellers that don’t own vehicles and travelers who don’t necessarily need a rental car.   In an effort to encourage drivers to work during busy times to ensure that Uber customers don’t receive a “No cars available” notice, Uber instituted surge pricing. In essence, surge pricing is a multiplying factor based on demand. Let’s say you need a ride home from downtown New York City on New Year’s Eve, after watching the ball drop. Chances are great that with 2 million people trying to get home, there won’t be many taxis or Ubers available. In these cases, Uber surge pricing has been known to grow upwards of 9 times the normal fare. Revelers found this out this past New Year’s Eve when they woke up to find they had paid $205 for an 8 mile ride. Or, in one m...Read post

  • Is This the Red-Headed Stepchild of Your Dealership?

    We all know that feeling when you walk into an auto dealership that's on top of its game. The interior is gleaming. The exterior is impeccable. The service department is clean and humming. The sales staff is professional, organized, and hitting their goals. Even the coffeemaker is state of the art!   But I know a secret. In many dealerships, in the back rooms and behind the walls, lurks a red-headed stepchild. An afterthought. Often overlooked, it only gets attention when it causes a problem.   That red-headed stepchild is your information technology (IT) strategy. Let's face it. You're probably not devoting as much time to it as your Daily DOC, checking the numbers daily, weekly and monthly to ensure you're on track. You're probably not showing it off like those fancy software programs you invested in to help you achieve your sales and service goals.   I understand the red-headed stepchild can be complicated. You know how important it is, but you're just not sure what to do w...Read post