Find out how Hiley Hyundai delivered 74% new shoppers to their website. VIEW CASE STUDY
Currently we use both AutoTrader and Cars.com. We have used them both for quite some time. The measurement that we use for them is cost per vehicle detail page. We feel that it is a good measurement for them. In our opinion it is their responsibility to get the customer to our vehicle detail page. We feel that our marketing takes over at that point. (Good pictures, right car, right place, etc.)
They are currently below .50 cents per vehicle detail page. We try to keep them under .60 cents per vehicle detail page. My question for the community is this. Do I need both? Based on our reporting both companies are performing well. AutoTrader seems to perform slightly better. They are also a lot easier to work with then cars.com. I just do not know if I would get the same customers with just one of them.