Notifications & Messages

Jared Hamilton
From: Jared Hamilton
Hey - It’s time to join the thousands of other dealer professionals on DrivingSales. Create an account so you can get full access to the articles, discussions and people that are shaping the future of the automotive industry.
Ryan Gerardi

Ryan Gerardi Futurist

Exclusive Blog Posts

Rock's Rants: Training (Lack Thereof)

Rock's Rants: Training (Lack Thereof)

Here's what I've noticed in dealerships: the problem isn't just a lack of training, it's the general lack of a thought process that any tra…

4 Easy Ways to Crack Down on Unethical Used Car Dealers

4 Easy Ways to Crack Down on Unethical Used Car Dealers

We all love getting a good deal, especially when it comes to making a large investment like a vehicle. Used cars are a great way to save some cash whil…

The Hidden Costs in Your CRM

The Hidden Costs in Your CRM

The CRM is arguably one of the most essential tools for the dealership other than the DMS. However, one thing to note and consider are all of the hidden fe…

WEBINAR RECORDING - 5 Tips for Improving Customer Engagement in Every Customer Interaction

WEBINAR RECORDING - 5 Tips for Improving Customer Engagement in Every Customer Interaction

The online and offline worlds are colliding. Customers carry pocket-sized computers everywhere they go, but that doesn’t mean that personal face-…

Why Human Capital Management?

Why Human Capital Management?

“People don’t leave companies, they leave managers”  I love this quote by John Stemph, Ex-CEO of Wells Fargo. It does a great job…

Dealers Still Own Their DMS Data...For Now

Last week's news of Authenticom being granted its request from the court for an injunction against CDK and Reynolds and Reynolds to continue accessing dealerships' R&R data management systems to provide the information that dealers and agencies need and have a right to was a BIG WIN for the auto industry. 

Information is power – it’s a truism we all know. But in the 21st Century, access to information is where the real power lies. This point has been illustrated with crystal clarity in the recent CDK / Reynolds & Reynolds lawsuit brought by Authenticom. The public fight between these companies is finally getting its day in court and the first round has made headlines throughout the industry.

CDK and Reynolds & Reynolds handle the vast majority of the data management software sales for the auto industry. CDK alone boasts more than 27,000 retail client locations and is the primary provider of data management systems (DMS) to most of the top US dealer groups.

Reynolds also represents a large portion of the market and bundles DMS solutions with consulting, training and management systems for the entire dealership. Both companies also offer data integration, the combining of separate data to present one, unified view. Simply put, the two companies represent the lion’s share of the data available in the auto marketplace.

When you’re dealing with that much information, you’re also talking about a lot of power.

CDK / Reynolds & Reynolds - The Story

The story begins back in the early 2000s. At that time, the data management system market was developing – and flourishing. Both CDK and Reynolds had come out publicly supporting the idea that data belonged to the dealers.

At the time, Reynolds emphatically stated “The data belongs to the dealers. We all agree on that.” CDK agreed and said they had "always understood that dealerships own their data and enjoy having choices on how best to share and utilize that data with others."

This inclusive and open environment allowed the data integration market to flourish. With more than a dozen providers offering data integration services, the competition kept prices competitive while fostering plenty of innovation in terms of user-friendly software.

But all that began to change in 2007, when Reynolds and Reynolds was acquired by Bob Brockman. At the time, Brockman was the owner of Universal Computer Systems (UCS), a company he founded in 1970. Over three decades he built the company up to become a heavy hitter in the world of automotive services. When he headed up the acquisition of Reynolds and Reynolds, people expected a change – and Brockman delivered.

Almost immediately, Reynolds began restricting who could access the data their system had. Other data integrators found themselves with their credentials yanked and a wall built between them and the data they needed to deliver results to their own clients. It was a complete about face from the position of Reynolds just a few years ago, and the dawn of a new age when it came to data integration.

In a somewhat niche field like the auto industry, the actions of Reynolds and Reynolds effectively cut off nearly half of the available data to other integration service providers. Over the next few years, this tug of war over access to information effectively killed off much of the competition.

But even as Reynolds was limiting the flow of data, they were placing a higher premium on the data they alone could provide. Fees to access their data climbed to almost staggering numbers, with some dealerships coughing up $150,000 or more every year simply to access and manage their data.

Meanwhile, their stranglehold was about to become even stronger. While the number of players was dwindling in the field, Reynolds clearly wanted to narrow things even further. According to the story laid out in Authenticom’s Complaint, in February of 2015 Reynolds and Reynolds reached out to CDK to strike a deal.

The two teamed up to freeze out everyone else. They would attack, undermine and thwart the efforts of everyone else in the market, ultimately leaving the two companies to reap the full rewards of a niche – but lucrative – market. Not only would this plan leave the entire market theirs for the taking, it would allow them to set any price they wanted. They would control ALL of the information – meaning they could charge whatever they wanted for it and dealerships would have to fall in line.

Since then, the companies have controlled the data integration system world with an iron fist. It became the Nasty Little Secret everyone knew about. As companies fell by the wayside, turning their focus to another area of service or simply going under, the pressure was turned up on the competitors that remained.

A Problem (Not Just) for Authenticom

One such competitor was Authenticom, headed up by President and CEO Steve Cottrell, who was another well-known player in the automotive data industry. With more than three decades of experience in the industry, he had spent 15 years building Authenticom into an impressive and well-respected company.

During that time he managed to grow their revenue from $3.7 million to $20 million in under 5 years. In 2015, the company was saluted by President Obama as "one of America’s own fastest-growing private companies”, so his efforts were clearly paying off.

Until, he says, CDK and Reynolds decided there wasn’t enough room for all of them. Authenticom, like other rivals, felt the pinch of CDK and Reynolds’ attempts to prevent data integration companies from accessing their data.

Read the full story on DealerRefresh.

Chris K Leslie

 Unlock all of the community & features  Join Now