Notifications & Messages

Jared Hamilton
From: Jared Hamilton
Hey - It’s time to join the thousands of other dealer professionals on DrivingSales. Create an account so you can get full access to the articles, discussions and people that are shaping the future of the automotive industry.
Brian Pasch

Brian Pasch CEO

Exclusive Blog Posts

6 Tips for Better LinkedIn PPC Advertising

6 Tips for Better LinkedIn PPC Advertising

With a little over a year’s experience with LinkedIn Advertising and some insights from a connection at LinkedIn, I’ve put together a list of 6…

The 3 Laws of Extreme Ownership

The 3 Laws of Extreme Ownership

“These are all things that may help you justify your results. But is your dealer any happier because of this?” I just finished reading a…

The Q1 Inventory Glut - Expert Insight

The Q1 Inventory Glut - Expert Insight

You've heard about it, read about it, and probably experienced it. Q1 for the auto industry was a pretty rough one. Experts are diving into what the pr…

Online Reviews Drive Customers to Your Dealership

Online Reviews Drive Customers to Your Dealership

We’ve been in the business of reviews for quite some time now – 15 years to be exact.  As DealerRater has grown, so has the power and infl…

Devising a Perfect Landing Page

Devising a Perfect Landing Page

When your business is taken online, you have to make sure your website is generating customers and visitors. This is one of the most important things in on… To Add Dealership Reviews From Consumers

By Brian Pasch  

David Barkholz, Information Technology reporter for Automotive News, broke the story today that will be adding dealership reviews to their popular website in 2014.

According  to Automotive News, Autotrader Group President Sandy Schwartz commented: "I feel we should be agnostic and have an open architecture where a number of ratings are used. I don't think we should be tied to just one."  

You can read the article directly on Automotive News

There are many questions to be answered on how reviews will be implemented on, especially if they plan to show a compilation of review sources like we see on Google+.  Dealers will be anxious to know if there will be any review moderation similar to or will it require consumers to create an account, like review-sources

Reviews Influence Consumers

The announcement should not be a surprise for industry watchers who have witnessed the growth and visibility of reviews in organic search as well as the growing popularity of sites like and Google+ Local reviews are the most influential for consumers using Google's search engine because they are place right underneath the dealer's primary website listing, as shown above.

There are a number of studies that document to impact of reviews on consumer choice and David Barkholz cites a recent study by Volkswagen in his article.  Frequent shoppers on or road warriors who reference all know the power of peer reviews.  Review platforms for car dealers however have been a source of frustration.  So much that OEM's have even created co-op programs to help dealers with their online reputation. is well known to filter most dealership reviews and only show reviews of active Yelp members.  Google+ Local (formerly Google Places) has had a number of policy changes and technical issues over the years that have raised and lowered dealer reviews.  The granddaddy of dealership reviews is which allows dealers, subscribed to their service, moderate reviews before they are published. The DealerRater system seems to be working well for dealers who actively monitor their online reputation.  Some dealers may be reading this article and saying under their breath "Now I have another place to check each month?!"


If you are a subscriber to Sirius/XM radio, you probably have heard national commercials from  The first time I heard their commercials, I smiled.  Internet Reputation Management (IRM) had gone mainstream and in fact, the company's commercials were extremely well scripted.  Business owners were put on notice by that negative online reviews would damage their reputation and impact sales.

Today, automotive solutions providers like, Cobalt,, and Dominion Dealer Solutions offer car dealers software to monitor online review sites. OEM's have started to encourage dealers to incorporate online review monitoring in their monthly business processes.  GM has even taken the aggressive step of requiring dealers to choose one of three "approved" IRM providers to monitor and manage online reviews.

Reputation Management is a booming industry which is attracting entrepreneurs and scammers.  Business owners nationwide are being emailed and/or called on a regular basis by companies offering "assistance" to mitigate negative online reviews.  Some dealers have been ensnared by companies offering non-compliant review posting services which violate the "terms of service" agreements on popular review sites.  Dealers must understand the rules of engagement with online review sites because compliance failures can be costly.


It will take some time to see the full impact of how implements their review system but one thing is for sure, the real estate on Google Page One will likely now have another search result for reviews. Dealers reading this article can take a quick test to see the visibility of review platforms, just search your dealership name and add the word "reviews" to the search.

With's monthly traffic, I would expect their review system to index on Google very quickly just like we noticed when added reviews.  This means that smaller review platforms will most likely be pushed down the Search Engine Results Page (SERP) when searching for dealership reviews. Having consumer reviews on gives dealers another tool to amplify their excellent customer service practices and draw more attention to their VDP's and dealership.

Of course with any new review platform comes the potential for negative reviews to be posted, which I consider part of normal business operations.  Dealers should not fear that they will get a negative review on The opportunity for dealers is how they respond to negative reviews, which often can turn into a win for the dealer.  It will be interesting to see if dealers can respond to reviews without being a paying customer of Autotrader.

In any case, adding reviews to will upset some dealer customers and be seen as an added value to other dealers.  The fact that paved the way will likely make online reviews a standard on third party classified websites.

What is your thoughts on adding consumer reviews of dealers?  Since we know what the system looks like, what changes would you suggest to Sandy Schwartz? readers have a great opportunity to provide feedback to before the system goes live because I am confident Autotrader executives will be reading this post.

So speak up and give the ATC team some guidance.


Brian Pasch, CEO

PCG Consulting



Chris K Leslie
I can still remember standing on my soapbox preaching that reputation management was going to be a very important market and that it was a market that would drive home increases in digital revenue vs. relying on display and search programs. that was 5 years ago at the newspaper media company I was working for as the social & mobile director. Fast forward to today and here we are with about a million more review/listing sites than we had 5 years ago and million more problems too. That being said, I do feel that reputation management is and should be a priority. But over the years it has continued to churn out an unreliable and variable set of rules on both the consumer and business facing sides. I don't see AutoTrader adding any value here. I do see value if they were to integrate with Google or Yelp. That to me has value and promotes the bigger picture. Short of that it appears to just be another place dealers will find themselves defending their reputations and business. Allowing yesterday to hold tomorrow hostage again and again.

 Unlock all of the community & features  Join Now