Community

Share your automotive expertise

2 Write a Blog Post

Filed in: None

To Spiff or Not to Spiff? That is the Question!

By Ron Henson on Jan 9, 2013

Ok, full disclaimer.  I know that this is a polarizing topic in dealerships everywhere.  That having been said, without bias to either side, I would like to present an argument for both sides and see where the community lands.  Hilary Clinton once said, "Freedom means the right of people to assemble, organize, and debate openly.

So, SPIFF.  A dirty word to some dealers and a heavenly gateway to results for others.

Position A: I have spoken with many dealers who take the position that their sales consultants are very well compensated within the confines of their pay plan and should be expected to perform to certain standards without cash bonuses playing a part.  One dealer also expressed the very analytical opinion that the additional expense generated in manpower required to track such cash bonuses and assure that they are properly accounted for in payroll for tax purposes was not worth any "lift" they would receive from offering them.  Phew, quite a mouthful indeed.  And furthermore, (Yes, he had more to say) offering spiffs is like giving your consultants Crack Cocaine!  Give it to them one time and they are addicted.  

Position B: I heard it said by more than one GM in my NADA General Dealership Management class (Many moons ago)  that if they offer up a Saturday morning $100 spiff for the 1st unit sold, oldest unit sold, and for a hat trick, they are guaranteed to have a good day.  In fact, many sales consultants will chase that "Cash in Fist" so hard they will stack appointments for Saturday!  (Hmm, does that statement belong in position A?)  Someone even went so far as to say that he would offer a full commission at the end of the month or a 50% cash spiff on the spot in lieu of said full commission. (I do not advocate that for accounting and payroll legality reasons but it was his store surprise)  Any guesses on how many opted on the "Cash on the spot?"

In conclusion, I have my own thoughts about spiffs but I throw this debate out to the Ultra Intelligent DrivingSales community for a healthy discussion on what your position is......... TO SPIFF OR NOT TO SPIFF?

Let's move some metal!

 

Comments

Wow, Ron, what a great topic. I completely understand the sentiment about paying someone already to do their job, so spiffs seem over the top. And once you give a mouse a cookie, he's going to want some milk. However, I think one of the most important things in a leader is knowing what motivates your people. Everyone is motivated differently and it's not uncommon for average salespeople to be strongly motivated by money and short-term accomplishment. In this case, spiffs would seem a viable option. Of course, if your pay plans are set up differently or you know your team doesn't thrive in that setting, spiffs would be obsolete. Great question, Ron!

Jan 10, 2013

Once again and as usual, Lindsey Auguste is dropping the knowledge. Way to go Lindsey!

Jan 10, 2013

As we progress in this digital age, what about "spiffing" people to grow the business digitally? For example, "spiff" a guy at the morning meeting who put an idea out there that worked.

"Hey, let's video our sales guys Sunday morning run and put it on YouTube showing what we're like outside of the business."

Offer incentives to think outside the box....and watch as the ideas start to flow - even from an older team that's not very tech-savvy.

Jan 11, 2013

Well said Kyle! I like the way you think

Jan 11, 2013

Comments 1 - 4 of 4

You must be logged in to comment

Login Create an account

Add your comments:

   

Ron Henson's Recent Posts

Related Posts

  • Defining the Digital Advertising Buzzwords That All Dealers Should Know

    Every industry has its own proprietary vocabulary to meet the unique demands of the work. Digital advertising is no exception. And since digital ads are nascent relative to the entire history of outbound marketing, confusion and misinformation are likely to surround the terminology that is helping shape the practice. So what are the digital advertising buzzwords you ought to know? We can help. We’ve compiled a glossary containing some of the most commonly used digital advertising terms. Read post

  • Keeping your customers happy and employees engaged through proper training

    Recently I was called by a dealership about a previous employee. Of course we were able to discuss how well he preformed for me in a lot of the typical advisor critical measurements along with some of the areas that needed some improvement. Overall this was a young service advisor that has a great head on his shoulders and does really well with the customer. Typically he was the top producing service advisor on our Honda service drive among four other talented service advisors. I wanted to share with you why I was not able to give my previous employee a “go ahead” nod to his future employer and why I explained to the service director on the other line a glairing cause for concern. It all boiled around his willingness to train and continue his growth early on in his career. Right now you may be questioning the head on my shoulders but I wanted to explain the reason “why” a good training program can teach you so much about how a potential employee will fair in todays service driv...Read post

  • Why I Quit my 25 Year GM Job: My Exciting New Adventure into Online Deal Creation

    How can it be possible that I would leave a job I LOVE after 25 years?   The fact is that I have always liked to be ahead of the curve and today’s customers are rewarding evolving dealerships that offer true Online Deal Creation with real perfect payment – where all that is left is the test drive. Don’t believe this can be done? Well, I am convinced that it can – and the results prove it. In fact, after 35 years, I have decided to leave the world of automotive retail to join my wife, Kim Orr, and her team, to build our automotive industry marketing/branding company, DealerSuccess, into a tech heavyweight. Kim and her team spent the last year launching CloudEngage, an extraordinary geo-technology product. We have now ramped up to launch Virtual Deal, an online deal creator for the consumer that uses an innovative perfect payment DMS-integrated technology.   For the last 25 years I have worked at Dick Hannah Dealerships, most of the time as a GM for the Honda store. Whil...Read post

  • The Last Piece of the Digital Marketing Puzzle: Inter-Vendor Communication

    Pointing fingers. It's something that everyone at the dealership who has dealt with vendors over the years has experienced from time to time. The website provider to the inventory provider. The Inventory provider points to the pricing tool. The pricing tool points to the DMS. The DMS points to the website provider. Can't someone just fix it? I'm going to keep this short so my day doesn't start off in anger. Vendors need to stop pointing fingers and start fixing things. That doesn't mean pointing fingers at the perceived source of the problem. That means making calls, sending emails, and using smoke signals if necessary to bring everything together the way it should be rather than waiting for the dealer to call these guys so those other guys can do something that allows this guy to help that guy. It means communication. We require communication directly with other vendors that service our clients. It's the way it should be. We can often get things done much more quickly. There's no...Read post

  • Joe Orr Leaves Beloved 25 Year Career as Top Auto Dealership GM To Pursue Online Deal Creation as DealerSuccess CEO

    After 35 highly-successful years, automotive industry powerhouse, Joe Orr, has left the world of automotive retail to follow his passion. Orr is now the CEO of DealerSuccess, an automotive industry marketing/branding company. He has joined the team full-time to help build it into a tech heavyweight, with the launch of VirtualDeal, an Online Deal Creator for the consumer that uses an innovative perfect payment DMS-integrated technology. Orr spent the last 25 years at Dick Hannah Dealerships, where he redefined the role of a General Manager in the 21st century. He helped build the group, and its Honda dealership, into one of the largest in the North West. While working as GM, Orr served on the creative team with DealerPeak to totally re-create and re-brand their Online Deal Creation tool for his Honda store. He fell in love with the product and decided to leave automotive retail so as to further develop this tool (now Virtual Deal) for use in auto dealerships. Orr now works with his team at DealerSuccess to offer consulting and other revolutionary products that are meaningful to both dealerships and consumers. As a true entrepreneur and visionary, Orr is addicted to opportunity and can always be found on the forefront of new technology. He is a driving force in progressive digital initiatives and a strong advocate for winning dealership solutions and processes that, if followed, ensure success. “How can it be possible that I would leave a job I LOVE after 25 years? The factRead post

  • How to Create Better Content in Less Time

    One of the problems most individuals and businesses face with content production is the amount of time it takes to create great content. Whether you’re a nutritionist trying to build an incredible blog, or a car dealer that wants to improve your automotive SEO, content takes a lot of time and it can oftentimes feel like there’s never enough of it to do quality work. In this post, I’ll provide step-by-step details on how you can stop feeling overwhelmed by and start creating better content in less time:   Do Research in Bulk If there’s one thing that slows down content production, it’s on-the-fly research. You should be gathering resources and taking notes before committing to anything substantial. Not only will this help you better understand the topic at hand, it will allow you to reference things quickly without getting lost in a sea of resources. You need to have a plan ahead of time in order to efficiently produce content. In the end, bulk research also helps yo...Read post

  • Digital Marketing Journey....What's Next?

     We have a Hyundai store that has been in business for quite some time. We have always had a straight talk branding message in our advertising efforts. We have also had always a very generous budget to work with. About four years ago we really started working on our digital presence. While we started these efforts a little behind everyone else we have outpaced most of the dealers in our area. We started by looking at the processes that we have in place at the dealership. We needed to make sure that the leads were being handled properly. Once these were in place, we started working on our SEO for site. We took a long term approach to this along with our digital vendor. We also started working with our website vendor and tweaked our website. Once we had the site looking good we started spending money on sem advertisements. Originally all of our efforts were directed at Google. Once we started looking good on Google we started to tackle Bing. W...Read post

  • Dealers Taking Control of DMS Data & Operating Costs

    Operating margins for dealers continue to be razor thin with requirements for set rate financing and automobile sales and service pricing transparency driving these trends.  Taking control of certain operational functions is simple and logical for dealers to eliminate unnecessary expenses and the trickle down of layered costs incurred through business partners. We see the direction that the DMS companies are moving for adding access fees through the guise of certification and security measures. The incremental costs being added are exorbitant (200, 300 and up to 500% increases in DMS access fees) to dealer partners, and end up coming back to the dealer in the form of higher monthly service fees for all applications using the dealer’s data (i.e. – advertising/marketing services, service retention applications, connected car features, equity calculators, inventory & reputation management tools, lead generation & vehicle history information, etc.). Since these are all necessa...Read post