Share your automotive expertise

2 Write a Blog Post

Quick Response vs Quality Response

By Ron Henson on Apr 2, 2013

One of the popular buzzwords (It's actually 2 words) in the industry when it comes to Internet Sales is "Response Time."  Oftentimes dealers fall into the trap of thinking that managing their response times on Internet Leads is the Holy Grail of Digital Operations.  I was chatting with a dealer recently who was frustrated because they had worked very hard to reduce their response time from an average of 5 hours 35 mins (YIKES!) to 25 minutes.  While 25 minutes is certainly respectable, and a massive improvement from where they were before, it is not anywhere near a best practice benchmark.  Anyway, the dealer was frustrated that the improved response time had not had a measureable effect on their conversion percentage to appointments.  So he and I began to dig a little deeper into what was going on.

Over the next couple of days the dealer and I started to take a look at what was going on in his CRM.  FULL DISCLOSURE:  I have the dealer's authorization to publish these responses as long as I don't divulge the dealership's name or location.  That disclosure gives you a pretty good idea as to the nature of the responses you are about to see.  (responses are word for word including typos and grammar)

Question: What is the "out the door" price on this pre-owned 2010 Civic? 

  • The price isn't important unless you're paying cah which I sure you not.  How much down?

Question: Do you offer financing for people with credit problems?

  • We can get you bot.  All I need is a 5 liner. What are yor prilems?  (WHAT?)

Question: Dealership XXX has quoted me a slightly lower price on the same vehicle and I was wondering if you price match.

  • Dealership XXX is giving cars away to buy market share.  Go buy it there.


At this point I probably don't need to write anything more in this blog post to properly convey my message.  While repsonse time is certainly an improtant and vital piece of the puzzle when it comes to having a top notch Internet process, it is only 1 piece of the puzzle.  Not the only piece.  This dealer was astonished and furious over what we uncovered when we just took a peek into the responses that were going out from his dealership.

The key is Quick Response in conjunction with Quality Response.  

Take a look at the responses that are going out from your dealership and always inspect what you expect.

Let's move some metal!


Ron, I recently wrote an eBook on my experiences of email follow up. I found when testing lead forms out, no one really answered my question. If your interested in reading my ebook you can download it for free here:

Apr 2, 2013

Hey Ketty, Interestingly enough, I have found the same thing when I mystery shop dealerships. While this post shows some of the poor responses, many times the responses will evade the question completely. It's pretty good technique if you are trying to assure that your dealership gets eliminated from consideration.

Apr 2, 2013

Great article Ron! In my experience it's a mix of aspects that create an appointment conversion. Basics are punctuation, respect and timely response. If you don't have the basics, forget it.

Providing an incentive works nicely. For an "Out of town" customer that is interested in a used vehicle. Let them know that you will cover their gas if they don't buy the car. With a closing ratio of 80% on internet leads, we were more than happy to promote that offer.

The little things that make your dealership different will help convert a lead to an appointment.

Remember, people searching online probably submitted a lead to five dealers. Why should they come to you?

Apr 2, 2013

Thanks for the thoughts Grant. I especially like "The little things that make your dealership different will help convert a lead to an appointment."

Apr 2, 2013

Improper work flows (processes), misspellings, wrong email templates going at certain times, overused and common email templates with mo originality, etc. That is the name of the game. It is unfortunate but it is CRM companies that have enabled technology which helps makes the sales professional lazier. I am not saying CRMs are bad as everyone knows I am an advocate of having an effective CRM system and believe that everyone should have one. However, dealership management needs to play a bigger role in managing the settings of the CRM. The CRM needs to be evaluated on a weekly or at the very least a monthly basis. Also, when you get a CRM setup in the dealership, stop relying on just the generic stuff that the trainer will come in to set up. CRM companies do not care what processes you will put into place but are generally trained to have their own generic best practices. Remember, it maybe a best practice somewhere else but it might not make sense at your dealership. My advise is to get creative and write out specific email templates that can be edited or a allow a custom message to be added when needed. Also, check the email for spam. It is frustrating me how many dealers send out emails and they hit my spam filters. While it may not always be controlled there are tools that help minimize that. I use to make sure every email that I install is spam free in addition to the spam checker that some CRM companies offer.

Apr 2, 2013

Here here Stan! The tools are only as good as the people turning the wrenches.

Apr 2, 2013

Hence why I said that management needs to be on their game and manage the CRM system.

Apr 2, 2013

The great lesson here is we have to approach internet leads with the same mindset as we would a customer right in front of us. We investigate, build rapport, build value, and do our best to walk the line of being "Client Focused" It's like a friendship. Someone is putting their trust in your care. You now entered an unspoken or unwritten contract that you'll hold the relationship sacred. A customer puts their trust in you as a the expert, and that you are there to provide them with outstanding service..for no other reason than it's our JOB.

"Whatever your life's work is, do it well. A man should do his job so well that the living, the dead, and the unborn could do it no better. -Martin Luther King, Jr."

Apr 3, 2013

Very well said Simone! The steps to the sale are the same and building rapport is still of utmost importance! Many are approaching Internet leads like they are interacting with a bot. They're a person, you're a person. Engage.

Apr 3, 2013

Quality and response time count. They aren't mutually exclusive as we all know. We process just over 3,600 workable leads a month for our dealerships and have an initial response time of less than 15 minutes. The quality of our responses improved dramatically when we established a 2nd and 5th day reveiw completed by team leaders. They check to see if the initial response answered all quesitons from the prospect, including an internet price and alternate vehicle. On the 5th day the leader insures that any ongoing questions and progress is being made. In the event the quality is less than acceptable training and additional supervision is set up.
I am curious about how Grant Gooley is measuring the result and getting an 80% close ratio.
Mike Morrow, Director of Online Sales

Apr 3, 2013

Comments 1 - 10 of 23

You must be logged in to comment

Login Create an account

Add your comments:


Ron Henson's Recent Posts

Related Posts

  • Want to Know Why Consumers Don’t Trust Us?

    The reason that consumers don’t trust us is simple… the messages we send them aren’t believable.   Point in case: Doug Demiro, a former manager of Porsche Cars North America, and now author of a popular column on automotive website Jalopnik, answered a reader’s question in his column that illustrates this point very clearly.   The question essentially boiled down to this: “Do those letters and e-mails from dealers saying they really want your trade-in actually mean anything? Do dealers really want your trade-in? Are they going to pay top dollar for your vehicle because they have some customer who desperately wants it?”   His answer: NO   Go ahead and read the article. It’s pretty much how consumers perceive these offers. The comments are also rather entertaining. It’s all consumers sharing experiences in which they received a similar offer and actually wanted to take the dealership up on it -- until they found out the dealer couldn’t deliver, or that the...Read post

  • Customer Retention Starts With Employee Retention

    Periodically I get the opportunity to roll up my sleeves and dig into a dealer’s pain point. More often than not these pain points lately are, “how do I get all the customers in to my shop and completed in a timely manner” or “do you know any techs” and “what is the best way keep my customers coming back.”  Here is the extremely tough answer to Mr. Dealer’s questions. The short answer goes something like this “I have an answer but I don’t think you will like the timeline it will take to accomplish this once and for all.” After a frustrated perplexed look from the dealer I usually say, “The complete fix sits within your people, your training program and your ability to grow and mentor your staff.” Obviously this is not an overnight fix. Most of the time I feel they are looking for the silver bullet to Customer retention starts with having a solid process and business model, yes this is a given. The execution of customer retention sits fully on the shoulders o...Read post

  • Not in My Backyard! How to Protect Your Turf with a Geofence

    Most of the time the goal of a dealership's advertising is to reach car shoppers and convince them to visit your store. But what about the customers who are already in your dealership? You're probably thinking there's no need to advertise to them. If they're in your showroom, there's a pretty good chance you can close them. And you're right - unless one of your competitors makes them an offer they can't refuse, while the customer is standing right in front of you.   By now you've probably heard of geofencing as a mobile marketing strategy that can be used to lure customers out of a competitor's dealership and into your dealership. It works like this: Jane walks into Smith Chevrolet and immediately gets a push notification (or text, or email, or sees a banner ad) on her smartphone.   The notification informs Jane that Brown Chevrolet down the street has a lease special on a car she's interested in for only $159/month. Jane sees the special and is excited because that price is we...Read post

  • One of a dozen ways chat can kill your deal – and 3 tips to prevent it

    I once had a general manager tell us that Disney had a vice president of parking to ensure the first and last experience guests have at their parks are not tainted by stress. I don’t know about the VP part, but they certainly have it down to a science, as evidenced by nearly two dozen personal visits and this Wall Street Journal article. What does that have to do with live chat on dealer websites? Only everything. Just like a crappy parking experience can ruin an amusement park visit, OFFERING auto shoppers a chance to chat on your dealer website, then not answering the call when they click the CHAT NOW button is a sure way to kill a car deal. For all the things that can go wrong in an auto shopping experience, and even just during a live chat experience, killing it from moment one by not answering the virtual phone is surely the biggest. Check out my stop watch on this live chat inquiry. This dealer is taking their own chats – or is deluding themselves in to THINKING they a...Read post

  • Drive End-of-the-Year Sales by Targeting Current Customers

    Up next in OneCommand’s Holiday Marketing Guide is an easy way to drive end-of-the-year sales to your dealership. We all know marketing to current customers to keep them coming back is significantly cheaper than going out and conquesting for new business. Although bringing in new business is extremely important, try these three ideas to put current customers into your sales pipeline. Find Pre-Owned Opportunities Chances are you have several pre-owned vehicles in such high demand that they are sold before they ever hit your lot. Look into your database to determine if any of your current customers drive one of these desirable vehicles. Then, reach out to them to see if they are interested in selling their vehicle. If so, you have a win, win; you’re able to stock your pre-owned inventory lot with desirable vehicles and potentially sell a new vehicle. Find Equity Opportunities Another way to find potential sales for an end-of-the-year push is to look into your database and find cust...Read post

  • VW Recalls: The Polarizing Effect on Consumers

    Unless you’ve been in hibernation for the past few weeks, you’ve undoubtedly been barraged with news and opinions about the VW Recalls. Regardless of the intent of Volkswagen, it’s quite fascinating to observe the polarizing reactions by owners of the diesel engine carrying cars. No doubt the government regulators are going to compel Volkswagen to fix all of the vehicles. It’s possible that we could see a buyback. Ultimately though, there’s a battle going on. It’s not quite the battle you would think, however. I’m not here to rehash any of the many arguments regarding Volkswagen itself, but rather to relay an interesting dynamic that now exists in regards to these vehicles and the consumers who own them.   There were many consumers who bought these vehicles because they wanted to be more environmentally friendly without sacrificing power. Similar to electric and hybrid vehicle owners, these consumers wanted to feel as if they were making a difference in the world, ho...Read post

  • What’s Exceptional About Your Dealership? Share THAT with Women Buyers

    Last time, we discussed not selling cars like they are “power tools” in your advertising. You know, “the best this, the best that”— it is so cliché and it doesn’t resonate with women. Here are four recommendations to ensure that your sales approach doesn’t fall into the “power tool sales” category, but rather, speaks to women about what’s important to them: Sell more than cars in your advertising. Women look at car ads, read dealer reviews and use social media to help make a car buying decision. Do your ads only talk about price? If so, spend more time conveying your reputation for excellent service and trustworthy business. Be the dealership that attracts women buyers because they can get a great car from a trusted, respectful sales advisor AND great service for the next five to eight years. Show that your customers matter before, during and after the sale. Include reviews by women on your website and social media. Provide stories about happy customers. Show wom...Read post

  • How Employee Causes Can Help Increase Volunteerism

    Auto/Mate has been recognized for six years in a row as a "Best Place to Work" by the Albany Business Review and four years in a row as a "Top Workplace" by the Times-Union. One of the perks Auto/Mate offers is eight hours of paid volunteer time to every employee. To encourage employees to use the time and get involved in the community, Auto/Mate organizes groups to identify and participate in local charities.   Ronald McDonald House   Kelly Shaw, a payroll benefits specialist with Auto/Mate, discovered the Ronald McDonald House when her own child was in the hospital. "I started making small dinners, or cookies and cakes, and dropping them off at the hospital," Shaw said. "When I realized that some of the parents were from out of town and were staying at the Ronald McDonald House, I started bringing food over there."   Shaw's involvement with the charity grew and her manager at Auto/Mate encouraged her to get fellow employees involved. When Shaw posted flyers asking for volunt...Read post