Driven Data
The Inbound Call Pre-snap Read
It’s the third down with 12 yards to go and, after the quarterback relays the play from the offensive coordinator to the team in the huddle, everyone gets into formation. As the play clock ticks down, the quarterback identifies the defense shift into a blitz formation. He signals the receivers and offensive line to make the required adjustments for their individual routes and protection assignments. He turns to the tailback and lets him know his blocking assignment. With everything set and ready he approaches the center hikes the ball, drops back and hits an open receiver for an easy completion and a nice gain for a first down, not to mention making this entire process look relatively effortless to the casual observer.
The pre-snap read and audible in football is one of the ultimate expressions of teamwork under pressure in all of sports. As fans, we typically applaud the individual, almost instinctive decision the quarterback made — not the effort that went into being able to make the decision. The pre-snap read was the effort of hundreds of hours of film study, coaching and overall preparation by the entire offense. By knowing the play the defense was running, the offense has the advantage, but this opportunity can only be seized if the entire system works together.
Luckily for dealerships we, too, have many opportunities to have an advantage.
However, before I identify these advantages, please understand your customers are not the competition. Your competition is the level of preparation, training and execution of the other dealers with whom your potential customers are also communicating.
Your dealership is receiving calls from a vast array of sources for new vehicles, used vehicles, marketing campaigns and voicemail returns. How can you organize them to go to the right person at the right time so you can diagnose the situation correctly? Before I answer that, you must first understand what “one-call resolution” truly means. It means stop transferring calls, stop paging and stop making people wait. The person who answers the initial phone call must be the best “available” person to handle anything that may surface on the call. This core value requires a combination of training and technology.
With customer expectations at an all-time high, you need to separate yourselves from the pack by making your dealership’s customer service look effortless. All things being equal, an organization where customers are routed to the right person faster will enjoy higher conversions than one where the customers have to wait — where calls are paged, transferred and put on hold.
1. Marketing Call Tracking — For a single dealership, you should have well over 50 toll-free tracking numbers in use. Each source must have unique ad source assignments. This step is initially a challenge, but if setup correctly, it’s one of the single best ways you can improve your marketing business intelligence. It is also essential for the inbound call pre-snap read.
2. Phone System Call Routing and Skill-Based Logic — Calls can route to the correct person based on logic through an Automatic Call Distribution (ACD) phone system. The technology evaluates the source and/or location, then determines who has the highest skill level to handle that type of call who is in an “available” status. By segmenting the calls, the highest performers can receive more calls, the most important calls and the return calls from the voicemails they left previously. In skill-based routing, for example, a rep can be certified to handle specific new or used car questions. Since agents will receive the same type of calls every day, they become increasingly better at their individual focus.
3. Advanced Caller ID and CRM Integration — Thanks to advanced caller ID from a modern ACD phone system, your BDC reps know the advertising source, location, department and the customer’s caller ID information, as well as the previous call history of the customer all before they answer. They can now give a custom response based on each call situation. The BDC rep doesn’t need to ask the source during the call. All the rep needs to add is the additional contact information, appointment and notes. Call logging can now reach nearly 100 percent.
4. Phone Call Handling — Ultimately, your employees need to be trained on how to handle each situation that may come up on their calls. You can prepare for this by categorizing and scoring a sample of your calls. Build an ongoing report of the most common initial questions customers ask, as well as the questions that lead to the wrong call result, whether it be a hang up or no appointment. You should also set up your phone system to dynamically change the phone scripts based on the type of customer and source. Again, this is possible with most modern ACD phone systems.
Jon Berna
Driven Data Consulting
Driven Data
Aristotle and Data Driven Decisions
So what about Aristotle? Aristotle’s the Art of Rhetoric contains the ‘Three Means of Persuasion’ which are Ethos, Pathos and Logos.
- Ethos - The moral cause to agree or the audiences perceived character/reputation of you
- Pathos - Emotional, can be either negative or positive, fear of loss > fear of gain
- Logos - The logical justification to make a choice, the cold hard facts, figures, specs and data
In most selling situations you will have to rely on all 3. The trick is finding the right combination that is suited to the person you are trying to convince. So what about YOUR processes and YOUR management decisions. How are they made? How are you persuaded and how do you persuade others? A Moral Cause / Reputation, Emotion, or Logic.
Let’s use your advertising as an example.
There are really two sides to consider. How your advertising persuades the customer and how your organization is persuaded to sell it. Let’s focus on your team, because if they can’t sell it your customers won’t buy it. Apply the right combination of the 3 means of persuasion to get your team on-board with the right mix to each person. Think about how each of your employees, employee groups, managers, top managers are persuaded. Here are some examples.
- Community-driven: food drives, local sponsorships your company can believe in
- A better customer experience: no hassle transparent sales process – your sales people want this
- The competition: who are your current primary competitor? Is everyone in your organization aware of their strategies?
- Honestly cultivated brand advocates: Testimonials from true fans. A clearly visible sterling reputation the customer can feel.
- Defining how the current course of action creates a great future of opportunities for everyone
- Allowing your team the opportunity to help in its development. Give them emotional ownership in its results (intrinsic motivation)
- Explaining the expected result from the plan and how that affects their performance and compensations (extrinsic motivation)
- Establishing one version of the truth in your reporting.
- When possible establish your own business intelligence as opposed to relying solely on your vendors.
- Developing an overall advertising dashboard with ALL of your top metrics.
- Sharing all of your metrics with your team, regularly and honestly.
- Installing clean data processes through the sales funnel.
- Automate process where possible and enforce proper technology usage at all levels.
- Flow chart each high value process that effects sales. Ensuring each person understands them and their role.
By Jon Berna
Data Driven Consulting
No Comments
Driven Data
Selling the way Your Customer Wants to Buy
Here is a story about a customer that communicated and negotiated at one of the highest levels I have seen to-date. This was near the beginning of my career in auto I was the BDC Director at a great up-and-coming dealership in the North Chicago suburbs.
The customer in question had inquired on our website about a specific $12k, 30k mile, Honda Civic for his son. He was clear, to the point and no nonsense in his initial request asking for additional pictures of the interior, tread depths on all 4 tires, pictures of the underbody (with the car up on the rack) and scanned copy of the repair work we had completed after taking it on trade. After quickly complying with all of his requests as well providing an in-depth video walk-around, I explained in email that I would be calling in 20 minutes to ask him when he would be able to drive in. He quickly emailed me back and set an appointment within the next 1 hour. So far so good, right?
He shows up for his appointment early and very pleasant. We have the car pulled up and ready to go. He thanks me for being honest and prepared. He then takes an hour test drive with our top sales person (sells 25-30, 10+ year’s tenure). After the trial close, he asks for a write-up goes through the full process, multiple TOs etc. Using a binder we display the complete repair history from previous customer, our internal repair work, the car fax and a list of cars in the market that are close in miles and options. We go over our internet pricing technology and how this car is priced well below the market.
He is clear at every turn that he feels the car is a great candidate but he has others to review. Our store had a write-up everybody approach, so those of you thinking let him walk without numbers, please understand this was a core philosophy of ownership. The GSM lets him go with a slightly reduced price and doesn’t do any hard selling. I call the customer back that evening and thank him for visiting, any questions etc. and ask for the appointment. He tells me he will call me in 2 days at a specific time. I attempt to turn the phone appointment into a store appointment and he restates his prerogative to call me in 2 days.
2 days later… He calls me on-time and explains that he would like to come in that evening as he had driven the other vehicles. Again, he is on time and very thankful. The original sales person starts the write-up from the number we let him out at. He brings a folder that appears to contain the same information that we provided him the on the other cars. The sales person asks to see the other vehicles and he says that he would prefer to purchase our vehicle with price being the only remaining factor. We ask multiple times in every imaginable way to see the other 2 cars. He never shares this with us. After multiple rounds of numbers and no end in sight our GSM starts pressing him harder to commit. The customer remains very calm and simply states that he does prefer our car in all aspects other than the price. He thanks the GSM for his passion and after about 1 hour says that sometimes it’s just not meant to be and starts to walk. The owner jumps in and attempts to charm him…45 minutes later and some of the best back and forth from a customer I have ever seen the owner has dropped everything selling the car at zero profit.
Quite simply the customer was the best sales person in the building. He was honest, punctual, and extremely pleasant to speak with and never allowed his emotion to enter HIS sales process. After the customer agreed to purchase the owner asked him what he did for a living (he wouldn’t answer prior) he politely explained he was the Senior VP of purchasing for one of the largest grocers in the Midwest. He was responsible for all bulk purchasing deals for the entire company.
The owner told him that his skill as a purchaser was the best he had ever seen and because he was so pleasant he was fine with selling the car at the price…stating you 100% earned it.
I am sure that nearly anyone in the business that reads this has at least 1 customer that you are thinking of right now that performed similar to this one. Why is this type of customer so good at getting an awesome deal? They cannot be persuaded by emotion, only logic...their logic.
Today we have tools that allow us to negotiate through documentation as we did in the story above. Is your team using them at every stage in the sales process? It was the philosophy in the dealership in the story that if the deal was worked properly and it got down to a near zero profit deal we sold the car, earned the customer and built the relationship with service.
In the case of the customer in my story he did give our sales person referral business, purchased a warranty and did use us for service. However, this didn’t just happen. The F&I manager conducted his interview after the numbers were agreed to even though he said he was paying cash. The sales person asked for the referrals after the F&I interview and before the customer went to F&I. After all of the paperwork was complete, he was given a full walkthrough of the service department as well as introduced to the parts and service director. It was here that we enrolled him in our loyalty program and scheduled his first service appointment. 90 days later a post card was mailed and 95 days later an outbound call was made reminding him of his appointment.
And he continued to be punctual showing up on time for his appointments.
It is my experience that when you sell a vehicle at a lower front-end profit everyone in the dealership rallies on the second half of the sales process. Fear of selling the tougher customers based on the selling price alone excludes you from all of the other potential profit opportunities. An effective sales process must plan for these at or below zero front-end profit situations and as a team adjust accordingly on the fly.
Jon Berna
Driven Data Consulting
4 Comments
Remarkable Marketing
Great article! This is so relevant to what we deal with in todays shopper. I love how you related the customer to being the best sales person at the dealership.
Driven Data
Thanks Grant! Although this was awhile back, I remember the satisfaction everyone felt within the dealership when it all started to click.
AutoAlert,Inc.
I have always thought that this should be the philosophy in most stores:it was the philosophy in the dealership in the story that if the deal was worked properly and it got down to a near zero profit deal we sold the car, earned the customer and built the relationship with service. Years ago, it always frustrated me that the deal that was turned down, became a "get that customer back" (31st of the month) since we are 2 cars short of our goal and projections. When I started desking it was simple: if I would take the deal on the last day of the month, then I would also do so on the first day of a new month. Grosses always even out -with a nice deal tomorrow to off-set a lousy one today!
Driven Data
Improving Appointment Show Rate and Sold Rate
The phrase “Roll out the red carpet” or “We are going to roll out the red carpet for you” is one of the more common ways we have defined our sales process to customers as different from our competition. I argue that any person or better yet, organization that is truly going to do this doesn't have to say this to a customer, the customer just feels it! The term itself directs the dealership down the wrong path for giving a customer the best experience possible. The customer doesn't want an overly dramatic staged experience, they just want to feel respected, important and most of all they want us to make everything easy for them. This to me means understanding what they need before they need it as well as avoiding the all-too-common pitfalls we see every day. We tend to look for 'silver bullets' to help us sell cars. Like finding that miracle vendor, ad campaign or product to help us take our business to the next level. If you wanted to grow your business 25% the best place to start is finding 1% in 25 places. Each sale can be measured much the same. I don’t think any one step or person by itself directly causes a sale. It takes a completely random combination of events executed at the highest level to sell even 1 customer. Think of each process down the sales funnel: advertising, website, email, phone, pre-visit preparation and finally in-store. The area of focus in this document is what steps to take to maximize your appointed customers show rate and sold rate.
If you start viewing the down stream stats from the time you receive a lead (overall phone, internet and 3rd Party) you should have the following conversions over a rolling 30 days period:
This gives you an overall 25% appointment to sale rate. Although benchmarks create false barriers for success this number if combining all sources would be considered healthy. Sometimes we over-think common sense. Over the last 10-15 years of the ‘internet-sales person’ versus the ‘old-car-guy’ rift we have seen countless internet sales people enter the business lacking tried and true common sense saleswoman and salesmanship. All of the best practices you see below are taken directly over the years from nearly 100 sales people of all tenure in the car business. This guiding document sets the table for what can be done situationally for your customers.
- What would you add?
Post-Appointment Checklist
Prior to Arrival -------------------------------------------------------------------
- Confirm Appointment
- Confirmation phone call
- Fact Find, confirm vehicle(s) of interest, broaden
- Ask what vehicle they will be driving to the store today
- Add Notes to their CRM profile
- Send email w/ video (if not already sent)
- Confirmation phone call
- Confirmation Text Message (if applicable)
- Vehicle Prep
- Find the vehicle
- Find all sets of keys
- Make sure there is plenty of fuel
- Make sure you have plates
- Do a walk around to make sure the interior & exterior are clean. Don’t forget the trunk, under the hood, dash lights and the wheels & tires.
- Hang tag / sign with customer’s name
- Either physically or mentally choose back-up vehicles
- Paper work:
- Carfax
- If certified, inspection sheet and/or RO
- Any current Incentives & Rebates on new vehicles
- Pull vehicle(s) up front – this means you’ve started the car
After Arrival -----------------------------------------------------------------------
- Direct to VIP Parking / VIP Check-In Area (if applicable)
- Check In / Register (Mark them ‘shown’ in the CRM)
- Strong, friendly greeting followed by…
- Brief tour of dealership
- Sales Manager introduction
- Make sure customer is ‘checked in’ in crm
- Get copy of driver’s license
- Brief tour of dealership
- Provide beverage & snack remove consumer guilt (just provide it anyways)
- Don’t forget to point out the restrooms
- Full walk-around of vehicle
- Test drive
- Interview
- Trial Close
- Park vehicle in ‘sold row’
- Back at your desk
- Gather additional contact info
- Add notes
- Make it happen
By Jon Berna
Founder Driven Data Consulting
7 Comments
CBT News
Great thoughts Jon. Creating the buying "experience" can be tough for a walk in. But when you know who the customer is, when they are coming, and what they are looking for - there's no reason not to be prepared to give them the red carpet experience that can go a long way in creating a sale today and a life time customer moving forward.
Driven Data
Thank you Russell. I know most of this is common sense and the challenge is not "if" doing this will help, rather how to implement it as close to 100% of the time. In a single store this is a bit easier with improved appointment visibility. In a dealer group with a centralized BDC this takes well refined processes and oversight.
CrossCheck, Inc.
It's amazing just how quickly what we think is common sense goes right out the door when the sales pressure is on! One way to improve things when customers DO show for those appointments? Have an awesome waiting room. You can WIN the waiting room game - start here and download my new free eBook! (No waiting!!!!) http://bit.ly/1dOyonN
Driven Data
Heather I downloaded your eBook and this doesn't have anything to do with sales appointments and improving their show rate and sold rate. The last thing a dealer would ever want to do is make the customer wait after they arrive.
CrossCheck, Inc.
Jon, I'm sorry you didn't actually get to read the eBook after downloading it. I welcome feedback anytime. Would you mind giving it a read before commenting? The eBook is all about how to make customers who do have to wait more comfortable, including tips on what kind of reading material and electronics to stock in the waiting room, healthier snack options, etc. It's geared towards more of the auto repair area, but in my experiences, I saw new car customers wait up to 8 hours for their cars to be detailed, F&I to go through, etc. Some even had food delivered right to the show room floor. So, when the wait is unavoidable, it can be more pleasant, depending on the waiting room. Best of luck to you on DrivingSales!
Great fundamentals Jon! I think salespeople try so hard to build rapport that they forget to build credibility by truly listening to their customer and responding to their needs in a timely fashion. All any customer wants is to feel important. Building rapport may help you if you if you are trying to invite them over to the house for dinner, but if selling a car is on your to-do list, credibility that is built by asking the "right" questions and following a consistent process is key.
Driven Data
BDC Call Routing Done Right | Managing Your BDC Like a Call Center 4 of 4
This is the 4th article in the series Managing Your BDC Like a Call Center:
Ok your BDC is receiving calls from a vast array of sources, for new vehicles, used vehicles, marketing campaigns, voice mail returns (call backs) how can you organize them to go to the right person at the right time? Before I answer that you must first understand what 1 call resolution truly means. It means stop transferring calls, stop paging, stop making people wait! The person who answers the initial phone call must be the best available person to handle anything that may surface on the call. This core value requires a combination of training and technology. Customer expectations are at an all time high, that requires that you separate yourselves from the pack by making your customer service look effortless. All things being equal, an organization where customers are routed to the right person faster will convert higher than one where the customers have to wait (calls are paged, transferred, on hold etc). This should be common sense. So how much does this impact the customer experience?
I will pose the answer in the form of a very recent personal example:
While building a website for a client, I had to contact their domain registrar to setup additional web hosting. I couldn't complete the full transaction online so I was forced to call. I called their sales line and the person that answered was awesome, they helped with all of my questions, gave me a concise recap in an email and directed me to all of my next steps. Unfortunately, I needed a very specific piece of information from my client to complete the transaction.
When I called back the next day after going through 5 prompts (sales had 0 by the way) the person that answered had no clue what I was talking about. They transferred my to another department and the previous agent didn't tell them a single iota of the 7 minutes I had explained previously. After taking them through what I need (in cliff notes now) they were able to determine I needed to become an approved user on my clients account before I could call support. According to this person I would have to have my client call them and give my information. Keep in mind I already have my own account as an admin on my clients profile on the site. I explained this and was told of their protocols etc. At this point I am furious.
The package we are purchasing is expensive and they are not letting us buy from them unless we jump through 10 hoops backwards and on fire. I ask to speak to the sales agent I originally spoke to and the caller tells me that's impossible because I am not approved! The next day my client calls and they tell them we didn't need to take that step as I was listed as an admin, my client tell them to call me to complete the transaction. The original sales agent calls me and we finish in less 2 minutes.
Think of the last time you called a call center and had a bad experience, everyone has one if not tons. A common theme was the time it took to get you the information you needed to get you to whatever the next step was.
We can break these down into the following root cause categories:
- Unable to quickly pull up the customers information. Ever heard the, "My computer is acting up" line?
- Poor product knowledge. You get the sense it is their first time hearing your question.
- Had to transfer you to another department, subsequently you have to repeat your whole story (sometimes multiple times).
- Takes zero ownership of the customers needs. Their focus is on getting off the call as quickly as possible.
- Their goals are not aligned with the business goals. They let a sale walk because of misinterpreted rules or lack of common sense.
Your customers journey from inquiry to sale requires that you plan to avoid these pitfalls and here is how. Below are 3 situations with two accompanying flow charts.
Click to View Larger Image:
Basic call routing: Call is answered by the operator. They attempt to transfer to the BDC rep the customer asked for. If they are not available she will most likely blind transfer to the BDC phone tree. From here it rings all phones until the quickest BDC rep answers. If the intended BDC rep is available they transfer, otherwise they make the customer repeat their request and attempt to handle the call.
Advanced Call Routing: Call automatically routes to the BDC rep. This is done a couple ways. The phone system identifies the CRM assignment and automatically routes the call based on the assignment. Customer calls a specific routing number assigned to the BDC rep. Before the call is routed the phone system evaluates if the agent is available. If they are not the call routes to a designated person or team. On their computer screen it shows them the call is for the original agent (who is either on the phone or gone). They quickly inform the customer they work directly with the other agent and immediately pull up the customers record all while following the appropriate script for this situation.
Basic call routing: Call is sent to the BDC phone tree ringing every phone in the department. The quickest BDC rep answers the phone call. The agent is unaware of the callers information, the source or location the call is for so they must handle this by asking the customer questions. If they handle multiple departments or locations they have to answer generically, "Thank you for calling ABC Auto Group, this is Steve how can I help you?" This 'first impression' puts the prospect on defense and lengthens the total call time. Sourcing is based on if the BDC rep asks and if the customer gives it (they may not even know). Contact information collection is also based on if the BDC reps ask and if the customer gives it. The logging of the call is up to the rep and the managers ability to cross check multiple reports.
Advanced Call Routing: Call routes to the BDC rep based on logic. The system evaluates the source and location then determines who has the highest skill level to handle that type of call that is in an available status. By segmenting the calls the highest performers receive the most important calls / more calls etc. Since we are using skill-based routing, as an example the rep can be certified to handle the manufacture for that location and trained on handling specific new or used car questions. Since agents will receive the same type of calls every day they become increasingly better at their focus. Your BDC performs like dozens of mini assembly lines where agents are specialized to perform their jobs. BDC reps know the advertising source, location and caller id information before they answer. They give a specific response, "Thank you for calling the pre-owned department at ABC Motors, this is Steve how can I help you? The BDC rep doesn't need to ask the source and when they ask for contact information they already have the name and number from caller ID. Data entry for inbound calls can now automated via http post integration with your CRM. All the rep adds is the additional information, appointment and notes. Call logging goes to near 100%
Basic call routing: The BDC uses either their number or a generic number that goes to the BDC phone tree. When the customer phones the number the call is answered by the quickest rep. They ask the customer for their information. Keep in mind customer forgets the name of the person that called them nearly half the time. This requires the BDC rep to search in the CRM to find who most recently called the customer and what they were calling about. The customer tries to explain what they may need and the BDC rep either transfers to correct rep or handles on their own. If the BDC rep left their personal number and the customer called after they left the call goes to voice mail where hopefully the rep contacts them back the next business day.
Advanced Call Routing: The customer calls back an individual number assigned to the specific BDC rep. This number is in all of their emails, voice mails and customers caller ID (on their phone). When the call hits the phone system it determines if the agent is available, if they are the agent gets the call. Before they answer they know the customer's information and that the call is call back from a voice mail. The agent answers the phone, "Good afternoon, Stacey, this is Steve thank you for calling me back..." If the BDC rep is not available it routes to a designated roll-over team. "Good afternoon Stacey, this is Sara, Steve informed me you would be calling and we work on the same team..." Calls do not go to voice mails in this system, everything is handled live by agents that are trained.
Thank you for reading my 4 part series on Managing your BDC like a Call Center. With 10 years of experience in call center operations both outside the auto industry and within, these tips I have learned the hard way. Effective communication is at the foundation of progressive companies.
Comment below with your feedback!
No Comments
Driven Data
BDC Phone Systems and Reporting | Managing Your BDC Like a Call Center 3 of 4
This is the 3rd article in the series Manage Your BDC like a Call Center:
The decision of what type of phone system to secure for your department requires an understanding of the options and features available. This article will present the current options as well as define the reporting needs that are essential for dialing in your department. The reporting capabilities of phone systems contain vast differences. I will cover some of these and shed some light on how you may not need a overly expensive solution and still get all you will need for years to come. Nearly all of your telephony costs are up front however your improved consumer experience will continue to get better as you drive efficiencies. After you review the features review how you can leverage your new found data in the section near the bottom. Here is a list of common features your BDC will need:
With an ACD and the correct surrounding BDC Phone Systems and Reporting you can now correctly staff your BDC based on data instead of guess work. Here's how...
The 6 metrics below are all pulled directly from the call data in reports that should be very easy to pull on-demand. The first metric you need to understand is setting your Service Level Agreement (SLA). This is a stated benchmark of anticipated performance. For example 90% of your calls being answered in 20 seconds or less. To figure this out you sum the number of calls with a ring time under 20 seconds divided by the total number of calls. If you fall below this target you are either under-staffed or inefficient. You can determine your efficiency by reviewing your call center occupancy. This percentage can be expressed at an individual level but is more commonly used to review the entire department. This number is the total time on the phone and doing after call work divided by the time staffed. If your under your SLA and have high occupancy you are most likely understaffed. The other factors that can hurt your SLA are high Average Handle Times (AHT) and aggressive outbound dialing. Your BDC is what is called a blended call center meaning it both takes and makes calls (versus inbound-only or outbound-only). Every time and agent dials out it makes them unavailable. Since there are gaps between calls usually this isn't a problem. However when 2 agents are on break, 1 is sick and 3 are at lunch you have to be careful not to overdo it.
These 6 metrics are the driving force behind both daily and long term strategic planning. Having these at your disposal affords a BDC Director or eCommerce Director the intelligence they need to move the needle forward. If a regular BDC runs at 60% effectiveness a well run Call Center BDC will run in the mid 90%s.
Metric | Description | How to Use (application) |
Service Level Agreement (SLA) | Single most important metric to monitor. The department should be built with an SLA (Service Level Agreement) i.e. 90% of calls answer in 20 seconds or less. | This stat is used for determining staffing size and overall efficiency to an agreed target. Now you know how your department is answering all calls. |
Average Seconds to Answer (ASA) | The amount of time on average it takes for a call to be answered after arriving in the queue | Primary metric used in tracking the SLA. |
Average Handle Time (AHT) | Average Talk Time plus After Call Work. This is the indicator of call and agent efficiency. | The number should not be too high or too low. Look for outliers and match with other signals, like poor call scores or low inbound contact rate. |
Occupancy / Utilization (OCC) | Total handle time (talk time plus after call work) divided by the total availability (time spent logged in to the queue) | How effective the call center is able to schedule its staff. The aim is to achieve the right balance between too much idle time on one hand and overworked staff on the other. Usually around 85% is target |
Cost Per Contact (CPC) | Number of calls per month divided by (operating cost + labor). Do not include marketing costs | Cost per call is a way to track how well resources are being utilized and to measure the ROI for the center |
Schedule Adherence (SA) or Work Force Management (WFM) | Total time the agent is available for calls divided by the time they are scheduled to work. You must take breaks and lunches into account. | You are looking as a % to see excessive unapproved breaks, not available etc. Real time data and staff accountability improve this |
Next up, I will dive into how call routing impacts customer service with tips how you can route calls more effectively in your dealership or you can get a sneak peek here
No Comments
Driven Data
Advanced BDC Phone Metrics | Managing Your BDC Like a Call Center 2 of 4
This is the 2nd article in the series Manage Your BDC like a Call Center:
As call volume increases you will find that your basic phone system is quickly becoming a major source of profit leakage. How can you measure profit leakage in a BDC without a more modern phone system? Call the dealership yourself once a day asking the common questions your customer ask everyday. You should also take a look at how many inbound calls came in versus being logged. If you are using tracked local and toll free numbers on all of your customer facing marketing and communication you can make an effort to listen to these calls. Keep in mind there is something wrong with nearly every call you will hear, so try not to over-react. Unfortunately it is going to be very hard as it will lack the tracking capability some very basic phone systems can.
So, is there a better way to handle calls then every phone in the department ringing at once until someone grabs a phone...yes and its called automatic call distribution or an ACD.
Technology makes this inspection very easy. Your phone tracking and reporting infrastructure needs to be 100% custom to your business. The metrics in this article are for phone systems with an ACD. This type of phone system delivers calls to agents based on logic and availability. So what is and ACD and what makes is so much better? An ACD is software and hardware that is installed locally or hosted remotely designed to handle all of your incoming calls by distributing them in a more controlled streamline way. The software allows for separate rules for different types of calls as well as situations. Here are a few examples.
- You have 7 dealerships and you want all of the calls for your Honda dealership to be answered by your 4 Honda trained BDC reps (called skill based routing). The calls for the Honda dealership are routed to a range of ACD groups designated for this store (basically a bank of local DIDs) that have rules built in to send the call to the agents that are Honda certified. The system will automatically 'see' who is available of the 4 and send the call there. If all of the 4 agents are unavailable we can setup a backup plan to roll the call to another team of agents (called a roll-over team).
- You have a BDC of 12 reps and you want more calls to route to the highest performers. Simple, ACDs have what is called priority based routing where you can set everyone on your team a level. If 1 is the best and 5 is the worst and each agent is setup the phone system will evaluate availability by skill level from 1-5 until it finds the best agent to handle the call and send them the call automatically
- Your BDC reps leave voice mails in the morning that call back after they have left for the day and you want them to be handled live. The phone system can be customized so that calls can not go to a voice mail with out first going through a specific partner (buddy system) or a roll-over group.
These are 3 examples out of 100s of ways an ACD with advanced bdc phone metrics can drive efficiencies for your team. Dealers are spending a large portion of their money on getting the phones to ring, yet very little on the phones themselves. With an ACD let's learn how we can review performance on a whole new level with advanced bdc phone metrics:
Metric | Description | How to Use (application) |
ACD Calls | The number of calls that hit the automatic call distribution system | This is the top of the funnel, this can be used as a base for conversions |
Active Calls | The number of calls that are on the line in real-time | So agents and managers know who is on the phone and for how long |
Waiting Calls | The number of calls on hold in queue waiting for an agent to become available | So everyone is alerted that a customer waiting. |
Accepted ACD Calls | The number of accepted calls by the agent from the queue | You can see accept rate from ACD Calls by agent to determine where call are going |
Login and Logout | When the agent starts or ends their shift | Agents start and end their day by entering or exiting specific ACD Groups |
ACD Group | An isolated channel within the ACD that calls can route to. ACD groups allow for the customization of rules for which agents can answer calls, the timing, roll over groups, voice mail and overnight handling | |
Available Status | An agent in a ready to receive calls disposition | Know who is ready to receive calls |
Not Available Status | An agent unable to receive calls (break time, lunch time or from self-disposition) | Fewer staff = longer wait times for customers |
After Call Work | Defined amount of time the agent has to complete data related tasks before they will automatically be place back in an available status. Usually around 30 secs to 1 minute. | |
Time in Queue | The duration of time from the call arriving to being answered by an agent | Review for specific calls as well as patterns (shift change, end, lunch-time etc.) |
Abandoned Calls | Calls that hit the queue that hung up before being answered by an agent | One of the worst thing that can happen in a call center. High attention to this. |
Live Answered | Calls that bypass the queue because an agent was available to answer immediately | This is a good thing and a metric you want to see a high % of. Divide by ACD Calls |
Re-Queued | A call that was connected to an agent’s phone but not answered in a preset amount of time. This call is then sent back to the queue or rolled to another agent | Big red flag, either agent left desk without switching to 'Not Available' or they saw the call and chose not to accept the call. |
Next up I will discuss go over how your reporting and feature needs should drive your next phone system purchase. Here is that article
No Comments
Driven Data
When does a BDC become a Call Center | Managing Your BDC Like a Call Center 1 of 4
This is the 1st article in the series Manage Your BDC like a Call Center:
Every department needs boundaries so the employees know their responsibilities. This department I would argue has the ability to impact every inch of your business with a higher magnitude than any other. With that great power comes the need for 100% transparency of its actions. It is also fair to hold every other department to the same 100% transparency standard and dealers all across the country are already doing this. Let’s be honest though this is a high dollar investment with high expectations, not to mention a few people in the organization may choose to keep their head buried in the sand to the need for improved customer communications and fight this change. The response to that must be this, if customers are your most important asset than their experience with your organization should be giving top priority.
"The simple answer is when you decide to make it the communications hub of your organization."
You can measure this by tracking how customer make their way from person to person when they call. You will find the long holds, multiple pages, repeat callers and poor communication skills. Typically we blame the person who handles the last call, but if you had to wait 10 minutes to get an answer how pleasant would you be to set an appointment or come in for service. Let’s de-personalize this and blame the process. Phone training only goes so far, the most highly skilled person in the world will still be at a huge disadvantage if the customer is already frustrated.
Before you start purchasing technology and creating process you first need to understand the metrics and how you can build this communication hub with the end in mind.
Metric | Description | How to Use (application) |
Total Dials | All calls regardless of origin, destination or duration | Simple enough every number that was dialed |
Total Calls | Calls with a duration over 10 seconds | This usually cuts the bad number / mis- dialed amount |
Total Contacts | Calls with a duration over 45 seconds | 45 secs. Is enough time for 4 rings and a voice mail. A conversation occurred |
Inbound Contacts | Calls from an external number over 45 seconds | A measurement of quality of call and ability to handle first question |
Outbound Contacts | Calls to an external number over 45 seconds | Quality of call and quality of the tasks the agent is working on |
Internal Inbound | Calls from an employee number or line | This can be problematic if your agents are receiving too many |
Internal Outbound | Calls to an employee or line | Identify higher than normal levels |
Call Backs | Return calls from the customer to a tracked line designated for call backs | Low numbers = poor or nonexistent voice mails / sent emails |
Total Production | Sum of all calls less internal | Quick number to see effort towards customer communication |
Unique Callers | Number of calls with discrete records, count 1 per unique number | For inbound, a great way to compare to leads that were logged |
Total Talk Time | Duration of time less ring time | We are look for a sweat spot, not too high not too low |
Off-Hours Calls | Number of calls that arrived prior to or after the department was open for business | These must be called back and if too many adjust business hours |
*Items in blue require some additional segmentation and algorithms to develop
These metrics cover the preliminary phone KPIs you will need to manage your call center production. (list does not include other areas of information including lead levels, conversions, call scores, CRM data etc. You will need to add that information in to get the full picture of your teams performance)
In addition to the metrics you will also have to define the dimensions you will slice the data by. The dimensions would include:
- Time - (calls this hour, day, week, month)
- Assignment - (specific agents, extensions, teams, shifts, locations/stores)
- Source Information - (website, cars.com, retargetting, email campaign)
Next I will discuss how you take to to the next level from here by adding automatic call distribution with advanced call metrics. Here is that article
No Comments
No Comments