Notifications & Messages

Jared Hamilton
From: Jared Hamilton
Hey - It’s time to join the thousands of other dealer professionals on DrivingSales. Create an account so you can get full access to the articles, discussions and people that are shaping the future of the automotive industry.
Ralph Paglia

Ralph Paglia Editor-in-Chief

Exclusive Blog Posts

How SEO Impacts the Service Department

How SEO Impacts the Service Department

Digital marketing in the dealership often is viewed and conducted solely from a sales perspective. But the service department, often called the "backb…

What 89% of salespeople are failing to do...

What 89% of salespeople are failing to do...

  According to Dale Carnegie only 11% of salespeople ask for referrals. We all know how valuable referrals are but when it comes time to ask for a …

Why Your Online Shoppers Don’t Take the Bait

Why Your Online Shoppers Don’t Take the Bait

You think you’re dangling an enticing lure in front of your customers’ eyes. You plan to set the hook and reel them in. But what you don&rs…

Click-to-Call [Infographic]

Click-to-Call [Infographic]

  Most dealers understand the importance of making it easy for customers and prospects to find contact information. Websites often have prominent &…

Quick Tips for Improving Dealership Culture

Quick Tips for Improving Dealership Culture

Car dealers have a terrible reputation. It's such a negative experience for so many that people are electing to make a major purchase like a vehicle fr…

There are several automotive industry technology suppliers offering various automotive sales Internet Lead Scoring solutions for deployment and implementation in a variety of ways at Tiers 1, 2 and 3. They are:

1. R. L. Polk (see Jeremy Hambly's blog post)
2. Urban Science
3. Trilogy
4. ????????

After having had lengthy discussions with each of the above, and participating in numerous presentations, then speaking with dealers, enterprises and car companies who have implemented some form of using Lead Scoring, I am convinced more than ever that Lead SCORING is a strategy with several major flaws.

Do customers lie in their lead forms? Of course, but that is not the worst problem...

Are some leads distributed to more than one dealer, diluting each dealer's probability of selling that customer a vehicle, regardless of any arbitrary score a software system assigns? Of course they are...

If I send 10 leads to any dealership in America that have been automatically assessed by a software system and then assigned a rating number that indicates which lead is most likely to result in a sale...
How will each dealership assign resources?
How will each ISM allocate the most valuable resource a salesperson has, their time and effort?

Lead scoring is now, and will forever be prone to the self-fulfilling prophecy effect... I think I can, so I will and then do... I think I can't, so I won't and I don't.

The fact is that Lead Scoring has existed ever since 1995 when the first dealerships to receive 3rd party Internet leads went active with AutoByTel... When any ISM receives 150 leads in one month, he or she will decide by looking at the lead details which leads they will allocate their time and greatest efforts to, and which ones are probably a waste of time... Lead SCORING is nothing more than scientifically based CHERRY PICKING! Now, if you have accepted all the reductions in total sales that Cherry Picking implies, and you are going to Cherry Pick regardless of the net reduced sales that result, then putting some logic into the decision making process as to which leads will get time and attention required to sell a car is probably better than most ISM's gut instincts... But why would anyone want to?

In 1999 I watched Tom Vann, the owner of Team Hillsdale Dodge in MI use his own Lead Scoring system... Only it helped sell more cars because he did not "score" the lead as much as he "categorized" it and then assigned a specific Salesperson based on which ISM would be the best match for that lead. In other words, Tom used what others would mistakenly re-invent as a Lead Scoring system 6 years later to, instead, raise the likelihood of each lead becoming an appointment and then a sale by prescribing a certain level of customization in how each lead would be handled by assessing the lead based on the characteristics that could be determined by the limited data within each lead. By assigning specific ISM's to each lead based on assessing each lead, Tom knew which people would handle any lead assigned to them in a specific manner reflecting their individual differences. Therein lies the best and most productive use of the technology created to generate Lead SCORING...

Take out the Scoring bullshit and insert logic that predicts and prescribes what manner a lead should be handled in to maximize the probability of selling a vehicle to that customer... Lead SCORING should die... RIGHT NOW... It is a Frankenstein monster that should never have seen the light of day...

Lead SEGMENTATION that places each lead into a category that corresponds with the type of lead response and handling most likely to create a sales opportunity, either this week, next week, next month, or next year is what our industry needs... NOT a glorified Cherry Picker!!!!

Here is what Lead SCORING looks like:

Here is what Lead SEGMENTATION looks like:


Of course, how each dealer implements their use of Lead Scoring will vary and so will either the positive or negative impact. The point I am trying to make in this article about Lead Scoring and the dangers it presents in the most common current iterations is that Lead Scoring systems need to be modifiied. Their programming technology must be changed so that rather than a score, a predictive case scenario model is developed that places each lead into a category or segment that correlates to predefined variations on lead management processes.

These variations in lead response attributes would include such dealership driven tasks as phone and email follow-up and how or who the lead is routed to... Some leads go to an ISS, others go to special finance, some are sent to a BDC (inhouse or outsourced), others are sent to the used car department because despite coming in as a new vehicle lead the system tells us we have an 80%+ probability that this prospect will buy a used vehicle, if they buy anything. There would be at least 5 and maybe a dozen or more lead management and response attributes that are assigned to each lead by the system based on maximizing and optimizing the outcome.

In other words, don't put a number on the lead, tell us what the best way to handle it REALLY is!!!


Chris Spensley
Thanks for posting this David, This letter sums up a lot of the challenges with this "consolidation", the general public is being told that the selection process is eliminating weak players etc and yet here is a dealership doing everything right that is losing their franchise. It is clear that there are too many dealerships nationwide, what is becoming evident is the plan developed to reduce the number is not well thought out and is doing real damage to the American dream. The same can be said about the oldest Jeep dealership here in the Pittsburgh area (also profitable) that is closing shop. With any luck enough activity will cause Chrysler to take the time and eliminate only those dealerships that are a proven negative draw on their ledger. Some examples would be dealerships that are consistently being backflagged for large numbers of improperly documented warrranty claims or those that have not been able to maintain profitability etc.
Michael  Walden
A point of note is that it is not just "week dealers that have been weeded out" but dealers who have multiple brands on the same site. Even with the list of GM dealers I know of one dealership that sell a large number of Chevy products, but the owner has refussed to up grade the building, so Chevy told them good by. Chrysler & GM seem to be using this as a chance to say good by to anyone who doesn't quite fit the mold.
Grady Maples
Unfortunately the President of the United States does not care what merit car dealers have in this country. To him this is an ideal power grab. How else can he give 55% ownership of a car company to a union? He has taken lessons from the Communist Manifesto and applied them to our industry. He will not stop with this. He will continue to further tear down this country until we are a former shadow of ourselves. He controls the banks, the car business. Next will be health care. He will steal our guns and ammo. Then ultimately, he will shut off our communication and swallow the Internet as his. He has introduced the first of many subversive judges to the supreme court. Scoff if you will at these comments. When you see these things come to pass you might remember them. Americans should be very scared right now and have enough faith in where we come from to fight this man and the people that surround him. I am an on old man and retired. It is the young people that are going to have to unite and fight back and save our great country.

 Unlock all of the community & features  Join Now