Community

Share your automotive expertise

2 Write a Blog Post

Filed in: None

To Spiff or Not to Spiff? That is the Question!

By Ron Henson on Jan 9, 2013

Ok, full disclaimer.  I know that this is a polarizing topic in dealerships everywhere.  That having been said, without bias to either side, I would like to present an argument for both sides and see where the community lands.  Hilary Clinton once said, "Freedom means the right of people to assemble, organize, and debate openly.

So, SPIFF.  A dirty word to some dealers and a heavenly gateway to results for others.

Position A: I have spoken with many dealers who take the position that their sales consultants are very well compensated within the confines of their pay plan and should be expected to perform to certain standards without cash bonuses playing a part.  One dealer also expressed the very analytical opinion that the additional expense generated in manpower required to track such cash bonuses and assure that they are properly accounted for in payroll for tax purposes was not worth any "lift" they would receive from offering them.  Phew, quite a mouthful indeed.  And furthermore, (Yes, he had more to say) offering spiffs is like giving your consultants Crack Cocaine!  Give it to them one time and they are addicted.  

Position B: I heard it said by more than one GM in my NADA General Dealership Management class (Many moons ago)  that if they offer up a Saturday morning $100 spiff for the 1st unit sold, oldest unit sold, and for a hat trick, they are guaranteed to have a good day.  In fact, many sales consultants will chase that "Cash in Fist" so hard they will stack appointments for Saturday!  (Hmm, does that statement belong in position A?)  Someone even went so far as to say that he would offer a full commission at the end of the month or a 50% cash spiff on the spot in lieu of said full commission. (I do not advocate that for accounting and payroll legality reasons but it was his store surprise)  Any guesses on how many opted on the "Cash on the spot?"

In conclusion, I have my own thoughts about spiffs but I throw this debate out to the Ultra Intelligent DrivingSales community for a healthy discussion on what your position is......... TO SPIFF OR NOT TO SPIFF?

Let's move some metal!

 

Comments

Wow, Ron, what a great topic. I completely understand the sentiment about paying someone already to do their job, so spiffs seem over the top. And once you give a mouse a cookie, he's going to want some milk. However, I think one of the most important things in a leader is knowing what motivates your people. Everyone is motivated differently and it's not uncommon for average salespeople to be strongly motivated by money and short-term accomplishment. In this case, spiffs would seem a viable option. Of course, if your pay plans are set up differently or you know your team doesn't thrive in that setting, spiffs would be obsolete. Great question, Ron!

Jan 10, 2013

Once again and as usual, Lindsey Auguste is dropping the knowledge. Way to go Lindsey!

Jan 10, 2013

As we progress in this digital age, what about "spiffing" people to grow the business digitally? For example, "spiff" a guy at the morning meeting who put an idea out there that worked.

"Hey, let's video our sales guys Sunday morning run and put it on YouTube showing what we're like outside of the business."

Offer incentives to think outside the box....and watch as the ideas start to flow - even from an older team that's not very tech-savvy.

Jan 11, 2013

Well said Kyle! I like the way you think

Jan 11, 2013

Comments 1 - 4 of 4

You must be logged in to comment

Login Create an account

Add your comments:

   

Ron Henson's Recent Posts

Related Posts

  • Think Broadly For Automotive PPC

    While looking for specific long tail keywords that convert for the lowest cost is imperative in any PPC (Pay-Per-Click) campaign, automotive PPC has an extra set of issues to deal with. Many times, potential zero moment clients still use basic terms to search out and ultimately purchase a vehicle. SEM (Search Engine Marketing) approaches are often geared towards avoiding basic one or two word keywords, instead opting for laser specific long tail terms that indicate buying signals. Unfortunately, this becomes a tad more nuanced when dealing with automotive PPC because many customers will perform an extremely basic search looking for the nearest dealership in order to see its available inventory, and ultimately submit a lead and purchase a vehicle. Thus, while no true buying signals might be present in a given search, clients may still use those broad queries in search engines to find places to purchase. Another issue frequently arises because manufacturers and competing dealerships re...Read post

  • The Mobile Tipping Point

    For those of you who have never heard of the phrase tipping point, there are a lot of variations in terms of a definition - depending on who’s asking. To physicists, the tipping point is when an object gains enough nuclear material to sustain a chain reaction at a constant rate. To computing geeks/experts, “The tipping point is the critical point in an evolving situation that leads to a new and irreversible development.” To a “car guy” it could be when a customer walks into your showroom five minutes before closing time on a Saturday. We have all had a few of those. According to TechTarget, marketers define the tipping point as “a threshold that, once reached, will result in additional sales.”Read post

  • Seven Mistakes Employees Make That Could Cost You Millions

    Recently an auto dealership experienced an all-too-common security breach. An employee in the accounting department received an email from someone who he thought was the dealer asking him to initiate a $30,000 transfer from the dealership's bank account to another bank account. The accounting employee complied with the request and it was discovered later that the email was a scam. Unfortunately, there was no way to retrieve the funds. This dealership has a state-of-the-art firewall and security software, but today's increasingly sophisticated hackers are finding ways to get through even the toughest defenses. The most common method for gaining access to a dealership's network and data is to trick or 'scam' employees. That's why it's so important to have a corporate security policy in place and to train your employees, so they don't make these mistakes: 1) Not verifying email addresses. Any time an employee receives a request to transfer money, check the sender's email address and be...Read post

  • Gorillas, Balloons and Wavy Tube Men. Oh My!

    Our industry does a lot with gimmicks. You’d be hard pressed to drive through an auto mall or other area dense with dealerships and not see balloons, giant inflatable gorillas or wavy tube men. On nice days, we attempt to lure shoppers in with hot dogs and sodas. We incentivize test drives. We offer televisions, iPads and Playstations with purchase. There’s always a gimmick just waiting to be unleashed on our customers. But do any of these really attract (and keep) business? Sure, they might get someone’s attention. However, I highly doubt someone has ever decided to buy a car simply because they saw a gorilla on your roof.   We’re faced today with increasing competition. No longer are you simply competing with the dealerships in your PMA. Shoppers are able to buy cars online, through vending machines and, soon, straight from a GM pool of 30,000 cars. The ability to REALLY attract business lies not in the gimmicks you can throw in front of your dealership, hoping to attrac...Read post

  • Domain Explosion | Spammy?

    ARE DOMAIN EXTENSIONS SPAMMY? "1 of 5 Part Series" By: Grant GooleyRead post

  • Don't Let Fear Hijack Your Test Drives

    I’ve been in the automotive industry since I was 18 years old and the one thing that has remained the same, no matter what technology has been introduced, is the value of a test drive. Our research proves that including a test drive into the sales process is imperative. But lately test drives have been taking a beating. From the idea that millennials want an entirely online transaction without the test drive, to the kidnappings in recent news, test drives are getting a bad rap. We’re seeing safety concerns ramp up in our industry, from vehicles stolen during the test drive to a recent situation where a salesperson was actually kidnapped and physically harmed. While the safety of employees should be first and foremost on the minds of dealership management, we cannot let this critical step fall through the cracks of the process out of fear. If we stop giving test drives, our salespeople will be missing out on the biggest value builder available to them.  So much so, that only 4% of ...Read post

  • BREAKING NEWS: 2016 U.S. Women’s Car Dealership Report | Insights from Progressive Dealers

    This week, hot-off-the press, we’ve got the 2016 U.S. Women’s Car Dealership Report, showing how progressive car dealerships make a difference in the experiences of women and families. This national report shows what is important to women when shopping, buying and servicing their vehicles. The information in this report is drawn from over 4,000 women’s reviews and opt-in surveys. Using the reviews, Women-Drivers.com generates a Women Satisfaction Index® (WSI Score), ranging from a high of 5.0 to a low of 1.0. The surveys are used to delve deeper into women’s shopping, buying and servicing experiences. This information is specifically generated from dealerships certified through Women-Drivers.com based on the customer reviews. These progressive, forward-thinking dealers use the company’s platform to improve sales and service experiences for their women clients. Dealers who participate, continually evaluate the data an consumer intel they receive to ensure they maintain high...Read post

  • Dealerships Can Now Add and Switch Between Multiple Instagram Accounts

    In the past, anyone managing an Instagram account for a dealership, if they had a personal account, had to log out and log back in to switch accounts. This was a tedious process. Now, that is no longer the case. Instagram announced that users can now quickly and easily switch between multiple accounts. How to add multiple accounts 1.  Go to your profile and tap the settings button in hte top right 2.  Scorll down and tap Add Account 3.  Enter the username and password of the account you'd like to add  To switch between accounts you've added:        1.  Go to your profile 2.  Tap your username at the top of the screen 3.  Tap the account you would like to switch You can add up to 5 accounts.  ...Read post