Ian Cruickshank

Company: Speed Shift Media

Ian Cruickshank Blog
Total Posts: 19    

Ian Cruickshank

Speed Shift Media

Apr 4, 2016

3 Big Problems that Automotive Digital Marketers Need to Realize Today to Survive Tomorrow

No you’re not dreaming it. It is getting more expensive to attract the same amount of in-market shoppers as last year. What happened? As a digital marketing professional, how is it your budget gets bigger every year but the amount of in-market buyers you attract don’t grow by the same margin?

Actually it’s pretty straightforward - Everyone else is now using similar tactics to get valuable in-market shoppers and the field is getting saturated.

Yesterday your dealership was one of the pioneers in the digital game and you were reaping the rewards of fairly open playing field. Today, anyone who has the budget can easily achieve what you have with a handful of vendors. Dealerships are competing with the guy across the road, across town, and across their own dealer groups and these guys are all using the same tactics you are.

You used to be able to invest a good chunk of your budget into listings sites online, a little bit extra for top spot on SEM and BOOM! your showroom was the top seller in your area and your team thought of you as their “Digital Guru” (PS - don’t ever call yourself a digital guru). But now everyone is using the exact same tactics.

That was then, this is now. You can’t just go out and throw more money at the problem and expect to be back on the top of the heap. Dealership advertising has moved way past the “good ole days” listings and search solving all problems and the sooner you realize these problems the better.

Cookie-Cutter Dealership Websites and SEO won’t separate you anymore.

You have a dealership and you list your cars on your web site. Great! It’s vital to be online, having your inventory online is a big part of the search engine game.

Tell me, does this scenario sound familiar to you?

You decide to spend a whole bunch of your annual budget on SEO optimization so you can be found on the first page of any relevant search and at the end of the year, after you’ve spent tens of thousands of dollars, your competition across town is still ranking higher than you! Crap - better start looking for that new gig.

Let’s face it, there are only a handful of vendors that make really great dealership websites and unfortunately many of you are required by your OEM’s to work with the usual suspects like DDC or CDK. Therein lies the problem. In order to “separate yourself from the pack” you’ve got to find something new but you're forced to use the same vendor that offers the same services to your competition.

How is it possible for your Ford dealership be more competitive than the other two Ford dealers in the same city that use the same vendor for their websites and SEO? Ding Ding! - it’s not.

Listing Sites are Over-Saturated

Many dealerships start their digital marketing here and the appeal is simple: These listing pages are designed to get your cars in front of interested buyers close to your dealership. Exactly what you need! Plus - you’ve been working with the Orange guy and the Purple guy for the last 15 or 20 years, so why not keep doing it?? Right… Wrong!

Don’t forget, that same listing site is making the same guarantee to all the other dealerships that compete with you. If your ads need to be showcased at the top of that listing page, you have to buy the “Premium Positions” which cost more than what a basic listing costs but displays at the top of the list with a minor color splash that says something quipy like “Prefered Listing”.

Worse yet, your Ford Explorer is top of the list with your main competitors Ford Explorer and both of your ads look identical! How does this differentiate you? Once again, you’re back to spending money to maintain the same results rather than increasing results. Double crap!

The Inevitability of Diminishing Returns for SEM

No you’re not dreaming, the average CPC is skyrocketing year over year. A study by  AdGooroo.com has found that the average automotive CPC has increased a staggering 83% from 2012 to 2014. Our own internal study completed at the end of February 2016 has the current average CPC, for Tier 3 Automotive spending in AdWords, at $2.65. This is right in line with that growth figure. Ouch.

Rise-in-Average-CPC-US-AdWords-2012-2014-update-AdGooroo.png

This means that you will HAVE to increase your SEM budget next year just to maintain the same returns you saw this year.

When you were one of the only few dealerships in a city, it was easy to stand out in the crowd. As more dealerships moved in and increased their digital savviness, the competitive landscape became more saturated, the ad space became more crowded and listing pages more competitive (and expensive).

What comes next?

As with many things in life, the strategy is straightforward, but the execution is difficult. In order to get ahead of your competition you need to focus on what your competition doesn’t do rather than keeping up with them.

This means experimenting with your advertising and marketing dollars on the new digital technologies and techniques that will not only get your inventory in front of more in-market buyers but also in a channel that isn’t already saturated with the rest of your competition.

The key to surviving in today’s ultra-competitive digital marketing landscape is to be in front of the advertising trends. A savvy digital marketer will know what will be competitive tomorrow, today.  

What have have you seen that not many dealerships are doing? Leave it in the comments.

Ian Cruickshank

Speed Shift Media

VP of Sales and Marketing

2910

1 Comment

James Lawrence

DealerEFX.com

Apr 4, 2016  

Great Post!  I have watched over the years as the OEMs enforce a "generification" of the digital marketing tools meant to support the differentiation of dealership's "positioning"...Websites, SEM, SEO, etc...with CDKG and ReyRey and soon to be Cox Auto Uber Alles, "generification" of marketing channels means the hunt is on for new ways of doing things that traditionally have been overlooked (DealerEFX email response program) or underserved or in desperate need of simplifcation.  There are opportunities for new players in the niches of marketing.

Ian Cruickshank

Speed Shift Media

Feb 2, 2016

Attract More Online Car Buyers: Ways to Reach Buyers at Every Stage of the Buyer’s Journey

a2bd630bf41b834d0a3a754e4be6189b.png?t=1I’m sorry to have to say this: Your digital marketing is less and less effective every year. That’s not because you’re doing anything wrong, it’s more the fact that there are just more players coming into the game every month and that’s diluting the playing field.

And this isn’t anything new. Even in late 2014, Media Post found that  “... ad budgets are up 17% [for the automotive sector]. Online media accounts for 95% of this year’s increase.”

As digital marketers, it’s your job to attract buyers that are shopping online, and as GMs, you have seen the impact that online media has on sales and the bottom line. However, with new players coming into the fold and existing dealers upping their investments, it will be increasingly difficult to reach car buyers with your dealership’s message.

One way to increase your message reach is to customize your marketing on different parts of the buyer’s path to purchase.

In 2012, Microsoft Advertising had created a report that identified the stages of a car buyer’s journey from the initial realisation of a need (or want) all the way beyond the purchase to ownership.

Each of these stages has a variety of media outlets and online information sources which are useful at each stage. Back in the day (or until just a few years ago) we marketers would have to rack our brains to determine the best time and place to display each ad. Fortunately, in today’s digital marketing age we can get extremely targeted with our messages and our content.

Thus, the ability to move from "educated guessing" to "data driven certainty".

What we found missing from the stages that Microsoft had outlined is that car shoppers aren’t actively engaged in shopping 100% of the time. As a result, we need to add another dimension to these stages.  

  1. Active Auto Shoppers
  2. Passive Auto Shoppers

Actively Shopping

Simply put, this is when shoppers are actively researching or looking for a vehicle.

Actively Researching

During this time, shoppers are looking at review, research and comparison sites to determine which car best fits their needs and wants.

Historically, one of the only methods to reach these buyers with your dealership message is through basic display advertising. Typically, this is a branding or offers strategy with messages that talk about financing or general dealer incentives.

However, in recent years, new inventory advertising products have been able to provide dealerships with the ability to show live dealership inventory during this stage to entice buyers to visit their website.

2016-02-26-Reach-buyers-at-every-stage-1-1

Traditionally, the only way to get your dealership’s message out to car shoppers in the research phase was to promote a generic offer.

2016-02-26-Reach-buyers-at-every-stage-2

New inventory display advertisements now allow dealerships to show these buyers their actual inventory while they are researching.

Actively Searching

During this time, car shoppers have selected the car, their car of the moment, and are then looking for where they can find one to test drive or evaluate in person.

Reaching buyers during this mindset is relatively straightforward as people are actively looking for vehicles. As long as you have your inventory listed, and have a decent SEM campaign, you’re in the mix.

Traditionally, this is also where the bulk of the digital budget is spent. As a result, this stage is also where dealerships encounter the highest competition and see the most diminishing returns. As we mentioned above, the more players that come into the game, the less effective per dollar your digital marketing becomes.

Due to this oversaturation and highly competitive arena of listings and SEM, some savvy digital marketers have expanded into Inventory Display and other digital mediums to drive VDP traffic. Similar to listings advertising, Inventory Display feature interactive ads that link directly to your VDP to convert. However, unlike listings advertising and SEM, Inventory Display does not yet suffer from a high level of saturation and competition.

2016-02-26-Reach-buyers-at-every-stage-1-1

Active car shoppers need a great SEM and listings campaign. 

2016-02-26-Reach-buyers-at-every-stage-2

Inventory Display Ads are effective to attract shoppers at this stage but do not suffer from the high competition found in SEM and listings ads.

 

Passively Shopping

During this time, car shoppers have stopped actively looking or researching the cars they want to buy. These people are going about their other browsing habits in other environments that are completely non-automotive.

Typically, dealerships rely on retargeting or demographic targeting for this phase. However, retargeting only works if the buyer has gone to the dealership’s website and targeting by demographics paints everyone with a wide brush and may not be as effective as you think.

A better method would be to combine retargeting from the dealer’s site and behavioural targeting based on the shoppers actual online auto browsing history, learned by a Data Management Platform (DMP) in the Active Stage. By doing this, you can deliver advertising that is relevant even in an environment that is not automotive specific.

2016-02-26-Reach-buyers-at-every-stage-5

Your message must be relevant to the consumer to be effective in the Passive Stage. Relevance can be achieved with behavioural targeting if they have not visited your website and retargeting methods if they have.  

 

By having tactics to reach buyers at every stage, you will be able to increase your chances of attracting more car buyers to your website and ultimately help increase the sales of your dealership.

Are there any other ways you have been able to attract buyers through these three stages? Let us know how in the comments section.

 

Ian Cruickshank

Speed Shift Media

VP of Sales and Marketing

2697

No Comments

Ian Cruickshank

Speed Shift Media

Dec 12, 2015

What Thanksgiving has taught me about Dealership Marketing

28ceab8543c7501bc53b8d0fc73f1676.jpg?t=1

Happy post-Thanksgiving everyone. I hope you were able to spend time with your loved ones, watch some amazing football and of course, eat as much turkey (or Celebration Loaf/Tofurky in my case) as possible.

I’m not sure if it was my third helping of Tofurky, the belly full of wine or the fact that I’m just a total workaholic, but I couldn’t help draw some similarities between Thanksgiving and the world of automotive dealership marketing. (Yes, seriously.) 


You see, my mother-in-law cooks a mean Turkey (or so I keep hearing), and as I watched all the magic in the kitchen, I couldn't help but draw some interesting parallels:

Keep a constant eye on your turkey/digital marketing performance

There are many ways to cook a delicious turkey and there are many to achieve great results in your digital marketing. All of them require close attention and regular check-ups to ensure that you get the results you’re after. Just as you would baste your turkey frequently while it’s cooking, you should also constantly monitor the Time On VDP, VDP Efficiency and VDP per session of your digital ads during a campaign. Doing so will prevent short-term performance issues from becoming a dry turkey, er... I mean an unsuccessful campaign.

Presentation is everything

When reflecting on the dining room table, it’s obvious to me that presentation plays a huge role in this event. The fine china is out, the glasses are sparkling, the cutlery matches (it’s a big deal in my house), and the turkey is positioned as the star of the dinner.
Likewise, to maximize the performance of your marketing, your ads also have to be well presented. Like the turkey is the star of the dinner, the car needs to be the star of your ads. Take great photos, and make sure that the description is well written, clear and concise.

Get some help

Sure you can make the turkey, mash the potatoes, bake the pie and set the table yourself, but wouldn’t it be much easier if you had some help? Like your kitchen helpers that boost your kitchen productivity, OEM co-op programs can help provide you with the additional funding you need to boost your marketing reach. Remember, it’s in the OEM’s best interest that you sell more of their cars, and the OEM co-op program is like kitchen helper that does just that - they help.

It’s not about you. It’s about them!

A big part of Thanksgiving is about giving thanks to what we received throughout the year. It’s about thanking everyone for helping you achieve your accomplishments. It isn’t about you; it’s about being thankful to everyone else.
 
 
Likewise, your messaging and differentiators shouldn’t be about you or your dealership; it should reflect what you can do for the car buyer. Translate inward facing statements about your dealership's achievements into outward facing statements illustrating why those achievements are good for the car buyers. For example: If you’ve moved more inventory than your competitors, try “More GM buyers have trusted us to deliver the car they want” rather than “We’ve sold more cars than any other GM dealership.”

 

By taking some pragmatic lessons from a Thanksgiving Day dinner and applying them to your dealership marketing, you can help improve your dealership's marketing performance, attract more buyers, and ultimately eat more turkey… er, I mean sell more cars.

Perhaps it was the wine. Anyone else find a connection between Thanksgiving and automotive marketing? Leave your thoughts in the comments.

Before signing off, I want to take a moment to thank all of our amazing customers and agency partners. This has been an amazing year for Speed Shift Media, and we are thankful for your continued support of our business.

Ian Cruickshank

Speed Shift Media

VP of Sales and Marketing

1432

No Comments

Ian Cruickshank

Speed Shift Media

Nov 11, 2015

Do you like free money? Here’s how to take advantage of your OEM’s Co-op program.

e332201be2fc077a376b626d121e05f4.jpg?t=1

Marketing vehicles (or anything for that matter) can be broken down into four parts: message, creative, distribution channels, and measurement. Of course, what is typically implied in all of this is execution and the money that fuels this execution.

You can have all the greatest plans and strategies in the world but without the funds to execute, that’s all they’ll ever be: plans. As we’ve all found out while growing up, money doesn’t grow on trees. Raise your hand if you’ve ever buried a dollar bill in hopes that a money tree will sprout. I even went so far as to buy a “Money Tree” – I call it Ben. (Yes, Franklin)This can especially be troublesome for smaller dealerships or groups that are starting out where advertising dollars are sparse.

Luckily, OEMs are there with co-op programs. These funds are available for your dealership to advertise the brand’s vehicles. Typically OEMs will reimburse you back with a percentage of the cost to run the advertising. In some cases, they will cover the entire cost of the program.

So, if you’re not taking advantage of your OEM’s co-op programs, you’re leaving money on the table. My guess is that 95% of you know that there are funds available, but it’s the co-op process that gets in the way. This time, raise your hand if you have a stack of co-op affidavits/tear-sheets that need to be submitted. I’ll bet that the total annual unused co-op funds are in the 10’s or 100’s of millions annually.

Here are some tips on how to take advantage of co-op programs for your brands:

Follow the guidelines
 
Sounds simple enough, that is until you start reading the 50+ paged guideline book. I was cleaning up my office just this past week and I found a stack of them: BMW, CDRJ, Ford, Mazda… all thicker than the last issue of the Strategy Mob magazine. However, you have to appreciate that OEMs (like you do… or should), need to maintain a consistent brand. As a result, OEMs have spelled out everything for you. The good news is that typically most of these requirements make sense and their “restrictions” are in line with the best practices you should have when designing an ad.

Pay attention to the specifics for each brand

While this may seem straightforward, in practice things can get tricky. For an automotive group that may represent multiple different brands the task can be fairly tedious. Heck, even if you have one brand, you may actually have 4: Chrysler, Ram, Dodge, and Jeep are all different brands. Some need a disclaimer (Toyota), some need the model code (Nissan), some require specifics on pricing (MSRP vs. list price). The point is, each brand is willing to provide you funds to advertise their cars, you just need to follow their rules.

Be aware of changes in guidelines

Brand standards will change from time to time and OEMs will typically send you new guidelines when this happens. It’s important to fully re-read the documentation as small details may change that will affect the approval of your ads. 

For example, in May of 2015, Volkswagen changed their corporate font from “VW Utopia” to “Volkswagen Text” and more recently, Volkswagen has decided to remove "Das Auto" from the logo completely. After a grace period, any ads with the old font and the tag line "Das Auto" will be rejected from co-op funding. 

Take the easy way out - Get your agency to do the legwork.

If you think this is a lot of work, you’d be right (They are giving you “free” money - after all). So why shouldn’t they want things done correctly. In many cases, each ad needs to be submitted to the OEMs for pre-approval and then resubmitted with a screenshot of the ad as it appeared “in the wild” before your dealership is reimbursed. Think for a second about the years and years that brands have spent developing their brand. Now imagine you and all your DP and GM buddies coming up with your own Chevy, Audi, and Kia ads. Do you think they would look better or worse than the guidelines?
 
Now as a result of the hurdles, we’ve found that only a fraction of dealerships are taking advantage of co-op funds from OEMs. Most cite the lack of capacity or resources to submit their ads properly. Others tell us that they can’t keep up with the changing guidelines. Many have submitted ads which were rejected and that left a bad taste in their mouths.
 
Typically advertising agencies that specialize in automotive dealerships will have a service that will handle this process. When selecting an agency that does this, try to find one with a motto similar to “We do the heavy lifting, so you don’t have to”. This likely means they have a turnkey solution and you won’t have to do much work. Some will charge a fee, however, the fee is usually nominal and by not taking advantage of co-op funds, you literally are leaving money on the table. In other cases you may be able to find Agency partners who are fully certified by the OEM such that all activities they manage for you are co-op approved. Many Auto Audience Network Certified Partners have taken the time to setup these relationships with your OEM and you should ask them for a list of “approved vendors”.


Remember, it’s in the OEM’s best interest that you sell more of their cars. Co-op is another tool that they provide you to do that. By taking advantage of this tool, you’re able to stretch your advertising dollars, reach more buyers and sell more cars.

What are some other interesting things you have learned about co-op funds? Or, challenges you’re facing. Share them in the comments.

Ian Cruickshank

Speed Shift Media

VP of Sales and Marketing

2578

1 Comment

Big Tom LaPointe

Preston Automotive Group MD/DE

Nov 11, 2015  

how many dealers are NOT using their co-op money? most i've been around pay closer attention to that wallet than their own kids...

Ian Cruickshank

Speed Shift Media

Nov 11, 2015

Best Selection? Lowest Price? These Differentiators Don’t Work. Here’s What Will.

Here’s a reality check. You have the same new cars as your brand competitor, and you are all competing for the same car buyer’s attention. How can you differentiate yourself from the competition and convince that buyer to come to your dealership?

In large cities, there can be as many as ten dealerships selling the same new cars. For example, the small city I live in has four BMW dealerships. Los Angeles area has eight, Atlanta area has three and New York City area has nine. If a car buyer lived in any of those cities and wants to buy the same black M6 Grande Coupe with red Nappa Leather, which one of those dealerships should they visit?

All dealerships can order the same new cars from the factory and all vying for the attention of this car buyer. So the question is:

What can you do to make sure the buyer comes to your dealership and not your competitors?

Successfully differentiating your dealership can make the difference between selling more cars, or losing valuable market share to the competition.

Let’s go over how this can be done.

Find out Exactly how you’re Different

Driving to work, I heard countless advertisements on the radio about dealerships talking about the best selection or lowest prices, and I think to myself “They can’t all be right”. And when this happens, people tune out or – worse – they completely mistrust this message. In that case, you’ve lost.

What you need to do is some customer research and find out why they come to you and why they buy from you.

After a successful sale, make sure to do a win analysis. Get your team to ask these questions:

  • Why did you come to this dealership?
    Is it location? Is it selection? Was it a referral from a previous buyer? Did we have the best reviews on Google? OR, are you just in a part of town that’s next to the lottery corporation and all the winners see your dealership first after picking up their big bag of money?
     
  • Why did they ultimately decide to buy from our dealership?
    Did they like our salespeople? The service? Was it the lowest price they found? What was compelling enough for them to drop thousands of their hard earned dollars on your lot versus the other guy?

Keep in mind that your sales team may, or in many cases may not be, the right people to ask these questions. You may want to ask these questions by way of a follow-up phone survey. Do this as part of the call that you make a few days after the sale – you know, the call that you are making to ensure your customer had a great experience and that they are not suffering from buyers remorse (you are making that call – Right?). If you have a marketing team member on staff, they are likely the best candidate to carryout this process.

Once you have about 30 or more responses you’ll be able to find trends in the answers provided. These trends will provide you with unbiased input on why people like your dealership and will provide you with differentiators based on what the market actually feels about your dealership.

This gives your message much more resonance than something simply made up in a board meeting, and will attract more people like the ones that have already bought cars from you.

Construct the Message

156258d2d9170e4965ed960512c11718.jpg?t=1Now that you have found out why people truly come to you, it’s time to distil those findings into a succinct message that buyers can relate to. When creating a message, try to keep these things in mind:

  • Use unlike statements
    Using "unlike" statements is the quickest way to show you’re different from the rest. For example, your Toyota dealership is in the suburbs, try: Unlike many other Toyota dealerships that are clogged up in the dense city, we are located right off the highway for your convenience. Or if your dealership opens on the weekend, try: Unlike many other Ford dealerships, we are open the entire weekend, so you can find the car you want without taking time off work.
     
  • Message on benefits not just features
    Frame and explain the benefits of your differentiator to the buyers. As with the examples above, if I had simply stated that I was off the highway, I could have been met with a “so what?”. Once the statement "being off the highway" is framed as being convenient, then it will resonate with buyers who value convenience. Likewise, if you simply stated you are open all weekend, people may just be thinking you’re promoting your hours, rather than understanding the value you are open later or longer than your competitors.
     
  • Avoid inward facing statements
    I get it, you’re the biggest dealership in your county. Or you’ve sold more cars than your next three competitors combined. As much as this is something to be proud of inside your dealership, this doesn’t hold as much weight with a buyer. Frame your message from the perspective of the buyer and ask “What’s in it for me?”. So, if you’ve moved more inventory than your competitors, try “More GM buyers have trusted us to deliver the car they want” rather than “We’ve sold more cars than any other GM dealership.” 

By creating the right message, you’ll be able to communicate your strengths in a way that resonates with more car buyers. This in turn, will attract more shoppers and – ultimately – help you sell more cars.

Ian Cruickshank

Speed Shift Media

VP of Sales and Marketing

1699

No Comments

Ian Cruickshank

Speed Shift Media

Oct 10, 2015

The Great Photos, White Space, and 2 Other Ways to Keep Your Ads from Sucking

ec0960387c4ee6df46654df84768e020.jpg?t=1The Great Photos, White Space, and 2 Other Ways to Keep Your Ads from Sucking.

There really is just one way to mass broadcast your vehicles to potential buyers. Luckily it’s also very effective. Yes, I’m talking about inventory advertising.

You can argue that word of mouth or some other methods are more efficient (when measured by cost per lead), but you simply can’t beat the volume of leads that inventory advertising brings. Honestly, that’s why it’s still around - Transitioning from the inventory ads that were prevalent in the local papers to the state-of-the-art behavioural-based programmatic digital ads that hover in cyberspace.

All things being equal, it stands to reason that the more effective your inventory ads are, the more likely they’ll attract the right buyers and turn over cars on the lot.

And therein lies the problem - as with many things in life, not all inventory ads are created equal, and the "less equal" ones perform very poorly at attracting auto buyers.

Previously, we chatted about how to create a compelling and competitive message to differentiate your dealership, but those words or phrases don’t magically arrange themselves into beautiful ads ready to attract prospective car buyers, they’re just words.

Now, I’m a data guy, a marketing guy, a sales guy, and most definitely a car guy, I even fancy myself to have a little design skill, but those skills pale in comparison to our own super design juggernaut!

I’ve interviewed our own Creative & Co-op Advertising Manager, Danielle Borisoff, about what makes an ad attractive to a car buyer, and as a result, effective.We also talked about what not to do… like the age old giant Starburst!!

Here’s what she said:

Ian Cruickshank (IC): So Danielle, throughout your career you have created thousands of  ads and designed the creative behind all of our customers’ ad templates. What is the single biggest piece of advice that you would give regarding inventory ad creative?

Danielle Borisoff (DB): I believe the phrase “The car is the star” sums it up very nicely. It’s important to remember that people choose cars before they choose dealerships, so advertisers need to be aware and play on that fact. By making the car the focus of the ad, you can better attract and pique the interest of the buyer thus making the ad more effective.

 

IC: I like that, “The car is the star”, so what are some ways to make that happen?

DB: The easiest way is to use real photos and not stock photography. This applies to both new and used cars. Car buyers now are so inundated with information that they gloss over stock photos. Even if the stock photo is of the same car and same color, people won’t trust the stock photo. Incidently Doug Demuro - a columnist for Jalopnik.com wrote a great piece specifically about the annoyance of stock photography (Attention Dealers: For God’s Sake, Take Pictures Of Your Inventory).

 

IC: Any tips on how to take the right photos?

DB: The quality of photography of the car is vitally important. To resonate with the buyer, you need to capture what the buyer wants to see. Almost all buyers want to see the car as if they are about to pick it up for delivery. This means a clean front quarter shot and without any distractions such as a busy background or dealership brand graphics placed over the frame of the image.

example_smith_300x250.jpg

example_smith_300x250_overlays2.jpg

A clean photo without any busy graphics makes the car more attractive to the buyer.

 

IC: Why are dealership graphics on the image not recommended?

DB: Two reasons actually.  First, graphics often obscure the top or bottom of the vehicle preventing the buyer from seeing the full picture. Second, and more quantifiable, you run the chance of not passing the Co-op or Compliance program guidelines of the OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) compliance agencies. For example: if your dealership sold Ford and Lincoln, and the photo of your new Ford F150 has “Ian’s Ford and Lincoln” banner on it, the Lincoln logo would violate Ford's branding guidelines and the OEM agency would then refuse reimbursement for this particular ad.

IC: Wow, that’s great advice. What about the ad creative itself? Are there ways to design the ad to further complement the car?

DB: An effective way to stand out in the actual ad creative is to embrace white space on your inventory ad. Many dealerships that we work with will, understandably, want to maximize the number of vehicles they can have on their ads. However, this doesn’t always work in their favor. Many automotive ads are placed on busy, high traffic websites. Having a busy ad on a busy site detracts from the experience. Like a piece of art, including some white space in an ad will give the inventory some room to breathe and will draw more eyes to it.

example_smith_160x600.jpg By framing the ad in white space, you give the ad room to breathe and allow it to become more noticeable.

 

 

Danielle’s guidance dives into the actual art of marketing and is particularly useful as we live in a world where all dealerships have access to the best technology.

All else being equal, the art of the message and the creative can be the edge in a hyper-competitive industry where we all want to attract new buyers and sell more cars.

 

i5N_osbJWWU6UY2POy5wsELpPwjzn54-rimQA4Ys

Danielle Borisoff is the Creative & Co-op Advertising Manager and has been working at Speed Shift Media for over six years. With a Fine Arts degree from Emily Carr University of Art and Design, she handles the design for and implementation of all graphical elements for Speed Shift Media and many of their clients.


What kind of creative rules does your team adhere to? Add them in the comments.

Ian Cruickshank

Speed Shift Media

VP of Sales and Marketing

4020

4 Comments

Dave Hicks

Ontario Motor Sales

Nov 11, 2015  

Hmmm. Best idea winner at DSES this year was "showing the steering wheel first" Thoughts?

Shawn Long

Ed Martin Automotive Group

Nov 11, 2015  

This article is spot on with what i see converting. The only thing i would point out is i keep my text on even a bit more of a minimal level to make sure i am in compliance to the 20% Text Facebook Ads TOS . Great read, thank you for it.

David O

Multi-Franchise Dealer

Nov 11, 2015  

Steering Wheel first is a great idea... Anything to stand out is a great idea... Starbursts, cheesy image would stand out. The key is to determine your placement first... If you are looking for more VDPs, then the steering wheel as the first shot would work to get people to click onto your VDP. BUT if you want to make sure the person clicking SEES your message (banner ads,etc...), then a clean visible message on the ad copy is the way to go. Great points IC

Ian Cruickshank

Speed Shift Media

Nov 11, 2015  

Hi Dave H. - great question, and I think Josh Pogue (a great Canuck) would agree, that it's about the context in which you are using the images. In a listings environment where all other players are going for the 3/4 view you can standout with the steering wheel shot. That said, when you are trying to distract a consumer with a display ad the Steering Wheel is not likely to have the same effect. I don't think I would be incorrect in suggesting that few car buyers, in the milliseconds required, will recognize the steering wheel of the cars they have been considering. Shawn - Thanks for your comments - Compliance with FB is important for sure, additionally you have to consider OEM compliance when seeking Coop. Happy to help on both anytime. David O - you're right on the money with your comments, Cheers.

Ian Cruickshank

Speed Shift Media

Oct 10, 2015

The Non-Analytical Guide to Google Analytics for Car Dealers

I’m a car guy at heart, and it’s my 5-year old son who reminded me. We all love cars – that’s why we do what we do. Their lines, their smell, the rush you get when you climb inside a car with more horses than you could fit on a football field. I love how old cars have so much character and meaning. As a tech nerd, I love how new cars are beginning to push the boundaries of technology and connectivity. I’m an analytical guy and at the same time, I’m a feelings guy, so I choose my cars with fairly equal parts heart and head.

8bfdafa64ae28b8dafd74a57fdf106c1.jpg?t=1Like many of you, this is why I initially had so much trouble understanding VDP analytics – they were nothing but numbers!

As a leader in your dealership, you need to understand the significance of these numbers to make informed decisions about the performance of your website, and to evaluate your marketing spend. In brass tacks, you need to choose how you drive traffic to your website and your Vehicle Detail Pages based on numbers, instead of which vendor rep is more fun (I’m not saying you think that way… I’m just saying…).

I’ll let you in on a little secret: It starts making sense when you equate website numbers to numbers you would normally find on your dealership’s lot.

Think about it, a dealer’s website is the virtual representation of a brick and mortar lot. The unfiltered Search Results Page (SRP) is the representation of every car on your lot, and, if someone searches for all the SUV’s, that’s the equivalent to the big row of SUV’s at the back of your lot. The Vehicle Detail Page (VDP) is the representation of a specific car on your lot – like when a customer is effectively saying I like that Black XLT.

Once you start thinking about it this way, your dealership's web analytics start making much more sense. Instead of focusing on the technical metrics themselves, focus on the numbers that you would otherwise ask your sales manager.

Here are some of the basic (less useful) metrics.

Website Analytics

Real Life Dealership Equivalent

Why it’s not as Useful

Time on Site

The average amount of time someone spends on your lot.

There are many reasons why someone would come to your lot. Only one of which is to shop for cars. When you include time spent on all pages (instead of time spent only VDPs) you get a skewed result that raises more questions than answers.

Pages per session

The average amount of things a shopper interacts with on your lot, showroom and service center.

This metric is the easiest to get skewed as it counts everything. Imaging if you were counting the number of times a person was interacting with the coffee machine or your dealer group’s magazine. These numbers only tell you that the shopper is doing something and doesn’t accurately tell you if a shopper is interested in your cars.

What are some of the "more" useful metrics?

Website Analytics

Real Life Dealership Equivalent

Why it’s Useful

Time on VDP

The average amount of time someone spends on your lot looking at specific cars.

This gauges the level of interest people have in your cars. Typically the longer they look at a car, the more interested they are in it.

VDP per session

The average amount of cars a shopper looks at per visit.

This indicates the level of interest your market has in the cars on your lot. The more cars they look at per visit, the more likely buyers are going to find the cars they want to buy.

Return VDP views

The average amount of visitors that come back to look at the same car.

This determines how many people are interested in a certain car. This metric refers to the amount of people that come back into your lot to look at your cars again.

As with the behavior of someone looking to make a large purchase (a TV, a home, a car), the shoppers will typically visit the product page over and over again if they are interested in purchasing it.

Likewise, the more return visits a VDP gets, the more likely someone is interested in that car. If you begin to see spiking traffic on specific cars, you’ll likely see that car leave the lot in the near future.

 

See? It isn’t so bad once you translate these virtual metrics into plain English and think about them in terms of real life scenarios. With this method, you can make sense of all the technical mumbo jumbo, discuss VDP quality in a language that’s easy to understand and make the right decisions surrounding the performance of your website.

Ian Cruickshank

Speed Shift Media

VP of Sales and Marketing

5473

2 Comments

Jon Berna

Driven Data

Oct 10, 2015  

Great post Ian! One of the other more useful stats we employ across our dealer dashboard we call Q-Web which is based on user level stats. Essentially we use GAs segments, under the advanced section click on conditions. Filtering by users you can adjust the count of sessions, session duration and pageviews. We see this stat correlates to sales at a rate of about 70-80% depending on what you set each stat's variable to and the dealership. To setup this up for yourself go under admin > segments > conditions. If you look at the Source/Mediums that drive Q-Web you will see organic traffic, autotrader, cars.com and referrals from the OEM. Which based on the correlation to sales makes sense. I know this is a bit more analytical but definitely useful!

Ian Cruickshank

Speed Shift Media

Oct 10, 2015  

Hey Joe, thanks for the recommendation on Q-Web. I'll have to check that out! The more dealer intelligence we have the better!

Ian Cruickshank

Speed Shift Media

May 5, 2015

Why Would you do the Thinking for your Ads – Sorry, You’re just not that Fast

Automotive Advertising for Dealerships Using Data Driven Display Ad Solutions

ea5b7f77db1bfc59338f94e12a245dc5.png?t=1In this day and age, marketing technology has made advertising for dealerships inventory increasingly more sophisticated. Dealerships, Data, and Display Ads are more closely linked than ever. But, it can be challenging to understand this form of advertising and how it works. An important part of understanding why car dealerships and dynamic inventory advertising are a good fit is to learn about how advertisers use layered data to help make advertising more effective.

 

What Is Layered Data?

Programmatic advertising refers to a systematic method of purchasing and dynamically serving advertising that leads to a reduced cost and greater ROI for advertisers. Programmatic advertising gives your dealership a more targeted advertising focus than other advertising methods. A dynamically delivered programmatic approach gives car dealerships an advertising campaign that shows the right vehicles to the right people at the right time. In an Adweek article from November 2013, former VP at NBCUniversal, Peter Naylor, calls programmatic advertising the “newer, better mousetrap” of the advertising industry.

 

Why Does Programmatic Advertising Help Auto Dealerships?

Programmatic advertising and car dealerships are a good fit because of the very specific way that people shop for cars online. In many cases, prospective car buyers use something called “long tail” search terms. These are search terms that are much longer than the common keyword searches that SEO marketers target in their marketing efforts. It is challenging for dealerships to engage these prospects through traditional online marketing methods. This is where programmatic advertising’s layered data approach becomes very important. Using the breadcrumbs of data left behind by car buyers as they travel through the path-to-purchase, enables the intelligent delivery of display ads with the right content.

 

How To Get Ready For Programmatic Advertising?

The first step for dealers that want to use programmatic inventory advertising is to make sure they have their vehicle inventory well merchandised and up to date on their website. This will ensure that the vehicle inventory displayed in dynamic inventory ads look their best. Then you need to get your inventory into the programatic ad system. Depending on the advertising company you are working with, this is typically done automatically and it is constantly updated, since a dealership’s available inventory will change on a daily basis, as cars move on and off the lot. 

 

What Data Is Used In The Process?

Car buyers who are searching for cars in your inventory will be shown your advertisements based on several important data criteria. Here are a few examples of the kind of layered data that programmatic advertising takes into account for car dealerships:

  •     Which websites and vehicles the user is reading reviews on
  •     What vehicles are being compared in their research
  •     The vehicle a user searches for in listings 
  •     Other historical browsing activity
  •     Where the user is located
  •     Etc.

 

How The Automotive Industry Could Promote Programmatic Advertising?

Another reason car dealerships and programmatic advertising are excellent together is because of the unique structure of the industry. When leveraged correctly, this structure facilitates partnerships that can lead to greater profitability across every level of the automotive industry’s distribution model. The typical way we break down the parties involved in the automotive industry is the three tiers: manufacturers (OEMs), regional dealership groups, and local dealers. Programmatic advertising has seen immense growth already, but according to an article in eMarketer from January 2014, the continued growth of this trend in advertising depends on partnerships between groups in the three tiers. Individual dealers will rely on regional groups and manufacturers to support them with sophisticated, approved, advertising networks that account for modern digital marketing principles. Conversely, local dealerships will play an important role in the promoting of specific vehicle inventory with more tightly targeted advertising tools. A concerted effort across the industry, to combine the available data, would lead to greater access to the information that is used in programmatic advertising, which would in turn, lead to greater effectiveness of overall campaigns.

 

About Ian Cruickshank

Ian has spent over 10 years in Marketing and Digital Advertising. His early days were spent with two of the largest media companies in Canada in sales and sales-leadership roles. In recent years he has spent his time both consulting on digital disruption and as the head of sales and marketing for a social media marketing firm in Vancouver, BC. As the VP of Sales & Marketing for Speed Shift Media, he is the head of all revenue generating activities. With a Masters in Business and IT Management and as an Adjunct Professor at the University of British Columbia, he is regularly called on to present and lecture on a variety of Information Technology and Digital Marketing concepts. Most of all he loves to be outside with his wife and his young family in Port Moody, BC. Feel free to contact him directly @Ian_Cruickshank or ian@speedshiftmedia.com.

Ian Cruickshank

Speed Shift Media

VP of Sales and Marketing

3108

3 Comments

Timothy Martell

Wikimotive

May 5, 2015  

The guys over at Dealer Inspire have been doing this for over a year. One of only 2 website providers we recommend to our clients. Also, I am not compensated in anyway for that opinion. They're just the best we've found so far.

Ian Cruickshank

Speed Shift Media

May 5, 2015  

Great to hear - I’d love to chat with them and I’m in Chicago in two weeks. Who would be the best person to meet with? Or you can have them contact me directly: ian@speedshiftmedia.com

Timothy Martell

Wikimotive

May 5, 2015  

Joe Chura, CEO. I'll shoot you both an e-mail now.

Ian Cruickshank

Speed Shift Media

Apr 4, 2015

Make Your Display Ads Actually Matter To Car Buyers

 

Dynamic-inventory-display-advertisementYou likely have a solid grasp of the online marketing techniques that work effectively for your dealership, you know that delivering relevant information to the right people, at the right time, is key to your success. Dynamic inventory ad creative is a concept that’s relatively new to most peoples’ marketing tool box, but it has been experiencing explosive growth and the trend is expected to continue.

Dynamic inventory ad creative is an important digital marketing tool for auto dealers because it allows dealers to personalize the ad for each user. It’s been proven to increase the effectiveness of online advertising campaigns by delivering a better experience before and after the click. Dynamic inventory ad creative has significant advantages over a non-custom approach, and as a result, it is more cost effective even if it has a higher sticker price. When you consider the high percentage of clicks resulting in direct VDP and SRP views to most campaigns, which may net only 20 to 25 percent VDP and SRP views, the ROI is easy to understand. You would have to buy 4 or 5 times as many clicks to get to the same volume of VDP/SRP views as a well run Dynamic Display Ad Program, which can deliver up to 100% of it’s clicks to the Vehicle Detail or Search Results Pages. 

 

The Power of Dynamic Inventory Ad Creative

Most big name ad exchanges have provided online marketers with a wide range of tools to capture the attention of targeted Internet users. The current influx of consumer data serves to amplify the importance of dynamic creative for digital marketing, as we now know more about buying habits, trends and purchasing, than ever before. For example, networks like the Auto Audience™ Network are able to match the make, model, and year of the vehicles being researched before the consumer ever reaches a Dealer’s website. 

There are many ad exchanges focused on qualifying prospects that fit certain criteria, and then selling ads against those segments to dealerships with varying results. However, the latest in online marketing tools enable marketers to capture an individual qualified prospect at the right time, and when showing them the right vehicles the results have been impressive -- in both cost-effectiveness and scale.

 

Sophisticated Targeting Needs the Right Message

The technology that helps us to deliver the interests of individual users is meaningless if it doesn’t have the content to support it. Cashing in on dynamic inventory ad creative means combining the target audience data with a compelling message that is extremely relevant to them. For example, you typically wouldn’t serve a convertible sports car to a demographic profile like this — Retired Female 65+ living in Chicago who has been behaviouraly segmented as an Auto Intender. The typical marketing plan would suggest that an appropriate vehicle might be a Honda CRV or a Toyota Corolla. But with data targeting the individual user the old way of using broad stereotypes and demos like Male 18-49, or Female 25-54 are all but gone. Now with one to one user targeting we know that this Kick-Ass-Grandma is in the market for the new BMW M3 convertible and Dynamic Inventory Ads can deliver that specific vehicle from her local BMW Store — Go Grandma Go!

 

How Dynamic Inventory Ad Creative Works

Without getting overly technical, dynamic inventory ad creative operates by breaking down an ad into its separate components and developing different content to fit within each piece. The concept is similar to a rooms floor plan where you can swap out different furniture to get a range of styles. Effectively, it is a template waiting to be filled with the right vehicle content. Such as, Image, Vehicle Make, Model, Year, and Price. Once you have your ad with its separate puzzle pieces, you add the engaging content. The content will vary depending on what the ad network knows about the user, and it will rotate your vehicle inventory according to that data on each user.

The first thing you’ll notice when you look at an ad that has been optimized with this approach is that the message is more relevant, and this is why dynamic creative is important for automotive retailers. This type of ad speaks to the individual buying a car based upon their specific known interests, rather than a group of potential auto purchasers in a broad category or stereotype. Dynamic creative can be refined to the specific vehicles that the user has been researching – right down to the VIN level.

Dynamic inventory ad technology informs the buyer which local car dealership features their chosen vehicle, and gives them specifics on the models in stock. The design templates used in  dynamic creative are typically flexible and simple to use, so they enable you to experiment with style and aesthetics. When consulting with an a vendor or your agency, ask about the how the ads are served. They should be delivered via an Ad Tag. If the ads are Flash or Gif files, they are likely not completely dynamic.

 

The Bottom Line

The advantage dynamic creative offers to digital marketing is clear – it's the online display ad tool that enables you to deliver highly personalized content to qualified car buyers at the right time. For your dealership, it's a necessary component of your online marketing strategy.

If you have any questions about this or any other part of your online marketing activities, please feel free to comment on this blog or contact me directly via LinkedIn or at the office. I’m always happy to to help.

Ian Cruickshank

Speed Shift Media

VP of Sales and Marketing

3499

No Comments

  Per Page: