Image Auto LLC
Carvana Calls Out Dealers
Who's seen Carvana's newest ad? I can already predict the responses.
They're directly communicating to the feelings stress in shopping with a dealer. 99 out of 100 shoppers EXPECT some level of hassle, yet, plenty of dealers still believe that they can get away with the same level of friction they always have. And when that doesn't work, they blame everyone except themselves.
Dealers blame millennial buyers. They blame government regulations. They blame the economy. Nobody blames the fact that the majority of dealers are years behind the curve in their omni-channel experience.
Branding is something you feel when you think of anything. A person, a dealership, a company, anything. We live in a world of influencers with "personal brands".
A brand needs to be more than a guy on a lot yelling that he has the lowest prices. The shopping experience can't force shoppers to sit in your building for hours doing paperwork and dreading the experience. Even people in the industry don't like they buying process.
Better experience starts with better branding and goes hand-in-hand with making sure that branding is felt in the customer experience.
Image Auto LLC
Kodak. Blockbuster. Toys'R'Us. Dealers?
Three household names. Three brands with opportunities to innovate. Three bankruptcy filings.
It might not be common knowledge, but Kodak actually invented digital photography in 1975. However, when the bulk of their profits came from film, what logical reason was there to advance the technology that would diminish the lion's share of their business?
The same can be said for Blockbuster. Blockbuster rented movies and charged late fees. After interest in a particular movie started to die down, they supplemented their business by selling the previously rented movies at a lower price than new DVDs. In 2000, Netflix offered Blockbuster the opportunity to acquire them for $50 million. Today, Netflix nears a $150 BILLION market cap while Blockbuster continues to operate a handful of stores in Alaska.
What could have these industry giants done differently? They could have paid attention to their customers; identifying and assessing how they would be served best. The "deafening and scary silence", as Dale Pollak puts it, in the lack of dealership conversation about self-driving cars, ride-sharing-services, online and direct-to-consumer retailing, and a list of other things is truly terrifying.
Opponents of any change to the current dealership model cite stats that most consumers wouldn't buy a new car with a 100% process, but they ignore all the data that says the majority of shoppers are frustrated with how long the process is, over half of shoppers feel anxious in dealerships, and that in the average of 24 touchpoints before a car is purchase, 19 of those touches are online.
Yes, people still want to kick the tires before signing the paperwork. That doesn't mean they enjoy shopping in a dealership.
This is a call for change. Stop ignoring the data that disagrees with you and start paying attention. Our friend, Gary Vaynerchuk, put it best in saying that people will push back saying "Well it's 2019 and I'm not dead yet", but they're dead in 2022. Are those 3 years that important? Dying sucks either way.
Let's take a note from the industries that have failed before us and work together for the success of this industry. How can we collectively serve our customers better?
6 Comments
Dealership News
Kodak was out there licensing it's name a few years back. Two guys were trying to get some play out of a total buggy whip alas, to no avail. My best buddy had a major conflict with Blockbusters "new owner" several years ago and he made them pay double what they tried to screw him out of. Once these brands outlive their usefulness, the scoundrels and vultures try to leverage them, usually to no avail.
Image Auto LLC
Definitely true on the Blockbuster end, but I've got to give Kodak some credit for introducing KodakCoin. They found a need in their industry (hosted photos being stolen and used without attribution/licensing) and developed a way to help photographers protect that while also piggybacking onto the digital currency model.
Just like online retail tools, they're finding a new way to serve their industry in a way that is more than a gimmick and actually provides value to a user. Smart move.
Dealership News
Patrick, wasn't aware of KodakCoin. I'll check it out, seems like something fairly new.
Image Auto LLC
It's probably about 3 months old and not accelerating at the rate of BitCoin, but it's definitely serving a niche.
Dealership News
Good luck with that...I know there will be huge success stories so looking forward to hearing more about it. Not sure Kodak was the right brand license to anchor such a project on but why not?
Image Auto LLC
Better Used Inventory Management Can Start Today!
It's evident that a level of change is needed in the dealership model. We've discussed hiring better, branding better, and countless other things to make a dealership a customer-first business that empathizes with their community. But, many dealers still hide behind feelings that these changes are too big to execute to right now.
I have two things to say to that: 1) It's not going to be easy, but nothing worth doing is ever easy. 2) It isn't expected to happen overnight. This is a long game. If there was a tool that could reinvent business overnight, it'd be groundbreaking. But success is one step at a time. So let's start with a step you can implement today.
Thanks to all the advancements in technology, we have more data than ever. People are tracking their steps, sleep patterns, and a bunch of other stuff that they probably aren't going to actually analyze or fix.
But in business, there's still data that matters. Your used inventory manager should be able to tell you how long you generally hold on to a vehicle, which vehicles are selling best, and what they're usually selling for. Use this information to educate whoever is buying your used inventory. Dale Pollak uses the guiding principle to not buy anything for more than 84% of what you expect to sell it for.
For example, if you're selling a lot of family oriented sedans and you see a blue Toyota Camry come up at auction, you should know that your average used Camry is selling around $13k, you should know that (packs and reconditioning aside) you shouldn't spend more that $11k to ensure you turn the car around quickly and for a profit.
In the same mindset, if you see a red Mustang come up to auction, you should know that those are lasting 180-210 days on your lot and retailing around $22k. So once the auction gets past $18,500, stop bidding.
I know, you don't have any Mustangs on the lot. I know, it'll be cool to share on social media. I know, "someone" will want it. But is it really worth a spot on your lot when you could be better investing your finances into inventory you can sell?
The second practice to start your path to success is to set a cap on your inventory. Don't go to auction with the intent of filling your lot at whatever cost. Go with a budget. If your goal is to fill the lot, you'll make more thoughtful spending decisions. If you sent a kid to a candy store and said "what do you want?", they'll want it all. If you send them with $2, they'll start to decide if they really want more candy or better candy.
So I ask...do you want more inventory or better inventory? Either way, an educated look at your inventory purchasing will lead to better purchasing decisions.
No Comments
Image Auto LLC
Taking Care of Your Biggest Investment
No, it isn't your inventory. It's your people.
Turnover rates in the automotive industry are atrocious. Our founder recently spoke with Adam Robinson, founder and CEO of Hireology, and he passed along an anecdote of a time early in his career where he would train a dealership on software, just to have them call him back three months later because the staff he trained had all left.
Culture matters. If we can't keep employees happy, they won't stick around. If they don't stick around, we're constantly replacing them. This brings a vicious cycle of fighting to create culture in an environment that is constantly changing. How will we ever create anything effective in an environment like that?!
You might be saying "well, that really doesn't affect my business", but studies say otherwise. A 2015 study by the University of Warwick shows that happier employees are 12% more productive. Adam even suggested to consider how constantly being short-staffed affects your billable time. You could be constantly short one employee... or worse, you have your most proficient employee training the new guy and now it feels like you're short a team of people.
See...happy employees lead to higher retention and happier customers. They'll get personal service in a reasonable timeframe. The customer can feel the difference when an employee treats them with genuine concern for their needs. They don't feel they're being taken advantage or that they're only being taken care of on because a company policy says to check in with each customer twice.
Trust is valued significantly higher than price. Building a culture of trust with your employees will breed a culture of trust with your customers.
What do you think? Have you made any efforts to make your staff your priority?
1 Comment
Congruent
I just spent the week at NADA observing immense offerings to help dealers track and measure attribution, engagement and sales. It is SO logical that a solution to do the same with dealers' teams should follow suit. The ONE thing that dealers can control is who they put on their team and whether or not they create a culture that regards their value.
Image Auto LLC
Is The Juice Worth The Squeeze?
Time is an often overlooked, and costly, asset in business operations. A company will often try to save a few bucks by bringing a service in house. (We'll stick to reconditioning for this example.)
Sometimes, it works great. The service team and the used inventory manager work hand-in-hand to make used vehicles frontline ready while ensuring that paying customers don't wait days for their repairs. But I'm sure many can identify with the times it didn't work so well...
Have you ever felt the tension in the air while the service director argues with the used car manager about the value of taking care of customer services over reconditioning a vehicle no one has purchased yet? It's a very valid concern. If customers are waiting days for repairs, they'll stop coming back and the dealer will lose repeatable revenue. But, studies show that a dealer loses an average of $85 per day in holding costs and potential front-end gross for each day that a vehicle isn't retail ready. If it takes a week, the dealer loses nearly $600 to make the same amount in service gross profit.
Does that change the way you value your time? This is the point you should be asking if the effort is really worth the return; if the juice is worth the squeeze.
The Pareto Principle states that 80% of your business will come from 20% of your efforts. Imagine your success if you took your team's valuable time and had them only focusing on the 20% while vendors service the tedious work that often put your team behind.
There isn't necessarily a right or wrong answer. Some dealers feel a personal connection to the work because it's their name on the line, while other groups, like Sonic Automotive, feel like they work best by letting someone else handle reconditioning while they focus on the 20% yielding the biggest ROI. It's all about what works best for YOU!
In short, it's important to address the bigger picture when looking at analyzing your internal efforts. You might be asking why you'd pay someone else to do something you can easily do, but you could be overlooking major inefficiencies that cost you a LOT of time and money.
What works best for you? Have you figured out the efficiency to reap the benefits of internal work or do you let someone else handle it to free up your schedule for the big returns?
No Comments
Image Auto LLC
Will Dealers Become Obsolete Thanks To Amazon?
Do you feel like you're struggling to keep up with the changes in the industry? Advancements in technology and changes in consumer culture are constantly pushing forward, but the "current" business model for dealers has been more or less the same for decades.
When 99% of customers EXPECT a hassle, shouldn't we admit something needs to change? Think about it...as a child, most people hated going to the dentist. There's this person shoving tools in your mouth asking you how school is expecting you to answer. What's fun about that?
If you enjoyed the experience, wouldn't you be less apprehensive going back? If you were less apprehensive about the whole situation, wouldn't you feel less skeptical about everything the professional was telling you? I mean, we can all agree that sugar rots your teeth, but if the dentist hadn't just made you uncomfortable while telling you that, wouldn't you be more likely to heed their advice when they also told you to floss daily?
We can thank Amazon for this rapid shift in consumer culture. They've created such an enjoyable consumer experience that if something showed up more than 2 days after you've ordered it, you'd be asking for a full refund. It's this kind of friction-free shopping experience buyers crave in ALL transactions. A panel of automotive leaders at the Agent2021 conference even predicted Amazon will begin testing an automotive sales model by the end of 2018. I don't think any of us are ready for that.
So I ask...at what point are we going to realize something NEEDS to change? At what point will we admit that people don't trust us? At what point will we take ownership of changing the poor perception of the industry?
Our company, Image Auto, is taking the first step in that direction. We've produced a full web-series for auto dealers asking absolutely NOTHING in return. As a reconditioning company, we know that our business will become obsolete if the dealership model fails. We are simply a small, but engaged contributor.
You can sign up to be notified of new episode releases at DealersCompressed.com. We promise we're not selling you anything. We simply ask that you spread the word and share this content with every dealer or automotive expert you know. Something needs to change before we're all the rusty junker in the compactor.
14 Comments
Dealership News
Amazon is amazing, just got a baseball bat for the kids on a Sunday, a day earlier than expected. WTS, not sure how'd they ever corner the market on used inventory. Maybe they buy fleets and off-lease inventory en masse, build a big classified like Carmax and go for it.
Self
I ADORE and massively respect Amazon but EVERYONE tries to get into the car game and quickly finds out how challenging it can be. Especially when it comes to pre-owned.
Image Auto LLC
If anyone is up for the challenge, it's Amazon. I'm sure if you had asked a grocery store executive in 1998 if they could ever see this new online bookseller owning the largest organic grocery store chain they'd say "Selling books is one thing, but selling groceries is a different challenge. They won't succeed." Now that online bookseller owns Whole Foods and sells perishable goods through Amazon Fresh.
They've already started testing the process selling new Fiats through the site in Italy. Experts are saying they'll go the Carmax route, but as they grow, I could see them buying dealerships and using them as distribution centers. Eventually, it will hit a level of join or die.
With Amazon Vehicle being a system to help users figure out what vehicle would be best for them, they're already developing a system that would integrate well with "This is the type of car you want, we have this many at your local distribution center or we can have the luxury model shipped there in 2 days."
DealerSuccess
Amanda, I totally agree with you. Reports last week were dismal at best with Carvana losses of $47 million Q4 of 2017 as reported by Automotive News and Vroom allegedly preparing to lay off up to 50% of its staff (Tech Crunch article). I've worked many dealerships nationwide and Canada helping them implement digital retailing and geo-targeted marketing platforms and those who have been early adopters of these types of tools have increased margins. We can't lose sight of dealership processes and relate to consumers on a personal level. Humans still want human interaction and I think this is the biggest challenge facing mega online dealerships. How will a consumer be committed to a dealership that they have zero emotional connection with? Yes, Amazon is the most amazing company on the planet. But, there's a much different emotion attached to buying small ticket items online than an automobile consumers are normally financing. In my opinion, dealer's will not become obsolete any time soon. But, all dealers, whether independent or dealer group, need to implement a digital retailing tool and provide the consumer with a personal 'experience' from the time they hit the dealers online showroom or website.
Congruent
Such a great conversation here and I'm so glad Patrick got it going! One of the reasons we created the Dealers Compressed series is BECAUSE WE BELIEVE IN THE DEALERSHIP MODEL. Dealers have been staples of their communities for the better part of a century. They know their customers, they are involved in the same things.
I believe there is ZERO reason the local dealer shouldn't be able to deliver the very best CX. Period.
Here's the rub: If they aren't quick to adopt the new consumer shopping preferences and cater to them, they will begin to lose market share. The traditional road to the sale has to be thrown out and a customer driven, flexible process has to be adopted.
Yes, Beepi died. Vroom isn't far behind. Carvana is losing a lot of money but they are a heck of a lot farther down the road. Soon there will be 5 more and one of them will stick. Amazon will likely acquire brick and mortar because they CAN!
Bottom line, consumer preference will ALWAYS find a way to the top. At this point everyone has a shot at it and I would argue dealers have the advantage, but that window is closing fast.
Dealership News
A world whereby Amazon sells everything and eliminates SMB is not healthy for any economy in the long run, and we're almost at that point.
Image Auto LLC
Kelly...that's our whole purpose behind the series. We don't want to hit that point. The warning signs are all there...acquiring Whole Foods, acquiring Ring, Toys'R'Us filing for bankruptcy...industries looking to join before they're crushed.
Everyone wants to say that selling a car online is hard, but the envelope keeps being pushed. Someone's going to figure it out and consumers are going to love it. Let's all help dealers figure it out first.
Dealership News
Anyone see the picture of Bezos eating an iguana? Disturbing. How they went from selling books badly, to the evil empire of consumerism is a staggering tale. It seems to me that Bezos is just anti-human enough to make some "political" miscalculation and get blacklisted by the public. Perhaps it's too much AI vs actual employees, perhaps it's a whistle blower that spills some beans, maybe his space rockets crashes into NYC, who knows. He makes too much money, has too much power, and has climbed too high...for what good? Seriously, what good? So we can get a couple bucks off an eye cream that arrives the next day instead of 3? I'd be building out inner cities with recreation and job training facilities, investing in natural remedy research for disease, building artificial limbs for people who need them, buying up huge tracts of property to help endangered species etc. This guy wants to build his own starships...fine. Our species isn't going anywhere except earth so, better seriously consider that no one gets off of this raft and we better keep it afloat. For 39 billion a quarter - you can just leave the auto industry alone Jeff.
Dealership News
Hey, PB, I want to interview you...email me with your info: Kelly@dealershipnews.com
Dealership News
BTW, the reason we had a record year for car sales last year and in 2015 was because we lost 1.5 million vehicles due to hurricanes. Show me a big hurricane season and I'll show you...the money!
Image Auto LLC
I'd argue there's probably a less destructive way to raise automotive sales.
Beepi died, but it's founders son got a $600 million payday out of it and he went onto become a billionaire himself! And some of you will make $10 for the appointment and $100 flat if it sells. We're on the wrong side of big money. So when people tell me about some new car website, some hot new gimmick - I know why they are in business.
Image Auto LLC
But gimmicks are only gimmicks when they're something to get a customer in the door and really offer them nothing extra. A new online feature to sell cars more efficiently that actually works would just be good business practice to give customers what they want.
7 Comments
Chevy Dude
Bachman Chevrolet
"newest ad"?? this commercial is WELL over 2 years old.
Jason Volny
DrivingSales
I would agree that is old.... but still relevant. Lots of customers and car buyers do think the car buying process sucks! But I also don't think it's fair to say dealers are blaming everyone but themselves... dealers are very hard at work. this industry is quickly changing for the better.
Sherri Riggs
DrivingSales
I thinking branding is pretty important... but there also has to be follow through! You can brand all you want, but if a dealership doesn't follow through on their branding promises what's the point?
Amanda Gordon
Self
I think they are killing the game as far as branding just as Kelly Blue Book and Carfax and neither one of them sell cars (Kelly sort of by way of being owned by Cox automotive). I digress, I have said it a thousand times, you are not going to be able to remove the human element out of a sales process as large as a car purchase. Not going to happen Carvana!
Kelly Kleinman
Dealership News
At some point, salesmen will be forced to read; "How to Win Friends and Influence People", which was written many moons ago by Dale Carnegie, and is still the basis for countless books, tapes, and vids on how to interact with fellow humans. We are a social being by nature, and although video tours, software, and websites tend to shield us from personal interaction, Amanda is correct, you can't take the human element out of the equation, rather develop it, and turn it into an asset. Hmm, the theme of my next article I believe!
Derrick Woolfson
Beltway Companies
@Amanda, I 100% agree. Not to mention, what really bugs me with this model is that it fails to address the elephant in the room. That is the "trade-in" how are they "calculating" actualized values without seeing the vehicle. And with their "return" policy, I would imagine the customer would "return" their vehicle if they did not agree to the trade-in amount. All of which can cost Carvana (they have not been profitable yet, no?) thousands of dollars.
Dave Page
CreditMiner
Carvana makes a good point, but can customers really make a complete and informed deal entirely online? Not really. Our solution is SARA (Smart Automotive Retail Assistant). Frictionless process, saves time at the dealership, and allows customers to structure their deal without leaving their house. Learn more here: https://ecreditminer.com/best-automotive-digital-retailing-tool