Dealer Authority
Apply Local Flair to Your Facebook Promotional Posts

Facebook has been a challenging venue for marketers and advertisers ever since it started really getting popular in 2009. At that time, it was clear that it was the social network to beat and the company started trying to cash in with different types of advertising options. Most of them failed miserably for the same reason that many marketers continue to fail today: people go to Facebook to be entertained, not to be the recipient of ads.
Today, it’s getting easier. People are more accepting of ads. A lot of it can be attributed to the way that Facebook has handled their promoted posts. They have done an excellent (some would say Draconian) job of keeping messages off of news feeds that are too promotional. Between the manual vetting they do of ads and the 20% text rule they apply to images, they’ve been able to keep a relatively strong balance between letting advertisers get their message out and keeping their users happy through minimized spam.
When it comes to putting out a message that resonates, that users can enjoy while still getting the promotional message out, businesses (local ones in particular) should consider adding a touch of fun and flair to their posts. In the example above, the goal of the car dealership in question is to promote their oil change special. There are a couple of different ways to go about doing this. They can make it a Facebook offer which can be very effective if the special is a true Facebook-only special. They could make it an event, but they would have to really make it a true event for that to work and few people would consider car maintenance an event. They could be direct – post about the special and throw some ad money at it. This is not recommended as the negative sentiment would murder the page’s EdgeRank.
In this case, they added the localized and timely flair of focusing on a wonderful aspect of living by the Great Smoky Mountain National Park. It’s spring and people are thinking about what they’re going to do when school is out, when vacation time comes, and when the weather is in a state of awesomeness that they can venture forth and enjoy the world. The message is clear and ends with the “pitch”:
“Spring in Waynesville, NC. You know what that means, right? Time to plan a trip to the Great Smoky Mountains National Park.
“Before heading out, make sure your ride is in “Mountain Ready” condition. Here’s an oil change special just for your trip…”
By positioning it in a way that takes a positive aspect of local life and applying the marketing message at that point, it allows for the post to flourish. Even though the page itself has around 700 fans, it was liked by 80 people, shared by 3, and commented on by several. Branding was achieved. Positive sentiment was achieved. The link to the special itself on their website received a nice amount of clicks. Most importantly, the message was seen by around 10,000 locals.
There’s a fine line between tricking people into interacting with a post to click on an advertisement and actually engaging with them on their terms and getting the message to them as a result. Using local flair is one of the easiest ways to make this happen.
Dealer Authority
You Just Don't Need 50+ Social Networking Profiles
I've written about this before and I hope I never have to write about it again. Unfortunately, this past week at Digital Dealer proved to me that more companies are pushing the concept of having the dealership present on 50+ social networks.
Let's get beyond the argument that they're not useful. As I've said before, many used to sell SEO by saying that they'd get dealers listed on thousands of search engines. The same holds true in social. There are only 7 social sites that truly matter to a business today.
What's more important to understand is that getting on all of these social sites is not only useless, it's detrimental. Here's why:
If You Have Them, Be Active On Them
What's worse than when a potential customer doesn't find you on their favorite obscure social network? When they do find you on their favorite obscure social network and you haven't been active in a year. Believe it or not, it's insulting to some people.
Still, that's what's happening. Dealers are buying into these bulk social media products and finding that their vendor is creating these accounts. They might even post some things to them. In most cases that I've seen, they're either putting them on an automated feed or not posting to them at all after a certain period of time (the first week?).
So here you are with dozens of social network profiles floating out there. Are they really being monitored? You don't know. What happens if you cancel with that vendor? Are you going to start monitoring them? What happens if you have, say, a Tumblr account branded to your dealerships name and you and/or your vendor stops posting to it and monitoring it. Someone comes along and starts posting their spam links to the page, perhaps links to their favority Viagra site, multi-level marketing scheme, or porn. You get the picture.
If you're going to build it, put the effort into keeping it up. If you're going to have a vendor build it, they certainly better be spending the time and resources to keep it active and monitoried. You don't want it to get hijacked by a porn spammer with your dealership's name attached, which leads me to my next point...
Don't Pay to Reach Nobody
That's what's happening. If you're paying to get onto these 50+ social networks, you're paying to reach literally nobody. Some of the profiles that they get you on have zero chance of ever being useful. Why would you pay for a package that includes worthless profiles (that will go dormant at some point and potentially become spam havens under your name?).
Here's the worst part. Many of these profiles can't even be found under direct searches such as "[Dealership Name] Profile/Page". The pitch is that they will help with search. The reality is that the only chance they have to appear in search is if a spammer comes along, posts their links, then optimizes the profile so that people can find it.
It's either worthwhile (why would it be part of a product and not be worthwhile?) or it shouldn't be draining the resources of the vendor you're paying for social media (in which case, are you simply buying fluff?). There's no in-between.
It's Just Dishonest
If the companies who are selling this product realize that these profiles are worthless, why are they selling it to you? If they don't realize that they're worthless, why are they claiming to be social media experts?
The truth of the matter is this: they know they're worthless. They also know that "50+ social networks" sounds a lot better than "4 primary social networks" when they're delivering a sales pitch. That's all it is. It's fluff for the pitch.
100% of the attention of a proper automotive social media service should be focused on Facebook, Twitter, Google+, and Pinterest. YouTube, LinkedIn, Foursquare, and the other major social sites are best controlled by the dealership at the local level. That's all there is to it and I'd happily debate any vendor who says otherwise.
Don't fall for fluff.
4 Comments
PCG Digital Marketing
Well said JD. We run across this as well when clients come to us. Our team struggles at times to convince them that they do not need all of these sites but they feel they paid for them from as previous vendor and they need to use it. Thanks for being an advocate for reality
Dealer Authority
"Advocate for Reality". I need new business cards. Thanks, Glenn!
Motofuze
Just a sales tool to sell the snake oil. This is why I respect you highly JD. You pour out the snake oil and replace it with facts.
DealerTeamwork LLC
This is a great approach to a very daunting topic. I am curious to hear about the "other social networks" others are recommending? Anyone care to share?
Dealer Authority
You Just Don't Need 50+ Social Networking Profiles
I've written about this before and I hope I never have to write about it again. Unfortunately, this past week at Digital Dealer proved to me that more companies are pushing the concept of having the dealership present on 50+ social networks.
Let's get beyond the argument that they're not useful. As I've said before, many used to sell SEO by saying that they'd get dealers listed on thousands of search engines. The same holds true in social. There are only 7 social sites that truly matter to a business today.
What's more important to understand is that getting on all of these social sites is not only useless, it's detrimental. Here's why:
If You Have Them, Be Active On Them
What's worse than when a potential customer doesn't find you on their favorite obscure social network? When they do find you on their favorite obscure social network and you haven't been active in a year. Believe it or not, it's insulting to some people.
Still, that's what's happening. Dealers are buying into these bulk social media products and finding that their vendor is creating these accounts. They might even post some things to them. In most cases that I've seen, they're either putting them on an automated feed or not posting to them at all after a certain period of time (the first week?).
So here you are with dozens of social network profiles floating out there. Are they really being monitored? You don't know. What happens if you cancel with that vendor? Are you going to start monitoring them? What happens if you have, say, a Tumblr account branded to your dealerships name and you and/or your vendor stops posting to it and monitoring it. Someone comes along and starts posting their spam links to the page, perhaps links to their favority Viagra site, multi-level marketing scheme, or porn. You get the picture.
If you're going to build it, put the effort into keeping it up. If you're going to have a vendor build it, they certainly better be spending the time and resources to keep it active and monitoried. You don't want it to get hijacked by a porn spammer with your dealership's name attached, which leads me to my next point...
Don't Pay to Reach Nobody
That's what's happening. If you're paying to get onto these 50+ social networks, you're paying to reach literally nobody. Some of the profiles that they get you on have zero chance of ever being useful. Why would you pay for a package that includes worthless profiles (that will go dormant at some point and potentially become spam havens under your name?).
Here's the worst part. Many of these profiles can't even be found under direct searches such as "[Dealership Name] Profile/Page". The pitch is that they will help with search. The reality is that the only chance they have to appear in search is if a spammer comes along, posts their links, then optimizes the profile so that people can find it.
It's either worthwhile (why would it be part of a product and not be worthwhile?) or it shouldn't be draining the resources of the vendor you're paying for social media (in which case, are you simply buying fluff?). There's no in-between.
It's Just Dishonest
If the companies who are selling this product realize that these profiles are worthless, why are they selling it to you? If they don't realize that they're worthless, why are they claiming to be social media experts?
The truth of the matter is this: they know they're worthless. They also know that "50+ social networks" sounds a lot better than "4 primary social networks" when they're delivering a sales pitch. That's all it is. It's fluff for the pitch.
100% of the attention of a proper automotive social media service should be focused on Facebook, Twitter, Google+, and Pinterest. YouTube, LinkedIn, Foursquare, and the other major social sites are best controlled by the dealership at the local level. That's all there is to it and I'd happily debate any vendor who says otherwise.
Don't fall for fluff.
4 Comments
PCG Digital Marketing
Well said JD. We run across this as well when clients come to us. Our team struggles at times to convince them that they do not need all of these sites but they feel they paid for them from as previous vendor and they need to use it. Thanks for being an advocate for reality
Dealer Authority
"Advocate for Reality". I need new business cards. Thanks, Glenn!
Motofuze
Just a sales tool to sell the snake oil. This is why I respect you highly JD. You pour out the snake oil and replace it with facts.
DealerTeamwork LLC
This is a great approach to a very daunting topic. I am curious to hear about the "other social networks" others are recommending? Anyone care to share?
Dealer Authority
Getting More Facebook Fans is a Minimal Need Compared to Reach
For years, the acquisition of a bigger, “better” Facebook page has been a focus of many in the social media marketing realm. There are companies that are dedicated to the task. The reality now (and for a long time, actually) is that fan acquisition for business Facebook pages is such a minor piece of the puzzle that it’s something most businesses should push to the back burner. It’s not that you don’t need them at all, but the success of a Facebook page is determined by reach and fans are only a small part of the equation.
When someone likes a page, they have the potential of seeing your posts. For better or for worse, Facebook has made it challenging for the majority of your fans to actually see your posts on their news feed. They have to really, really like your posts a lot for them to appear on their news feed without help, which causes a chicken and egg conundrum. They have to see your posts to be able to like, share, or comment on them, but they need to like, share, or comment on them before they start seeing them in their news feed, at least organically.
This is where Facebook ads come into play, but there are distinct challenges there as well. Those who discover the reach potential of Facebook ads often make the mistake of promoting the wrong content. It’s not just about posting the “fun” stuff naturally and using Facebook ads to boost the promotional content. That is only effective until the content starts getting negative feedback. Remember, every time someone is presented with the content and chooses not to interact with it, that’s a bad thing.
A common series of events with Facebook ads looks like this:
- A user tries Facebook ads for the first time and their reach explodes for very little money spent.
- The content wasn’t super-viral and while it gets more interactions than most of the page’s content, it doesn’t do well in relation to the people it reached.
- Over time, the Facebook ad budget starts to yield reduced results. Hundreds of thousands reached becomes tens of thousands, then thousands.
- Budgets go up but engagement and reach stay stagnant.
Play the ad game the right way with EdgeRank in mind. That’s an entire other post. For now, let’s get back to reach versus fans.
Here’s an example of an above-average car dealer’s Facebook reach statistics:
In this example, you see that they’ve done a pretty good job of keeping it local. They have a page for their dealership in the Los Angeles area with around 4K fans. They post good, engaging content regularly. Their reach isn’t bad for an organic-only strategy.
Here’s an example of how a properly managed Facebook page should look for a local business. In this case, it’s a car dealership in Waynesville, NC:
The targeting is hyper-localized. They’re getting almost all of their views and engagement from within a 50-mile radius and the vast majority within a 20-mile radius.
They have around 700 fans.
Getting fans is important, but it’s only important in that it helps to expand a page’s reach. It isn’t who likes your page. It’s who sees the posts. The more people you can get to see your posts, the more effective your social media campaigns can be. Fans are part of it. Ads are part of it. Content is part of it. Putting together the exact right mix of the three is one of the biggest keys to success.
No Comments
Dealer Authority
Getting More Facebook Fans is a Minimal Need Compared to Reach
For years, the acquisition of a bigger, “better” Facebook page has been a focus of many in the social media marketing realm. There are companies that are dedicated to the task. The reality now (and for a long time, actually) is that fan acquisition for business Facebook pages is such a minor piece of the puzzle that it’s something most businesses should push to the back burner. It’s not that you don’t need them at all, but the success of a Facebook page is determined by reach and fans are only a small part of the equation.
When someone likes a page, they have the potential of seeing your posts. For better or for worse, Facebook has made it challenging for the majority of your fans to actually see your posts on their news feed. They have to really, really like your posts a lot for them to appear on their news feed without help, which causes a chicken and egg conundrum. They have to see your posts to be able to like, share, or comment on them, but they need to like, share, or comment on them before they start seeing them in their news feed, at least organically.
This is where Facebook ads come into play, but there are distinct challenges there as well. Those who discover the reach potential of Facebook ads often make the mistake of promoting the wrong content. It’s not just about posting the “fun” stuff naturally and using Facebook ads to boost the promotional content. That is only effective until the content starts getting negative feedback. Remember, every time someone is presented with the content and chooses not to interact with it, that’s a bad thing.
A common series of events with Facebook ads looks like this:
- A user tries Facebook ads for the first time and their reach explodes for very little money spent.
- The content wasn’t super-viral and while it gets more interactions than most of the page’s content, it doesn’t do well in relation to the people it reached.
- Over time, the Facebook ad budget starts to yield reduced results. Hundreds of thousands reached becomes tens of thousands, then thousands.
- Budgets go up but engagement and reach stay stagnant.
Play the ad game the right way with EdgeRank in mind. That’s an entire other post. For now, let’s get back to reach versus fans.
Here’s an example of an above-average car dealer’s Facebook reach statistics:
In this example, you see that they’ve done a pretty good job of keeping it local. They have a page for their dealership in the Los Angeles area with around 4K fans. They post good, engaging content regularly. Their reach isn’t bad for an organic-only strategy.
Here’s an example of how a properly managed Facebook page should look for a local business. In this case, it’s a car dealership in Waynesville, NC:
The targeting is hyper-localized. They’re getting almost all of their views and engagement from within a 50-mile radius and the vast majority within a 20-mile radius.
They have around 700 fans.
Getting fans is important, but it’s only important in that it helps to expand a page’s reach. It isn’t who likes your page. It’s who sees the posts. The more people you can get to see your posts, the more effective your social media campaigns can be. Fans are part of it. Ads are part of it. Content is part of it. Putting together the exact right mix of the three is one of the biggest keys to success.
No Comments
Dealer Authority
Dealers Need Seven Social Accounts, Not Dozens, Hundreds, or Thousands

In the early days of search engine optimization, the pitch that many companies used was very appealing. “We’ll get you listed on thousands of search engines so that everyone can find you.”
Today, this seems like a ludicrous statement. There’s only three real search engines that account for 97% of the search traffic and it’s been like that for some time, but back as recently as 2008, many companies were still pushing automated search engine submission as their primary selling point for search engine optimization. The same thing is happening today, only with social media.
There are companies out there promoting the concept of building and maintain profiles on dozens of social media sites. This is a joke on many levels. First, the majority of social media sites are not profile-driven. In other words, having a presence on them is only somewhat useful based on high levels of activity on the feeds and interactions with other users. The profiles of individual businesses themselves are never seen, never show up in search, and not viewed from the site itself. Second, any time a profile is associated with lightly trafficked social sites, there’s an additional chance of failure. Smaller sites get hacked. They go dormant. They get shuttered. There’s no good reason to have these sites because of the potential negatives associated with them.
The most important reason to dismiss these sites is that they’re simply padding. Businesses often like bulk. They like knowing that they have all of their bases covered. Unfortunately, the majority of social media sites out there are simply not bases that need to be covered. Why pay to have a presence someplace that is useless? It’s just fluff. It’s filler. It’s a way to say, “look, you get more out of our social media service because we give you dozens of social sites!”
There are four must-have social media profiles for the sake of engagement and three others that are relevant for different reasons. That’s it. The rest is just part of a sales pitch.
Facebook, Twitter, Google+, and Pinterest
These sites are necessary components of social media marketing for just about any business. They are where the action is currently happening. They bring value from a search perspective and are well-visited by people when they search for businesses by name because they actually have a chance of ranking.
Most importantly, there’s engagement potential. Properly managed, these four sites are where 99% of the social interactions can occur. It is a focused strategy that does not look at fluff as a primary sales tool and focuses on the things that actually matter in social media.
YouTube, LinkedIn, blogs, and others
YouTube is a channel. It’s a place where businesses can expose their message. LinkedIn is the professional component. It’s a measure for recruiting, a venue for public relations, and an excellent place to display the nuts and bolts of a company. While it’s arguable that it can be beneficial for B2B companies, it should not be utilized as a venue to attract B2C prospects.
Blogs are the personal repository for business communication that does not happen through video.
With blogs and YouTube, it could be argued that they are social media sites in that they are content-driven and attract eyeballs, but in reality they are monologue components of the marketing strategy. Yes, people can comment on them so technically dialogue can happen there, but it’s an internal dialogue. When blog posts or videos are shared on the above-mentioned four social sites, the dialogue can truly happen.
“Others” are the sites that are potentially valuable but not absolutely necessary for success. Tumblr, Foursquare, Chime.in, Flickr – these are sites that can bring value and should be considered by companies that have all of the above profiles humming and running on all cylinders, but are often a distraction otherwise. Also included in “others” would be the rising social sites. Yes, there are still websites and services that have potential to become players and they should be monitored, but putting effort into them in the early stages is not prudent. For every Pinterest that we put early-adopter effort into, there’s others that nobody has ever heard of that wasted time.
A quick note on automation
This is a debatable topic and I respect those who disagree, but the concept of running the smaller social sites through automation is a bad idea in my books. Yes, it’s possible to create a social profile, then hook it into a feed or other posting protocol that allows hands-free social integration. Some use this as the reasoning behind having dozens or hundreds of social profiles. “I build it and then I let it run itself.”
That’s appealing, but it’s also dangerous. Again, these sites get hacked. They become devalued. They get overrun with spam. They fall off completely. The risks are greater than the rewards.
* * *
Social media done right has the potential to help businesses advance their marketing and improve their customer communications. It should not be viewed in the terms of “more is better.” A proper social media strategy puts all efforts into venues that count. Otherwise, it’s just fluff to help a sales pitch.
No Comments
Dealer Authority
Dealers Need Seven Social Accounts, Not Dozens, Hundreds, or Thousands

In the early days of search engine optimization, the pitch that many companies used was very appealing. “We’ll get you listed on thousands of search engines so that everyone can find you.”
Today, this seems like a ludicrous statement. There’s only three real search engines that account for 97% of the search traffic and it’s been like that for some time, but back as recently as 2008, many companies were still pushing automated search engine submission as their primary selling point for search engine optimization. The same thing is happening today, only with social media.
There are companies out there promoting the concept of building and maintain profiles on dozens of social media sites. This is a joke on many levels. First, the majority of social media sites are not profile-driven. In other words, having a presence on them is only somewhat useful based on high levels of activity on the feeds and interactions with other users. The profiles of individual businesses themselves are never seen, never show up in search, and not viewed from the site itself. Second, any time a profile is associated with lightly trafficked social sites, there’s an additional chance of failure. Smaller sites get hacked. They go dormant. They get shuttered. There’s no good reason to have these sites because of the potential negatives associated with them.
The most important reason to dismiss these sites is that they’re simply padding. Businesses often like bulk. They like knowing that they have all of their bases covered. Unfortunately, the majority of social media sites out there are simply not bases that need to be covered. Why pay to have a presence someplace that is useless? It’s just fluff. It’s filler. It’s a way to say, “look, you get more out of our social media service because we give you dozens of social sites!”
There are four must-have social media profiles for the sake of engagement and three others that are relevant for different reasons. That’s it. The rest is just part of a sales pitch.
Facebook, Twitter, Google+, and Pinterest
These sites are necessary components of social media marketing for just about any business. They are where the action is currently happening. They bring value from a search perspective and are well-visited by people when they search for businesses by name because they actually have a chance of ranking.
Most importantly, there’s engagement potential. Properly managed, these four sites are where 99% of the social interactions can occur. It is a focused strategy that does not look at fluff as a primary sales tool and focuses on the things that actually matter in social media.
YouTube, LinkedIn, blogs, and others
YouTube is a channel. It’s a place where businesses can expose their message. LinkedIn is the professional component. It’s a measure for recruiting, a venue for public relations, and an excellent place to display the nuts and bolts of a company. While it’s arguable that it can be beneficial for B2B companies, it should not be utilized as a venue to attract B2C prospects.
Blogs are the personal repository for business communication that does not happen through video.
With blogs and YouTube, it could be argued that they are social media sites in that they are content-driven and attract eyeballs, but in reality they are monologue components of the marketing strategy. Yes, people can comment on them so technically dialogue can happen there, but it’s an internal dialogue. When blog posts or videos are shared on the above-mentioned four social sites, the dialogue can truly happen.
“Others” are the sites that are potentially valuable but not absolutely necessary for success. Tumblr, Foursquare, Chime.in, Flickr – these are sites that can bring value and should be considered by companies that have all of the above profiles humming and running on all cylinders, but are often a distraction otherwise. Also included in “others” would be the rising social sites. Yes, there are still websites and services that have potential to become players and they should be monitored, but putting effort into them in the early stages is not prudent. For every Pinterest that we put early-adopter effort into, there’s others that nobody has ever heard of that wasted time.
A quick note on automation
This is a debatable topic and I respect those who disagree, but the concept of running the smaller social sites through automation is a bad idea in my books. Yes, it’s possible to create a social profile, then hook it into a feed or other posting protocol that allows hands-free social integration. Some use this as the reasoning behind having dozens or hundreds of social profiles. “I build it and then I let it run itself.”
That’s appealing, but it’s also dangerous. Again, these sites get hacked. They become devalued. They get overrun with spam. They fall off completely. The risks are greater than the rewards.
* * *
Social media done right has the potential to help businesses advance their marketing and improve their customer communications. It should not be viewed in the terms of “more is better.” A proper social media strategy puts all efforts into venues that count. Otherwise, it’s just fluff to help a sales pitch.
No Comments
Dealer Authority
Keep it Local, Local, or Local on Facebook
I was moderating a small panel at a conference about two and a half years ago that focused on Facebook fans. The two panelists represented the two different sides of Facebook promotion at the time: one focused on local quality fans and the other focused on bulk fans. After the debate, one might have called it a draw. That was over two years ago. Today, there’s really only one side that deserves any representation at all. Local businesses should focus solely on getting local fans, period. To get a broad reach of fans outside of the market area as a local business can do more harm than good.
Only one side of the argument “deserves’ to be mentioned today, but unfortunately that’s not the case. There are still plenty of companies out there that try to use contests or other incentives to coax people to like their pages. Some even purchase fans. Both methods are antiquated.
Don’t Reach Too Far
This is still very prominent today and it needs to go away. No games. No giveaways. Get that our of your head. You don’t need to get fans that way.
To the right, you’ll see a standard demographic breakdown from a Facebook page we recently took over. They had been growing their fan base through contests for some time. Despite the fact that the drawing for a free iPad required that the winner had to come to the car dealership to pick it up, there were still hundreds of entries in the form of likes on the page that came from outside of the area, even outside of the country. I know that iPads are great and all but nobody’s going to hop on a plane to get the iPad they won.
Fan growth can and should be organic and transparent. We’ve had extreme success with stating the absolute truth. In one example, we took over a car dealership Facebook page in Honolulu that had 26 total fans. Three months later, they have over a thousand and their demographic composite is exactly what we want it to be:
Other than the four people in Cincinnati dreaming of living in Hawaii, the likes we’ve built have been completely localized. The goal should be that every person who follows you on Facebook should be within driving distance of becoming a customer. Some would argue that you can expand your reach beyond the immediate local area, but in the vast majority of America, keeping it hyper-local is the way to go. It isn’t just about focus, either. It’s about exposure. Your brand needs to be seen by as many locals as possible and the easiest way to do this is to make sure that only locals are following you.
Don’t “Coax” Fan Growth
Here’s the thing. People will follow businesses. It has been proven time and time again that people are willing to follow businesses if they give them a valid reason to do so. A contest is not a valid reason. Getting the latest funny cat pictures is not a valid reason. The latest Facebook game is not a valid reason.
The valid reason that you’re looking for is all around you. You’re the expert in your field. People come to you and trust that you know what you’re talking about when it pertains to your business. If you’re a car dealer, you know cars. Period. Your content should reflect a deep understanding of the automotive industry, your brands, the local area, and your customers.
Present it just like that. There’s no need to promise that you’re going to be interesting. Promise tangible things that pertain to your business. For example, you can advertise that your Facebook page is “The home of the most important Chevrolet news, pictures, and videos that pertain to you, Honolulu.”
It works. We know. We’ve seen it in action.
When people like your page because they think they can win something, play a game, or perform any action that has nothing to do with your business, they will not be engaged. If they’re not engaged, they’re wasted fans. Having fans that are not engaged kills your EdgeRank and makes your actual business-relevant messages and branding invisible to your audience. I cannot stress this enough. In the future, I’ll compile a blog post that proves beyond a doubt that this is true, but for now, you’re just going to have to take my word for it.
When Your Fans Are Local, You’ll Reach More Locals
This is arguably the hardest thing to do on Facebook when a page has been algorithmically damaged by poor strategies. Getting the algorithm to like you again takes time, but it can happen. It’s a healing process.
In the example above, it’s clear to see where the engagement is happening. By keeping the page completely local, we’re able to more easily target the dealership’s message towards those who can come buy a car, get their oil changed, or interact in some way with the dealership.
This isn’t a large dealership. It’s not a large Facebook page. In fact, it has around 700 fans. Thankfully, those 700 fans are engaged and we’re able to reach the local audience with their message much more easily than if they had fans spread out across the country or around the world. That’s the key to all of this. By keeping it local, you can reach the people that matter. Unless you’re Dell or Skittles, chances are that you aren’t going for a global audience. Make sure your Facebook page reflects this concept.
No Comments
Dealer Authority
Keep it Local, Local, or Local on Facebook
I was moderating a small panel at a conference about two and a half years ago that focused on Facebook fans. The two panelists represented the two different sides of Facebook promotion at the time: one focused on local quality fans and the other focused on bulk fans. After the debate, one might have called it a draw. That was over two years ago. Today, there’s really only one side that deserves any representation at all. Local businesses should focus solely on getting local fans, period. To get a broad reach of fans outside of the market area as a local business can do more harm than good.
Only one side of the argument “deserves’ to be mentioned today, but unfortunately that’s not the case. There are still plenty of companies out there that try to use contests or other incentives to coax people to like their pages. Some even purchase fans. Both methods are antiquated.
Don’t Reach Too Far
This is still very prominent today and it needs to go away. No games. No giveaways. Get that our of your head. You don’t need to get fans that way.
To the right, you’ll see a standard demographic breakdown from a Facebook page we recently took over. They had been growing their fan base through contests for some time. Despite the fact that the drawing for a free iPad required that the winner had to come to the car dealership to pick it up, there were still hundreds of entries in the form of likes on the page that came from outside of the area, even outside of the country. I know that iPads are great and all but nobody’s going to hop on a plane to get the iPad they won.
Fan growth can and should be organic and transparent. We’ve had extreme success with stating the absolute truth. In one example, we took over a car dealership Facebook page in Honolulu that had 26 total fans. Three months later, they have over a thousand and their demographic composite is exactly what we want it to be:
Other than the four people in Cincinnati dreaming of living in Hawaii, the likes we’ve built have been completely localized. The goal should be that every person who follows you on Facebook should be within driving distance of becoming a customer. Some would argue that you can expand your reach beyond the immediate local area, but in the vast majority of America, keeping it hyper-local is the way to go. It isn’t just about focus, either. It’s about exposure. Your brand needs to be seen by as many locals as possible and the easiest way to do this is to make sure that only locals are following you.
Don’t “Coax” Fan Growth
Here’s the thing. People will follow businesses. It has been proven time and time again that people are willing to follow businesses if they give them a valid reason to do so. A contest is not a valid reason. Getting the latest funny cat pictures is not a valid reason. The latest Facebook game is not a valid reason.
The valid reason that you’re looking for is all around you. You’re the expert in your field. People come to you and trust that you know what you’re talking about when it pertains to your business. If you’re a car dealer, you know cars. Period. Your content should reflect a deep understanding of the automotive industry, your brands, the local area, and your customers.
Present it just like that. There’s no need to promise that you’re going to be interesting. Promise tangible things that pertain to your business. For example, you can advertise that your Facebook page is “The home of the most important Chevrolet news, pictures, and videos that pertain to you, Honolulu.”
It works. We know. We’ve seen it in action.
When people like your page because they think they can win something, play a game, or perform any action that has nothing to do with your business, they will not be engaged. If they’re not engaged, they’re wasted fans. Having fans that are not engaged kills your EdgeRank and makes your actual business-relevant messages and branding invisible to your audience. I cannot stress this enough. In the future, I’ll compile a blog post that proves beyond a doubt that this is true, but for now, you’re just going to have to take my word for it.
When Your Fans Are Local, You’ll Reach More Locals
This is arguably the hardest thing to do on Facebook when a page has been algorithmically damaged by poor strategies. Getting the algorithm to like you again takes time, but it can happen. It’s a healing process.
In the example above, it’s clear to see where the engagement is happening. By keeping the page completely local, we’re able to more easily target the dealership’s message towards those who can come buy a car, get their oil changed, or interact in some way with the dealership.
This isn’t a large dealership. It’s not a large Facebook page. In fact, it has around 700 fans. Thankfully, those 700 fans are engaged and we’re able to reach the local audience with their message much more easily than if they had fans spread out across the country or around the world. That’s the key to all of this. By keeping it local, you can reach the people that matter. Unless you’re Dell or Skittles, chances are that you aren’t going for a global audience. Make sure your Facebook page reflects this concept.
No Comments
Dealer Authority
Why Your Posts are Seen (or go unseen) on Facebook News Feeds

EdgeRank. It’s a mythical beast in many ways, not because it isn’t real but because it is very misunderstood by many. It’s one of those things that makes total sense once you get it but that can be very misleading before the light bulb ignites.
The basic way to understand it in one sentence is this – when your content gets positive engagement, it can be seen by more people, but when it gets negative sentiment, it gets hidden. There is a science behind it but that’s not really necessary for success. When you post good content and the people that do get to see it interact in a positive manner, the chance that others will see it too goes up. The opposite is true as well.
This is where posting the right content and “earning” the right for your business to market on Facebook comes into play. Some will say that Facebook can only be used as a branding tool, that if you focus on putting out high-quality content and never actually talk about the business, that you’ll get the maximum benefit. It’s a fair strategy, a safe on, but not necessarily the best, particularly for local businesses. A good mix of engaging content with marketing material mixed in is the best strategy, but that takes more than a blog post or an infographic to explain fully.
In the meantime, here’s an interesting infographic by PostRocket to get you started.

* * *
“Hidden Under Hat” image courtesy of Shutterstock.
No Comments
No Comments