Kijiji, an eBay Company
The Modern Way to Overcome a Cash Buyer
There was a time in the automotive business where cash was “king”, but that kingdom has long been overthrown. Back in the late 1970s and most of the 1980s, interest rates were at an all-time high[1] and lenders were staggeringly more stringent on approving loans. What that meant for the automobile industry was, if you walked into the showroom looking for a monthly payment there was a legitimate chance you were not going to get approved. If, however, you came in with cash, the only roadblock was… well, in that time there were no roadblocks. You were going home with a car whether you wanted to or not! :P
Today, the scenario is quite the opposite: 0% financing is commonly stretched to 96 months and beyond, and if you can fog a mirror, chances are someone will finance you. More importantly, this means paying cash is no longer desirable to a dealership. Unfortunately, someone forgot to explain this to the general population, causing a major disconnect during the negotiation process.
Many customers still believe paying cash is the best way to negotiate to the lowest price. At least once a day I will see a lead saying something to the tune of, “Give me your best offer and I will pay cash!” The customer assumes I’m running to drop my pants, when in fact I’m pouring another strong shot of whiskey lamenting in frustration. I kid – actually, if I have the opportunity to speak with a “cash only” customer one-on-one, it is one of the easiest closes in the book, and here is why/how.
In addition to the customer believing offering cash will get them the biggest discount, they also believe that monthly payments are inherently evil. That we, as dealers, play the numbers like a game of three-card shuffle and steal their wallets from their pockets. Searching for “How to Negotiate a Car Payment” will bring up countless examples of how the customer should ONLY negotiate with cash:
Dealer Trick #1: Negotiating on Monthly Payments
When the salesperson starts talking about monthly payments, watch out.
Clever salespeople want you to focus only on low monthly payments because it gives them room to inflate other variables, such as the loan interest and length. This increases the dealer’s profit — while you spend thousands more on the car overall.[2]
If it’s online, then it must be true, right?
It is no secret that negotiating via monthly payments can make for a smoother process and allows for more flexibility on offering back-end products. However, it also has benefits for the consumer that are often forgotten.
For example, ask a cash-only customer where they are actually getting the cash from. Unless they have a vault full of gold coins like Scrooge McDuck[3], likely they are borrowing the money from the bank. As of today, Bank of America is offering auto loans as low as 2.34 percent[4].
“And why would you want to pay 2.34 percent when we are offering zero percent financing, Mr./Mrs. Customer?”
This isn't a surprise to us in the auto industry; we handle cash customers all the time. We are well versed in the benefits of leasing, GAP insurance, only paying for what you use, etc., etc. Yet these are not the best tactics when dealing with a cash-only customer. The close I use is right under your nose, and it may surprise you.
I didn’t notice it at first either. It wasn’t until I needed an upgraded version of the Adobe Creative Suite when it hit me. If you are not familiar with it, Adobe makes a line of design software that is used in advertising, web development, etc. It’s not cheap, either: just ordering Photoshop alone used to set you back upwards of $1,000. When I went to order the latest version, there was no option to “buy” the software, you can now only rent it with a monthly plan. What was normally a one-time fixed expense is now a monthly payment of $29/month[5].
It’s not just Adobe that has switched to the software plan platform. I also pay Microsoft $9.99/month for Microsoft Office[6], $5/month for Evernote[7], $9.99/month for Dropbox Pro[8] and $5/Month for my SurfEasy VPN.
Under the cover of darkness the software industry has switched platforms from one-time expenses to a monthly payment system. In a way, it makes sense: buying a subscription allows you to always have the latest upgrades and content. Additionally, it’s a lot easier to swallow a monthly payment than a gigantic lump sum, increasing the conversion ratio for large programs. However, it’s not just the software industry that has gone this route; media has as well.
Remember when you bought movies? Unless you are hitting the DVD discount bin at your local Walmart, it’s actually quite difficult to purchase a movie these days. Instead, the most common platform is a subscription service like Netflix. Instead of paying $25 for a single movie, you can get access to thousands of movies and television shows for $7.95/month[9]. Or, if you want something seemingly more tangible, you can buy permanent access to media through iTunes or the Google Play store. However, in none of these scenarios are you actually purchasing a product – you are only paying for the access to the product. At any time, the media you purchased access to could disappear.
Music is no different; the days of buying the latest album from your favorite artist are gone. If you tasked me with purchasing a CD today from a store, I don’t know where I would even begin to shop. I do know that I can buy access via iTunes, or I can subscribe to an online streaming service like Spotify for $9.99/month[10]. Same goes for books and magazines – you are only buying the access to the content and not the actual content. For only $9.99/month[11] you can access all the magazines you want with your phone or tablet, and books are easily downloaded to your e-reader. It certainly is saving a lot of trees, but isn’t it interesting that entire industries have moved to a leasing-only platform and everyone seems to be cool with it? Yet, when you offer monthly payments to a customer purchasing an automobile, they suddenly reject the idea.
See where I am going with this? Right under our noses, every other industry switched to a monthly payment platform and we all have blindly followed like a horde of zombies. Let’s look at some other examples:
- How did you pay for your cellphone? Did it come packaged in your monthly plan?
- What about Internet, is that paid monthly as well?
- Do you still have a cable bill? Monthly, right?
- Home insurance, auto insurance, life insurance, pet insurance – obviously monthly?
- Taxes – monthly or semi-monthly?
- Mortgage is monthly?
- Costco member? Have you tried that new kale mix salad? That stuff is heavenly. Yeah, it’s yearly, but I hear they are planning to re-brand to monthly.
- Video games? Which, Xbox or PlayStation? Yeah, now PlayStation has a monthly online fee too.
- Gym membership? Yeah, I should probably use mine more as well. Monthly, right?
- Electric bill, gas bill, water bill – monthly, monthly and monthly?
- Retirement contribution? I know, it stings now but it’s necessary, right? Monthly?
- Got little ones? Day care, how did it get so expensive? Monthly?
- Do you support any charities? Did they hook you on the monthly contribution?
- Credit card payment is due monthly, obviously? I know, this past January I nearly fainted when I saw mine.
- Any social clubs? I myself am thinking of joining an axe-throwing league. It’s only a couple of bucks monthly. Yes, axe throwing, you should try it.[12]
“So Mr./Mrs. Customer, it seems that most of your expenses are in a monthly payment format. It appears this is your preferred method of payment. Therefore it would make the most sense to also pay for your vehicle needs in the same way, correct?”
The media and software industries have done the automotive industry an insurmountable favour. They have succeeded in transforming the North American consumer into a monthly payment junkie. Additionally, seemingly without the consumer’s knowledge, they have also transitioned them from a purchaser to a leaser overnight. All we in the auto industry need to do with a cash-only customer is remind them their entire life is now lived by leasing everything with a monthly payment.
Here is a sample of how the process works:
“But I want to OWN my car, I don’t want to pay to use it,” said Mr./Mrs. Customer.
“Not a problem, but may I ask, you have a Netflix account, correct?” asked the salesperson.
“Yes I do.”
“As do I. May I ask, how much would it cost to buy physical copies of all the movies and televisions shows you watch on Netflix?”
“Why, it would cost an awful lot,” replied the customer.
“So you would agree, paying a monthly fee for the use of these movies and shows is a better option, even though you don’t OWN them, correct?”
“Well, I guess,” replied the customer.
“And, back in the day when you did buy CDs and DVDs, how much did you spend on your collection?”
The customer looks up, and thinks for a few moments.
“A lot.”
“And, may I ask, where is that collection now?”
The wheels begin to turn in the customer’s head.
“I gave most to Goodwill, and some are in a box in the basement,” replied the customer. They frown. Look down. Fumble with their hands.
“So that wasn't the best… investment, was it?”
“I guess not.”
“And, back in the 2000s, if Netflix existed, you probably would have used it instead of buying all those movies and shows, right?”
“Probably. Yeah.”
“Leasing a vehicle is no different, Mr./Mrs. Customer, there is just more money involved. Can I ask you another question?”
“Sure,” replied the customer.
“What happened if one of those CDs or DVDs got scratched? Would the value go down?”
“Of course.”
“And you would be at a financial loss. Same goes if you purchase a vehicle and, God forbid, it gets into a fender bender. Even if someone dings it in the parking lot while you are shopping, you lose money on the re-sale. With leasing, providing you opt-in for GAP insurance, you wouldn’t find yourself at a financial loss when the vehicle value diminishes after an accident. Providing you have adequate insurance, of course.”
“Really?”
“Yes, really. So Mr./Mrs. Customer, since you already are well invested in monthly payment services like Netflix, let’s look at how a lease can also easily fit into your monthly budget.”
To get technical, why this works so well is that you are using their own lifestyle against them. It is very difficult to discredit something when so much of your life is already involved in it. People are naturally influenced to continue with what they have already committed to. Since they are already committed to so many monthly subscriptions and payments already, the transition from paying cash for a vehicle to paying monthly makes all the sense in the world.
Think about it yourself. How much of your life is paid for in monthly lease agreements? You may surprise yourself.
[1] United States Average Monthly Prime Lending Rate | 1950-2015 | Data | Chart. (n.d.). Retrieved from http://www.tradingeconomics.com/united-states/bank-lending-rate
[2] 4 Car Dealer Tricks You Need to Know Before You Buy a Car. (2014, November 21). Retrieved from https://smartasset.com/personal-finance/4-car-dealer-tricks-you-need-to-know-before-you-buy-a-car-3
[3] Scrooge McDuck and Money. (n.d.). Retrieved February 10, 2015, from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bEmjiCoZ6e4
[4] Auto Loan Rates & Current Car Loan Rates at Bank of America. (n.d.). Retrieved February 8, 2015, from https://www.bankofamerica.com/auto-loans/auto-loan-rates.go
[5] Adobe Creative Cloud. (n.d.). Retrieved February 8, 2015, from https://creative.adobe.com/plans?single_app=photoshop?store_code=ca
[6] Choose your Office. (n.d.). Retrieved February 8, 2015, from https://products.office.com/en-us/compare-microsoft-office-products
[7] Evernote. (n.d.). Retrieved February 8, 2015, from https://evernote.com/premium/
[8] Dropbox - Upgrade to Dropbox Pro. (n.d.). Retrieved February 8, 2015, from https://www.dropbox.com/upgrade
[9] Watch TV shows & movies anytime, anywhere. Plans from $7.99 a month. (n.d.). Retrieved February 8, 2015, from https://www.netflix.com/us/
[10] Premium. (n.d.). Retrieved February 8, 2015, from https://www.spotify.com/ca-en/premium/
[11] Next Issue Canada | Unlimited Access to Over 100 Top Magazines. (n.d.). Retrieved February 8, 2015, from https://www.nextissue.ca/en/
[12] BATL - The Home of Axe Throwing. (n.d.). Retrieved February 8, 2015, from http://www.batl.ca/
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Creating an All-Inclusive Dealership Experience
I just returned back from a trip to an all-inclusive resort in Ocho Rios, Jamaica where it rained for the entire duration of the trip. When I say rain, I don’t mean a little drizzle. It was an unrelenting monsoon. I took a video from my balcony to document just how bad it was:
As much as the rain dampened the trip (pun intended), it also offered some very interesting observations on customer service.
The rain began as we approached the resort and continued throughout the first night and into the following day. The weather report for days 3-7 called for sun, so it appeared that it would prove a mere inconvenience. Unfortunately, Day 2 revealed more rain. Day 3, again, more rain. Day 4, more rain—and this was when things really started to fall apart. The ceiling inside our room began to collapse, and the TV got an unexpected shower. The resort was beginning to flood; multiple sections became unusable, and the staff was attempting to use beach towels as sandbags. The plaster ceilings everywhere were coming down in chunks, including in the rooms, dining areas, and lobby. Water was flowing freely into wind-facing rooms. All excursions were cancelled, and all guests were confined either to their rooms or the one indoor bar. Day 5, inconceivably, more rain. They were evacuating neighboring towns, the medical centre was shut down due to flooding, and local residents were marooned in certain areas. It was a nightmare.
You can imagine this would have been an extremely trying situation for the resort staff. Keep in mind that they had to deal with the rain as well. Imagine working a twelve-hour day dealing with depressed and angry guests at a resort that is literally falling apart, and you get to celebrate all this by walking home in the rain on a dirt road. Only to walk back to work in the rain a few hours later.
Yet, despite all of this, every single resort employee had a smile on their face as wide as the coastline. Every employee said “hello” or “yeah mon” to you as you walked by, and then asked how you were doing and made an honest attempt to brighten your day. It was near impossible to speak with a member of the staff, and not have your rainy frown turned upside down. It was a miraculous thing to experience.
The attitudes of the staff single-handedly took a nightmarish situation and made it pleasant under some of the worst vacation circumstances possible. I made a point to speak to them personally and thank them for all their hard work during this trying situation. It was during these conversations that the gravity of their efforts truly came to light.
After thanking a member of the staff, I would say, “This must be really hard for you, with the rain and the guests and all.” Each reaction was the same; they all for a brief moment released the façade, and their true self came out. Some would sigh, others would show a quivering smile, and some even appeared to be holding back tears. But just as quickly as it began, you could watch their surprise at their own reaction, and they would quickly revert back into “happy resort employee mode.”
These humanizing moments allowed me to see what the true driving force of their superb customer service was. It’s not “just for the tips” as many may assume, rather it is pride that fuels their passion for creating the ultimate customer experience.
Imagine how my vacation experience would have differed if half of the staff succumbed to the depressing rain and only focused on their immediate tasks. In fact, if even a handful of resort staff grimaced instead of smiling it would have had a compounding effect on my experience. Even one negative experience can spoil a platoon of positive experiences, especially during a monsoon.
It was the efforts of the entire staff as a whole that created the All-Inclusive Experience. If every resort staff member did everything they could to enhance the customer’s experience, they would all equally benefit. Even if you factored “tips” into the equation, if everyone provided exemplary service equally, the monetary payback would work itself out in the wash.
Now, I am aware that the concept of “providing the best customer experience” in your dealership is by no means a new one, but what I am suggesting is changing the context of that message. Often, we forget that we live in the automotive bubble and that the more we learn to separate our perspective the better we can adapt, improve, and adjust to changing market conditions and ideas. I suggest, instead of preaching the concepts such as, “smile and greet every customer,” “acknowledge everyone within 10 feet of you,” or one of the many broad descriptions such as “creating excellent experiences.” Think of how you, as an individual and as a leader, build a culture of providing an all-inclusive vacation type experience at your dealership.
Start by imagining if you could buy a vehicle while vacationing at an all-inclusive resort. What would that experience be like? [Tweet This] Imagine that scenario, and then compare it to the process in your store; does it stand up?
Does everyone on your staff take a moment to speak with every customer they walk by? Do they ask if they are having a great day? If there were an unmitigated weather disaster, would your staff maintain the same demeanor?
Or if you really want to get creative, hold your store accountable to the same level of scrutiny of a Trip Advisor review.
- What is the quality of food / coffee at your store?
- Are your bathrooms immaculately clean?
- Can a customer get their shoes shined?
- Are there noticeable scuffs, dents or dings on the walls?
- What is the quality of the waiting room entertainment?
- How attentive are your staff?
- How fast is the Wi-Fi connection? Is it easy to access?
- What is the ambiance of the waiting area? Volume level? Pleasing scent? Décor?
- Is the showroom easy to navigate?
Customer experience doesn't limit you to being compared to other dealerships; it compares you to every experience a customer has. You aren't just competing with the dealer down the road; you are competing with the coffee shop, grocery store, doctor’s office, and all-inclusive resort. Why, just the other day, the woman at the McDonalds drive-thru window addressed me by name when returning my credit card, “Thank you Mr. Karbaum. Here is your coffee. Have a great day!” My mind was blown. I briefly considered tipping her as the window shut. Later that evening the pizza delivery man did the same thing. Upon opening the door, he greeted me by name; after all it was on the receipt. He proceeded to open the box in my doorway to ensure the order was correct, a product presentation of the pizza that I ordered.
Every industry is stepping up their customer experience game, and we especially in the automotive industry must do the same. The next time you walk into your store, imagine you were walking into an all-inclusive resort and judge accordingly. Heck, walk in wearing flip-flops and a bathing suit if you really want to create the total experience—and surely alarm your fellow staff members—but use this opportunity to transform your relationship with your customers.
Have some other tips to share? How does your store do things differently to excel in Customer Experience?
Share in the comments below!
7 Comments
Autofusion Inc.
Great post Robert! Many companies forget about customer service and concentrate too much on immediate profit. But the key thing to remember about your staff is that they are the FACE of YOUR company. When they think about your dealership, this is the person that the consumer will remember. No matter how great your technicians are or how great your product is, a significant portion of customer satisfaction is typically based on the customers experience with your staff. This is the reason why at Autofusion, we invest so much into our customer support.
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Just in case anyone is wondering, the picture of the gentleman above is real. Hartland was one of the bellhops at the resort I was staying at. He was quieter than most of the other staff, but only in voice. He had one of the most expressive smiles on the resort. He was one of the many staff members who helped to turn my trip around.
You did it again Robert. Well done. I could gather all the blogs, articles and video tutorials that address the consumer experience and the bricks and mortar culture but the majority of my GM's just won't by in. They just want to "sell cars". They are suffering from the wrong side of Digital Darwinism. I just took over this group a few months back I'm so pumped to see the results in the coming months.
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Thanks Jeff! Best of luck! Sounds like you need it!
Faulkner Nissan
Great post - customer service and making the experience different is one thing that is lacking at a lot of places -- and not just in our industry. Now here's the question - would you go back to the resort?
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Yes, I would go back to the resort. It's a great little place.
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Right, Wrong or Insane: My Auto Industry Predictions for 2015
There are three types of people in our industry; those who are drawn to change, those who hide from it, and those who pull out their big guns to protect the way things were. I have never had a problem determining which side of the fence a person stands on, as I am never shy about sharing my visions for the future.
When discussing the future of the automotive business I often use the analogy of when the Finance Department first entered the dealership. Prior to this, the concept of removing the salesperson from the deal was preposterous. It would be perceived as a disaster if the customer was handed off to someone else, let alone someone in another office. Today, a dealership without a Finance Department would seem ludicrous. The potential profit loss would be monumental, right? Maybe right now, but again, the tides are a-turning and what seems crazy today may be commonplace tomorrow. Often, the best ideas start out sounding the craziest; as Einstein once said, “For an idea that does not first seem insane, there is no hope.”
Since John North Willys sold the first vehicle out of his Elmira, New York, sporting-goods shop in 1901[1], the car-buying process has fundamentally remained the same. That’s 115 years of an industry operating on the same basic principles that it was founded on. Fortunately, or unfortunately, depending on which side of the fence you subscribe to, that is about to change in 2015. In fact, next year has the potential to be one of the most revolutionary years the auto industry has seen in a very long time.
Some of these changes are small, some are crazier than others, and some have monumental implications, but I believe we will see all of them happen in 2015.
OEM Direct Sale to Consumers
Tesla is doing the dirty work for the other automotive manufacturers right now. The manufacturers won’t admit it, for obvious reasons, but they are all cheering on Elon Musk behind the scenes. While Tesla is fighting to sell their niche vehicles online and in their boutiques, the big OEMs are rapidly approaching a digital wall, preventing them from innovating into the future. Last year General Motors launched their Shop-Click-Drive online platform nationwide,[2] but it represents the furthest the manufacturers can progress unless Tesla is successful in their manufacturer direct-to-consumer sales battle. Sooner or later, the big OEMs will need to sell direct to consumers too.
Shop-Click-Drive is an online e-commerce-style platform where a customer can select their vehicle, estimate payments and trade-in value, apply for credit, accessorize and schedule a test drive at the location of their choosing[3]. In its first year of operation, the platform sold over 13,000 vehicles nationwide[4] with only a third of the dealers participating and little, if any, advertising. 2015 will see a sharp increase in Shop-Click-Drive sales as GM will be forced to advertise heavily to fend off new competitors to the online vehicle sales space. Additionally, GM may even make the program mandatory for all participating dealers, as they have with other online initiatives this past year[5].
Once fully up and running, Shop-Click-Drive will begin to have a profound impact on the automotive industry. Unfortunately, it still falls short of competing with every other retail sector because you cannot fully buy a vehicle online. Yes, with Shop-Click-Drive you can get close, but ultimately you must finalize everything in the dealership. Imagine your disappointment if you were told you HAD to physically go to a Best Buy to pick up the GoPro you just ordered online.
GM is sure to gain market share until the other OEMs catch up but this is a small Band-Aid on a gaping wound. Customers want everything online, and if you refuse to adapt, someone else will happily provide a better solution. Blockbuster believed heavily in the customer in-store experience[6], while Netflix realized there was a much better solution online.[7]
If you want to see a glimpse into the auto industry’s immediate future, we can look at what is happening to the car-rental industry right now. First, car-sharing services started eating up market share, then came Uber to finish the job. This resulted in almost zero growth[8] for the rental industry in 2013, yet car-sharing memberships increased globally by 53 percent [9] and Uber is expected to generate $10 billion in revenue for 2014.[10]
The emergence of new competition was proof that the car-rental industry’s old business model wasn’t working. It was stagnant, outdated and needed to be overhauled for the needs of the modern online shopper. Fortunately, they decided to change and fight back by both buying out some of their competition[11] and, more importantly, modernizing their business model. For example, National Car Rental just launched their “Control Enthusiast” campaign this November featuring actor Patrick Warburton. The concept of the commercial is about eliminating their old business model and showcasing the new:
“That’s why this road warrior rents from National. I can bypass the counter, and go straight to my car and I don’t have to talk to any humans unless I want to. And I don’t.”[12]
The car-rental industry was forced to adapt to the needs of the customer, and so will we. Teasing the customer with an “almost e-commerce” experience may actually do more harm than good. The efficiencies GM is attempting to create with Shop-Click-Drive are all but eliminated when the customer is forced through the same old hoops once they arrive at the dealership. Once you invite customers to the online space, they will expect it to operate like every other online retail space. Otherwise, you are just putting lipstick on a digital pig.
Where this will take us in 2015 is that one of the major automotive manufacturers will begin a direct-to-consumer e-commerce trial “coincidentally” in one of the states in which Tesla has successfully changed the laws. Instead of stopping before the sale is completed and forcing customers into the store, the trial will allow a customer to 100 percent purchase the vehicle and wait for it to arrive, just like any other online purchase. But what about the test drive, you ask? The percentage of customers declining a test drive before purchase has risen to 17 percent in 2014. [13] That would equate to 2.8 million out of a potential 16.4 million[14] new car sales in the United States in 2015 that would be purchased without a test drive. That is more than enough for an OEM to do an online direct-to-consumer trial.
The OEM will convince their dealer body that this trial is a good idea by counting each online sale towards the targets and bonus plans of the lucky dealer who represents the market area of the online purchaser. The dealer will benefit by getting sale on their books, much like when the manufacturer gives away vehicles in large contests. The closet dealer to the winner gets a complimentary house deal—if their Customer Satisfaction Index is high enough, of course.
We may hear rumblings of this direct-to-consumer trial by summer, as the manufacturers, save for GM, have to act quickly because the dealers themselves have already started trekking down this trail. AutoNation announced in November it would be launching its new online SmartChoice Express platform[15] backed by a promised $100-million investment. While it is similar to GM’s Shop-Click-Drive platform, it is significant because it serves as an awkward reminder that a dealer group is leading the digital race against the other manufacturers.
Remember, it will only be a trial, but the results could change our business forever.
Satellite Service Centers Will Fuel Fixed Operations Sales for Dealer Groups
If the sales process is headed online, the need for expanding brick-and-mortar shifts entirely to Fixed Operations. Why, then, would anyone buy or build new dealerships (other than by force) when one can buyout our industry’s oldest enemy: the mom-and-pop repair shops.
As vehicles become more computers than cars, the traditional repair shop is already having trouble handling the new technology. Any vehicle produced today can have as many as 50 to 100 different tiny computers controlling everything from steering to acceleration. [16] The modern mechanic needs to know just as much about re-flashing the ECU as she/he needs to know about a cam shaft. So it’s not as much of a takeover as putting this component of the auto industry out of its inevitable misery.
When Starbucks sought to take over the local coffee shop, they did so by oversaturating the market to the point where Starbucks locations were literally across the street from other Starbucks locations[17]. A large auto group can easily do the same against the small-point competitors in their market.
Ford already started down this road when they began opening their Quick Lane Tire & Auto Centres to compete against the Jiffy Lube and big-box stores. Now they have over 700 locations across the United States[18] and 69 in Canada[19] capturing market share.
Expect to see large auto groups buying up and converting existing local shops as a means of handling overflow and, more importantly, increasing market share in geographical areas between or surrounding dealerships. The consumer can receive the same factory-trained technicians, the same loyalty promotions, and the same OEM parts at a shop around the corner, as opposed to driving the extra distance to your main operation. With careful purchasing, a large automotive group could entirely take over the fixed operations in a geographical area overnight.
Added satellite locations can also fuel additional sales opportunities, with additional test-drive starting points, e-commerce parts and accessory sales pick-up locations, and most importantly, more parking. What dealer group wouldn’t want to expand their footprint in a short period of time for a significantly lower cost than buying or building entire dealerships?
The Death of the Salesperson
This is not a new concept and has been the heated topic of many arguments around the auto industry for some time now. The concept is that people will no longer need a salesperson to purchase an automobile and can do everything online. There is some merit to this. In 2012, 10 percent of car buyers opted not to test-drive. [20] By the beginning of 2014 that number was up to 17 percent.[21] While a surprising number, it still leaves 83 percent of the population wanting a test drive.
Eventually there will be no need for a car salesperson, but that time is more than a little ways off. What we will start experiencing in 2015 is something entirely different. The current salesperson is dying off with age, not by lack of interest.
The seasoned salesperson that sells you 16-25 cars a month, with a large portfolio and years of experience, is on her/his way out of our industry. They are just getting older, and many are tired of what the industry has become. Margins and commissions are thinning every day, everything is online first rather than belly-to-belly, and their customer base is buying fewer vehicles at longer intervals. As these veterans start retiring out of our industry, a huge gap is left in their wake, as fresh bodies are nowhere to be found.
The newest generation of workers, Gen Y, has little to no interest in entering a career as a car salesperson. They are highly educated, digitally focused, have zero experience with negotiating and, most importantly, cannot grasp the concept of 100 percent commission. Try asking someone under the age of 35 if they want to work 60+ hours a week for an average of $1,500 a month with no guaranteed pay. [22] There is a break in the line, and dealerships are really starting to feel the pinch.
Ask any manager if she/he has enough salespeople on the floor. The unanimous answer is a definite no, followed by, “Why, do you know of anyone?” The situation has reached despairing levels, and seasoned salespeople are taking advantage of it. If you have any previous experience selling cars, it is nearly impossible that you couldn’t walk in the doors of any dealership in the country and get a job on the spot. This is a dangerous situation for management. Job security and loyalty are meaningless, and if the dealership next door is offering an extra 1 percent on the commission plan, your salespeople could be out the door tomorrow. Managers are dealing with a declining level of control on the floor, as discipline becomes next to impossible if every dealer is one-upping each other to take the best sales staff. Suddenly you are more worried about your competitor’s pay plan than the price of the cars in their advertising.
What will become the new trend in 2015 is the “Product Specialist,” replacing the commissioned salesperson. In order to refill the barracks with fresh blood, dealerships will have to adopt a salary and bonus, or all-salary structure. [23] The 100 percent commission strategy will either be grandfathered out or removed altogether. It’s not going to be an easy pill to swallow, but there are no alternatives on the horizon. The next generation to fill the ranks of your dealership value opportunity over money and job security. [24] They would much rather receive standard pay than a possible range based on their performance, and more importantly value a flexible work-life integration over anything else.[25]
In 1989, Best Buy modified their pay structure away from commission, a revolutionary move at the time that was scoffed at by their competitors.[26] The reason for doing so was because their business formula was out of sync with their customers. At the time, the electronics customer had little need for a salesperson and preferred the hassle-free buying experience. The gamble paid off, helping to grow sales from $439 million in 1989 to $2.6 billion in 1993[27]. Auto dealers have already begun to follow suit, moving to non-commission pay plans already as a means of acquiring a new generation of car salespeople[28]. Some are even dubbing it the “Best Buy” pay plan, in reference to the company’s very successful shift away from the aggressive salesperson. But these numbers have been small thus far, as the perceived risk is quite high.
The commissioned pay plan isn’t only a problem for attracting talent, it also is viewed negatively by the purchaser as well. Much like Best Buy’s problem in 1989, today’s automotive customer does not like dealing with commissioned salespeople as much as they wouldn’t want to be one. So much so that in a recent Microsoft study on millennials found that more than half said going to a dealership was more painful than going to the dentist. [29]
“J.D. Power and Associates agrees. The company has advocated for years that to avoid commission breath, dealerships should pay bigger monthly salaries and less commission. But there have been few takers -- certainly too few to be statistically significant, says Jon Osborn, research director for J.D. Power, of Westlake Village, Calif.”[30]
So as a dealer, you have a problem at both ends. Attracting top-level sales talent is getting harder and harder, in addition to your CSI dropping because you are putting more pressure on your staff for higher sales and higher gross. It’s a dire situation to be in, but for many, the solution of a non-commission pay plan appears riskier than staying the course. 2015 will spark the beginning of change, where by force or by courage, many dealers will take the Best Buy pay plan leap of faith. Those who keep their heads in the sand will find their sales floor quite empty in the coming months.
Death of the Single Point
It used to be that if you worked in the automotive industry, a viable dream was to one day own your own store. Today, unless you’re Warren Buffett[31] that likely will never happen. Furthermore, if you did achieve that dream and currently own a single-point operation, or maybe even two or three stores, that dream is also about to roll the credits.
For once, the Canadian market is ahead of the U.S. market in an automotive statistic, with close to 50 percent of vehicles sold in the country coming from automotive groups[32]. The largest group and the only publicly traded, AutoCanada, literally has been buying locations on a bi-weekly basis[33].
It’s not all bad news – rumors are rampant on both sides of the border that groups are happily paying two to three times the value of the stores. It makes for an easy decision for the single-point owners. Rather than face increasing competition, smaller margins, increased employment and capital expenditures, they can opt to sell for a gigantic cheque and retire in paradise.
Not to mention increased pressures from the manufacturers to update facilities on increasingly shorter timeframes. Hyundai recently unveiled their new Global Dealership Space Identity a mere four years after 50 percent of its U.S. dealers spent millions to update their facilities to the rooftop cube.[34] In Hyundai’s defense, they are also spending a monumental amount of money to upgrade their own headquarters in Korea [35].
The acquisition of the Van Tuyl Group by Buffett’s Berkshire Group sparked a frenzy of mass acquisition rumors across the industry. Overnight, the “more is more” philosophy was reignited, as the vast majority of dealerships in the United States are currently not part of a dealer group.[36] With big names like Buffett entering the picture, groups like AutoNation and Asbury will be forced to continue their single-point buying spree like they have been doing in 2014. [37]
What does all this mean? 2015 will see a significant move towards grouping dealerships together into large, corporate and too-big-to-fail entities, not unlike what has happened to the banking industry over the last 20 years[38]. The same fate will find Berkshire Automotive, AutoNation and the largest dealer groups in the United States invading single points like it’s a giant game of Risk.
Dealer Advertising Goes All-In on Digital
This may seem like old news, but in reality an alarming number of dealerships are still spending the majority of their yearly advertising budgets on newspaper. This is the result of manufacturers’ outdated co-op rules, in addition to the perceived risk of abandoning what has worked for so many years.
2015 will represent a full swing in the digital direction with a new industry forecast predicting newspaper spending by the automotive industry will decline 27 percent over 2014 to a mere $2.14 billion, down from $2.94 billion.[39] Other traditional forms of advertising are also expected to decline.
“Dealers are expected to slow spending on TV, telemarketing and direct mail by 11, 7 and 5 percent, respectively, in 2015.”[40]
Most importantly, it also forecasts automotive online advertising spending will increase 25 percent, to $15.1 billion in 2015. This will produce some interesting opportunities for digital vendors in the automotive landscape as advertising online is big step up from putting together a newspaper ad. Dealers know they need to be advertising online, but few know how to do it themselves.
Pay-per-click, display advertising and email marketing vendors have long existed, but new emerging advertising mediums have yet to be adequately represented. Social media marketing (SMM) is one example where few vendors have yet to provide a quality solution to dealers. SMM is far more than being coached on how to respond to negative reviews, it is an entirely new advertising medium that is crushing other digital advertising investment returns. Without SMM vendor representation, the savviest dealers can succeed in this advertising venue without being swallowed by a wave of competition.
Unfortunately, with such a rapid switch to digital, many dealerships will find themselves at the mercy of their vendors. When new technology sweeps across any industry at this pace, it can be difficult to discern who are the "good guys". At the 2014 NADA convention it was evident this was the direction the industry was headed. If you were there, you would have noticed that for the first time, digital vendors significantly outnumbered traditional vendors. Not surprisingly, all claimed to be the best solution to the trendy buzzword “big data.”
As dealers get deeper into the weeds of digital advertising, they will realize the need to hire help from within to protect themselves. This will result in a significant increase in Dealership Marketing Manager job postings in 2015.
Finance Fallout Begins
It is no secret that vehicle loan terms are getting longer each year, incentives are rising, and collectively we either don’t realize or don’t care about the gigantic hole that the auto industry continues to dig itself into. In the first quarter of 2014, 25 percent of all new-vehicle car loans were at a length of 73- to 84-month terms. Four years ago, that number was under 10 percent. The current average new-car loan today is 66 months,[41] an increase of 5 percent over the 2010 average of 62.9. [42] While that increase may seem small, extending the vehicle-purchasing cycle of the entire industry by four months while attempting to increase sales is a monumental problem.
In order to maintain sales forecasts and capture market share, manufacturers are forced to shell out more incentives and larger loans to get customers out of their contracts earlier each cycle. Hitting targets each month means expanding the “bubble” a little more each time.
In 2013, new vehicle incentives grew by 3.7 percent to an average of $2,576 per year.[43] In July of 2014, incentives were being pushed higher at a year-over-year increase of 7.1 percent. [44] As manufacturers continue to fight each other for top spot, these incentive increases have seemingly no end in sight. What that does is directly reduce used-vehicle pricing and demand, as in many instances a new car is less expensive than a pre-owned one. The industry is literally robbing Peter to pay Paul.
Now, add infinitely increasing incentives to lending amounts and terms at an all-time high. According to Equifax reports, “U.S. auto loan volumes are at an all-time high, with some $902.2 billion outstanding at the end of the first half of 2014, up 10 percent year-over-year.”[45] Car buyers are financing new-car purchases by rolling old debt at an alarming rate. Ninety-six-month amortization is now commonplace, as is rolling negative equity from the last vehicle into the new contract.
“A debt-rating agency noted recently that in some cases consumers are borrowing up to 135% of the value of the vehicle. These “Negative Equity” loans, as they’re called, are the same sort that premeditated the U.S. mortgage market before it collapsed in 2008.”[46]
Now add the sub-prime business on top of all this, which in the first three months of 2014, increased upwards of 15 percent to $145.6 billion[47] with no signs of slowing. Oh, and don’t forget that the average vehicle lifespan is also at an all-time high of 11.4 years[48].
This perfect storm, or “bubble,” will burst sooner than later, and the cracks will be large enough to see in 2015. Any change in the system, be it the expected Federal Funds Interest Rate hike beginning in spring 2015[49] or increased delays on a global airbag shortage[50] or the Japanese recession,[51] could be the catalyst to pull the floor from underneath our industry.
2016 – What Is on the Horizon
I can’t close this off without taking a Hail Mary stab at the long, long-term future for the automotive industry. Having already tackled some pretty significant topics for how I envision 2015 will play out, I might as well share a few things that I have on the radar for 2016. We will see how these, and all my other predictions, fare come December 2015.
- Uber Takes Market Share from Auto Industry
- Uber goes public, or Uber acquisition talks begin
- CarMax, EchoPark strengthen hold on used market
- Self-driving cars on sale
- No-haggle pricing dominant
- Insurance plug-in “snapshot” mandatory
- Car loan bubble bursts/Picking up the pieces
- Eric Miltsch and Jay Radke become world's first human cyborgs
In Closing,
If I wasn’t open to criticism, I wouldn’t publish something like this. The goal wasn’t to be a fortune-teller, but to spark conversation about the future of our industry. As the old adage goes, “If you are not riding the wave of change, you will find yourself beneath it.”
So please, comment, critique or call me crazy; conversation allows us to be a part of writing the next chapter.
Robert Karbaum arguably has the best name in the automotive industry. His combined experience over the past decade in E-Commerce and the automotive industry has allowed him to master the art of “AutoSpeak”; the ancient language that bridges the gap between internet geeks, the showroom floor and everything in-between. He manages the E-Commerce, Social and Digital Marketing operations at Weins Canada Inc. (formerly Don Valley North Automotive Group); a prestigious automotive group in Canada which includes the #1 volume Toyota and Lexus dealerships in the country.
Catch him on Twitter (@karbaum) or DroppinBaums.com.
References:
[1] Cohen, R. (2009, January 1). THE HISTORY OF AMERICA IS THE HISTORY OF THE AUTOMOBILE INDUSTRY— WHICH IS FAR OLDER AND STRANGER THAN YOU MIGHT IMAGINE. Retrieved from http://www.believermag.com/issues/200909/?read=article_cohen
[2] Colias, M. (2013, November 6). GM to expand online Shop-Click-Drive program nationwide. Retrieved from http://www.autonews.com/article/20131106/RETAIL01/131109874/gm-to-expand-online-shop-click-drive-program-nationwide
[3] (2014). Retrieved from https://shopclickdrive.com/
[4] Lutz, H. (2014, November 10). GM touts 13,000 vehicles sold under Shop-Click-Drive. Retrieved from http://www.autonews.com/article/20141110/RETAIL/141119986/gm-touts-13000-vehicles-sold-under-shop-click-drive
[5] MCEACHERN, S. (2014, May 5). General Motors Revises Customer Satisfaction Survey. Retrieved from http://gmauthority.com/blog/2014/05/general-motors-revises-customer-satisfaction-survey/
[6] The New Blockbuster Annual Report 2007. (2007). Retrieved from http://www.b2i.cc/document/553/49897_full_blockbuster.pdf
[7] Cohan, P. (2010, September 23). Why Blockbuster Went Bust While Netflix Flourished. Retrieved from http://www.dailyfinance.com/2010/09/23/why-blockbuster-went-bust-while-netflix-flourished/
[8] Market Data [U.S. Car Rental Market]. (2013). Retrieved from http://www.autorentalnews.com/fileviewer/1897.aspx
[9] Briggs, M. (2014, July 4). Future of Mobility: Growth & Investment Sees Carsharing Become Mainstream. Retrieved from http://www.frost.com/sublib/display-market-insight.do?id=291327683
[10] Shontell, A. (2014, November 20). LEAKED: Internal Uber Deck Reveals Staggering Revenue and Growth Metrics Read more: Http://www.businessinsider.com/uber-revenue-rides-drivers-and-fares-2014-11?op=1#ixzz3KBJwTl3W. Retrieved from http://www.businessinsider.com/uber-revenue-rides-drivers-and-fares-2014-11?op=1
[11] Kell, J. (2013, January 2). Avis to Buy Car-Sharing Service Zipcar. Retrieved from http://online.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424127887324374004578217121433322386
[12] National Car Rental: Control Enthusiast [Video on YouTube]. (2014). USA: Https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ls78ieMvORA.
[13] 1 in 6 Car Buyers Skips Test-Drive; Nearly Half Visit Just One (or No) Dealership Prior to Purchase. (2014, April 15). Retrieved from http://www.dmeautomotive.com/announcements/1-in-6-car-buyers-skips-test-drive-nearly-half-visit-just-one-or-no-dealership-prior-to-purchase#.VHXiTDHF98F
[14] Shepardson, D. (2014, October 14). U.S. auto sales expected to rise modestly in 2015. Retrieved from http://www.detroitnews.com/story/business/autos/2014/10/14/auto-sales-rise/17263907/
[15]Wilson, A. (2014, November 17). AutoNation's plan to change the retail game. Retrieved from http://www.autonews.com/article/20141117/RETAIL/311179969/autonations-plan-to-change-the-retail-game
[16] Pagliery, J. (2014, June 2). Your car is a giant computer – and it can be hacked. Retrieved from http://money.cnn.com/2014/06/01/technology/security/car-hack/
[17] Starbucks reaffirms rapid growth strategy. (2007, March 21). Retrieved from http://www.nytimes.com/2007/03/21/business/worldbusiness/21iht-starbucks.4985454.html?_r=0
[18] Quick Lane Tire & Auto Centre. (2014). Retrieved from http://www.quicklane.com/about
[19] Quick Lane Tire & Auto Centre. (2014). Retrieved from http://www.quicklane.ca/locations
[20] Bomey, N. (2012, August 13). Study: More car buyers bypass test drives. Retrieved from http://content.usatoday.com/communities/driveon/post/2012/08/more-car-buyers-refuse-test-drives/1#.VHXebjHF98G
[21] 1 in 6 Car Buyers Skips Test-Drive; Nearly Half Visit Just One (or No) Dealership Prior to Purchase. (2014, April 15). Retrieved from http://www.dmeautomotive.com/announcements/1-in-6-car-buyers-skips-test-drive-nearly-half-visit-just-one-or-no-dealership-prior-to-purchase#.VHXiTDHF98F
[22] McDonald, M. (2014, February 14). Car Salesman Confidential: How We Get Paid These Days, the 'Home Run' Is Harder to Come By. Retrieved from http://blogs.motortrend.com/1402_car_salesman_confidential_how_to_get_paid.html
[23] Rogers, C. (2013, November 20). Say Goodbye to the Car Salesman No-Haggle Price, Online Selling Transform Auto Retailing. Retrieved from http://online.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052702304672404579182061400578466
[24] Generation Y: Powerhouse of the global economy Restless generation is a challenge – and a huge opportunity – for employers. (2009). Retrieved from http://www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/Deloitte/us/Documents/human-capital/us-consulting-hc-generationy-snapshot-041509.pdf
[25] Agshar, R. (2014, January 13). What Millennials Want In The Workplace (And Why You Should Start Giving It To Them). Retrieved from http://www.forbes.com/sites/robasghar/2014/01/13/what-millennials-want-in-the-workplace-and-why-you-should-start-giving-it-to-them/
[26] Crosby, J. (2012, May 19). One man's force of will built a retailing empire. Retrieved from http://www.startribune.com/business/152098405.html
[27] Best Buy Co., Inc. History. (2004). Retrieved from http://www.fundinguniverse.com/company-histories/best-buy-co-inc-history/
[28] Jones, M. (2013, November 18). Innovative Texas Auto Dealer Ditches Sales Commissions in Favor of "Solutions." Retrieved from http://www.edmunds.com/car-news/innovative-texas-auto-dealer-ditches-sales-commissions-in-favor-of-solutions.html
[29] Wells, G. (2013, February 1). Selling to Millennials. Retrieved from http://www.autodealermonthly.com/channel/the-showroom/article/story/2013/02/selling-to-millennials.aspx
[30] Henry, J. (2010, May 31). Simple remedies for 'commission breath' Retrieved from http://www.autonews.com/article/20100331/RETAIL02/100329887
[31] Bachman, J. (2014, October 2). What Turned Warren Buffett Into a Car Guy? Economics. Retrieved from http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2014-10-02/what-turned-warren-buffett-into-a-car-dealership-guy-economics
[32] Kennan, G. (2013, February 12). Big dealers remodel Canadian car lots. Retrieved from http://www.theglobeandmail.com/globe-investor/big-dealers-remodel-canadian-car-lots/article8535918/
[33] Investors Press Releases. (2014, November 26). Retrieved from http://www.autocan.ca/investors-press-releases.htm
[34] Beene, R. (2014, August 12). Hyundai goes global with store design. Retrieved from http://www.autonews.com/article/20140811/OEM03/308119979/hyundai-goes-global-with-store-design
[35] Mundy, S. (2014, September 23). Hyundai Works Strike in Protest of HQ Pricetag. Retrieved from http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/85df9c68-42ea-11e4-9a58-00144feabdc0.html#axzz3JwkTLHrl
[36] Buffett to buy Van Tuyl Group, create Berkshire Hathaway Automotive. (2014, October 2). Retrieved from http://www.autonews.com/article/20141002/RETAIL07/141009938/buffett-to-buy-van-tuyl-group-create-berkshire-hathaway-automotive
[37] Wilson, A. (2014, February 10). AutoNation, Asbury boost spending plans. Retrieved from http://www.autonews.com/article/20140210/RETAIL/302109981/autonation-asbury-boost-spending-plans
[38] Big Bank Theory Chart. (2010, January 1). Retrieved from http://www.motherjones.com/files/images/big-bank-theory-chart-large.jpg
[39] Chappell, L. (2014, November 15). Dealerships' newspaper ad spending forecast to dive. Retrieved from http://www.autonews.com/article/20141115/RETAIL03/311179994/dealerships-newspaper-ad-spending-forecast-to-dive
[40] Car Dealership Newspaper Ads Expected to Die Off Faster in 2015. (2014, November 17). Retrieved from http://www.carscoops.com/2014/11/car-dealership-newspaper-ads-expected.html
[41] Mays, K. (2014, September 7). Long-term car loans skyrocket. Retrieved from http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/cars/2014/09/07/car-loans-long-term/15237795/
[42] TATE-OF-THE-INDUSTRY REPORT - 2012. (2013). Retrieved from http://www.nada.org/NR/rdonlyres/C1C58F5A-BE0E-4E1A-9B56-1C3025B5B452/0/NADADATA2012Final.pdf
[43] 2014 Q1 White Paper NADA Used Car Guide Special Report: 2014 Used Vehicle Price Forecast. (2014, April 1). Retrieved from http://www.nada.com/b2b/WhitePaper-2014-Q1.aspx
[44] Young, A. (2014, July 29). July 2014 US New Auto Sales Forecast: Record High Auto Lending Pushing US New Car Sales To Highs Unseen Since 2006. Retrieved from http://www.ibtimes.com/july-2014-us-new-auto-sales-forecast-record-high-auto-lending-pushing-us-new-car-sales-1642516
[45] Niedermeyer, E. (2014, July 29). Is Your Car an Underwater Time Bomb? Retrieved from http://www.bloombergview.com/articles/2014-07-29/is-your-car-an-underwater-time-bomb
[46] Marr, G., & Shecter, B. (2014, November 22). How Canada’s auto loan bubble has become a ticking time bomb. Retrieved from http://business.financialpost.com/2014/11/22/how-canadas-auto-loan-bubble-has-become-a-ticking-time-bomb/
[47] Silver-Greenberg, J., & Corkerry, M. (2014, July 19). In a Subprime Bubble for Used Cars, Borrowers Pay Sky-High Rates. Retrieved from http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2014/07/19/in-a-subprime-bubble-for-used-cars-unfit-borrowers-pay-sky-high-rates/?_r=0
[48] Wile, R. (2014, June 9). The Average Age Of US Vehicles Is At A Record High Of 11.4 Years. Retrieved from http://www.businessinsider.com/the-average-age-of-us-vehicles-stays-at-record-high-of-114-years-2014-6
[49] Mahn, K. (2014, March 27). Fed On Target To Raise Interest Rates In Spring 2015. Retrieved from http://www.forbes.com/sites/advisor/2014/03/27/fed-on-target-to-raise-interest-rates-in-spring-2015/
[50] Sedgwick, D. (2014, November 24). Airbag inflator shortage plagues industry with tight capacity, 2 years needed for replacements. Retrieved from http://www.autonews.com/article/20141124/OEM11/311249954/airbag-inflator-shortage-plagues-industry
[51] Kurtenbach, E. (2014, November 24). Japan's Young Fret as Unexpected Recession Hits. Retrieved from http://abcnews.go.com/International/wireStory/japans-young-fret-unexpected-recession-hits-27133443
33 Comments
Haley Toyota Certified Sales Center
Great insights Robert. Eric & Jay are almost to the Cyborg status already. Those are two really smart guys. I would say that we will see more ways that wearable tech could benefit car dealers. Thats a topic that Eric & Jay are certainly on top of.
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Thanks Bill! Jay just posted on my Facebook to confirm he is already half cyborg. I honestly added that in as a spot test, haha. To see if people read to the end :P
Kruse Control Inc.
Robert you, my friend, are awesome! Thank you for such a well-thought out and well-written piece. I happen to agree with everything you wrote. One of my observations: I was just at the CPO conference and learned that the dominate loan term was 72 months! I've been out of the day-to-day operations of a store since 2008 so it came as a shock. JD Power gave an alarming report on the repercussions of this and I have a feeling everyone in the room had doom in their eyes but once they left the room, they went back to their "comfort space." Second observation: Online selling is happening elsewhere in the world so it's only a matter of time before it's here. Your line that Tesla is doing the dirty work is spot on. I could go on forever about your post. Instead, I will bookmark it and write my blogs about your observations and link back to you. Right on, brother.
FordDirect.com
Robert, exceptionally well written! You summarize very well the current threats / opportunities facing our industry. Still not flying car....
Sloan Ford
Awesome article Robert! Really enjoyed reading it and glad to see someone's asking the tough questions about our very future. Any ideas if the rumors about Lexus going to one price are true? My rep won't confirm nor deny...
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Thanks Chris! Since the Scion Brand is already Pure Price, and now Pure Process+, Lexus would be a likely next candidate. I haven't heard anything official yet.
CarGirl, Inc.
Great article! Very well spoken and right on. I love the evolution of the industry and your insight helps. I hope to be on the cutting edge until my motor blows.
DealerKnows Consulting
First off, FOOTNOTES!!! I totally agree with most of the points, however I feel it'll take longer in the States to transition. I thought when I started delivering cars, site-unseen, from a single rooftop in 2003, everybody would be buying their cars that way in just a few short years. When I helped AutoNation do the same thing four years later, I thought everybody would be buying their cars that way in just a few short years. Here we are seven years later, and that's just a promise of reality. Consumer behavior is a crazy thing, and it might take more time to adapt. That being said, I totally agree that Tesla is setting the benchmark. Right now, volume wise, it's analogous to Porsche Cayenne sales. When Tesla starts offering a $30K sedan, it'll be in the meat of the mainstream market, and it'll be fun to watch the sparks fly. Great post!
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Thanks Jeff! Not sure if that is positive or negative, but either way!
Stream Automotive
Robert - very well written and insightful. It's up to dealers (and those that council them) to adapt ahead of this curve.
PureCars
You missed one Robert. Actually it's more of a combination of a couple of your predictions. Details forthcoming soon ... ;)
Lexus of Queens
Robert, Fist off, Great post. I happen to agree with most of what you have written. These topics are what many of us have thought of happening for some time now. It feels like the ball is rolling at a much more rapid pace and the acquisition frenzy seems to indicate this as well. As an automotive professional I can hope to be working for one of the few groups that recognizes good talent and pays accordingly; with some sort of performance based pay plan as opposed to straight salary. Using bestbuy as an example, I can say I NEVER get excellent service there and it seems more associates there try and avoid helping you rather then help you. Their product knowledge is terrible as well. This to me comes from a no performance based pay plan. This is speaking from my market (NYC) only. Having said this, vehicle purchases are a much larger expense and have more involvement so I would guess dealer groups / manufacturers would invest in good talent to avoid that issue. Once again thanks for the great post !
WheelsTV
Excellent article Robert! The only thing missing, from my perspective, is how digital video, and in particular video test drives and walk-arounds will make it easier for car shoppers to buy a car 100% online and have it brought right to their door. The last five years have seen an explosion in shopping and buying using mobile devices that provide HD video. Today, more and more car shoppers expect to virtually get behind the wheel when visiting a dealer's website. This capability makes for a more pleasurable experience for both the consumer and the dealer.
Wilsonville Toyota-Scion
Great stuff Karbaum! The only data point I take issue with - and the assumptions derived from it - is that test drives are down. DME doesn't reveal the question asked in the survey that led to these findings. Many people test drive at one dealership but didn't drive it at the point of purchase. Are they a yes or no for this study? People rent vehicles, drive friends' or relatives' cars. How many fleet sales are included in those numbers? Was the survey fashioned to account for these? Are those results broken down by make or type (budget vs. highline for instance)? I just would be careful about making CX decisions around the assumption that people don't want to test drive. Maybe they do and that we just don't deliver it the way they want. With that said, if I'm wrapping a 24-month lease on a 5-Series and loved the car, do I need to drive before signing paperwork on this year's model? Probably not. So loyalty will be a key segment of determining test drive frequency, right? Great observations and predictions. Scary stuff for the unprepared. Stay warm and well!
Bob Smith Motors
Great post, agree with you on most of this. Single point dealerships will have to become dominant digitally in order to either survive independently or position themselves for a profitable buyout, otherwise they will either fail and go out of business or sell out at a loss. Tesla - Yes, Musk understands consumers, what they want and how they want to buy. Loan Length - USA will have to follow Canada into the heady heights of 92 plus month loans as vehicles continue to increase in cost at a higher rate than consumers are getting pay hikes. Could see used vehicle leasing enter the market. Non Commissioned Product Specialists - We just contacted T.W.Jr to get his pay plan. Hiring new blood is very hard, good sales people have so many other avenues to take without the risk of 100% Commission, effectively eliminating them from our industry. Quick Lubes owned by dealerships is definitely the future for dealerships to continue to harvest their existing customers and attract new ones as long as the manager is competent and motivated to interact in a sales forwarding capacity. Many long time Dealer Principals have a hard time letting go of news print, it is their comfort zone and what they have used for many years. Savvy newspapers are converting that relationship into digital products they offer. This is where they will have growth to survive the collapse of newsprint which will become a means to the end eventually. 2016... Why did you get conservative there? :) All fairly safe bets. eSigning of finance and warranty docs and fully integrated shopping carts is where I see 2016 and am working towards that goal currently.
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Paul, great comments. As for the test drive reeducation there are a variety of different resources over the years that show an increasing decline. Not just e one article. That was the most recent. I will try and grab them when I am back from vacation.
DealerTeamwork LLC
Robert, Very well done man. It's a difficult thing to write a long piece and hold the reader's interest and you accomplished that here - solid topics with a thorough explanation that can help anyone in the business regardless of their experience or position. I'll do my best to help make your cyborg prediction come true next year:)
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Point #1 Completed Early : Volvo to launch online car sales in marketing shift https://ca.finance.yahoo.com/news/volvo-launch-online-car-sales-051726379.html Yes, it's one of the smaller but I fully anticipate more to follow very soon.
SELF
Robert and All, this is a well thought out and lengthy article touching many points, thank you for taking the time to do your research and share your thoughts. To begin with I am no longer with the company listed on my profile, my comments are of my own opinion and don't represent the opinions of any entity other than myself. In regards to OEM direct sales, I wholeheartedly agree that the Manufactures are far behind the times in the respect of the new era of "Digital" and " Big Data", but lets take a look at some of the roadblocks they face. Not only is the registration process and title process different in just about every state, but their is the logistics of the Manufacturers adding the needed employees to actually accomplish the ability for a customer to be able to 100% purchase vehicles on line or through digital and social media. While GM is ahead of the curve right now, that remains to be seen going forward, and I also agree that failing to provide an adequate medium for this process certainly would poison the metaphoric well. As for dealers and dealer management, there are number of key factors that need to be addressed in this whole potential process. NADA guidelines are clearly behind the times and that is by and large what dealers use to manage their metrics. Particularly in the category of marketing and advertising. NADA's determination of what should be spent per new customer acquisition and how it should be spent is archaic and as you mentioned, not at all in pace with the coming sweeping changes. This ultimately leaves dealers holding the bag, which is historically not a new thing either might I add. Dealers need to get ahead of the curve yesterday, PPC advertising, SEO and print ad worked 10 years ago but I don't see them working necessarily in the next 10 months. Age old marketing like direct mail has an abysmal response but can still generate a healthy ROI if focused correctly. In that regard you mentioned a significant increase in subprime lending in 2014, the latest number I saw was up 18% this year, and add to that the merger of banks like CFC and Flagship along with other subprime lenders expanding nationwide coupled with the looming threat of another mortgage bubble, the inevitable raising of rates and the fact the Fed can no longer artificially stimulate the economy by pumping in printed money every month to the mortgage industry, the pool of subprime buyers is destined to increase over the next 12-48 months in my opinion. Let's talk about your thoughts on the Death of the salesman, tied in with the need to increase fixed ops market share. While its true that the general perception of Car Salesman is generally as highly thought of us Lawyers and Politicians, removing them from the cogs in the wheel of the American Economy will leave a large dent in the disposable income of hundreds of micro-economies. Does the model need to change? Yes I agree completely, but taking those jobs out of the dealership moves a lot of that to the manufacturer and that means increased cost of doing business for them, and we know where that will end up, but it also creates more of a doomsday scenario for the " too big to fail" methodology, I think you can track where I am going with that. One of the biggest issues the Big three had to deal with the top heavy expense of unions and Pensions, after what happened in 2007-2010 do we want to take the ability to maneuver within a micro- economy out of the localities hands? I'm thinking probably not. Now tie this needed change into where the real profit center is within the dealerships. Fixed Ops. If you want to keep or acquire talented, qualified and ethical sales personnel, you need to create a model that will generate sustained profit, while still holding them accountable for productivity. I would quickly foray into your synopsis of how Best Buy changed their industry by removing the Commission aspect. In my opinion it ruined the industry. If you went into a Federated, a Good Guys or Circuit City in the 80' or 90s and bought something, you paid a premium, but you typically got a presentation from a qualified individual that gave you the vital information to make an informed decision. Remember that they had a 30 day return policy no questions asked so the sales person did their job right because they cared about their commission and didn't want a charge back. As I recall my lost visit to Best Buy the kid who was attempting to answer my questions was busy pulling his pants up and calling me "dude". Sign me back up for the well dressed professional who wants to make sure the job is done right the first time! But this also only solidifies what you said about the Y generation being the new salesman. And yes the dealerships are always asking for a real salesperson to show up anymore. Back to changing the model...Enter the Fixed Ops service drive customer, who's value is far greater than the profit of 10 new vehicle sales. Why not tie in the Sales persons pay plan to not only CSI as they do already, but as to making sure this customer comes back time and time again to the service drive? This ties in with what the Electronics stores did years ago when signing up new satellite customers, they were paid on the profitability that the customer represented to the satellite customer. To revolutionize the process we still need to offer an above average income to the dealership personnel and keep it local. Regarding your analysis of the Financial Fallout, I agree that 2016 looks like a potential mess, but I don't think it will be keyed or fueled by the auto industry, it will fall back on interest rates and the mortgage industry again, rates are too low right now, values too inflated again and still quite challenging on getting financing secured and completed. Not sure how I feel about big auto groups sucking up all the single point franchises, but your arguments have a lot of merit to them. Again overall a well written and thought article that I enjoyed and now you have my comments, but your not crazy!
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Eric, a big thanks for your comments! I will put another check mark in the "not crazy" column :)
Attrell Toyota Scion
Robert, I couldn't agree with you more! It is refreshing to know that others out there are breaching the tough conversations in their dealership context...and especially here in Canada! I will be forwarding your post immediately after I leave this comment to my Dealer Principal, this way he won't think that I'm the only 'crazy' person out there talking about these upcoming changes! You're a great man and do a great job - keep dropping baums brother!
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Article from Automotive News: Dealers offer better hours, but still see high sales turnover, NADA study finds http://www.autonews.com/article/20141203/RETAIL07/141209933/dealers-offer-better-hours-but-still-see-high-sales-tu "But Kraybill warns that dealers are turning off Gen Y workers because of the way that “dealers historically operate.” Specifically, he said, fully commission-based compensation doesn’t appeal to Gen Y workers."
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Article from USA Today: Volvo begins online car selling http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/cars/2014/12/15/volvo-gm-tesla-online-internet-car-sales-dealers/20454399/ "A buyer can order a Volvo online, submit a down payment using a credit card – forwarded by Volvo to a local dealer who then contacts the buyer. A buyer can get a refund if the buyer and the dealer can't agree on price, delivery date or other particulars." Getting closer....
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Help The Bargain Brothers Change the Public's Opinion of our Industry
It is no secret that our industry is negatively viewed in the general populace. That people consider us no better than a 1920’s Snake Oil Salesman. This is why the Bargain Brothers reality TV show is so important for all of us in the automotive industry to get behind.
Changing the perception of an entire industry is not easy. In fact it’s near impossible, but we need to start somewhere and fast. This is where the Bargain Brothers reality show comes in. Not only is it extremely funny to watch, but it shows the real side of owning and operating a dealership. It showcases the family values, the hard work, and most importantly how an honest car dealership is run.
The last time our industry was showcased to the public was the “King of Cars” reality series. I think we can all agree it did more harm than good in changing the public’s perception of a Used Car Dealer.
Bargain Brothers by comparison is a welcome breath of fresh air. It portrays us how we really are, hardworking, honest, caring, and a little kooky.
The success of this show will benefit ALL of us in the auto industry. The more we in the industry watch it, the more popular it gets, and the more it is exposed to the public. If the public has the opportunity to fall in love with the MacIver family their outmoded opinions of our industry can change, and we can shake off the old snake skin.
Now yes, I am a bit biased as I have had the fortune to spend some great times with Doug (@dougmaciver) and Andrew MacIver (@_andrewmaciver) over the years and consider them great friends HOWEVER I can honestly say that even if I had never met them I would be saying the same thing.
I urge everyone within the DrivingSales community to get behind Bargain Brothers and help promote it so that in the future when a customer thinks of a Used Car Salesperson they will think of an honest hard working family, rather than what you find on Google Images when you look it up.
Who would you rather be the face of our industry?
Watch New Episodes of The Bargain Brothers Tuesdays at 7 (EST) on the BNN Network, or watch all the aired episodes online right now at http://www.bnn.ca/shows/bargain-brothers.aspx or on the BNN GO Mobile App http://www.bnn.ca/bnn-go-app.aspx.
9 Comments
Auction Direct USA
Been loving this show and beleive that it gives great insight into some of the challenges that dealers face every day. A great way to connect with the public and completely agree that it helps elevate the profession and ruin stale stereotypes. Way to go Doug and Andrew, keep it up.
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Glad to hear so many American's are loving the show!
theBDCtrainer.com
Great Stuff! I will watch for sure! Kind of reminds me of Car Lot Rescue. What ever happened to Car Lot Rescue?
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Thanks Colin! Let us know what you think! Car Lot Rescue only lasted 1 season.
Small Biz Sales Coach
I love this series and the brothers and their weird wacky family. Their poor sister.......and sister-in-law. Hope they make more episodes soon! And ss a sales coach and 35+ year sales professional, we need to change the image of used car salespeople. Sales is an honourable profession and so are most sales people even the used car ones.
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Great comment Patti! The next episode will air on Tuesday, but you can watch all of the aired episodes at http://www.bnn.ca/shows/bargain-brothers.aspx
Steenman
Remember "The Chopper" that was a long form info-mericial but those guys were pretty darn funny.
Kijiji, an eBay Company
It may have been funny to us, but unfortunately it perpetuated negative and outdated stereotypes to the rest of the population.
Kijiji, an eBay Company
How to Use DrivingSales.com - A How-To Guide For New Users
The DrivingSales community is a wonderfully inviting and accommodating community. However, for those who are here for the first time, I can understand that it can be a tad intimidating. Especially if “digital” is not your first language, some of the topics and conversations can seem overwhelming at first glance.
I wanted to write something for first-time users to DrivingSales.com, to ease them into the culture and experience that is found here. My goal is that if new users are more comfortable on their first experience, we will convert a higher percentage into active users. After all we are in the business of conversions, and the more people we have contributing, the more we will all get back from it. We are all in this together.
This article is for both the brand-new, hip, young digital girl/guy in the automotive world, and the veteran that is looking to broaden their horizons. Together we all have vastly different skill sets, and on DrivingSales, we can all work together.
Basics – Creating a Profile
Yes, today every site asks you to create a profile, leaving you with another password you can’t remember. However, a DrivingSales account will help launch you into the community. First and foremost, as you spend time on DrivingSales you will begin to foster online relationships. Creating an account allows you to connect with others in the community, and allows you to be easily contacted as well.
I always enjoy meeting people in person that I have communicated with on DrivingSales. It’s amazing how the conversation can naturally flow from the online community to IRL (In Real Life). At the last DrivingSales Executive Summit I had the fantastic opportunity to meet community members for the first time, even though we have shared many conversations in the past.
In addition to your new profile being like a DrivingSales online business card, it also tracks your activity and notifies you when anyone responds to a post or article you have been participating in. This can be very helpful if you need to recall information weeks or months down the line. Just last week I looked up a YouTube link that I thought I had lost.
Once you have a profile started, head to mine: http://www.drivingsales.com/profile/24699 and click “Add Connection.” I don’t bite, I promise.
dScore
http://www.drivingsales.com/dscore
Throughout DrivingSales you will see that every member has a number beneath their name. That’s their “dScore” and, in short, it is a measurement of their contributions towards the community. Low number = low contributions, high number = Rock Star.
It’s relevant to time as well, meaning if a user goes dormant for a few days the score will begin to decline. This way, you know at any exact moment where a member stands in the community.
What this means to you is that you can use dScore as a measuring stick when taking suggestions or advice from other community members. A high dScore would suggest they are a more trustworthy source. However, it’s just a guide; you definitely don’t want to discriminate against a great idea because of a number.
You can see the full-length official description of dScore here:
Forums
www.drivingsales.com/forums
The forums on DrivingSales make up the bulk of the activity on the site. The goal of the forums is knowledge: share and gain as much as you can. Think of it like a 20 Group that never ends, where you can “talk shop” with your colleagues till the cows come home.
You will see a wide variety of topics in the forums: questions on how to solve a problem, industry news and events, general sales & service topics, opinions, best ideas, and so much more. For example, the current all-time most commented topic is “The Most Important Website Metric” and the most-viewed post is "Favorite or creative spiff ideas.”
It doesn’t always have to be “digital” – many conversations surround dealership operations, fixed ops, and day-to-day activities.
Forum Comments
Topics are just the beginning – what makes the forums so useful is the communication in the comments section. Depending on the subject matter, the comments from the other DrivingSales members can range from a lengthy debate to a brainstorming session.
Sometimes conversations can get quite heated, especially when there is a stark difference of opinion. Yet, what is great about DrivingSales is that there is always a level of respect and professionalism amongst the members. So you can get right into a debate, but remember to keep classy.
Now, since this is a guide for new members, I will guess that you haven’t posted yet. What are you waiting for? Jump right in! Even if it’s just to introduce yourself. There are no dumb questions or comments. Everyone here is very supportive and eager to help.
If you have a question to ask or have something to share, I highly encourage you to post away. Just click the “Ask a Question” button on the front page and you are off to the races. Or, if you want to start small, start commenting on the other posts.
Best Ideas
http://www.drivingsales.com/best-ideas
This section is a little bit hidden, but it should be a MUST-visit for all. It’s like the pizza place in the Cosmopolitan in Las Vegas – a little hard to find, but well worth it once you arrive.
Here you can find some fantastic ideas that others from the community have contributed, most with detailed descriptions, how-to guides, and statistical results of how well it worked. Not to mention, they are great conversation starters where the DrivingSales community can discuss how to take a great idea and make it even better.
If you have a great idea that you can share, I strongly encourage you to do so. The better we operate as an industry as a whole, the better off we all are.
Blogs:
http://www.drivingsales.com/blogs
Blog articles on DrivingSales are separated into two sections: Exclusives, and Community Blog Posts.
The Exclusives section are articles that are only available on DrivingSales, whereas Community Blog Posts are likely to be circulated elsewhere on the web.
Exclusive blog posts are important, because you know that they were written specifically for the DrivingSales audience. This drastically increases the relevancy for the reader, and should encourage you to read as many as you can.
Now, that isn’t to say that the Community Blog Posts are not good, as there are many articles I have found that were terrific. However, as time is a precious commodity, if you are looking to maximize your ROI on a short budget I would make sure to check the Exclusives section first.
Blogs: Topics
Blog articles on DrivingSales are separated into several sections:
- Accounting
- Finance & Insurance
- Fixed Ops
- General Management
- Marketing
- Internet/BDC
- Misc. Industry
- New Car, and
- Used Car
The categories make it easy to separate what you are most interested in. For example, someone from the financial side of the business can hang out in Finance & Insurance, while an Internet manager can spend her/his time in Internet/BDC.
Since you are new to the site, don’t limit yourself to just the latest posts. Look back over the past few weeks and read everything that has gone on to really familiarize yourself with the community.
Notification Settings
http://www.drivingsales.com/profile/preferences/settings_edit
Many users are not aware that you can tailor your notification system to suit your needs. By default, your account is set up to notify you of pretty much everything. However, if you are looking for a tailored-down experience, you can change any of the settings yourself.
News
http://www.drivingsales.com/news
http://www.drivingsales.com/news/add
Did you know you can share a news item? It’s super easy – just head to the news section and click on the “Share Auto News” section. Or, if you know that a particular story may create a debate, you can also share a news story in the forums.
The News section itself is a terrific place to stay informed. It’s curated by the community to provide the most specific automotive news for the community. You will always find a different perspective here, as the content is coming from individuals across North America.
DrivingSales News
http://drivingsalesnews.com/
Speaking of news, DrivingSales also has its own content stream, including their very own reporter, Dave Martinson!
DS News provides a steady stream of targeted automotive news and stories that you need to hear right away. It features the heavy-hitting stories from the automotive industry, including big news from the OEMs like recalls, new models, and marketing shifts. On the flip side, DS News is always up-to-date on the latest and greatest from the technology side, with features on things like the new Facebook Places updates and Google’s latest upgrades to mobile extensions.
Between DS News and the community-moderated news, you will be fully informed about everything that is happening in the automotive world.
Vendor Ratings
http://www.drivingsales.com/ratings
One of the most important sections of DrivingSales is the Vendor Ratings. Here is where you can research all the vendors in our industry and get an unbiased view of how they stack up.
It is the first place you need to go when you are looking for a vendor solution, whether you are looking at mobile apps or fixed operations solutions.
DrivingSales Vendor Ratings are also fully transparent, and each rating is verified by a phone call from the DrivingSales team to ensure accuracy and honesty.
As Jared says:
We promise to provide a completely neutral platform for Dealers to anonymously rate and review their Vendors. We promise to verify that every single rating is accurate, trustworthy and from an actual dealership employee (we don't like cheaters). We promise to present this unbiased data to the entire industry via our website, DrivingSales.com, and our quarterly publication, the Dealership Innovation Guide.
Reading ratings is only half of the equation. It is also highly encouraged that you rate your vendors as well with your unique experiences. The more ratings in the system, the more value it holds for the entire community.
There are over 1,000 companies within the system already, and almost 20,000 reviews, so chances are your vendors are already included in the list. However, if you have a new vendor to add, it’s a very simple process. Just head to: http://www.drivingsales.com/ratings/companies/add and put in the details of the company.
Best of all, reviews are time-sensitive, meaning that they only last for 365 days. This ensures that if a vendor is beginning to decline in their quality, it will be reflected in their ratings.
Is there anything I have forgotten? Have some other tips to share for new users? Share in the comments below!
Also, if you are new, use this as an opportunity to introduce yourself!
6 Comments
Autosoft, Inc.
Robert, as usual, you have provided a clear and concise article that should help many people not only utilize Driving Sales, but understand the effect and reach it may have in their success. Thank you for sharing!
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Thanks Mark! I actually learned some things myself during it. For example, I wasn't even aware there was a "Best Idea" section until I started writing this article.
JATO Dynamics - North America
This is really cool for you to do, Robert! Surprised that the guy who won Best Idea at this year's #DSES didn't know there was a section of the site dedicated to it! That's funny. The only thing I would add is to new users in BIG LETTERS is: CONTRIBUTE!!! Ask questions. People on here love to help.
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Haha, yes I was just as surprised when I found it!
Faulkner Nissan
Great tips, Robert! I recommend anyone who doesn't have a profile pic to at least put that up - it's nice to put a face to everyone's comments! :-)
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Top 8 DrivingSales Executive Summit 2014 Takeaways
Conferences are easy. Free food, free swag, free parties, and more information than you can shake a stick at. It is like going back to college, condensed into 3 days.
Now comes the work; taking what you have learnt and doing something with it. Creating an actionable items list and work-back schedule.
Our day-to-day lives catch up with us very quickly and it is all too easy to put off making a plan. Before you know it, it's the next year and the next conference season and you haven't moved on anything you have learned.
A similar but equally daunting problem is hoping to accomplish EVERYTHING. Often there are so many fantastic ideas it is impossible to choose. This past DrivingSales Executive Summit is a prime example. The great information I took in, is far more than I could ever accomplish.
The reality is this: you can't implement everything, but you can't afford to implement nothing. [Tweet This] You need to determine what is most important and how you are going to accomplish it. To assist you in this endeavor, here are my top 8 takeaways from DSES 2014. In no particular order.
Rand Fishkin (@randfish) - "Google is an Answer Engine"
Rand, self-proclaimed "Wizard" of MOZ (and I don't disagree) gave us an update of Google and how it is no longer a "search engine" but now is moving towards a Skynet inspired sentient being, or "Answer/ Intent Engine".
We no longer seek out information, we seek out answers. Our instant gratification culture is in full force. We want an answer box, and we are not willing to accept anything less.
To facilitate this change Google now acts to solve the world's questions, before they are asked. The engine, now smarter than keywords and meta tags alone decides what answers it wants to use based on how it interprets content. Not on how you present it.
The Takeaway: You can't just pump out content anymore. Not only do you need quantity to build yourself up as a reliable source, but you also need quality original content that is designed to answer user intent.
Jared Hamilton (@DrivingSales) - "We are going to be competing on customer experience"
Jared gave us a sneak peek into the massive study DrivingSales is currently undergoing that focuses how we are perceived by the customer, and what they want in the car buying process. The results thus far are scary. This study, to be unveiled at NADA 2015 focuses on what customers ACTUALLY want in their automotive buying experience, not what we think they want. Or, more accurately, what we are cramming down their throats.
Right now the automotive industry is at a serious fork in the road and we have run out of race track. We need to decide today if we are willing to put in the effort to make serious changes to how we do business.
If we continue on the path that we are on, customers will moved towards alternatives that offer a better customer experience. We have all seen the Blockbuster story, the Kodak story, the Borders story, Blackberry, Tower Records, Circuit City, Polaroid, Sega or the countless other incidents where empires have fallen because they refused to adapt to the needs of the customer. If we don't change, right now will be the point where everyone looks back and says,
"How could they not see it? They had a chance to save themselves"
Now, where this hits the DEFCON-5 alert status is that we ALL need to work together to provide a phenomenally better customer experience. Not just one dealer, or one group, or one manufacture; we ALL need to really, truly, and honestly change. Else, stick your head in the sand and wait for it all to be over.
The Takeaway: Customer Experience; we are all in this together.
Brian Solis (@briansolis) - "Asking "why?" Prompts "what if?" Which leads to "what's next."
I don't need to watch horror movies to be terrified this Halloween, when I have Brian Solis. This slide from his presentation is what I mean:
"9,480. The mileage per year you'd have to exceed in order for mid-size car ownership to be cheaper than taking an UberX car everywhere you go." [Tweet This]
That is terrifying for anyone who works in the car business. Now, I am aware some due diligence into the data needs to be done, but on the service it's enough to panic.
Terror wasn't what Brian was hoping to convey however. In fact, it was one of the best presentations that inspired the reality of today's marketplace. He took our hand, and together we walked off the cliff of the past into the future. I believe his goal was to inspire us. Allow us to see how rapidly things can change under our noses. Prepare us for the coming change by asking "why" and most importantly innovate.
When you add this presentation to Jared's, its blindingly apparent how much we as an industry needs to change to adapt to the customer expectations of tomorrow.
The Takeaway: Innovate your business to forecast the needs of tomorrow's customer today, and start by asking why.
Elise Kephart (@TheYoutubediva) - "Pick up the F-cking Phone"
While the majority of Elise's breakout was a glimpse into her utter brilliance as a self-promoter, one of the most pertinent points of the entire summit was her opening slide, "Pick up the F-cking Phone".
As much as I loathe the phrase, "Back to basics" I can't argue with Elise's opening. Especially at a tech-heavy summit filled with the latest and greatest technological advancements, it is easy to forget what works.
Yes, you can geo-target customers, hi-jack their email inbox and send personalized video messages, and track their every movement prior to and upon arriving at your dealership; however none of today's digital trickery works without having a conversation with a customer. Something best accomplished by simply: picking up the phone.
So, amongst all the fancy new software, processes and ideologies don't forget the most basic tool in the automotive business: the phone.
The Takeaway: "Pick up the F-cking Phone, then focus on your digital wizardry"
Adam Justis - "Last Millisecond Marketing"
Adam easily had the best looking presentation. Being from Adobe you would expect that :P
Joking aside, his presentation outlined how the marketing world in the last two years has changed more than in the last 50. When you put that into the dealer's advertising perspective, traditional forms of advertising are so far out of the spectrum it's no longer funny. It's just sad.
The days of slapping together an advertisement minutes before deadline are gone. Long gone. Really long gone. To compete in today's marketing landscape takes some serious planning. Not just for what sales event you are going to run next week, or next month, but recording data and using it to plot where the customer will be next and drive content at the exact moment. The concept is last millisecond marketing, where literally in that last moment the advertising message can change based on the behavior of the user.
Now, this is some pretty heavy stuff for most, and that's okay. What is most important is the planning. If you aren't in the habit of seriously planning your advertising strategy, the follow of your website and what triggers which advertising; you need to start now.
The Takeaway: Advertising = Planning. Lots of planning.
Paul Wagner (CloudEngage) - "There is no reason to deploy an app. Period."
I've never been a fan of dealership APS. Not just because between 2011-2013 I was be pitched 5-10 times a week, but because I knew from the start they were a cash grab from unscrupulous vendors hoping to make a quick buck off an unsuspecting dealer.
The only aspect I saw promise in, was push notifications. That you could target your customer based, based on demographics and most importantly location. How fantastic would it be if you could notify a customer who is due for an oil & filter service when they are 2 miles from your dealership?
Somewhere along the way, aps and location based push notifications floated off my radar. It wasn't until I was sitting in front of Paul that I realized I've been missing out.
Push notifications are now available through a mobile web browser. Modern HTML5 mobile websites in conjunction with the latest iOS and Android Operating Systems now have the ability to push notifications to a user's smart phone. No ap required.
Not only that, but the idea of having your website morph based on location literally made my jaw drop. (Ask Paul, I was sitting right in front of him).
I'm going to throw it out there now, but this will be THE hot topic of 2015; mobile location based websites.
The Takeaway: "Stay ahead of the curve. Start planning now on how you can implement this technology ASAP"
Bryan Eisenberg (@TheGrok) - "Segments, sub-segments & self selection"
I will happily admit to being biased in favour of Bryan, as I have completed the DrivingSales University Conversion Optimization Certification that largely focuses on his teachings, in addition to having read countless of his books and blog articles. With that said, I believe the very best thing you can do with your dealership right now is to start picking up what Bryan is laying down.
Although his keynote didn't even begin to do justice to the information available in his books or the DSU course, it did touch on one of the most important aspects of his teachings: Customer Persona's.
All customers are not the same. One customer may be more emotionally driven, another more competitive. Each customer will require different items and touch points on their car buying journey. Why then, do we only have one way to flow through our websites? If each customer naturally follows a different path, why do we force them down the same funnel?
Bryan's concept is simple, but does take some planning. Determine all the different persona's that match your customers, and plot our how they will journey from search to website to sale. Each persona will have a different path. Take this information, and then modify your website / process to reflect the natural paths they want to take. Providing customers the process they want, will ultimately lead to a higher conversion ratio.
Let me explain it a different way. You are the parent of 4 children, two boys, two girls, all different ages and you want them all to clean their rooms. Which is a better strategy:
- Tell them all to clean their rooms, or else.
- Have a different strategy for each child based on their personalities.
Option "a", may work in the short term, but if your goal is to have them keep their rooms clean in the long term you know that each child will require a different strategy. One child may require a reward system, another may require "buy-in" on why a clean room is important, another may want to keep a room clean on their own.
Each persona will react differently to your sales process, so to maximize conversions your process should be able to adapt accordingly. It's a big overall task, but it's imperative to start thinking more about the differences between your customers.
The Takeaway: Your customers are different, don't paint them all with the same brush.
Mike Hudson (@verified_hudson) - "Auto shoppers are spending more time on pc than mobile, because are forced to."
Mike's data wasn't surprising, but it did offer hope for those willing to put into the effort. The mobile car buying experience is not ideal, so much so that customers are being forced to do their shopping on a PC.
The data shows that the shoppers want to interact with us on mobile, we just don't have the infrastructure to allow them to do this. What this means to you is, if your store has a truly fantastic mobile experience you will be head and shoulders above your competition.
This ties into the entire concept of customer experience. The car buying journey begins on your website, and if that experience is negative it sets the tone for the entire process.
The Takeaway: The better the mobile experience, the better the customer's ENTIRE experience will be.
What did I miss? Do you agree/disagree with any of my points? What were your biggest takeaways? Share your thoughts in the comments below:
5 Comments
Faulkner Nissan
Great takeaways! And for those of you who didn't go to DSES, this blog post screams "YOU SHOULD GO" doesn't it?
Netsertive
Excellent takeaways, thanks for sharing! I hope all dealers take a moment to think about new ways to attract cross-shoppers with conquest remarketing. I shared case studies at DSES. It's a new, cost-effective tactic most dealers aren't using - and it's boosting CTRs and cutting conversion costs in half. Grab my deck - "Success Stories in Search Remarketing & Advanced Mobile Search for Progressive Dealers" - from the master list here: http://drivingsalesexecutivesummit.com/presentations/ See you all next year! Tim McLain, Netsertive @tmclain
Remarkable Marketing
Robert, maybe you should take Kephart's takeaway for when I call you!! :P On a serious note, well said and some great info here. I've said it once and I'll say it a million more times... DSES 2014 was the year to remember. The DS team took the summit to an entire new level. These takeaways are a great example as to why it was so great!
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Haha Grant. I only accept personalized videos. No phone calls. :P
Kijiji, an eBay Company
30+ Video Ideas You Can Record in your Dealership Right Now
Content is king, and there is nothing more regal than video content. Problem is, great video content takes time and resources. After all, we are not ad agencies; we are dealers and sometimes it is difficult to see past the month's sales target. So, to make creating great video content a little easier I put together a list of ideas for video content that you can use today. So grab your phones and your cameras and get going!
New Vehicle Features
It seems that every new model off the line has a plethora of new features that never existed before. For example, the 2015 Lexus NX that launches this fall in North America comes with:
- Wireless Charging Tray
- Full Color Heads-Up Display
- New Remote Touch Interface with Touchpad
- G Meter and Turbo Boost Gauge
- Active Sound Control
These features are brand new, and it’s guaranteed that customers who purchase the all-new 2015 Lexus NX will be searching for how to operate these features. No matter what the manufacturer, there is always a new stream of tech updates that you can create walk-around and how-to videos about. [Tweet This]
Child Seats
Often a new bundle of joy requires a new vehicle, and most new parents have never installed a car seat. Creating a video on how to safely install and remove a car seat in each of your available models will be a great resource to your customers.
Emergency Service Questions
If the average person is in an emergency situation such as getting a flat tire or an overheated engine, the first place they will look for information is on their mobile device. Creating a video series surrounding roadside emergencies can provide much-needed assistance to customers when they need it the most. With the proper branding, you can encourage customers to come to you even when they aren’t stuck on the side of the road. Here are some examples:
- How to change a flat tire?
- How to boost a vehicle with a dead battery?
- What does smoke under the hood mean?
- My car won’t start, what do I do?
- What does a warning light on the dash mean?
Second Opinion Service Questions
When a customer walks away from a service advisor, likely they will look for a second opinion before agreeing to the work. Then, when they refuse critical work and something goes wrong, we aren’t allowed to say, “I told you so.” Creating a suite of videos to alleviate their suspicions and bolster confidence in your services can increase your average customer pay. Here are some examples:
- Why do I need an alignment service?
- Is a new air filter a waste of money?
- Why do I need to change my oil so often?
- Do I need to rotate my tires?
- Can I use all-season tires in the winter?
PDI / Admin
Most dealerships charge some form of administration or pre-delivery Inspection fees, and most customers either do not know what they are for, or believe they are scams. Creating a video series of what these services include can easily overcome their objections during the negotiation process.
Rewards Programs
Many dealership rewards programs are undervalued simply because they are not marketed correctly. Often there are too many benefits that are all crammed into a tiny pamphlet, and customers get lost attempting to read it. Why not create a video series on all the benefits of your rewards program, so you can adequately represent its value? If you partner with local businesses, this is also a great way to cross-promote your marketing efforts. A terrific example of this concept is MGM Resorts International’s M life TV showcasing their M life rewards program. M life TV includes countless videos both available online and in-room that reveal all that the M life Rewards Program has to offer. I have found myself watching the channel for hours in my hotel room learning about things to see and do in Las Vegas.
Tires
One of the biggest retention tools in our business is tires, but tires are also one of the hardest items to sell. A lot of this is a result of customer misinformation about how important tires really are. Creating a video series that details the importance of tires can increase your tire sales and your long-term customer retention. [Tweet This] Here are some examples:
- Do I need winter tires?
- What is the difference between Winter and Summer Tires?
- What are performance tires?
- Can I buy used tires?
- Should I store my tires at the dealership?
Certified Pre-Owned Programs
Telling a customer that you offer a 151/201/259 point inspection is good, but showing them a video of all the inspection points is phenomenal. Imagine the value you can build in your certified program with a video series showing how much thought and care is put into every certified pre-owned vehicle on your lot. It’s a lofty goal, but once completed, you can use it for years to come.
Vehicle Walk-Around’s
This is not a new concept, but few dealers see the value in these videos. If you make a point of creating a 15-20 minute walk-around video for each model every year, you will have soon have an entire library of fantastic content. What is even more valuable is that years later, you can use ALL of these videos to showcase your pre-owned inventory. If you are part of an automotive group with multiple manufacturers, you can share this pre-owned vehicle content across all of your divisions. Many birds with one stone.
Salesperson Profiles
People buy from people they like, know and trust. What better way to expedite the process by having a video series that showcases all your salespeople and why a customer should buy from them. Including personal details about their likes, interests, and passions makes them more approachable, and more trustworthy. These videos are great for a website, but even better for customer follow-up. Suddenly a customer isn’t being contacted by a salesperson, they are being contacted by Jerry who likes long walks on the beach, small animals and volunteers at a homeless shelter on weekends.
Get Creative
Overall you need your video content to stand out. If it doesn’t turn heads, it won’t translate into views. There are some rock stars already doing this; Elise Kephart is a fantastic example of keeping things fresh, fun and informative. Even Justin Timberlake says so:
What ideas have I missed? What has worked well for you? Share your ideas in the comments!
Robert Karbaum arguably has the best name in the automotive industry. His combined experience over the past decade in E-Commerce and the automotive industry has allowed him to master the art of “AutoSpeak”; the ancient language that bridges the gap between internet geeks, the showroom floor and everything in-between. He manages the E-Commerce, Social and Digital Marketing operations at Weins Canada Inc. (formerly Don Valley North Automotive Group); a prestigious automotive group in Canada which includes the #1 volume Toyota and Lexus dealerships in the country.
Catch him on Twitter (@karbaum) or DroppinBaums.com.
44 Comments
M10 Marketing Firm
Great article Robert. Video is such a powerful tool these days.
PCG Digital
Great article Robert! You can add customer testimonial videos and dealership tours to the list. Video walkrarounds and customer testimonials worked well for me back when I was still in the dealership.
John K Sinclair Consulting
Some great ideas for providing valuable information to customers and creating engagement. Additional ideas for consideration: Video on the owners/history of the business especially if it has a long heritage. Video on available accessories and how to use these. Video on promotional items/clothing especially if you are marketing a prestigious brand. Video on warranty explanation. Video on how to drive in different conditions - 4by4 driving, driving in snow, driving on soft sand. Video on explanation of consumer rights - depending on country you are living
M10 Marketing Firm
I would also add that while the content and quality of the video is important, it is equally important how you use the video. Are your videos just meant to be parked on Youtube to help with SEO and hope that someone finds them and acts on them? Or are you using specific targeted videos with more purpose? For example, I was speaking with a salesperson last night at a dealership that I am working with and he shared how our videos helped him save a CSI survey from disaster. He not only has a great video with good content, but he is using it the right way to make sure they it is very effective. So I recommend making sure that you have a way to really put your videos to use in addition to making great content.
M10 Marketing Firm
The example I mentioned was a thank you video where the salesperson thanks the customer for their purchase, tells them how great it was to work with them, asks them for referrals, and reminds them that if they have any questions or concerns to contact the salesperson before they take their survey. This video is automatically sent out via email to each and every customer that buys from that salesperson, so that it doesn't come down to if the salesperson remembers to send it, or how busy they get, take time off etc... It goes out every time. In this case the customer called the sales person and said "we got your video and it said to call you before we take the survey if we have an issue, well we have an issue." The customer came in and they resolved the issue and the customer then felt fine giving a good survey. The same thing could have been said in a follow up email with no video or in the follow up phone call, however the video is much more powerful and engaging, and isn't dependent on a salesperson actually making the follow up call and getting through to the customer. So walk around videos, feature highlights, tire videos and all the ones that you suggested above are fantastic! They are great for helping drive traffic to your site and creating value for your customers, and helping you to stand out from the crowd, but in addition to that having strategic targeted videos for specific purposes and a way to get those videos to the right people at the right time can also be very beneficial. Creating efficiency and consistency is a great way to make a huge impact with video marketing. This is a results business not a popularity contest, and at the end of the day what really matters is how many cars are sold and how much gross is made. The video strategy should be geared towards those results. I love all the suggestions above, they are awesome! I have had a lot of success with the salesperson intro videos, follow up videos, and thank you videos, of course when they are done the right way and with the right scripting. Most of this success has comes from having good videos and a consistent and efficient way of delivering those videos onto the screens of your customers. I am also creating videos for service departments that will include service advisor intros, declined service reminders, BDC/appointment reminders, etc... as well as some key videos for the F&I department.
Automotive Group
Here is one of the videos I just finished editing. for my Buick GMC dealership https://heroautogroup.wistia.com/medias/127a15a0rz
CBG Buick GMC, Inc.
Awesome Video Chris. It looked great and was short and to the point. No extra jabber about how great they are and you wont find better prices..etc!
MyKo Media
Robert, great ideas! And super additional comments. One other comment if a dealership needs to get started they don't have to wait for an agency to come film videos. With the right mic, it can be done with an iPhone very successfully. And the younger buyers will relate to a "professionally homegrown" video probably more that the slick stuff we're used to from dealerships. And Robert, with your permission and proper credit, I'd like to use some ideas from this in a presentation I have coming up this week. Let me know. - Rich
HomeNet Automotive
Great Article! Where would you recommend that dealerships should share this information as most beneficial? Their Youtube page, website, social media or all?
PCG Digital
Stephanie, I would recommend all 3. YouTube gives you the SEO power to reach all kinds of people, but the shoppers on your website and social channels need to see the videos as well. Make sure your vehicle walkarounds are on your VDP's. Create pages on your site for your customer testimonial sand how to videos, etc. Post the videos on your social channels to engage your fans. Tag people in the videos so their friends see the video in their feeds.
Auction Direct
We all know that the trade in appraisal process is generally not a positive experience for customers. Using a video appraisal, in which the customer gives a short description of their vehicle, its history, and why they loved it can help to put more of a feeling of control in the hands of the customer. Not only that, it can double as great content for sharing the used car stories of those trades you do keep and remarket as used vehicles! Just don't forget to get the customer to sign a waiver so you can use the video...
Automotive Group
Thanks Lauren, Thats what I was going for. =) I mounted an old flip cam on a mini tri pod I picked up at walgreens. The Mic is the biggest difference I think. I picked up the Rode Lav Mic from Amazon. http://www.amazon.com/Rode-Smartlav-Lavalier-Microphone-Smartphones/dp/B00BHN05H2 Used my iphone to record the audio and matched it to the video. iMovie for the editing.
Automotive Group
Robert just saw your comment too. Thank you very much =-) I should be done with some more here very soon.
CBG Buick GMC, Inc.
I have one of the Flip cams and have thought about bringing it up here to do little videos like that but every time I even MENTION videos everyone freaks out.
Automotive Group
Matt is the only good sport I have really. My other GSM's and such aren't super excited about it. So I am going to be doing a lot of our video myself... Hopefully I don't have a face for radio. lol. You should consider leading the charge too.
MyKo Media
I agree with Chris, the Rode Smart Lav is a great little mic for this kind of video. I've also used the Audio Technica ATR 3350 http://amzn.to/1CKB0Ac with Flip camera, and all types of smart phones. If budget is a consideration this is the way to go.
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Hey Rich, Please, go right ahead and use it. You are right, any modern smart phone is all you need to get started. Better recording equipment, and editing software can some if necessary, but don't let it stand in your way.
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Great idea Cathy! I have long wanted to do this, but have never gotten around to making it happen. I would love to see a store fully implement a trade-in testimonial process.
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Lauren, Something you have to show, instead of ask. Use what you have to create the concept, and then show how powerful it can be.
Remarkable Marketing
Nice! Thanks Robert. You put a ton of time and energy into this. Very valuable for everyone.. I personally love DIY videos. Huge hit on YouTube and also builds value with your audience. In turn generating trust. Something all of our dealerships could use more of :)
Waikem Auto Family
Can we all agree Robert needs to post atleast 1 article a week?
Mercedes-Benz & Infiniti of Birmingham
Great article! Always looking for new/different ideas for video content.
AutoStride
I know it's not the most professional job, using an automated robotic voice, but I take client blogs and showroom data from Chrome and turn them into videos @ https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCuhkjOb9REE-TqphJ4f2eOg/videos, using http://articlevideorobot.com. It's a load of work, but you should see the keyword dominance results and the amount of conversions that are measured through going after geo / localized long tail content. The telephone and backlink alone, make it well worth the cost. Obviously, we do pro-quality video commercial production, etc., but this is supports VSEO as well. I should mention Article Video Robot allows you to push your videos to the most popular video, bookmarking and social sites, with one click of a button. Can you say YouTube, Vimeo, Dailymotion, etc., in one click of a button?
Kijiji, an eBay Company
It's definitely interesting, and I am digging the British accent, but it's still a bit jarring for my taste.
AutoStride
It is indeed, I haven't upgraded to the better robot voice, I am testing it out and will upgrade very shortly. It's so much more professional and seamless. You can barely tell. Again, I don't care that much, it's driving results from a VSEO standpoint.
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Reminds me of my new favourite video: How to Care for Your Cermet - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y1QOAd6o0C0
AutoStride
Robert, stuff like this: https://www.google.com/search?q=bethlehem+nissan+leaf https://www.google.com/search?q=harrisburg+nissan+gtr It works and is more noticeable.
M10 Marketing Firm
Heres one that is one of many specific targeted videos that when used the right way can be very effective. http://youtu.be/ViZ2g-70-Xs
Blue Mountain Chrysler
Love this article Robert, working on some vid content at the moment I'll link you when we're done.
Rosenthal Automotive Organization
One of my coworkers forwarded your article to me. It is good to see so many people ready to embrace video in their sales efforts. We've be utilizing YouTube car review videos for over four years now to brand our organization and promote our products. We're just approaching 70,000 subscribers and have well over 15 million views so far. I believe video really works when it is properly applied. If you get a chance please check out our channel and let me know what you think. Thanks...:) Steve http://www.youtube.com/user/RosenthalAutomotive
Zimbrick Hyundai Eastside
I would love some creative feedback on this short video that I shot recently. Thank you ahead of time. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dkLdYGJBtnc&list=UUQJdnBWP01YMlkA7AwcODSg
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Hey John! Thanks for sharing! Video quality is great. Audio quality is great. Love that you are doing these videos, it's great initiative. Also think the pop-up links with the dealership website and phone number are a really professional touch. Just a quick piece of feedback I hope are helpful. After all, we are all here to help each other right? You need to be more physically expressive. If you watch carefully, you are as still as a statue through the whole video. Your hands don't move, your eyes don't move, and you can barely see your mouth move because of your awesome beard. Literally awesome. I'm a huge fan. Partially because I have an inability to grow a beard, so I like beards more than most. Anyways, you need to express yourself more, so you look less robotic. Use your hands when you talk. Move around a little bit. Be yourself, and less "deer in the headlights" What I suggest, is to have a family member (especially kids) help you do the video. When your family is present, you tend to be more natural on camera. It feels more like a home video. Then, when your customers are watching, they also pick up on the comfortable family vibe, which can lead to more trust in you as a salesperson. The more open, honest, and comfortable you can be on camera, the more guests will be able to build rapport with you over YouTube. You got everything else down, the script is great, the quality is great, you just need to loosen up a bit and show your true personality!
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Most importantly, KEEP MAKING VIDEOS!! When you are ready, make sure you share your video with every potential customer you come across!
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Should We Abandon Social Media?
Imagine social media was a new radio station that opened down the road. You decide it’s a good idea to support the community and spend some advertising dollars with them. Unfortunately, 3 months later you look at the numbers and sales are still flat. You call the station, give the rep hell, and they convince you to try again for 3 more months. Alas, another 3 months later the needle still hasn't moved. The rep begs on their knees for another shot. You comply, change the message, change the timing, maybe even increase your spend and the needle again fails to move. Do you continue with this advertising spend? My guess would be no. So why are we doing it with social?
As dealers, we are spending a considerable amount of time trying to make social work, with little results.
Maybe, we shouldn't be on social? It is a hard question to ask, but an honest one.
Few independent franchises who operate as part of a manufacture chain have their own social media profiles. The McDonald's down the road doesn't have its own Facebook page. It isn't allowed, nor does it make sense to compete against the other 35,000 McDonald's locations worldwide. Pep Boys operates as a single controlled social entity and so does Midas. CarMax has 128 locations across the United States and 1 Facebook page.
“A new report by Auto Trader found that only one percent of car buyers used social media sites to shop for a vehicle. “ i [Tweet This]The Chicago Tribune ran an article last week with results from a study by Automotive News bluntly stating that social media doesn’t sell cars, that even Millennials are apathetic towards the automotive industry’s efforts on social media. Yikes!
“I bought a car because of a tweet was said by no one ever.” iAre you really surprised? As someone that has closely worked with social media in the dealership for the past 7 years I can say that I don’t disagree. In fact the more I research, the more it becomes apparent that the dots are not connecting.
“Millennials are apathetic about whether auto Web sites or brands have a social presence,” Helms said. She added that 78 percent of Millennials in the study said their attitude toward a car brand would not change if the brand had a social networking presence.” iiSo why are we, especially the franchise dealers, trying to dig ourselves out of this social cavity? Is it time to pack up your Facebook page and go home? Not quite yet. Maybe the reason no one uses social in the car buying process is because we as an industry have not provided the right content. Maybe customers don’t care about our storytelling, delivery photos and testimonials we have been sharing on social? [Tweet This]
Or maybe, we are simply using social media incorrectly?
i Chicago Tribune: Auto Sales Not Influenced by Social Media: http://www.chicagotribune.com/classified/automotive/chi-auto-sales-not-influenced-by-social-media-survey-20140813-story.html
ii Automotive News: Even Millennials Bypass Social Media During the Buying Process: http://www.autonews.com/article/20140812/RETAIL/140819982/even-millennials-bypass-social-media-during-car-buying-journey?cciid=email-autonews-daily&r=8554G4925134G2S
What are your thoughts? Are the stats correct? Are you going to do things differently? Share your comments below!
Robert Karbaum arguably has the best name in the automotive industry. His combined experience over the past decade in E-Commerce and the automotive industry has allowed him to master the art of “AutoSpeak”; the ancient language that bridges the gap between internet geeks, the showroom floor and everything in-between. He manages the E-Commerce, Social and Digital Marketing operations at Weins Canada Inc. (formerly Don Valley North Automotive Group); a prestigious automotive group in Canada which includes the #1 volume Toyota and Lexus dealerships in the country.
Catch him on Twitter (@karbaum) or DroppinBaums.com.
67 Comments
CBG Buick GMC, Inc.
Robert, Great read! Favorite quote "I Bought a car because of a tweet was said by no one ever." It's so true. When we did our sales event last month I was on the floor asking all of them that I could where they had heard about us. Most of them sadly had never heard of us before our mail outs. And they were a short 30 minutes away. It says something for todays world that even with the internet they don't know where we are. I think it's time to break the mold of internet and social media to show that it is still very valuable you just need to find the diamond in the rough that your customers want to see!
M10 Marketing Firm
Nice article Robert and a good and fair question. I for one don't think that I would follow any car dealerships Facebook page, because for the most part, I am only thinking about a car dealership once every couple of years when I am actually in the market. The rest of the time my car sits in the garage until I use it to get me from point A to point B, and thats pretty much it, and I don't really care if my social feed has articles about cars etc... because they are not top of mind. There are a few examples however of how social can be beneficial to the car industry, but it may not be the way most dealers are doing it. The first example comes from a couple of friends of mine who are no longer at the dealership but have since moved on and started their own accessory company. When they started they had a third party Facebook page that filled the social world with really cool pictures of really big lifted trucks and dead animals (and the occasional attractive woman). They were marketing specifically to the hunting industry, and they generated a lot of interest and quite a few leads that led to some very good car deals and a great following. They created a loyal following within the hunting community that drew in leads from several states and again led them from being sales people at a dealership to now having their own accessory company and selling the leads to the dealers that they work with. The lesson here is that if you narrow down your social activities to a specific target and post things that that group cares about (which in this case is big lifted trucks, slaughtered game, and a hottie or two), then you can create a loyal following that will decide they want to be as cool as the people you are posting, and in this example, that actually does result in deals. The other way that I think social can help is not on the dealership level, but on the actual sales person level. And I don't mean your desperate status update on the last day of the month saying you "just need three more cars so please friends come in and see me!". But what I mean is developing relationships with your customers and maintaining an overall awareness within your sphere of influence and your friends sphere of influence so that when the time is right and people are in the market to get a new car you are the one they think of. This requires a different strategy than what most dealers are currently doing for social and actually requires a disciplined, and determined sales person who wants to build a long term pipeline.
CBG Buick GMC, Inc.
Dustin, love the lifted truck and slaughtered game, and even the occasional hottie (so long as it's not me..joking). It does help narrow down who your customer base is. That is something that we can really market on here since we are prime country boy territory. For us it's the rig workers that come home from a two week haul and have money burning their pockets. It's just a matter of getting them attracted to our page. One thing that I see a lot of from a few dealers close to us is the constant posts of "funny" meme pictures. Most of the time the Memes include some thing along the lines of "you mean to tell me you didn't go see (insert salesmans name here) at (dealership name)! That's why you still drive the hooptie!" To me that drives the wrong kind of attention and to me is almost offensive since it's saying the customer has a crappy car. It's definitely time for dealerships to start thinking outside the box and push to find what works best for them. I don't think it's so much about posting all of your inventory and getting someone to buy straight from social anymore. And even just being the voice of knowledge for your customers obviously isn't cutting it since how many likes, post clicks, and shares do you get from sharing links to helpful pages about touch screen radio, onstar, xm radio and such.
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Thanks for the comments! I'm preparing an article for the fall that will go into great detail about what social really is, and how we as dealers should approach it. When I saw the Trader study this week, I knew I had to post a blog about it. I think we have been collectively drinking the social kool-aid for too long. It's time to be honest with ourselves and ask: is social really worth the investment of our time.
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Dustin, the analogy I use is, "Would you follow your Mortgage Broker on Facebook?"
Waikem Auto Family
Facebook sells cars, plenty, with utilization at the dealer personnel level, not dealership level. So yes, I would follow my mortgage broker if he was a true friend, but I wouldn't follow the "banks". For example I'm friends with my insurance agent but not "Progressive." Our sales staff should be using social media to sell, not the dealer overpaying vendors and staff (however, we have had great success recently in dark post facebook advertising). Most dealers are wasting their time and money on social media. Looking forward to your follow up article Robert.
CBG Buick GMC, Inc.
Craig, Definitely agree that the sales staff and even service staff being on facebook can be very rewarding for the dealership. You wouldn't want to go some place that your friend works and that they hate working there (or atleast I wouldn't). If a place can't treat their employees right why should they treat their customers right. But I don't think that the dealership pages are doing near as much as we are lead to believe in this industry.
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Shhh. Craig. Don't tell anyone about the dark posts. We don't want them to get too popular :P
M10 Marketing Firm
Craig, that is exactly right! It is much better used by te individual salespeople rather than the dealership as a whole. Social can be a great tool for relationship an value building and can certainly drive a lot of repeat and referral business when done correctly.
CBG Buick GMC, Inc.
ok time out for the newbie here. What's a dark post? No fair mentioning if your not gunna spill the beans!
CarNet
Hello, I provide sales strategy and marketing services for a group of three public auction/used car sale outlets in Australia. Our selling model sets us apart from others in that we are neither pure auction, nor pure retail, but a "bid or buy" option. It is this point of difference that we find to be effectively supported by using social media as a part of our wholly digital marking strategy. Over a 12 month period we have attracted just under 55,000 FB followers (not Kardashian numbers, I know - but respectable for a 3 outlet gig). We reinforce that all vehicles are under cover and that buyers (both trade and public) can either attend weekly public auctions or pay a premium to cherry pick selected items. We promote just a few price-leaders cars every Friday as an 'Album' supported by an 'event' notice. Each of the locations has their own very basic local page, where the post their delivery shots, auction event and weekend sale reminders from which we share selected posts. We also support related a car buying service page (under a different brand). We use 'post promotions' and probably spend around $1200 per week on that. My point here is that we focus on some granular points of difference. In that context it works as a part of the mix, along with auto portals and an increasing amount of Google Adwords but again in a very defined and granular manner (specific cars), certainly NEVER, 'best deals on used cars' twaddle. In my view it works - if your work IT. Happy trails.
CarNet
http://www.smartinsights.com/social-media-marketing/facebook-marketing/create-dark-post-facebook/
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Mark, can you share any of the Facebook accounts in question? I would like to dive a little deeper on them.
Robert Wiesman Dot Com
I can't see how a platform where hundreds of millions of eye balls are logging into daily shouldn't be utilized by not only car dealerships but any small or large business today. Facebooks ad platform the power editor in paticular is a massively powerful tool. Especially with access to the Polk data inside. At the very least Facebook is a amazing communication tool that can build relationships.
Black Wolf Automotive Merchandising
Like so many businesses, auto dealers are doing social media all wrong by focusing on themselves. Most dealers have an endless stream of inventory posts and 'special deals' -- but people don't get on Facebook to be sold. We're having great success with our clients with our 10-4-1 ratio -- 10 fun/viral/entertaining posts, 4 informational posts, and 1 sales post, plus using paid advertising to drive page likes and post inventory. It works if you know how to work it.
CarNet
Hello Robert, The primary FB account is www.facebook.com/CarNetcars In relation to Sherm's post, I pretty much agree, although I don't find that people are adverse to receiving promotional offers. Like I mentioned across three locations we carry around 500 vehicles, some weeks all locations list a few, this week just 1 site listed 6. They are indicative and we do not carpet bomb, just once per week on Fridays. Users are aware that can "unlike" whenever they choose. We loose a handful each week, but have averaged better than 1,000 new followers per month. However, in terms of grunt per dollar for driving inquiry Google Adwords works well as do the toll-free numbers we associate with every individual marketing channel. In that regard we find that overall phone enquiries are of better average quality. After-all, the potential purchaser who calls is generally seeking discussion with a sales consultant.
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Sherm, The study focuses on the entire industry, not just the dealers but the manufacturers as well. The point is, that our efforts as an industry on social media are not working. They are not influencing shoppers, and therefore isn't pushing any metal over the curb. I would argue that we spent tooo much time striving for the fun/viral/entertaining content and forgot that we need to move metal. No matter how much engagement you receive on your profiles (which is dismal at best for most), the bottom line is: what is your return on your invested resources?
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Mark, I think your "likes" are working to your detriment. If you want to calculate your Engagement Rate : Total Engagement (Likes + Comments + Shares) / Total Fans - more details: http://simplymeasured.com/blog/2013/08/14/facebook-metrics-defined-engagement-rate/ I looked at the page you mentioned over the last month, and your Engagement Rate is 0.000334107. Depending on who you speak to, the National average is 1.75. Now, I'm not trying to get personal. The rate on my social sites is equally as bad. In fact if you look at 99% of dealers they are in the same boat. My point is, as the AutoTrader study suggests, what we as an industry are doing on social simply is not influencing buyers.
CarNet
Hi Robert,On the pure 'engagement' scale, I agree entirely but perhaps the 'parameters for success' of social media apply too much weight to comments + shares, as opposed to brand awareness and action (both are definitions of engagement and I favour the second). It has often been stated that there are several touch points on the proverbial "road to the sale" I believe we can separate the 'Social' and the 'Media' components a little more, with less focus on the importance of the 'Social' in the purchasing cycle.I know that the "Followers / Likers" see our brand each week. Is it a given that they must share or comment to demonstrate the effectiveness of the campaign i.e. influencing buyers?If we go back to the halcyon print classifieds days, does a potential buyer spend a Saturday morning circling a few cars of interest in red crayon and then call his social network to 'share' the news of his vehicle interests? Not likely. I am not that sure that the propensity to comment or share acts as an indicator of whether the audience has taken on an increased brand awareness or an increased propensity to purchase from that brand (albeit over time).If the 'followers' are sticking around, at some point in time, many enter a vehicle buying cycle and at that point, they will have a pretty solid awareness of our brand and what we offer as a point of difference. The point of difference is (in my view) a major component of the secret sauce. In summary, I still see social media as a valid component of modern marketing, we need to place less less importance on a comment or share.An example: If I create a post - dark or otherwise :) and promote, I'll get more exposure in timelines by selecting followers and their friends than the population of my home state. I think that is pretty effective. It is up to me to provide the "quirk" or "hook" to engender enough interest that they also become a follower of our point of difference.
Black Wolf Automotive Merchandising
Lauren, a dark post is a post created only to run as a timeline ad. In other words, it will never appear in the organic posts of the page.
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Mark, Unfortunately if your engagement levels on Facebook are low, a low number of people will see your content. On average, only 3% of your "followers" see your organic content. So out of your 51,000 "likes" roughly 1500 will see your content. However if your engagement is below average, that number drops. So branding in the traditional sense doesn't apply. In a nutshell, the more engagement your content receives, the further Facebook expands your reach. If you get low engagement, that reach retracts. It's like Jeopardy. If you get the question wrong, you lose points. If your content gets low engagement, you lose reach. Now "Dark Posts", and Facebook advertising in general is a whole other ballgame. The AutoTrader report doesn't take that into affect, as very, VERY few companies (manufacturer or otherwise) advertise on Facebook. When I suggest "abandon", I am refering to the way we have been doing things for the past 5 years. Relying on this magical "social", posting, likes, etc, etc. Moving forward, social should be seen as an advertising platform. No different than PPC advertising,
Kijiji, an eBay Company
If you look at your Facebook Insights, you can see how many people were exposed to your content.
CBG Buick GMC, Inc.
I still have to agree with Robert. I see all of the dealerships around us doing the same thing (myself included). Blasting inventory, sales events, a few shared links from the manufacturers. There is nothing that really sets any of us apart. I do have to agree too that just because someone doesn't comment or share a post doesn't mean that they haven't seen it and it's not influencing their purchase. But I do know that the more engagement you have the farther out people see your posts and the more frequently
Dealer e Process
From Twitter: Laura Smith @SeriouslyLauraK 19h In the past two days I got at least 10 compliments on my car. Love my little Luigi. #fiat500 #ilovemycar From Tumblr: Subaru and snow! My cars first real snow day since I got her. #Subaru#Subaruoobz#Lucii#2004#I love my car From Facebook with picture of young lady sitting on the hood of her new Camaro: Deanna Nootenboom July 18 Love my car(: Don't tell me posts like these don't influence future auto sales. Somehow "word or mouth" has influenced auto sales in every automotive retail study over the past 50 years, but social media does not. Really? Social media will continue to influence car sales even if car dealers and manufacturers walk away and do nothing. Obviously, none of this came from car dealers. It came from the people car dealers matched with the right bundle of features and benefits to enhance their quality of life. That's what real car salespeople do. Along with, "Want me to take a picture of you with your new car so you can post it online?" and "I love helping people find the right car and financing. Mind if I can connect with you online so I can share that with my friends and family?" I doubt anyone will actively visit a social media site and search for these posts in an effort to be influenced in their auto shopping process. That’s just silly and was never the point of social media. Is a great deal of what dealers do with social media just as ridiculous as the latest negative vendor study about social media? Of course, but let's not throw the baby out with the bath water. I like Robert’s approach. Let’s take a fresh look at our activities and investments related to social media. Are we providing a boost to word-of-mouth advertising, or just trying to be the mouth?
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Dennis, Great insight as always! There has been a lot of talk on this study, both for and against. My main takeaway is to use it as a reason to start looking deeper into our strategies, and asking some hard questions about what we as an industry are doing with social.
Greenway
I believe you all are doing it completely wrong! https://www.facebook.com/business/success/castle-auto-group https://www.facebook.com/business/success/toyota https://www.facebook.com/business/industries/automotive Ever try using your manufactures buyers profiles to directly target your buyers and potential buyers? IT WORKS! Thanks POLK DATA.
CBG Buick GMC, Inc.
Robert P. Thanks for the great links. I love how it breaks them down and really tells of how they made it work. Here's one from my neck of the woods. This family is actually born and raised in my home town. https://www.facebook.com/business/success/stine-home-yard So any ideas yet as to how to shake up the facebook world and make our social more "Social"?
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Advertising on Facebook (dark posts, boost, etc) is most certainly the way to go, and the Facebook data Robert P shared alludes to that. What the AutoTrader study was focusing on was the organic elements of social.
AutoStride
Hi Robert, yes, I was the one that posted it here first in a reply to some "boastful" social threads. You all have good comments, it's whatever you need it to be, but don't look at it as your savior, you're going to end up highly disappointed.
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Alex, What specifically are you referring to? The ads or the organic? Or both?
AutoStride
I think it greatly depends on a dealer's demographic and how they perceive social media. There is no panacea or elixir for increasing car sales through social media, regardless of what social media service companies tell you. It takes hard work and understanding (research and analysis) on what works and what doesn't. That could be said of organic and paid search, not only for social media, but for any platform. Obviously, being able to reach the right demographic via paid search (promoted posts and whatever Google+ is calling it) has a higher potential for conversion.
AutoStride
If you're talking about Twitter and hunting customers, http://www.needtagger.com is the best. Hunt your customers, don't expect them to come to you, with Tweets you assume are going to work and fail. http://i.imgur.com/hh2SM2Q.jpg
CBG Buick GMC, Inc.
Alex, I agree that it does depend a lot on demographics. How can someone compare a dealership in a town with 50,000+ to a town with less than 10,000? It makes absolutely no sense. Not only the sheer number of people but the type of people that you have in your location.
AutoStride
Exactamundo, Lauren. I don't find it worth the time for a small dealer, in the middle of nowhere, to do a full-scale social media attack. Actually, I've been honest and told potential customers a similar story. It's not always about the money, when I know the dealer will fail to convert, based upon such a small demographic option.
CBG Buick GMC, Inc.
Haha and you JUST described my dealership. Middle of BFE, with the main attraction being Walmart and Sonic.
AutoStride
Oi, I'm not very sure what to tell you. Tread lightly, test some things, don't go overboard. :-)
AutoStride
@LaurenMoses. I love DeRidder: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DeRidder,_Louisiana, but you don't have a lot of peeps, yo! ;-) Demographics As of the census of 2000, there were 9,808 people, 3,819 households, and 2,616 families residing in the city. The population density was 1,155.4 people per square mile (446.0/km²). There were 4,454 housing units at an average density of 524.7 per square mile (202.6/km²). The racial makeup of the city was 60.81% White, 34.73% African American, 0.57% Native American, 1.42% Asian, 0.03% Pacific Islander, 0.57% from other races, and 1.88% from two or more races. Hispanic or Latino of any race were 2.40% of the population. There were 3,819 households, out of which 33.3% had children under the age of 18 living with them, 48.6% were married couples living together, 16.9% had a female householder with no husband present, and 31.5% were non-families. 28.1% of all households were made up of individuals and 11.7% had someone living alone who was 65 years of age or older. The average household size was 2.48 and the average family size was 3.03. In the city of DeRidder, the population was spread out with 27.1% under the age of 18, 8.6% from 18 to 24, 27.3% from 25 to 44, 22.4% from 45 to 64, and 14.5% who were 65 years of age or older. The median age was 37 years. For every 100 females, there were 89.2 males. For every 100 females age 18 and over, there were 83.3 males. The median income for a household in the city was $31,952, and the median income for a family was $39,384. Males had a median income of $36,388 versus $21,302 for females. The per capita income for the city was $16,996. About 15.0% of families and 18.0% of the population were below the poverty line, including 22.1% of those under age 18 and 18.2% of those age 65 or over.
CBG Buick GMC, Inc.
Yep, Like I said Walmart and Sonic. Oh and Tractor Supply... We actually just broke 10,000 this year. And what I'm reading from this is that we have lots of younger families, or mothers. Which really doesn't surprise me. Though our Parish is ranked 1st in the State for graduation rating. So maybe there is still some hope.
CBG Buick GMC, Inc.
I am all ears...well and eyes I guess. I have honestly thought about sending out an email survey to our customers and for followers that we have emails for to see what they would like to see us posting about. Besides just "win a free car!"
AutoStride
Huge fan of these guys, they break things down for smaller demographics, as well, I think: http://www.smartinsights.com/social-media-marketing/social-media-strategy
CarNet
Last week (13th - 19th) This past weekend, in addition to our regular weekend specials, we shared a short American video clip post on the dangers of teens texting and driving (always topical and relevant). Some of you may have seen it already. It is quite a powerful and sobering piece. https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?v=10152359791929200&set=vb.44265444199&type=2&theater The outcome: 14.5k organic reach 1.4k clicks, 136 likes 5 comments
Toyota Canada Inc.
I believe that many people sign up for a social page once they are already customers. I do believe that Social plays a role in engaging them with the product or service throughout their ownership cycle and keeps the product or service top of mind / on their consideration list for their service and next purchase - a retention channel, if you will.
ChatterUP
Great post and very thought provoking! I think there are far too many people spending far too much time on Social Sites to abandon it altogether. It does make sense though to really take a look at your strategy and adjust. I see a couple problems in the social media space for Automotive dealerships related to two key social networks. 1. Content marketing on Facebook is not truly driving people to buy. Even if it is to a small extent, it is extremely hard to track at the dealership level. I would think it is becoming far more important to have content that can be created at the dealership level and spend whatever Social budget you have more for targeted ads. Placing targeted ads in front of people who are in the market for a vehicle will undoubtedly lead to website hits. Less focus on incredible content and more focus on getting your message to the right people at the right time. 2. Dealerships are trying to use Twitter to push great content. The problem here is that so often dealerships skip the engagement step. Even if you have great content, if you’re never interacting with anybody, your content will easily be ignored. Dealerships that have a mix of engagement and content will see more benefits from Twitter. I often see a dealership hoping their tweets happen to land on the stream of someone who is in the market for a vehicle. A better approach would be trying to connect directly to those people that are actually in the market. Connecting directly to consumers in your area that are in the market for a vehicle will allow a dealership see more tangible benefits from Social. Long story short, content marketing is expensive and very optimistic. The data is out there to connect directly with people in the market for a vehicle, it’s just up to the dealership to take a look at their approach to Social and change if they need to.
Auto Industry
Thanks for having the stones to even bring up this issue. My own sense is the commercialization of social media is met with more resentment than anything by social media users. Further, why would we even be attempting to turn the industry upside down because of a few surveys of Millennials. While they buy a percent more in volume than their "parents," the value of the business is dwarfed by previous generations. Millennials buy cheap cars on average with little gross profit for auto OEMs, not to mention dealers. And they are ruthless, using the Internet to negotiate small margins on vehicles with small margins in the first place. They will grow up like previous generations, and their business will have a lot more value than it does today. In the meantime, the Boomers still buy a LOT more vehicles. The value of their business is vastly more than the sheer volume numbers might indicate because there is actual gross profit in their business. Like shooting ducks, you don't shoot at the duck but at where the duck is headed. Perhaps our industry should be thinking about where Millennials are headed rather than turning things upside down because of where they are at the moment.
AutoStride
There isn't a good car-oriented social media site out there, there lies the problem. One day, a group will create one and it might excite some people. I don't buy into Facebook, Twitter or Pinterest (regardless of their attempt at creating business solutions). Frankly, I think a dealership is much better off going through promoted posts at LinkedIn, but very few people talk about it. Guess what, there are more successful millenials, Gen Y and Gen X, etc. on LinkedIn than most of the low end (lack of education) users on the aforementioned, IMO. Yes, social media influences and is used more for branding than selling. There ISN'T a dealership in America that is able to ABSOLUTELY measure marketing dollar ROI. There are just far too many variables that bring in customers, both traditional and digital marketing factors, and the truth is, it's probably a culmination of factors that brings in customers. Physical location, word of mouth, past experiences, marketing, etc.
CBG Buick GMC, Inc.
David. Very true. And very well said. The good thing with millennials being so involved in social media is that it means when they do grow up (myself included) there is a better chance that they will be using that social media to help influence them. Time to pave that yellow brick road now to help them find their way. I think a lot right now with millennials as well is they don't know WHAT they want in dealerships social pages. Ones around here, pictures of jacked up trucks, trucks pulling boats, four-wheelers, and such. Talk about the best places to take vehicles off-roading. We need to figure out what they want to grow from there and turn the "I Don't Know, It's just so shiny" into "I can have this nice and Shiny".
Baker Automotive Services LLC
David R, as you and I have been around the block a few times, the millennium gen that is the leading gen for daily Social Media engagements, they also comprise 29% of all new vehicles purchases. 2nd largest gen now to us baby boomers in count. As their buying power is furthered, year over year, the common social 'monster' sites should include tactful, and meaningful robust dealer brand marketing Daily to prompt engagement. Target marketing precisely 1% of this current marketplace's Automobile buyers in next 30 days has not been accomplished by any of the traditional past medias, let alone social. As COKE and PEPSI, and TARGET are robust in Brand marketing via global advertising marketing silos, Dealers for the dollar should do the same on the social networks.
Wikimotive
Yes please! Abandon it! It will make the few of us who know how to target and illicit consumer behavior that much more effective without the diluted pool of crap that dominates the auto marketing vertical. I mean, we all know car dealers are well known for adapting to change and becoming experts at new ways to market. I doubt its because they're using social media the wrong way! /sarc
Wikimotive
the first rule about dark posts is, you do NOT talk about dark posts! the second rule about dark posts, is, YOU DO NOT TALK ABOUT DARK POSTS! lol
Kijiji, an eBay Company
hahaha. Nice Tim. I should go watch Fight Club again.
Automotive Group
You could have the best strategy (so you think) in the world for social and it will fail. The reason is a lack of knowledge on what and how things like facebook work. In addition the lack of understanding what people do when on said platform. Here's the deal, the majority of you are simply not interesting. That's fine you don't need to be to make facebook work for you. Against all "so called" social guru's out there. Plain ol' content marketing isn't enough. All the buzzwords like relevant, engaging and unique aren't really all that important. Now, I could go into super mega detail on why this is. But, I would rather you see forself. Here are a few things I would challenge you to do for 1 week. After that, report back what you see on your insights. 1. Create a 24hr posting schedule 2. Only post and schedule using the native facebook platform 3. Don't share your videos from youtube to facebook. Upload to FB directly 4. Tag other pages that have more fans than you as often as you can. 5. Share from your oem's FB pages to yours. 6. If you are not doing ads consider 10% off your posts should be ads 7. Don't used boost post. Create actual ads. 8. Post things related to driving. Not related to you 9. Stop navigating people to your site from FB. They don't like pages that take people from FB 10. Stay image and video heavy.
AutoStride
If there’s a local or community event important to the dealership, focus on it. That’s a major part of the strategy. Dealership don’t need to remind their social followers that they have cars for sale, they already know that. When choosing what to post, realize that you shouldn’t act like a dealership, but still remember that you are a dealership. Don’t be pitchy. Don’t feed into stereotypes. Don’t be too “sales-oriented.” Instead, be brand, community, fun, and familial in orientation. Truth is, to be successful on social media as a dealership, you have to stop thinking about yourself as a dealership, but instead, think of yourself as a company that helps out the local community. Giving people a social media smorgasbord of posts to review makes you more well-rounded. Like any delectable sampling of food does. (In no particular order) • Philanthropy and Charitable involvements • Photos of new customers with their vehicles • “Caption This” pictures • Video customer testimonials • Random pics of humor, quotes, or thought-provoking imagery • Questions to engage (think Trivial Pursuit, 1st date-style questions, Family Feud, or hypothetical in orientation) • Reviews / Ratings from happy customers • Service Discounts, Coupons – Not ‘sales-related’ content. (No “3.9% on Chevy’s until month’s end”- style posts) • Upcoming community events (and their involvement in them) • Nearby school events (and a mention of current employees from there) • Good staff bios • Job openings • Very odd vehicles taken in on trade (a 2006 Chevy Malibu isn’t a worthy vehicle to share on your wall regardless of the “low miles”, but a DeLorean would be). • Interesting facts based on that date in history • Service How-To Videos • Very high profile OEM/Dealership updates that are actually in the news (with your dealership’s response to it)
AutoStride
BTW, excuse the paraphrased effort on my part, I stole parts of that from an Automotive Digital Marketing member. Can't remember the source...
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Just saw this come across the non-automotive wire: Jeff Fromm: Social Media Marketing is Dead http://www.psfk.com/2014/08/jeff-fromm-social-media-marketing-dead.html#!bGWqDQ
CBG Buick GMC, Inc.
@Chris...Are you saying I'm Boring! *Gasp* Joking! Anyways. Great tips and it's something that I will be trying starting this Monday so that I can have it already planned out for each post on what days. So Thank you. Alexander, I love the mix of community involvement, service specials, and just general automotive talk. #trucktuesday anyone?
Automotive Group
Lauren, It's ok. I'm boring too. Thank god for the internets. =P Just to give you an idea of what I saw from insights. I saw increases of 200-300% in Reach, Engagment and Likes. It makes a lot of sense when you think about it from Facebooks point of view. They want all the objects. They don't what the objects are about. They just care that they keep the people within the platform. Object weight/type hold much more water than whatever the object contains. meaning that it could be a beloved local story. But depending on how I post that story to facebook could mean the difference of people actually seeing it and not seeing it.
AutoStride
http://www.smartinsights.com/social-media-marketing/ http://www.smartinsights.com/social-media-marketing/social-media-strategy/ Which is only one part of what your overall strategy should be... http://www.smartinsights.com/digital-marketing-strategy-guide
Attrell Toyota Scion
Great article Robert! I can't agree with you more regarding your frustrations as you produce or share 'good' content and get little to no response over and over again. In my opinion, I believe that social media for dealerships should be marketed and used more as a public customer service tool. In this case, people investigating our brand see how we respond to our guest's in times of need and that in itself can be used as a sales tool. What do you think?
AutoStride
The reason your great content isn't reaching anyone, Facebook's algorithm has changed and they themselves have come out and said it. https://www.facebook.com/business/news/Organic-Reach-on-Facebook "There is now far more content being made than there is time to absorb it. On average, there are 1,500 stories that could appear in a person’s News Feed each time they log onto Facebook. For people with lots of friends and Page likes, as many as 15,000 potential stories could appear any time they log on." Plus, it's pay to play to reach the correct demographic. Just because someone is following you or has liked you, doesn't make them a customer or care.
Dealer Sales Accelerator
Robert, Thank you for initiating this conversation. I agree it's long overdue. I look forward to seeing your published insights. The article you posted ended with this question. "Or maybe, are we simply using social media incorrectly?" The simple answer is yes. (Fortunately, as a detailed answer would take forever) But Why? Because the way the platforms are designed and the way people use them is not conducive to conventional marketing and sales practices.The positive results that sometimes occur are typically meager at best. One can indeed beat a dead horse, and every so often if struck just right some part of it will move. Could it be that there is actually a good reason that it's called "Social Media" and not "Commercial Media?" Social Med is outstanding as a research tool. The wonderful thing about social media is that it lends itself brilliantly to the collection of information. Information that once acquired reveals opportunities to exert influence both overt and covert to more effectively drive new sales, up-sells, F&I sales, parts and service sales and retention. The types of information that you can collect (if you know how) as well as the methods of collection are limited only by your imagination. The first commandment of marketing and sales is "Know Thy Customer."
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Wow. Just saw this article has over 60 comments. Intense! An interesting article from the Wall Street Journal this week: Social Media Spending is on the Rise But Impact Is Hard to Measure - http://blogs.wsj.com/cmo/2014/09/03/social-media-spending-is-on-the-rise-but-impact-is-hard-to-measure/ The article discusses that even the best in the marketing industry are lost on the true effectiveness on social advertising: "Only 15% of marketers in the study (351 top marketing executives) said they can show the impact of social media on their businesses using quantitative approaches, while 40% of marketers can only demonstrate the impact qualitatively. Nearly half of marketers said they haven’t been able to demonstrate the impact of social media spending on their business at all."
CBG Buick GMC, Inc.
I found this earlier and was wondering if anyone has tried it and how well any of these sorts of posts have worked for others. Any sort of success in increasing the engagement? Here are 10 that have proven to boost engagement with fans: 1. What was your first car, and do you wish you still had it? 2. When you were little, what did you want to be when you grew up? 3. Who doesn’t love that new car smell? If you could afford any car in the world, what would you drive? 4. What’s your favorite comfort food? 5. Who makes you want to be a better person? 6. Where’s the most embarrassing place your cell phone has gone off? 7. What would you try if you had no fear? 8. What was your favorite sitcom growing up? 9. What’s the best book you’ve read in the last year? 10. What’s the last piece of advice you took?
Kijiji, an eBay Company
19 Tips & Tricks to Prepare for #DSES2014
The DrivingSales Executive Summit 2014 is less than 80 days away, and Vegas can be an overwhelming experience if you aren't prepared. [Tweet This] After attending for the past several years, I wanted to share the best tips and tricks I have accumulated. Whether this is your first DSES or you are a Vogelheim Veteran, hopefully you can use this advice and benefit from my experiences.
Arrive Early
Fly in to Las Vegas before DSES begins on October 12. There is nothing worse than missing a portion of the conference because of a flight delay. Besides, you deserve a break. Take the weekend off and get your Vegas fix before the conference begins.
Leaving the Airport
You can choose a taxi or a bus; both are available outside baggage claim. The taxi ride is worth it, as the bus can take over an hour by the time it drops everyone else off.
When taking the taxi, Nevada state law requires the driver to ask, “Do you want to take the tunnel, or the freeway?”
Choose the freeway. The tunnel is a longer route and will ultimately cost you more, even if the driver says otherwise.
FREE Hotel Upgrades
Ever heard of the Vegas $20 Sandwich trick?
Tipping the hotel's front desk staff means the chance of landing a cheap room upgrade. Twenty bucks for a room upgrade is a no-brainer, right?
The so-called “$20 sandwich trick” or “credit card sandwich” is common across the U.S., but in Las Vegas – a city that runs on tips – it's universal.
When checking in, sandwich a $20 bill ($50 or $100 will have a greater effect) between your identification and credit card and ask the front desk clerk, “Are there any complimentary upgrades available?” Smile, be polite and cross your fingers.
According to FrontDeskTip.com the Bellagio has an 80 percent upgrade rate, so your chances are pretty good.
Stocking Your Hotel Room
The hotel mini-bar is heinously expensive, and you will find yourself famished when you finally crash at the end of the night. After check-in, head to the Walgreens just south of Planet Hollywood. It’s a hike, but worth it. Spending $20 in Walgreens will save you at least $100 in mini-bar fees. Grab snacks, chips, energy bars, Red Bull, Gatorade, Tylenol, and anything else you may need for your Vegas experience. You can also get an 18-pack of PBR for around $14 if that tickles your fancy.
If you are someone that likes a cold beverage, buy a Styrofoam cooler (approx. $4). Stock it up with ice from the hotel, and you can guarantee a cold drink in your room at all times. Or grab a collapsible cooler and pack it into your suitcase. In a pinch, you can always use your bathtub as well.
Portable Power
If you take away anything from this list, it should be this tip. Before heading to DSES, buy yourself portable power for your phones and tablets. You WILL run out of battery between taking notes, live tweeting, adding people to LinkedIn, and checking the baseball scores (Go Blue Jays!).
I pack myself two units: a pocket-sized Powerocks Super Magicstick for my phone, and a HyperJuice Plug for my tablet. These will be life-savers, and may even make you some new friends.
WiFi
WiFi systems have user limits, so if there are 100 spots and 500 people you need to be creative. It’s no one’s fault; it just is a reality. WiFi alone for a conference organizer costs $10,000-plus, so be patient.
To increase your WiFi chances, get to the conference early and secure a spot. As long as your device is running, the signal slot should stick. Make sure to share a hotspot with the people at your table.
If you are stuck and can’t find a signal, the Bellagio has a separate signal outside of the conference rooms that you can pick up. It’s limited speed, but will do the job.
Breakout Sessions – Be Selfish
If you are attending DSES as part of a group, you will likely hear “Let’s divide and conquer,” which is a great aspiration but unrealistic in execution. There is so much information to take in that when it comes time to “share notes” with your colleagues afterwards, you may only get one or two items from the other sessions.
Go to the breakouts that are of the most interest to you, and concern yourself with making the most of your summit. [Tweet This] If you take great notes, share those and hopefully your colleagues will too.
Meet as Many People as Possible
The first year I went to DSES I went alone, and I wish I’d made more of an effort to reach out and meet people. Make a point of sitting down with strangers for lunch, in a breakout or, if you are a smoker (the smoking patio is located on the Bellagio balcony just outside main hall), you can meet some amazing people.
One of the few people I met in my first year was Brian Armstrong (@BryanCarGuy) and he single-handedly made my first experience tremendously more enjoyable.
Bring a handful of business cards, or better yet, include your Twitter handle on your name badge!
If You Can’t Book into the Bellagio
My 2nd year at DSES I stayed at Aria. It wasn’t until the third day that I found the “secret shortcut” between the two hotels. If you walk through the Vdara (in the CityCenter complex) there is a walkway that directly connects with the Bellagio. It saves a quarter-mile of walking and easily 20–30 minutes.
If you aren’t a fan of the “Vegas smoke smell,” the Vdara is a non-smoking building and is easily the best hotel deal on the strip.
Taking Notes
DSES provides faaar more information than you can mentally retain, so taking notes is crucial. My brain is mush by the end, and without my notes I would miss out on some fantastic nuggets. Get yourself a tablet so that you can quickly type, but more importantly, take photos of slides.
For note software I am a big fan of Evernote. It’s free, easy to organize, adding pictures is super easy and it even has an audio recording feature.
Wear Comfortable Shoes
Walking from one end of the Bellagio to the other is half a mile. Everywhere in Vegas “looks” close, but you can easily pack in 6–10 miles of walking in a day. It’s a great excuse to grab a new pair of shoes from the outlets anyways.
Planning Dinner
Especially at the Bellagio, book your reservations at least two days in advance. Eating dinner at 11 p.m. after a full conference day is not pleasant. You can always cancel if need be.
If you can’t make it into one of the restaurants at the Bellagio, here are my favorite nearby establishments:
Rao’s – Upscale Italian. The meatballs have been compared to Jesus by Scott Stratten @unmarketing, and for the vegetarians, the beet salad is to die for. Located at Caesar’s Palace.
Five50 Pizza Bar – In my list of top five pizzas I’ve ever had in my life. You can grab a slice, or sit down for a whole pie. Located in the Aria next to the Sports Book.
China Poblano – Chinese-Mexican Fusion. Small portions, big flavour. Small spot hidden at the back of the Cosmopolitan.
Mon Ami Gabi – Casual French. Try to grab a seat on the patio so you can look over the Bellagio fountains. The goat cheese marinara dip alone is worth the trip.
Hidden Pizza – Legitimately hidden. If you have been out late doing nefarious things, this is the holy grail of destinations. Also on my top five pizzas in my life. Slices only. Basic, New York style, but perfect for late evenings. Hidden on the third floor of the Cosmopolitan.
Plan in Advance
DSES is intense. Your three days will be jam-packed with keynotes, breakouts, working lunches and dinners and general mingling. It’s almost guaranteed, unless you come a few days early or leave Vegas a few days later, that you won’t have time to gamble, shop, or reenact The Hangover.
Before you arrive, plan as much of the conference as you can as time flies quickly. Pick your breakouts, meetings and dinner reservations in advance so that you can focus on the conference once you arrive.
Shopping
If you do book the extra time, shopping in Vegas is for walks of all life. If you want to drop $15k on a Rolex, you can at Caesar’s. If you are like myself and are not rollin’ in dough, you can spend an afternoon at the North Outlets. A $20 cab ride away, there is a plethora of shops where you can moderately blow your hard-earned bonus dollars. Pre-plan your shopping excursion at premiumoutlets.com.
More important than regular shopping, @BrentWees is running a shopping trip to Chapel Hats at the Venetian. Tweet him for details.
Afterparty
My favourite way to cap off DSES is with a little karaoke courtesy of Joe Webb @zonewebb and Shaun Raines @shaunraines. What better way to relax after a mind-bending conference than to float your brain in suds and belt out your best rendition of “Don’t Stop Believing”. Be on the lookout for info leading up to the after-party. It’s where all the cool kids hang out.
Heading Home
If you are exhausted, your brain is fried from information, and your soul feels only slightly dirty, then you know you had a fantastic DSES experience. The flight home can feel like New Year’s Day: you are kind of sad, but excited to get things started. Thankfully McCarren’s Terminal 3 is a great airport terminal. There are plenty of places to eat and ponder on everything that happened over your three days at DSES.
If, however, you do get stuck overnight, don’t worry. Just do what this guy did: http://youtu.be/uE1ChQ8527I
Execution
DSES is only valuable if you execute. When you get home, take all your notes and create an action plan. Take 5–10 items, order them in order of importance, impact, resources and time and create an action plan to get them completed in 3–6 months.
You may want to rush and get everything started, but trust me, planning out what you have learned at DSES is the key to executing.
Extra Reading: The Vegas 30
Scott Stratten @unmarketing (DSES 2012) has a FANTASTIC podcast called The Vegas 30 (thevegas30.com), dedicated to experiencing the best of Vegas for those who are “too old to stand in line for a club, but too young to retire for the bingo hall.”
To date, there are 14 podcasts, all worthy of downloading and perfect for the plane ride while you are heading to DSES. Some of the topics include:
- Tips on attending Vegas conferences and trade shows
- Is Freemont Street worth the time?
- Off-strip entertainment
Check out all the videos and podcasts at: http://www.thevegas30.com/
Extra Reading: Anthony Bourdain – Parts Unknown
If you are a fan of Mr. Bourdain, you will know that Vegas and him go together like Frank Sinatra and Dean Martin. His travels in Las Vegas go from eating a hot dog in a gas station to eating the most expensive meal money can buy at one of Caesar’s villas. Definitely worth a watch:
http://www.cnn.com/video/shows/anthony-bourdain-parts-unknown/season-3/las-vegas/
What Have I Missed?
Tell me what I have missed in this list, what I am wrong about or what I’m SUPER-right about! Share your stories in the comments below.
Robert Karbaum arguably has the best name in the automotive industry. His combined experience over the past decade in E-Commerce and the automotive industry has allowed him to master the art of “AutoSpeak”; the ancient language that bridges the gap between internet geeks, the showroom floor and everything in-between. He manages the E-Commerce, Social and Digital Marketing operations at Weins Canada Inc. (formerly Don Valley North Automotive Group); a prestigious automotive group in Canada which includes the #1 volume Toyota and Lexus dealerships in the country.
Catch him on Twitter (@karbaum) or DroppinBaums.com.
30 Comments
DealerKnows Consulting
All great info, Robert. While I usually stay in condos off the strip to get away from the hustle and bustle one is inundated with during the lengthy Vegas conference stays, this year I'll be in the Bellagio. I hadn't thought of tipping, but that will certainly be something I try this year. And thanks for the Joe and Shaun Karaokethon mention. Last year's venue was lousy - but the one we had scheduled it for had cancelled their karaoke for that night. We found out THAT day. This time we hope it will be a little better. Not sure if we'll have a sponsor for the event or if everyone will be on their own for drinks. But the truth is, we're all fairly well-compensated at our work and the minute you go to a JASKT, you can rest assured that nobody will talk about what transpires there.
CBG Buick GMC, Inc.
Great read Robert. I would DIE to go, but doubt it is going to happen this year. I'll just have to live vicariously through ya'll posts and tweets!
Kijiji, an eBay Company
I had an unforgettable time at last year's Karaoke. The memories I have of Mr. White Suit Ponytail singing "This is why I am hot" or the dude in full army gear belting out Black Sabbath will never be forgotten.
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Bonus points for anyone who remembers this guys performance last year: http://youtu.be/JYDclNWhcR8
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Also Lauren, if you need help convincing your boss to go to DSES please let us know!
Gratis Technologies
Should vendors go? We usually do NADA but I may need help getting the okay for DSES.
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Josh, I would definitely recommend. If you find DrivingSales.com valuable, you will absolutely love DSES. Plus, it's a great place to mingle with clients and potential clients.
Gratis Technologies
Thanks! It has definitely been valuable so far and I hope as we start our ad campaigns it becomes even more fruitful.
Kijiji, an eBay Company
I would love to hear from other Vendors that HAVE been to DSES in the past. How was the experience for you?
Mercedes-Benz & Infiniti of Birmingham
Robert, great write up on the event. Last year was my first time attending, I was amazed at the amount of information/ideas gained as well as the overall experience. Robert, I am ready to see your next idea... good luck. Joe - I hope to catch the Karaoke show this year. Look forward to seeing everyone there. Adam Denault
M10 Marketing Firm
Fantastic article Robert, very thorough! Thanks for all the tips.
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Thanks Adam & Dustin. Looking forward to seeing you both there!
PERQ
Great post Robert, thanks for sharing! Josh - from the vendor perspective, 2013 was our first year attending and having a booth. It's been the best trade show I've attended in the decade I've been in the industry. The content is top notch, the audience is engaged and the Driving Sales crew (shout out to Larry!) is the best in the biz. If you have other questions don't hesitate to reach out.
CBG Buick GMC, Inc.
Robert, I honestly haven't even brought it up. Our GM goes to Detroit for something In August. I really don't know how they handle conferences and things of that sort around here. I will definitely be mentioning it soon though
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Lauren, you just gave me an idea for a Blog Article. How to convince your boss that you NEED to go to DSES 2014.
CBG Buick GMC, Inc.
haha Robert, Glad I could help. Let me know when you have it finished. I'm sure that it will be a great read. Maybe some tips on how to save them money (if there are any different ones than what you already listed in this one) for flights, hotel rooms, eating, fees, etc.
Remarkable Marketing
Josh, DSES is awesome for vendors due to the relaxed environment that DSES creates. It's very Dealer centric so as long as you LOVE to network and have fun, Dealers will eat you up. I'm sure there will some wins for you :) come on out!
Kijiji, an eBay Company
I have had tremendous success with the sandwich trick in Vegas, and elsewhere. The more money, the better your odds. In the end it's very worth it.
PERQ
Robert, I just saw on the Dreamforce (Salesforce's big conference) website that they have a pre-written letter you can download & personalize to show your boss the value in going to their conference. Would make a nice addition to your post...
Faulkner Nissan
I'm all stocked up on Portable Power - but I've *never* heard of the $20 sandwich chick!! GENIUS!! I also set up an IFTTT action for "If @skeetle tweets using hashtag #DSES2014 add a row to spreadsheet DSES2014 in Google Docs." That way, all the tweets I live-tweet during the conference automatically go into their own spreadsheet for me to review as "notes" later!
Faulkner Nissan
Yep! Thank Eric Miltsch for the tip (like you're surprised) - I used to just download my entire twitter archive into a spreadsheet & then sort it from there. Which took a minute (or 70) - the nice thing with them going into a google doc is that I can then share it with the rest of my team!
Kijiji, an eBay Company
I wonder how big the file would be if you exported your entire Twitter history Skeetle.
Faulkner Nissan
I was just going through my portable power - and wanted to drop this here. It can charge mobile devices AND MACBOOKS!!!! I use it religiously (in fact, I used mine last year & DSES & am going to purchase a higher capacity one so I can tweet more.... http://www.hypershop.com/ You're welcome :-P
Faulkner Nissan
Here's one I just thought of -- book your travel out LAAATE (& this might be too late [no punt intended for some of you], the conference is over at noonish, my flight leaves at 10:30 PM - so I'm taking the red eye back to Philly - but I get to enjoy what Vegas to offer aside from he amazing conference!
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Wow, this article is almost at 25k views. That's pretty awesome!
Kijiji, an eBay Company
The New “Google My Business” Has Just Launched, Should You Care?
Keeping up-to-date with changes to Google’s business platform is a full-time occupation. Every time you turn around, Google has either radically updated or completely changed their services. Just in the last short while we have gone through Google Places, Google+, Google+ Local and now Google My Business. Each step along the way, things got more confusing, as both Google Places and Google+ operated quasi-independently. However, with the launch of Google My Business, it appears they have finally fixed this (monumentally frustrating) problem and amalgamated everything into one system.
So as Google begins to market this product and buzz hits the Internet, I wanted to summarize why you should care (or not care) about the new updates and how they will (or won’t) affect your dealership.
For Veteran Users:
If you are a longtime Google Business/Places/+ Local user you will be overjoyed that you no longer have to manage two competing Business Services lists. And, that’s about it.
Existing veteran users will log in and say, “This is all the same. What am I missing?”
They would be right. Those already accustomed to trekking their way through the murky waters of Google+ Local will see basically the same thing. The ONLY difference I can discern is that it is easier to manage your online reviews. Previously, you had to sneak in through the back door to respond to your Google+ reviews. Now, they have moved the door to the front of the building with a big neon sign.
Should You Care?
Not really, other than knowing Google Places is now gone you may continue about your day and wait until Google changes this platform again. Call this a mulligan of sorts.
For Basic Users:
If you have gotten to the point where you have registered your business with Google and maybe uploaded a photo or two, these changes will affect you more significantly.
The new platform is a lot more user-friendly. Everything is split between six categories: My Business, Reviews, Business Insights, AdWords Express, Google+ and YouTube. Here is where to start.
First, if you haven’t already, claim your connected Google+, Google Analytics and YouTube accounts. These are intrinsically tied to your Google My Business profile and are crucially important towards your Organic Search Rankings.
My Business
The core of the system where you can update your business information including website, location, phone numbers, photos, categories, description and hours of operation. When you first jump in, you may want to comb through this to ensure all the information is correct. Having a customer show up at 7 a.m. after driving for 3 hours for a test drive appointment is a heatscore you want to avoid. Trust me, I’ve been down this road before :P.
Furthermore, what you enter into your My Business section will be spread across all accounts including AdWords. It will also affect how your business is viewed on Google.
Reviews
Google now has quick access into your Reviews Management, where you can not only view all the reviews posted about your dealership, but reply, flag and analyze your reviews. With its Review Analytics feature, at a glance you can see how many reviews your dealership has received from ALL review sources. That’s right, all of your Dealer Rater reviews now have made their way into Google’s algorithms. You can separate by source or time period, and as an added bonus, Google provides direct links to each and every review.
Business Insights
Insights is comparable to a bolt-on air intake for your Google Analytics. It affects change on its own, but it is part of a larger system. The main purpose of Insights is to give you a snapshot of your Dealership’s Google+ Organic Performance.
Business Insights is split into three subsections:
- Visibility: Where you can see the number of views, clicks, and can then discern your conversion ratio.
- Engagement: Where you can see the Reach and Actions of your Google+ activity on an item-by-item basis.
- Audience: Where you can see the metrics of your Followers such as increase/decrease numbers, and demographics.
All of this information is great, if you have a very active Google+ profile. (Hint, you should have a very active Google+ profile.) The fact that Google is tracking your Google+ reach is an indication that they are watching, and expecting you to participate in their little “+game.”
AdWords Express
Part of the magic surrounding Google’s world dominance is how they encourage the average user to advertise on their network by educating them on how to do so. However, AdWords Express (previously Google Boost) was designed to make it infinitely easier for Google to take your money.
Basically, you choose what site you want to promote, and how much you want to promote it for monthly and voila!
On the other side of the coin, Express also significantly limits the amount of data you can view as well, so you definitely get what you pay for. It’s akin to advertising in the local newspaper. It’s not a lot of effort, and you kind of know it’s working, but that’s about it.
Google+
If you are still new to Google+, you are beginning to fall behind the average. Most progressive dealers are at least aware, if not posting social updates and delivery photos on the regular.
Instead of rehashing the obvious, Mashable has a great article you can read: “The Beginner’s Guide to Google+”
For the basic Google+ user, as I mentioned above, part of the My Google Business platform is Google+ Insights. If you haven’t already, focus on expanding your Google+ connection network, and then work on delivering captivating content to those connections. It’s not as easy as it sounds, so here are a few tricks to get you started:
How to get quick Followers on Google+
- Search out and add other OEM-related dealerships, OEMs themselves, vendors and consultants to your circles. Most will add you back.
- Include links to “Follow” your Google+ profile on e-marketing and website content
- Reach out and add local businesses, and share as much content as you can. The savvy ones will happily do the same in return.
- Entrepreneur has a great article to dig a little deeper: “21 Simple Ways to Get More Followers for your Google+ Business Page”
YouTube
This is where things can get tricky. When Google chose to merge YouTube and Google+, there wasn't an easy way to keep an existing account and transfer it. In some cases (like mine) it was impossible. One of our dealer pages had over 250,000 views that had to be abandoned in order to link with Google+. We looked at every possible angle and eventually bit the bullet.
You may find that you have to do the same thing if you click through the YouTube link and it asks you to create a new account.
However, on the positive side, when everything is connected, your stats cross platforms and from the Google My Business dashboard you can see how everything is trending. Most importantly, the more you intertwine your business with Google, the more prominence you will receive within its search rankings. I've witnessed it firsthand each time I follow Google down its rabbit hole.
Should You Care?
Yes. Everything you need to do is more or less in one easy-to-use space, so there is no excuse not to get your dealership hooked up to the Google matrix. If you have any questions, please feel free to ask me, or just comment below!
For the Basic, BASIC Users:
If you are an owner, dealer principal, or general manager and you KNOW you are "deep in the weeds" on this one, do yourself a favour and hire an E-Comm manager/director. Even if you are a tiny little store in Akron, Ohio, you will need someone in-house that understands all this "techy stuff". At the end of the day, bringing in a young tech "kid" and teaching him/her the "car game" will cost you monumentally less than handing over wads of cash to a third party time and time again. Yes, vendors and consultants can be a valued assset but don't look to them to control your entire operation. After all, would you have a vendor/consultant sell on your showroom floor? Or service your customer's vehicles in the shop?
Should You Care?
Yes. A thousand times, yes. The automotive industry is past the point of "changing" – it's changed, and will continue to change at a faster pace each day. If you are just jumping into the waters, you need to catch up real fast. Hook your fishing line to a killer whale and hold on tight. You'll be all right.
Do You, the Reader, Care?
What are your thoughts on the new Google My Business?
What did I miss?
What are you going to do next?
Let's get the comments going!
Robert Karbaum arguably has the best name in the automotive industry. His combined experience over the past decade in E-Commerce and the automotive industry has allowed him to master the art of “AutoSpeak”; the ancient language that bridges the gap between internet geeks, the showroom floor and everything in-between. He manages the E-Commerce, Social and Digital Marketing operations at Weins Canada Inc. (formerly Don Valley North Automotive Group); a prestigious automotive group in Canada which includes the #1 volume Toyota and Lexus dealerships in the country.
Catch him on Twitter (@karbaum) or DroppinBaums.com.
9 Comments
Dealer e Process
Great read Robert. I was hoping someone would sort this out, and did a great job of it!
Dealerography.com
Great post Robert! The phrase "monumentally frustrating" to describe Google's development of these products is on point. We've had some epic battles with Google in the past and some genuine WTF moments, but I have also been pleasantly surprised by Google on several occasions, too. Where we're at right now: With the forced YouTube/G+ integration, I opted to continue calling our channel SubaruofWichita, so Google was "kind" enough to automatically set up another Subaru of Wichita Google+ page. We weren't presented with the option of just linking our YT channel with the G+ page I've been posting content to for almost two years now, so we have two. Google is treating its new one as the active page that meets quality guidelines (and also the one that shows up on maps, incorporates reviews, etc), so I'll probably make one more attempt to have them let us use the original page, which is hidden for being a duplicate, before deactivating it. This wouldn't be the biggest loss in the world, as G+ continues to attract scorn in the Wichita area for the average social media user. It would still be a bummer to lose all that content, however. Google is not an unreachable entity, though. For those who are experiencing challenges and frustrations, keep reaching out to them through the channels they provide. You might not get an immediate response, but they do give answers. When we were transitioning from Suzuki to Subaru, for instance, I received two separate phone calls from the Google Maps team to verify our change of name. I also received communication from Google+ Local that allowed us to keep our Suzuki of Wichita Reviews while changing our name to Subaru, as we were the same management team serving another brand. The question of should I care strikes me as funny, though, as I've learned to simply detach from getting emotionally wrapped up in the capricious whims of the Google monster. Yes, it's worth attention, but don't "care," because she'll break your heart. :-) At last year's Digital Summit at Mountain View, which took place on the Google campus, Monica Morse, the Social Lead of SMB Solutions for Google, described Google+ like this: "It's wonky." I couldn't have put it any better.
Dealer InLine
Thank You Robert! I needed a concise write-up on if this would be changing the way us “veterans” would be interacting with Google!
Kijiji, an eBay Company
Great feedback Aaron! "It's wonky." is a bit of an understatement in my opinion, but at least they have come this far. I can't imagine what you went through with the name change. I know how infuriating it was having 3 dealerships within a 2000" radius all starting with "Don Valley North". They would merge us in a new way on a weekly basis!
Automotive Group
For anyone interested in the ability to manage your presence from a mobile device for My Business. Here you are... http://www.google.com/business/manage.html
1 Comment
joe goodrow
earlys auto sales
The problem with your premiss is most most of the monthly payments we make are small and we can walk away from a non contract monthly service like netflix at any time usually without a penalty or perhaps in the case of a cellphone service with a small penalty. Point is, the person that has cash, real cash in the bank or under the pillow, still is King.