Community

Share your automotive expertise

2 Write a Blog Post

Does not being transparent make you invisible to customers?

By Ron Henson on Mar 11, 2013

BUZZWORD ALERT!

TRANSPARENCY.  Love it or hate it, it is relevant and plays a big part in your Digital strategy.

Let's see if we can look at things from a customer's perspective for a moment.  

  1. Google the product you're looking for.
  2. Read through the results on pages 1-5 to narrow your search. (Yeah, right!)  More like, Read through the first 3, maybe 4 results.
  3. Visit a couple of the sites to gather information including pricing and availability.
  4. Visit 3rd party sites. (Autotrader & Cars.com)
  5. ASSUME THAT NO PRICE = HIGHEST PRICE AND MOVE ON TO NEXT DEALERSHIP.

So is #5 happening?  You better believe it is!  If you aren't pricing your inventory and pricing it "On the Money" you are out of the Internet game.  Remember, we're looking at things from a customer's perspective.  So here's the rub, some dealers dig their heels in the sand and say, "Listing prices online just costs me gross and those mooches who insist on knowing he price before they come in can go see the guys down the street."  

The work I do with dealers affords me the opportunity to review many Internet mystery shops of dealerships all over North America.  It blows me away how many times we ask for a price and get an answer like:

  1. We'll make you a great deal. When can you come in?
  2. We've never lost a deal over price.  Come on down.
  3. What monthly payment were you hoping to get?
  4. Do you have a trade?

Let me address #4 specifically.  Now remember, customer perspective.  "Hey honey, did you know the price we can get on the new Tahoe we want is affected by whether or not we have a trade-in?"  "Hmm, I'll never understand the car business so I guess we better go down to the dealership that won't give us the price online because I'm sure they will be much lower than these other 2 dealerships that have been so nice and answered our questions so thoroughly."  

NOT!

The moral of the story here is that as the business owner you certainly have the right to make the business decision to resist transparency and not post prices on your website or with 3rd party vendors.  Whether or not that is a good decision rests with you and your management team but I would like to offer a suggestion.  Look at it from a customer's perspective when making that decision.  Think about the last time you shopped online for a high ticket item like a tv or a riding mower or whatever it may have been.  Chances are you were looking online for 3 pieces of information:

  1. Product info
  2. Pricing info
  3. Businesses that offered the product

Did you consider going to businesses that didn't offer one or both of the fist two items?

The Dalai Lama said, "The lack of transparency results in distrust and a deep sense of insecurity."

Go move some metal!

 

Comments

A good deal is a state of mind. It's based on perception. There is no real transparency. Its also perception. And the perception is transparency is much more important that transparency itself. Does anyone really think we are going to divulge our complete cost structure to each consumer, then negotiate the margin?

We'll have true transparency about the time Dealers are transparent with their managers and sales people, and not a moment sooner.

Mar 11, 2013

The word transparency is often over used, but that is because consumers have more influence and data to support their influence than in any time in auto industry history. The problem is not all data is equal, and using it in context can also be a problem. Research indicates the Gen Y buyer who will soon comprise over 40% of your consumers wants this type of validated experience. With-out this type of showroom experience they, Gen Y, purchases from a dealership willing to be "transparent" There usually is a difference between new and pre-owned gross profit, but both experiences have to be validated in a transparent way. The good news for progressive dealerships is you can become transparent in a lot of different ways and use data that works for your dealership and your consumer. I wouls strongly recommend beginning to look to address Gen Y the are different buyers and the data supports that fact.

Mar 11, 2013

David, I couldn't agree more than transparency has to happen between dealers, managers and sales consultants as well. Truth is, dealerships that aren't are not only losing customers to competitors, but employees as well.

Mar 11, 2013

Great comments Stuart! I believe that it's not about being the lowest price, but being in the most aggressive sample set and then letting your light shine through a process that builds value and trained & certified sales consultants. Thanks for your thoughts!

Mar 11, 2013

Carmax proves over and over that price is not the issue. You don't have to be the cheapest to have customers buy from you, but you do have to have a good online shopping experience. Getting instant gratification on a trade appraisal on your dealer website is very important and I would challenge you to do the research on which values are most realistic and relevant. Start a fresh or rare car a little higher price than a car that is aging and you'll make up the difference in gross.

Mar 11, 2013

Well said Carl.

Mar 11, 2013

As one of the generation in question, as mentioned above... this could not ring truer to me. Having been burned once (hard) by a very "non-transparent" dealership, I made it a point to never allow it to happen again. My weapon of choice? The internet. Since that first burn, I have made 2 more vehicle purchases. In both instances, I walked into the dealership with a wealth of information on hand, and spoke frequently to the dealerships I shopped with prior to coming in. And while both were adamant about not talking price before I actually walked in the door, I was ready anyways. Thanks in large part to sites like edmunds (which I used both times), I felt I had a decent idea what the cost of the car should be, and thanks to my smartphone, I had no problem forcing the salesmen and dealerships I visited be as transparent as possible with me. At the end of the day? Customers understand that the salesmen and the dealership need to eat too. It's about respect, tact, and honesty. These are the values we of ANY generation hold over slime, smarm, and snark.

Mar 11, 2013

Brilliantly put Marc! Thanks for weighing in.

Mar 11, 2013

This is a major part of what I am trying to solve with CarWoo!. You're on the money here Ron. Dealers that embrace what you've written are definitely more successful with the online buyer. Thanks for the post.

Mar 11, 2013

Thanks Tommy! Guys like you and I are trying to change the world one dealer at a time. :-)

Mar 11, 2013

Comments 1 - 10 of 46

You must be logged in to comment

Login Create an account

Add your comments:

   

Ron Henson's Recent Posts

Related Posts

  • The dealership sales and finance process has been built by dealers for dealers. Not consumers.

    There’s got to be a better way to sell a car. Everyone seems to think so.  In our recent dealer survey, 8 in 10 dealers agreed the time it takes to buy a car ought to take two hours or less but most say the average transaction time today is 3-4 hours from meet & greet to funded. The clear majority of these same dealers say that the biggest opportunity for change is to capture more information from the customer earlier in the process.   With the endless eCommerce sites available today, empowered ‘electronic’ shoppers have come to expect the transparency and immediate gratification made possible by the internet. It’s difficult for them to understand why buying a car still has to take so long. Most car shoppers today want to know what their payment terms will be while deciding on a vehicle, so it's completely illogical that dealerships make it virtually impossible for car shoppers to find financing information online.    Dealers should want to provide an easy, seamless...Read post

  • CallSource Automotive Brings Industry-Leading Call Tracking and Management System to Australia

    Company to help Australian dealers improve call-to-conversion ratios with U.S.-patented system that generates an average of $320K+ in additional annual earnings for US dealers; Hyundai Australia first to roll out system to dealer network   San Francisco, Calif. - January 23, 2015 - CallSource, the U.S. leader in call tracking, management and training, announced today at the 2015 National Automobile Dealer Association Convention in San Francisco that it has launched its patented system in Australia. This will give Australian auto dealers access to the same tools US dealerships are using to significantly improve their call-to-conversion rates. Partnering with Australia’s Dealer Solutions, CallSource’s initial rollout is with Hyundai Australia’s dealer network. Dealers and OEMs spend billions of dollars generating leads – a vast majority of which come in as phone calls. CallSource data shows that a mishandled call results in the customer defecting to another brand more than 50...Read post

  • DMEautomotive’s Driver Connect Collects Two More Top Honors: AWA Award and 2015 Digital Edge 25 Award

      DMEautomotive’s groundbreaking mobile app for dealerships wins Automotive Website Award for second year in a row, and is an honoree in the prestigious Digital Edge 25 Awards   San Francisco, Calif. – January 23, 2015 – DMEautomotive (DMEa) today announced that its groundbreaking dealer-branded mobile app, Driver Connect, has received two of the most prestigious honors in the automotive and technology industries: an Automotive Website Award (Automotive Mobile Apps category) and a Digital Edge 25 Award.  This is the second year in a row that Driver Connect has received an AWA and its first as an Honoree in the prestigious Digital Edge 25 Awards, which recognize enterprises that have leveraged digital technologies to transform their business.   Driver Connect was presented with the AWA at the National Automobile Dealers Association (NADA) Conference in San Francisco on Thursday, January 22nd.  The Automotive Website Awards are presented each year by PCG Consulting to re...Read post

  • Why “Transparency” is Just Like Hard-Core Porn

    Writing a decision in a 1964 Supreme Court pornography case, Justice Potter Stewart wrote that some things are hard to put into words, hard to accurately define – and this is especially true of abstract ideas. So Stewart wrote one of the most famous phrases in court history “…I know it when I see it”. It’s interesting to note, that Stewart went on to say that the film question was not hard-core pornography. I think it is often easier to define what an abstract idea is not, than what it is.Read post

  • CallSource CallTrack® Presented with DrivingSales Dealer Satisfaction Award

    CallSource receives a “Top Rated” Award for Dealer Satisfaction in Call Management Category   San Francisco, CA – January 23, 2015 – CallSource’s CallTrack® is the recipient of a “Top Rated” Call Management award in the sixth annual DrivingSales Dealer Satisfaction Awards, presented at a special event today in conjunction with the 2015 National Automobile Dealers Association (NADA) Convention & Expo.   “We are very honored to be acknowledged by dealers as a top-rated call management provider and thrilled to receive this prestigious award for the fifth year in a row,” said Andrew Price, President of CallSource Automotive. “And the biggest reward is the benefit we are delivering to dealers by improving their call-to-conversion ratios and helping them recoup revenue from mishandled calls.”   CallTrack® is the leading call tracking service for automotive retailers. CallTrack captures every caller’s phone number, identifies the advertising source and ...Read post

  • Creating an All-Inclusive Dealership Experience

    Customer experience doesn't limit you to being compared to other dealerships; it compares you to every experience a customer has. You aren't just competing with the dealer down the road; you are competing with the coffee shop, grocery store, doctor’s office, and all-inclusive resort. Every industry is stepping up their customer experience game, and we especially in the automotive industry must do the same. Imagine if you could buy a vehicle while vacationing at an all-inclusive resort. What would that experience be like? Imagine that scenario, and then compare it to the process in your store; does it stand up? Read post

  • DMEautomotive Releases The Pocket Innovation: New eBook on Mobile Strategies

      Second edition of groundbreaking eBook includes new data on mobile user behavior and multiple best practices - from mobile payment to geo-fencing and beacon technology   Daytona Beach, FL –January 22, 2015 – DMEautomotive (DMEa), the company that has led the thought leadership charge when it comes to mobile strategies and technologies for automotive dealers, today announced the release of The Pocket Innovation, the second edition of the company’s very successful 2013 eBook The Pocket Revolution:  The Complete Guide to a Killer Mobile App.    Available for download today at DMEautomotive.com, The Pocket Innovation helps auto dealers easily navigate the rapidly evolving mobile marketplace and is chock full of new data on mobile user behavior direct from the marketing scientists in DMEa's Strategy & Analytics department, as well as from respected third party sources. In addition, the book includes multiple best practices for mobile - including the difference betwee...Read post

  • AUTOSOFT FLEX DMS wins BEST DMS AWARD with DrivingSales “HIGHEST RATED” Dealer Satisfaction Honor

    Autosoft, Inc. Flex DMS has received the “Highest Rated” Dealership Management System Award in the sixth annual DrivingSales Dealer Satisfaction Awards, presented at a special event today in conjunction with the 2015 National Automobile Dealers Association (NADA) Convention & Expo. Autosoft, Inc. Flex DMS received the highest dealer satisfaction ranking in the Dealership Management System category, as determined by the thousands of auto dealers who are part of the DrivingSales.com community.Read post